i'm something of a pretty woman discerner myself editionPrevious: >>98813204>Newshttps://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-banned-and-restricted-february-9-2026https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-brackets-beta-update-february-9-2026>Current Banlisthttps://magic.wizards.com/en/banned-restricted-list#commander-banned>Bracket Informationhttps://files.catbox.moe/4tbvzw.pnghttps://files.catbox.moe/r62yfy.png>Former Commander Website: Learn the basics, and read the format philosophy laid down by the rules committeehttps://mtgcommander.net>Card Searchhttps://scryfall.com>Card Statistics: See what everyone else puts in their Commander decks based on what is posted to the Internethttps://www.edhrec.com>Deck List Sites: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck strategy and card choiceshttps://www.archidekt.comhttps://www.moxfield.com>Manabase Information: Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen color identityhttps://managathering.com>Proxy Guidehttps://pastebin.com/9Xj1xLdM>Preconshttps://magicprecons.comTQ: what are your waifu commanders? ai peak welcome.
>>98818058>what are your waifu commanders?Big-titty Jap princess.
>tqGuile is the prettiest waifu
>>98818092being surrounded by all those women?guile is so lucky...
>>98818058she cute, knyght, japan :D
>>98813443that does not happen anywhere except your gay fantasies. also the remake is irrelevant. in the actual game you find whatever cross dresser items to sneak into the brothel and get your girl back.its funny and you and Aeris bond over dealing with weirdos in the sector 5 slums who want to help you. the "stand up for groomer pride" is all additional shit added by the now fired North American woke team of squeenixany additional other faggot shit is in your own mind>>98813450go play 10 HD remaster, then FF6 pixel remaster then ff7 original version ("remaster"? not the remake whatever you do, which I dont think is even finished yet and sucks)>>98816609that is not true at all. he fully expected people to be trading and the whole point of ante was to nudge the trading card game aspect. buying singles is just one step removed from trading cards since youre just trading cards for cash. the meta game he imaged would be leagues of your play group, where he thought there might only be 1 black lotus per group of like 10 players. not one dude spending all week driving across multiple states and calling sports card shops and sending money orders to people you met over Usenet for cards __________>tq: I don't have any female commanders except the new pre-con with Giada. I have Garnet in a deck though. And Rinoa is going in a Rin & Seri build actually though before they announced the pre-cons I was thinking of making this baddie the commander of an Angel deck. but I think Giada works better as the commander so Radiant's just in the 99 for now
Any genuinely viable one drop commanders?
>>98818176
>>98818176funny you should mention that
>>98818176>Any genuinely viable one drop commanders?I'll do you one better
>>98818200BUILDING RIGHT NOW
>>98818058>TQShe has become my ever-growing IRL shitpost and I love her.She essentially plays like a classic mono-blue control deck with clones and theft effects, Bracket 3. My current record for non-infinite jellyfish in a game is 32.
>>98818222Take all your sloppy Red +1 cards and put them in a deck.
>>98818239cynettechad... I yield
>>98818200
>>98818239I admire the dedication, even if I don't get it. She seems pretty mid mechanically.
>>98818058>TQNone.
>>98818272have you considered this important fact: she cute
>>98818239Actually embarrassing.
>>98818239That's pretty based. I have my Fat Bastard monoblue deck, but I have to concede to your devotion for your waifu.
Did you guys pick up a copy of the soon to be gamechanger’d card before it soared any higher in price?
>>98818239Actually chadbearsing.
>>98818290I'll just proxy it.
>>98818292they should've made it a functional duplicate of toski
>>98818305I kinda hate that he's a rogue. It should just be Tosk.
>>98818290It won't be a GC
>>98818292Ah, yes, "Tosk," a very important tribe with strong synergies justifying its existence. Unlike pointless fluff flavorwank like "Cephalid" and "Viashino."
>tqAll my decks are Waifu decks. >Green QueenPretty similar to every other Tifa deck, though slower since I rely more on Bristly Bill alts to not obliterate the table by turn 5.>Italian TifaBunch of 'whenever attack get counters' and additional combat creatures.>AzulaGood ol' fashion pump instants.>Goth CatgirlPillowfort and clones.>YunaTokens and cards that put counters on creatures when they enter. Hurl tokens at players; they can block and kill them and and pump up my other creatures or let them through and die by the swarm.
>>98818349Tosk just has that branding that people can't forget, sorry bud
>>98818354>UBnormalfaggot thinks you can have multiple waifusGod I hate normalfagsGuaranteed you haven't seen Azumanga Daioh
>>98818373>you can't have multiple waif-
sol ring counts as a land right?
>>98818373Don't make me post my shitty AI proxy deck that is all variants of my shitty OC.on ever card.
>>98818393the ones where you cannot tell them apart? YES please!
>>98818402Telling them apart is big gay.
>>98818386Yes
>>98818058>TQI have one for each of my mono decks. r8 n h8
>>98818092AWOOGA
>>98818092Never thought I'd say this. Pia is kinda hot.
>>98818288I look like this
>>98818413damn the gay pedo furry said it so it must be true
>>98818386>>98818413Not sure if this is some retarded in-joke, but no, it's an artifact
Forgot to post it>makes deck of "hot" cards>every art is completely unappealing and uglyWas this some ironic joke?https://youtu.be/tXNTp0tLI6c
Licia is waifu, was thinking of making an alt of Carmilla from the Castlevania series but haven't found the right art yet.
>>98818373>God I hate normalfags>Guaranteed you haven't seen Azumanga DaiohYou are very clearly an Hispanic obese manchild that consumes Loli pornography, I recommend hopping onto incels dot is or kiwipharms for likeminded special needs spics.
>>98818588>seething this hardAs usual, I'm right.Normalfags don't even know where the term came from.
>>98818591>doesn’t even attempt to argue against the brutal feltening, just lays belly up like a lazy mexican
>TQ:Special place in my heart as my first commander.
>>98818630>local Naya player too retarded to attach his old Jund commander to the post
if you have more than one waifuyou will have no laifu
>>98818633
>>98818035Just 20 more years stay strong hybridsis
>>98818653sheldon wished he could live 20 more years to badly manage edh
My waifu is Freya Crescent, and yes I do have a folder filled with rule34 images of her.
