it's official :) edition
>In the same breath that Julie tells her mom she can sorta time travel she tells her mom she's a schizo for believing she's a eincarnated person. I fucking hate this writing.
>>221272128Half of the show is just retarded filler. Almost nothing has happened in this entire season. Why do I keep watching this coal
when I first heard of a show called from starring the waaalt guy I thought it was a joke but I might end up watching this
previous>>221268028
>Bell ringing is back. Based. When wss the last time Boyd did that? I can only remember it the very first episode and when that autist in colony house rang the bell
>>2212722221 episode ago
>>221272221I'll have what she's having
>>221272128I just want to know who the BiW really is and why he seems so powerless. Dude can only appear as an apparition that speaks in riddles, only ever interacting with a person physically when he pushed Tabitha, but MiY can run around causing all sorts of chaos and it's only by sheer luck that he hasn't done far worse shit yet. Why is BiW so useless?
>>221272128if sydney sweeny was hot as fuck
Why did they make write him so stupid
>>221272341Because they need consecutive blunders to keep the plot going.Remember how he kidnapped a woman because a ghost advised him?Very rational behavior.
>>221272244mid-life crisis
>>221272363Because the only way, this should have happened naturally is Acosta finding it while researching and getting killed, which they chose not to, its like the writers keep changing their minds, this was just removing a spare character for shock value.
>boyd literally saved by the biw>doesn't trust victorLeave it to a nog
>>221272430Well whats the plan otherwise, sacrifice Tabitha nd Jade, leave them down there?
>>221272430
>>221272430Boyd is right, trusting the supernatural entities brought them only death.
>>221272450Yup they are important players in the game, they have immunity to the Frombies
> Evil dollsWhere is the 3rd one that never showed up?Where is the one that "quit and moved away" after seeing the other doll stabbed with the totem?> Ghost in kitchenThis weird event was never spoken/shared with anyone of the town.Was it the MiY's way of suggesting that Tabitha should go to the kitchen and stay there?> Sara reappearanceWhat was the point of that all water/poisoning?To see if she can be a pawn again? If so, pawn to what?Her highlights so far in S4 are painting the MiY room in purple (now we know it's not his favourite color - duh!) and keepying an eye on the radio for (morse code?) signals and report back.> Donnas's heart attackWas this just to add some drama and have a reason (must stay in bed) for not having things for her to do?> Julie's abilityApparently dropped already the "time-travel/hair cut future version of her".But in this case that is good thing, because it was a cheap way of copying the much better and successful "Dark".Now she became a meme due to the ridiculous bad wig.> Fatima's GolemWhat was the end-goal for this creation? Keep her busy?Or just a try to bring some pointless religion folclore to the mix?> Acosta as Miss Failure '26She failed to find a getaway of the town.She failed to kill herself, i.e. make Boyd give her the bullets of her gun.She failed to found the photo of the original Sophia, ended up being found by the dumb fat guy with 1 eye only.
>>221272470They were killed in several different lives, the are not invulnerable.
>>221272463But he's choosing to trust the supernatural freaky kids>biw saved him and sara>biw got tabitha out of the forest>biw kept victor alive when he was there all alone>"J-just...j-j-...just listen, okay. Gah *stares off into space for 10 seconds* J-just Victor please...please....please....j-..You gotta go"
>>221272497Jade was said to have been killed by the townspeople in every life. Tabitha we don't know what exactly killed her yet, whether it was the town, the miy, or a fromster, all we know is that Victor found MiY eating her the next morning. But it's safe to assume if Jade is immune to the Frombies as per the script, then Tabitha most likely also is.
>>221272501Because of boy in white, Victor's father is in there with them, trapped.Seems like a negative result to me.Also Tabitha saw the same place as the old man's illusions, so she could also be hallucinating.
>>221272176Exactly why I avoided watching that slop after watching the first episode. I knew it would just be question box after question box with no answers and characters that were just archetypes with little development. The OP's image is what brought me here.
>>221272516The townspeople leaving them in the cavern to starve, would count, anyway they have to move the bones and rebury them.
The sophia horny posts are played out and performative
>>221272522this also makes no sense, the boy in white helps jade ask the right questions, yet doesn't want them uprooting the tree?
>>221272