>>98818662she cutethe impossible 1 2 4 commander
>>98818633This would be a fun card if it were 3 mana without the half baked forced saccing.
>>98818290opened it in draft opening weekend and they didnt wanna buy it from me so i will sell it once the price goes up
>>98818290No because:>I don't find this card interesting.>I'm not stupid enough to use MtG as my investment outlet.
>want to make funny norin etb ping deck>norin alone is $20>lgs doesn't allow proxies Cheap monored burn it is
>>98818793>I'm not stupid enough to use MtG as my investment outlet.and yet many third party businesses open and resell mtg and other tcgs as their source of income, how can this be?
>>98818808Because they are not only stupid enough to do this, they were stupid enough to make it their job.
>>98818808I have this great new opportunity for you, have you ever heard of NFTs
>>98818808The failures don't last long enough to be a blip on the radar.
>>98818806Just print one out they'll never know it's sleeved up anyways.
>>98818810so you're only stupid if you were late to the party, got it lmao
>>98818820Contact me at notascam.com for more info
Slight corrections on the Link.
finagling with spooky cards, MTG doesnt have this genre of ghost girl as a creature yet right?would she fit more in Duskmourne or Kamigawa
why make shitty new cards when you can make shitty alters of existing carads
>>98818836While flavorful, would instantly become a rules nightmare and that ability really shouldn't be free.
>>98818823Can't wait to get in on the ground floor of $rugpull. See you later losers!
>>98818849i am also doing thatbuilding rakdos madness for my girl (unless theres a better build theme that would work for this, seems like she wants discard synergies)
>>98818888nice get
>>98818849Exactly.
I think I’m done playing this game not at a store. Just had an argument over one player chunck shuffling who works as a dealer at a casino and when I called it out that he should be interweaving when shuffling I was then the rules lawyers. Then an incident with the same player happens that same game when their mother of machines was out and they cast 8 spells and I resolved my amphibian downpour and they argued its ability didn’t trigger from Norns passive I even looked it up and showed them and they said that’s not how they play. Just scooped there and am told them if they can’t play by the rules then what’s the point in playing. Not only that they were previously looking up my cards for legal interaction and arguing my fetchlands where not a legal color identity for my deck, Is this what kitchen table magic has turned into?
>>98818941>Is this what kitchen table magic has turned into?No, it was always this bad. Why do you think sacrifice effects specify "of their choice" and Stifle specifies you can't counter mana abilities? Because the average player doesn't read the rules and nothing stops them over tabletop. This is compounded by how tournament policy supports this with "If your opponent doesn't catch it, you get away with it" which led to a culture of angleshooting and lying to your opponent. 60-card right now is in the middle of a scandal where players are being forced to manually count every single card in their opponent's deck before every game because if the game starts, it's considered THEIR fault if their opponent is running less than 60 and now people are doing it to side in Urza's Saga targets only after it ticks up to 2 because the penalty is "warning" if the game already started.
Thirty (30) starting life is objectively superior to fourty (40)
>>98818941I once lost a modern tournament because my opponent and the LGS owner both said that giving hexproof after someone casts the spell targeting the creature doesn't stop the spell from affecting the creature. That store has closed down since then. Good riddance.
>>98818806Do they deck check every card or what? Just do it pussy
>>98819011My friend was banned from an LGS for proxying a deck. They do indeed check your cards sometimes. He did buy an outrageous number of cards like dual lands and shit. I warned him that Zheng's proxies vary wildly in quality but he didn't listen. Don't take advice from 4chan kids.
>>98818058I like her nun-like design more.
>>98819027>Not liking anime girls
a simple but strong custom card worthy of /trash/
>>98819023Nigga what is this the magic gestapo? I know tournaments, but that's one thing and sitting up to play casually is another>owner, I suspect anon is hiding proxies...>anon let me grab your deck>no, it's got expensive cards, you can't touch it>ANON ARE YOU HIDING ENEMIES OF THE STATE. ESCORT THIS MAN AT ONCELike if I pig out and actually buy an expensive deck with real cards, I have to let the owner handle it? Madness>>98819023
>>98819036I said design. I wouldn't mind an anime nun look.
>>98819042Why is it that CEDH is okay with proxies but the more casual brackets aren't?
>>98818941>>98819003Probably one of the most discouraging events to happen to me in magic in awhile. Used to play modern a lot up until 2020 and was invited by friend to play some “casual” commander and I haven’t ever really played this format. Pretty much a turn off for playing with that group if their selective enforcement is just for who the normally play with. And yeah I can see where your description of them of “ if no one catches it I’ll be fine” but the blatant cheat shuffle and then house ruling over official rules just because you don’t want to lose is crazy. It’s just a game and if we are playing at different understandings of rules then what’s the fuck are we playing exactly how am I supposed to know. Such a fucking autist why do I care
>>98818984Lmao didn’t mean to reply to myself
>>98819023
>>98819049it's one thing to proxy a $7000 cedh deckit's another thing to proxy a pauper edh deckwe have to gatekeep poorfags at some point, you know?and wotc actually made it easier to put the cutoff line as:>b3 and below, we expect your cards to be real>cedh, we expect your cards to be fake
>>98819042Yeah, unless you're competing, why would a game store give a fuck if you have proxies?
Alright, be honest. What is your weight?
>>98819079I don't know what to tell you anon, He was upset about it. It was back in 2013-14 maybe proxies have become more accepted these days. I make a lot of shit up on here but that wasn't one of my fake stories.>>98819042I'm sure he found it very odd too. He certainly thought he'd get away with it.
>>98819160270I just love burgers and cola too much
>>9881916075kg, 6"5, feminist
>>98819043Look at her hat. She's basically an anime nun. Unless you want her hair more covered up, which would be weird.
>>9881916085kg, 5'4" male
>>98819165>maybe proxies have become more accepted these days.Much much much much more accepted these days
>>98819049as faggoty as they are, cedh players actually want to play a challenging game
>>98819165>>98819179meh I think it varies. My lgs has also banned proxies on the premises, though they don't enforce it for edh, by petition of the some loud retards. There's still a lot of sunken cost fags in the community who want to push back against it
>>98819167280 here and same
>>98819160210.It was 270 a year ago.
>>98819189>There's still a lot of sunken cost fagsi too think artists and their dicksuckers are sunk cost fags that kvetch over ai, when will they learn that ai art are just proxies for real art?
>Playing my new deck, mono black>Scoop to an MH3 Emrakul cast trigger two games in a row>"Maybe run some couterspels next time if you don't want to get hit by that"These goofy ahhhh tourists bro
>signature look of superiority Thunder Junction is a fanfic and not canon
>>98819160Maybe 70kg, I'm afraid less than that even
You know when a card says "exile, then return", when is the "then"?
Why is this banned? Doesn't seem any more crazy than half the shit in commander
>>98819263just because a card isn't going to be a cedh allstar doesn't mean wotc wants the kind of gameplay it promotes
>>98819268But they're the ones that made and printed it...
>>98819268Punishing decks that depend on their commander is a good thing
>>98819263Commander players don't know what Wasteland is.
>>98819280cedh is a good thing yes
>>98819261Now.
I want to play a Kamigawa commander because I'm a massive weeb, but they don't seem that great as commanders
>>98819303
>>98819160I will not reveal my exact weight but I look a little something like this.
>>98819280I agree! Everyone should play Nick Fury TM, superstar card of Marvel (R) Superheroes TM! The format's way better when your commander exists just for colors.
>>98819339He's not just for colors he's also for enabling broken garbage like the free ikoria spells.
>>98819347Well you see controlling your commander is REALLY hard because the format as intended has them being dead 99% of game, so we need cards like 0 mana Negate or Past In Flames + Wheel of Fortune on one card, otherwise there would be no reason to play your commander!
Storm is the absolute coolest shit but only if you do it with something simple, powerful and effective, like a Grapeshot right at the end of a chaotic round of 4 players throwing down spells
>>98819339No, you should be able to win with out your commander at the very least have a few backup win cons
>>988191606'2"115kgAm big fat but was 135kg last year, so less fat
>>98818058>TQThese are my wives
For me, Progenitus is THE best art and I want to make a deck with him, but don't all 5 colour decks end up as 5c goodstuff.dek?
>>98819370Exactly! Nick Fury TM is really good at winning because even if you spend every turn removing him with Karakas, he's only 1 mana and his 5c identity means you can run all the best cards like Rhystic Study and The One Ring!
>>98819390Didn't they only print one copy of The One Ring, it being the only ring etc etc lord of the rings etc?
>>98819370your commander is just a cog to your 99
>>98819398Why is he good?t. newfag
>>98819398>your commander is just a cog to your 99Mines just one of several wincons
>>988194060 mana to enable free spells generate mana or get sacced for value is just broken
>>98819384I have seen a lot of progenitus decks that are focused on untapping bouncelands for some reason. Slapping Market festival on a selesnya sanctuary sounds pretty fun I guess.
>>98819412yours is also a shit deck in the grand scheme of things
>>98819424I don't run a CEDH deck
>>98819424>just buy a multi-thousand dollar card bro
>>98819433>buy
how the FUCK do you beat jin-gitaxias
Anything that beats my deck is against the spirit of the format, simple as
>>98819406Lots of small things that add up to make him better than pretty much any other commander.>Flexible colors>Enables lots of poorly-designed cards that produce way more value than they should if your commander is alive>Guarantees access to sac fodder (can mean 2 extra cards or 4 mana on turn 1)>Very noncommittal, opponents go negative when removing it while you lose nothing>Doesn't require your 99 to be built around him basically at all (contrasting cards like Kinnan, Sisay, or Magda where if you lock the commander they lose).The only ones really on his level are 4c partner pairs (similar reasons, but better colors and more easy value in exchange for more mana committment). Nick Fury is also unironically quickly reaching this level being only 1 mana and 5 colors.
>>98819430i'm indifferent to whether karakas actually gets unbanned, i'm just telling you why it's very unlikely for wotc to unban itthough if karakas does get unbanned i'd like an uncounterable infinite turns in my casual pods
>cast commander>lose What a combo
>>98819495in response to Phage being cast, i concede
>>98819526You play an island? I scoop
Why is Humility considered a complicated card? Creatures have no abilities.>b-but what about Creatures have no abilities >but this creature Creatures have no abilities It could not be more simple
Is it a dick move to lose on my own terms?>game a few days ago>i've got no flying blockers and current player sends a swarm of flying lifelink angels at me hoping to recover some hp>i churn through my library and deck out at instant speed without my wincon since my labman's in the yard>he doesn't get the life back since i cease to exist after losing>player after me can finish angel dude since he's tapped out and has less than 10 life left
>>98819556your seethe is palpable
>>98819568If you were digging for an actual instant speed out I'd say no. If you just decked out for spite it's only cool if you actually despise the person who attacked you.
>>98819582Humility would remove his ability, making nombasics back to normalHumility is easy to grasp, I'm thinking magic players are just retarded
>>98819595>Humility would remove his ability, making nombasics back to normal>Humility is easy to grasp, I'm thinking magic players are just retarded
>>98819597How is this difficult to understand for you?
>>98819604you will cite the comprehensive rulebook on layers yes?please be more entertaining there's an announcement coming up
>>98819604Why do you pretend to know the rules when you don't?
>>98819587Well I asked him not to attack me with everything as I could've lived if he didnt full send all tokensBut he committed them all anyway so I was like ehhh fuck it. I didnt have other outs in the deck since my cyc rift got countered and my aetherize got used up earlier
Seriously Now{1}{U}{U}Instant:Target anon stops shitposting
>>98819604If you're not baiting I'm happy to explain why you're wrong, just say the word
>>98819613>>98819614>le opalescence xDApart from that one interaction, Humility is incredibly simple.
>>98819630nobody mentioned opalesenceyou're having a hard time today
I love abusing greens ramp so much fuck maaaaaaan I love greeen im literally greeen nigggerrrrrr
>>98818383Motoko was my very first waifu.
>>98819282It's like Strip Mine
hypothetically >opponent plays symmetrical sweeper>I tap Jolrael to turn his lands into creaturessurely it's not MLD if someone blows up his own lands. right?
>>98818239yeah, it's based.
>>98818239I prefer just to play her as a flyers agro deck
/tg/ i need your help. I've got an awful idea. A retarded idea, even. Basically, the plan is as follows:>homer the hermit as commander>deck is full of lobsters and crabs>rest of the deck is full of cards that turn creatures into foods, like witch's oven and bake into a pieGonna call the deck "seafood boil". Only question is, how do i find the cards needed to turn stuff into food?
>>98818509they mean in terms of deckbuildinga deck wants to have X number of lands in it, so then the question becomes, if you have certain cards like Sol Ring, does that number go down (imo yes)but I think it becomes much less clear when your deck has multiple colors, or if you're trying to cast your commander ASAP if your commander has less than {2} in its mana cost. since Sol Ring adds no colored mana it won't actually curve out your commander faster. if it's Isshin or Baylen for instance you could end up having to mulligan a hand where a land would have let you keep it.personally I treat cards like Generous Ent as a tap land, and cards like Bushwhack, which require colored mana, as 1/x lands where x is the number of colors of my deck (it's only a land when I have green mana)
Bracket 2 deck coming along nicely
>>98819884if only the color ID allowed this.
>>98819855animating your lands in response to a board wipe isn't mld, gavin already covered these scenarios
>>98819041RWBY is one of these franchises that I can imagine getting actual UB.Kind of dead but still with a lot of dedicated fans that would murderfuck for any recognition. Obviously first they would need to figure out who is responsible for managing this wreck after Rooster Teeth died but why fucking now?
>>98819940viz media owns rwby now but i suspect they're going to let it sleep for a while before rebooting it in the 2030s
>>98818851True. Here's another attempt.
>>98819933Nah ragost isn't stupid enigmatic to do this deck imo. Can't run bake into a pie there. https://moxfield.com/decks/X0FMJrdVzU-hgYiyYZaXFwEither way, here's the finished decklist. I'll consider it a win if i manage to turn my creatures into foods or run out of creatures in my deck. This is for sure a bracket 1.
>>98819252and here I thought I was the only mr skeltal here
When is the commander panel update?
anyone getting any of they secret lairs?
>>98820278I'm debating about getting the festival in a box. There's a few cards from it that I want, but I'm not sure I can really justify spending $250 right now.
>>988191605'11" 185 ish.
>>98820187Lollmao
>>98818058I want her to discern my penis.
>>98819381>worst toph artReally dude?
>>98820278I really like both Bowie and Labyrinth so yes as much as I hate myself for itThe Delayed Blast Fireball and Thran Temporal Gateway in one of the packs is tempting but I don't care for the other three and part of me thinks I should just buy singles for it insteadTo anyone else who's done this shit before, do the Foils tend to come with any flashy treatment or are they just generic Foils? Seems like $10 more for a worse product if it's the latter
>>98820304That's what Paypal pay in 4 is for
>>98820278Got the Labyrinth ones, the tree one, and the marvel zombies one.
>>98820398The value on those 3 is the worst but has the best art. Might grab the Bowie one since it has a Trinisphere. Also obviously gonna try and get the Ashnod's Altar and Underworld Breach lairs. Also I'm a sucker for full art lands and the art deco artifact lands are sick.
>>98820446I don't plan on reselling so thankfully value isn't much of a concernThe lands are pretty nice though
>>98820460Nor do I, but it is nice to get valuable cards
>>98818290Cracked one eariler. Im currently using the law of attraction to crack another later today at my LGS when i pop in for new sleeves. And a pack fresh Jace
>>98820278>foil artifact lands sold out while I was mid checkoutWhatever, I'm just gonna grab Ashnod's Altar and Underworld Breach, I'll get Labyrinth singles later on.
>>98818426Lets see that Avacyn list anon
>>988191605'8600lbsI play blue and Izzet because those are the big brain colors.
>>98818058>TQMachine mommy is my front-facing answer.It's somehow easier to explain than Mabel, Heir to Cragflame.
>>98820597Forgot pic.
>>98820278I would have really liked to get these to frame and put on my wall but looks like they are already sold out during presale? how the hell does this shit even work, its not released but sold out but im still in a queue till tomorrow when they release?
I hate when I want to buy a secret lair and wait in queue, only for it to be sold out when i get to the checkout.But, I sure do feel good when I am on the other side of it. Wizards is the only company that gives me this love/hate feeling for a product.
>>98819568Kind of a dick move,yea. Basically Kingmaking
>>98819568I hold myself to the standard of conceding at sorcery speed. If you can instantly deck yourself on your opponents turn legally, I have no problem with that. Kingmaking is part of the game, regardless of motives.
>>98820623no it realeased today you got in before the sale but not before everyone else who got in before the salealso if you are just going to frame them anyway i'd probably just get a print that's meant to be framed from the artisthttps://www.seemachine.com/
wotc should adapt the rolex model where you can only purchase product if you have purchased previous products
>>98820666Interesting idea satan.
>>98820460>Look at this scene>All I can think of is "ass to ass"
>>98820666I only by singles
Im gonna convert my Kambal deck into the new ghost Niv-Mizzet. Any suggestion's?
>>98820766Yeah, don't. He's kind of boring, and is usually just a big removal magnet. Kambal is far more powerful in the right hands.
>>98820873Fair, kambal is definitely a menace. Any good suggestion's for him? Its the jew version - council of allocation
>tqI want to build the prostitute but all the best cards with death triggers rely on playing aristocrats solitaire which is profoundly boring to me.
>>98820941Yea unfortunately shes basically figured out already
>>98820925Honestly, he's kind of tricky to build, because you really do want him to stay under the radar. Grouphug and politics was how I built him, so that way people usually were more hesitant in blowing stuff up but more spendthrift with their spells. Treasure gen is really good, because then people waste their big spells early and drain themselves faster
>>98820954Got a list? Im considering loading him up with i win combos/ cards like Test Of endurance and Felidar Sovereign amont many others
Since searching is the most powerful thing you can do in this formathere are the OBJECTIVE rankings of the power of each 3 color pairingTeneb/Abzan: 729 cards Vorosh/Sultai: 715 cardsTreva/Bant: 707 cardsRith/Naya: 670 cardsDarigaaz/Jund: 663 cardsIntet/Temur: 635 cardsDromar/Esper: 500 cardsOros/Mardu: 455 cardsCrosis/Grixis: 438 cardsNumot/Jeskai: 432 cards
>>98820978This all seems unnecessary anon
>>98820418This. Just don't use it too often or you'll end up having 5 plans going on at once
>>98820972Not anymore, but i'd advise against cards that are 1. Easily removable and 2. Immediate targets. Like I said, you want kambal and your creatures to never really pose a threat, but you want to make other people more threatening. Master of ceremonies, or gonti, night minister are really good at doing that, since people will want to hit other people, especially if your spells are small and help other people more than you at first glance. Throw in some cards that care about artifacts dying for more value and you can start to really drain people.
>>98820994and that's why you will always be a second rate duelist with a third rate deck
>>98820388yea, I love her even at her worst
>>98820941It's what you signed up for. I'm in the early stages of putting something like this together and the only thing I will say is that you have to find the sauce for it.For me, the sauce is Ratadrabik and getting nonlegendary tokens of my legendaries (and then recurring my legendaries).
>>98820978Based. Teneb was my first EDH deck and still my favorite.
>>98821032Doesn't matter how shit my deck is if you beat me I'll just kms and say you made me do it. Enjoy prison.
>>98821169
>>98820941There is the Orzhov weenie route
>>98818058This waifu needs to go in my blue deck NOW
>>98820941Doomed TravelerCrawling ChorusGreedy FreebooterHunted WitnessInfestation SageNested ShamblerNesting BotNezumi Linkbreakerwhat >>98821214 said, go the weenie route with Lurrus type effects, grave pact, Drana, Liberator of Malakir, get some counters on stuff, basically laugh at boardwipes, sac your board for reach instead of for some solitaire combo
>>98818383For me it's Motoko Aoyama, and the episode where she gives up her sword to become the bathhouse's maid and Keitaro accidentally pulls down her panties.>>98819717Me too. Hello fellow Motoko bro
Should I proxy a cEDH deck at some point? And if so which one would (you) recommend to someone who plays mostly aggressive and midrange decks in ohter formats?
>>98821275You might have fun, proxying a deck takes me forever so depends on how fast you are at cutting out cards and how good of a printer you use.I personally liked cedh for a while and then fell off around partners, it can be interesting to see whats possible in the format but it doesnt really feel much like MTG, even for someone who likes edh.
>>98821275I suppose its worth trying out at least once. I recommend that with most format's actually. I have no recs , maybe K'rrik
>>98821023Thanks for the feedback anon
>>98821302I was going to use a service like MPC. I just did a test run of Premodern Zombies with them, hoping they turn out good when I get the cards.
the monarch has seized the initiative to venture into the dungeon in order to ascend to the city's blessing whereupon they will be tempted by the ring to achieve max speed, what an enduring story
>>98821364And the ring, as always, promises everything.
My interpretation of the wording of the legend rule would be that it isn't a sacrifice effect since that word isn't used, but would still trigger 'dies' triggers, as 'dies' is simply short for 'put into a graveyard from the battlefield'. Am I correct?
>>98821275Aggro = turbo grixis thoracle turn 2 win. Think Oops all spells in legacy. Netdeck any rogsai decks.Midrange = ramp + hold force of will t1/2 to stop turbo, then go infinite and win on turn 3-4. Netdeck any kinnan deck, but if you plan on playing outside of cedh pods, drop the clones/copy enchantments for more value slop. They exist in a meta game where rhystic study is a copy target at all times.
>>98818239
>>98821408Correct, nothing is sacrificed, but a creature does enter and die in a single state check.
>>98818239Now this is a level of dedication I aspire to
https://archidekt.com/decks/26200963/combo_oolThis will surely be a laugh to make and play.
>>98821570Congratulations on your pile of staples im sure you can win pretty fast
>>98821591Soul is for bracket 2 and 3.
>>98821601>playing anything besides bracket 2 and 3
>>98821732Wanna see what this high 4, or even CEDH stuff is all about.Don't think my deck will win a whole lot in CEDH but might as well try.
>>98821750cedh is kinda fun, I especially appreciate how there's no whining or bellyaching from casuals about "wow bro your commander/cards are too strong for this bracket". Everyone understands that it's a card game where you wanna beat your opponents before they beat you.
>>98821570why craterhoof?
>>98821852Just an alternate wincon if I get into a position where Doom and the spider are exiled, but I can still make a billion insects.
>>98820398I still don't get the two guards riddle
How would I do a viable vanilla creatures Jasmine deck?
>>98821883lots of testing
>>98821883Play B2 and still get your ass kicked a lot. You need to support vanilla with things that don't give them abilities while still finding ways to ramp, card draw, interact, ect... But you can't depend on your vanilla creatures to do any of that shit so you end up with a lot of non-vanilla creatures or other cards which makes it even harder to put vanilla creatures in it.And then someone snipes Jasmine or the fact that every other deck can shit out tokens for no reason and all your vanilla creatures still get blocked anyway. I still use her though.
>>98821883Which one? Because you can easily do Selesnya Morphs with the newer one. It will be underpowered as hell since you're literally playing Morphs but its something.
>>98819495Counter it and have some way of returning it from your graveyard to your handOr have some kind of ability that stops you from losing the game.
>the best oblivion ring is a UB card>can't even recontextualize it because its got ang's name in itLife is suffering
Hey anon looks like you posted in the wrong thread, the crybaby retarded pussies thread is here >>98702105
>>98822171>calls someone else a crybaby >while crying Sucks to suckEdhg is not a pro ub thread
>>98822216It's pro magic cards, which UB is.
>>98822087here you go
>>98822220What a gay way to say something that's not even fully true
>>98822259Based thanksDidn't even think about making it look like it's from a setI think I'll do aetherdrift cause nobody knows that set
>>98822260Seethe your way back into your pissbaby containment board
>>98822220You mean the thread that spent the last decade bitching about wotc printing cards directly into this format?lol newfag
>>98822216It clearly is since you homos had to make a gay little splinter thread to stop people from talking about UB cards.
>>98822273So sorry to let you know thisBut UB is (currently) legal in edh so it's an edh problem
>>98822286>I don't like it, so it's a problem.Git! Git back to your home pissbaby!
>>98822291For someone accusing me of being a babyYou sure are throwing one hell of a temper tantrum lol
>>98822300>>98822171Git! Shoo!
Why didn't Jace transfer his spark into the memorable and beloved character of Loot™ who is clearly meant to be his honorary child and who was hyped up as the big new it thing in Magic's interesting and well thought out world building?
>>98822314That was probably their plan, but he wasn't as accepted as they wanted him to be so they pivoted to yet another woman character they can try and put on a pedestal.
>>98822277I really can't get over how bad ff10 was Sure it arguably had the best atb system but the lack of enemy variety alone negates that factor and then you still have to deal with the inane characters and the dogshit winding plotI swear some people unironically experience Stockholm syndrome when playing games over 40 hours longSee>ff8>ff10>ff13 >especially ff14 holy shit literally not even a game 90% of the time
>>98822314He should have transferred it to Zimone so she could be in every setting
>>98822339>I really can't get over how bad ff10 was stopped reading right there
>>98822356Tends to happen to people who have an insane amount of sunk cost
>>98822356Ff 13 got a lot of heat for being a hallway but ff 10 deserves almost as much
>>98822339I agreeThe 2D games were the best
>Me with my Yuna and Serah deckI like 10 and 13...
>>98821862Consider swapping him for finale of devastation.It does.the same thing as craterhoof (spend big mana to kill everything), but also isn't a dead card in the midgame.
>POV: You're playing blue
>>98822424I will do that. Thanks.
>>98822415I fear you may be a tasteless rube.
>>98822415We know, tourist.
>>98822339You have no idea how bad it could bePray we never get a Persona set
New batch
>>98822636>0 mana dorkAlso>Tap, sacrifice: Add G
>>98822636Put it back in the oven
>>98822636Deku Scrub will end up banned in Modern (compare Elvish Spirit Guide. Mana for nothing is very good).
>ub dick riding >inability to understand the games rules >retarded custom cards>pedo ai slop proxiesim about at my breaking point with this general
>>98822636Please, for the love of christ, go back to the drawing board for the scrub. This would shatter commander over its knee. Guaranteed rhystic study, or any other 3 drop, would be oppressive as shit. This is basically just an elvish spirit guide in the command zone.
>>98822711Oh sorry chud we should be impotently whining about UB and Ur-Dragon all day. That would make the general way better.
>>98822636Nobody's commented on fierce deity yet, which is impressive, because a hexproof 12/11 for six that somehow dodges all color based wipes is only barely less insane than the 0 drop dork
>>98822636Really bugging me that the Goron isn't in White when you've got three colors to work with. That said, the overall design of the three feels messy. It feels like what they should be is creatures with relatively bad statlines (0/1 plant, 1/4 Warrior, 2/1 Merfolk) but decent abilities, which then become more impressive when used as Masks by link. And then they could have Sacrifice abilities as an easy way to put them into the graveyard.The only one that fits those criteria is the Deku Scrub, but that's its own mess for being a 0 mana creature for no reason.
>>98822636What's the point of giving darmani mountainwalk but also an ability that taps him so that you can't use it if he attacks and gets no value out of mountainwalk if he blocks
>>98822711>PedoYou don't know what that word means, clearly.
>>98821570Soul Cauldron and Devouted druid is Nobo
>>98822810I'm aware. Its not there for that.
>>98822711Nothing has been the same since the hack last year
>>98822880This thread became shit for a reason we're not allowed to name.
>>98822636>Darmani isn't white>Mikau's ability doesn't require Wshit design
why is felidar + resto angel + radiant solar insufficient for dack?
For my next deck, I think I'm going to try to recreate ProsBloom in EDH. Just finished a counterpost build that I'm really happy with. I'm really digging decks built off of historically relevant 60 card decks
>>98822711Me but when the /pol/shit made it as hard to discuss the game as it is to discuss video games on /v/. I barely use this thread anymore due to it.
>>98822711Don't let the door smack you on the ass on your way out.
>>98822935is the polman in the room with us right now? show me on the doll where the polman touched you
>>98822982This is what I'm talking about.
>>98822711Complaining will surely help.There's a ub free promised land right here on this site! Why stay someplace you hate?
>>98822935>lurkers when they finally postFeel free to contribute to the discussion of the format at any time
>>98822636>the living rock person that live on a volcano>blue and reen with no red anywhereIs this a joke
>>98823059whole game is a joke
>>98822653>>98822686>>98822703>>98822712>>98822734>>98822738>>98822743>>98822898I put your critcism into place. I think it's generally a lot better now. Although I am a bit sad about that 0 Mana Dork thing. Didn't know it's such an issue but I see the point. Wanted him to be dead before the game even started.
>>98822711Tourists and active threadshitting by the furfag OP hijacker, nothing more.
>>98823128At some point you gotta give it up and admit you're no longer the majority.
>>98823128At what point is someone not a tourist?
>>98823059Lorewise, color identity doesn't neccessarily need to match where you live, though if you're a magic user it impacts what mana you can draw. Beyond that, they're primarily snow-dwelling Gorons, and snow is sometimes considered White (though it is also sometimes considered Blue or even Red). Because Darmani is a spirit, I think it's okay for him to be mono white. Darunia not being Red would be a fuckup.>>98823111Is "Time Travel" an established mechanic? Fierce Deity not being Black (and having Devoid) feels strange. But I guess if this is meant to be like a Commander precon...
>>98823160I'm a tourist after 30 years so 31 minimum
>>98823170unfortunately time travel is an actual MTG mechanic
>>98823160When they act how I want them to act and say what I want them to say
>>98823180>unfortunatelyIt's a pretty neat mechanic and it would be retarded to pretend time travel is somehow not magic. We have entire sets based around it.
>>9882238213 has a boring woman as the lead10 wins because even hallway simulators can be forgiven if you have a good story
>>98820278Working nightshift this week, so I placed my order and went to bed. Woke up to no confirmation email, but my account has the items on Backordered. Motherfuck.Picked up the lands, the Labyrinth pair, the artist set & zombies. Overcommitted, but I like the promo card.
>>98823111>>98823170I still think white doesn't particularly work for link. White is the color of order, something link is usually pretty adverse to. The triforce is comprised of power, wisdom, and courage, and i think that red fits courage far more than white, since red is all about emotion.
>>98823111Honestly get this shit out of the thread, if there isn't a custom card general make one
>>98820540Sorry for the lateness anon, here you go:
>>98823322Make him tough guy
>>98823322Do it yourself, faggot. I like seeing people actually doing something productive instead of bitching constantly. Genuinely fucking sick of this playerbase being fucking armchair designers saying they could do better then never even trying to make something to prove that.
>>98823205>storyOk but were still talking about ff10Even if you like the plot points on paper (idk how) it's told in the most bubbleheaded way possible Its just an excuse for set pieces
>>98823170I thought there needed to be slight overlap with Eldrazi, with Emrakul being in the moon and such.
>>98823332>>98823334>>98822636Same fagging won't get you anywhere
>>98823343a lot can be forgiven if the ending lands with the audience and even you can't deny that 10 had such a powerful ending it spawned an unnecesary sequel that's just pure fanservice
>>98823355Imagine seething this hard that people actually enjoy OC instead of impotent whining.
>>98823355
>>98823355>Some people enjoy seeing people have fun with the hobby in some way instead of just bitter group think?! NOT POSSIBLE!Is it your time of the month or something? Who gives a shit about some custom cards, seriously? Don't take up post counts, we need all of it for whining about UB and prime time definitely being unbanned
>>98822711>poltard poster is also antiubfaglmao nothing we didn't already know
>>98822711Complaining will not help, cuz those who agree probably won't post in agreement and those who don't got free rein to fuck your ass with "STFU, complainer".
>>98823443think i won't leave, think i will remind them they need go kill themselves
I got the fallout mothman deck as a gift and am looking to upgrade it. I am thinking>thrummingbird>evolution witness>evolution sage>karns bastion>kodama of the west tree>muldrotha the gravetide>overgrown tomb>watery grave>breeding pool>icetill explorer>hedge shredder>mindcrank>ripples of potential>mesmeric orb>contentious plan>curiosity>windfall>slip out the backThis is just from friend recommendations, looking online and cards I have. Just focusing on counters, ramp and evastion really. Would those be good you think? I am just getting back in to MTG after a decade away so sorry if I am being retarded.>posted in old thread because I am retarded
>>98823506Spark Double and Altar of the Brood.
>>98823506I always shill this to fellow Mothman players.Mothman's ability does not say you can only target your own creatures.
>>98823559I can't believe I missed this
>>98823506guildpact informant is a second thrummingbirdexperimental augury is better than contentious planI don't know if it came with inexorable tide, but flux channeler, and I personally like dreamtide whalekeen sense is another curiositypersonal preference, you're in BUG, play more stuff that mills yourself and lets you use your GY; plus like one (1) card that shuffles it into your deck when it mills so you can do it again (an eldrazi titan or gaea's blessing for cheap)
This is an OP commander, right?>draw>ramp>no real downsides if built around>above rate on stats
Who's up knighting they garland? Putting together a Garland "Dragon's Approach" deck
>>98823622>green landfallslop>black sacrifice slop >do thing draw card slopWhat do you think?
>>98823656FIRE
>>98823368>hehe>I can inspect element
>>98823616I get decent mill just with the mothman. Some of the stuff is mill stuff too like mesmeric orb and the stuff the other anon suggested. And some decent recursion with things like icetill and muldrotha. >>98823516Oh these are great to get more mill nice. Two mothmen is better than one.>>98823559This feels really powerful but also mean. Lets go.Would Water Crystal be good? For boosting all the incidental mill in to major mill for more mothman triggers.
>>98823390>cant comprehend what off topic meansYou have to be 18 to post here
>>98823647
Does anyone know when the Warhammer precons are getting reprinted?
>>98823710>Two mothmen is better than one.Put this onto your spark double, which every time a land enters and if you can pay, you get another mothman.
>>98820666>can only purchase product if you've bought product before>nobody buys anything because it's a closed loop you can never break Real genius
Is it worth getting into cEDH or is it just infinite turn 2 wins/combosloppa?
>>98823716I DID ITMY WAY
>>98823786No. Even barring shit like ties the metagame isn't particularly interesting.
>>98823786Its playing the game on the stack for turn 2 wins that end up taking 3 hours.
did people really that mindbroken they think new marvel shit being in some darker plane is a win?
It's not in the plane of New York. It looks more magic than Aetherdrift and OTJ. It's an omega win.
>>98823851>No one here has said anything of the sort since the spoilers>Whoa guys, mindbroken much?!Wut
>>98823786No, Canadian Highlander is what is are looking for.
>>98823851Yes, we're finally back to that old school Magic: The Gathering feel.
>>98823877are it though? has anyone? even been?
>>98823786cedh will always be a joke until thoracle and demonic consultation are removed
>>98823851I like the marvel sets. Now what?
>>98823967This post was sponsored by Underworld Breach and Rhystic Study.
>>98823851i dont give a SINGLE FUCK about any of the mahvel sets even when they try to intermingle it with magic lore
>>98823851Better than the Jace set.
>>98823979fuck it they can go too
>>98823967>cedh will always be a joke until thoracle and demonic consultation are removedOkay, they just play labman, doom, or jace, and leveler.
>>98823863yeah 30 different doctor stranges is gunna be HYPE
Any mice tribal deck you guys have tested that worked? It could be any mice commander....
>>98824009Mice are a 60 card format tribe
>>98824009>take the mice>put them in a deckThere you go wasn't that hard.
>>98823994labman has a lot more counterplay than thassas oracle
>>98824027That didn't stop it from being the best cEDH wincon until they unbanned Flash Hulk for 2 years.
>>98823786Do you like:Using only preapproved decklists with basically no room for creativity whatsoever?Results largely not being the result of skill expression, but rather largely due to the rng of being interacted with the least after vomiting out your combo on turn 2? A community that has entirely missed the point of commander and has been the driving force behind it becoming a much faster format?wotc printing stupid new cards into the commander format specifically to make cards that cedhfags will pay $100 for?Interacting with only the most turbo-sperg part of the community when it comes to proxying?If you said yes to any of these, cedh might just be the format for you.
>>98824110>Using only preapproved decklists with basically no room for creativity whatsoever?sounds like EDH in general post-brackets
mice should just be rats
>>98824122Why?
>>98824082im not going to argue with you on this every card that makes you win for decking out was a retarded mistake you shouldnt be rewarded for decking yourself
>>98824122They should all be errata'd into being rodents.
Hero, Villain, Warrior, Rogue, Cleric, Wizard, Human, Alien, Animal, Elemental. Don't need any other creature types.
>>98824188>Get rid of goblinsHaha. No.
>>98824188Dinosaur erasure. Fuck you.
>>98824188>No zombies
What's the difference between Canadian Highlander, 7-Point Highlander and Australian Highlander?
>>98824122>>98824157Don't be silly. It's very important to have Rat, Mouse, Squirrel, Hamster, and Capybara all be different creature types.
>>98824188>Rogueroll into warrior>Clericroll into wizard
>>98824233Three of those are very different in what they do in game and have little crossover. Mice and Rats in game are as similar as Zombies and Goblins.
Does this guy cause salt when he’s part of the 99? I could replace him with someone boring like arcanis.
>>98824360Anything that fucks with people's hands will always cause bad feelings with at least one player.
>>98824360Depends. Are you paying him fairly are are you playing an underground sea, into a dark ritual into a sol ring, and an entomb into a reanimate turn 1?
>>98824377I have piracy and high tide in the deck but that’s pretty much it. It’s mono blue.
>>98824380You're fine.
>>98818058pic related is one of my draw engines in my boros deck
>>98824404he cute
>>98824377Oh but it would be okay if I played a Watery Grave into Dark Ritual, Entomb, Reanimate eh?
>>98822429>regular pod is discussing house banning "can't be countered" spells
ban counterspells and ban everything worth countering
>>98824463>"can't be countered" spellsHow many of those are even flying around and why is that even a discussion, attempting to ban things like that is a slippery slope for the health of your pod
>>98824463>regular pod casually admitting to being bitch-made
>>98824474>How many of those are even flying aroundhexing squelcher, Chimil, and people learning about split second broke half their minds outside of cards that flat out say "this spell can't be countered.""There's no counterplay anymore. Half our decks are bricks."
But the other day you guys said green was the most op color and anyone who plays it is a pubstomper
>>98824493>"There's no counterplay anymore. Half our decks are bricks."Tell your pod full of blue players that there are other forms of removal than just counterspells lmfao
>look inside>it's every free and 1MV counter spell
>>98824463Show them some "exile target spell" and "return target spell to its owner's hand" cards, then tell them to git gud.>t. control player
>>98820029Welcome to Mr. Bones ride
>>98820941that art sucks
>>98824515lore accurate then
>>98822935>muh /pol/shit You lost the culture war, deal with it
>>98824539Proving the point.
>>98824493Do they know that you can Bolt Bend a Dovin's Veto to target Bolt Bend, thereby bypassing it as an uncounterable counterspell?
>>98824560>Do they realize there are more solutions to problems when their first idea is to just ban what gives them a hard timeNo anon.
>>98818058Pic related, I need to get around to proxying her FDN incarnation with this. no idea why they redesigned her into a hag, and then re-redesigned her into an even haggier hag. none of the other FRF khans got that treatment. I guess it's more progressive or something
>>98824599>her
>>98824463Commander players would genuinely be better served with a le cozy everyone wins board gameMagic is PvP
>>98824681Yes.
What are the best commander(s) for Party? Some viable candidates:Nalia de'ArniseBurakos + Folk HeroBurakos + Guild ArtisanThe Destined WarriorTymna + Thrasios (Sadly this is also a really great party commander)Tymna + Rograkh (probably a shit color for party)Tymna + SakashimaTazri, Beacon of Unity
Is that shitskin still trying to flame in these threads? I'm pretty sure i already see him, but i want him to tell on himself.
>>98824744Cool schizo post.
>>98824758And you bark like a good bitch. Thanks for confirming so quickly.
>>98824737only slop eaters use partner commanders
>>98824764I genuinely do not know what you are talking about.
>>98824826unfortunately party is a mechanic about having 4 creatures in play and having 2 creatures in your command zone is half the job
>>98823786Even worse anon, it's about landing a rhystic before someone tries to land their turn 2 combo. If you don't you lose and if you (or anyone) does then prepare to spend 2 hours arguing about whether or not you should pay that 1 mana so some fat retard can draw a card and *maybe* draw the card that will stop the turn 2 win, and then that player will draw his own turn 2 win. It's so combo that it's about being the last combo on the stack. Decklists are extremely homogenized.
>guy wheels when an opponent has smothering tithe out>they jerk each other off with scheming symmetryWhy even bother banning this card, if players want to collude the entire nature of multiplayer will allow them to do it.
>>98824849Apparently you Americans play Commander and show each other your hands, talk about plays, no bluffing allowed, so I don't know why you people are even playing a game at that point. Makes me glad I live in a real country
>>98824849I should run scheming symmetry in more decks
>>98824849if people want to collude they should make it difficult for themselves by getting 2 consecrated sphinxes or wheeling with tithe out instead of needing just one 3 mana sorcery
>>98820629it was really funny to me to see all the seethe for the drop today. i woke up, realized it was drop day, loaded up the site, loaded up my cart, got in prequeue, then checked out less than 20 minutes after the sale started. only saw the complaints after the fact, all the while laughing at the fact that i got everything i wanted. can't wait to play with those artifact lands, baby.
>>98824855They do the same in Europe and Canada.
>>98824882Same. I was in and done in 25 minutes and had no problems. I didn't buy the lands though because I'm not paying 40 dollars for that.
>>98824892only glorious nippon can play tournament cedh correctly
I tried building dacky and I'm too brainlet to resolve his ability and win
>>98824899just show your opponents the flowchart and not waste everyone's timehttps://moxfield.com/decks/vGJ-QYkOiUmGCknsZyCKjw/primer
>>98824894>I didn't buy the lands though because I'm not paying 40 dollars for that.true, a bunch of the OG artifact lands will cost you less than 10 bucks, but the last lair they did with them (called mirrodinsanity, literally the same 5 lands with some pixel art) ended up being extremely lucrative. the cheapest of those, tree of tales, goes for like 15 USD. it was just a smart buy, even if you aren't planning to play with them. i have a breya deck that uses them and i love the art, so i got one for that. the other 3 i ordered was to sit on.
>cast bolt>have a card that says "deals that much damage plus 2 instead">have another card that says "deals that much damage plus 1 instead"So how much damage would bolt do?
>>98824992>>98824992>>98824992new thread
>>988249936
>>98824831it's genuinely funny how easily you are baited with so little effort and how stupid your back peddling is every single time.
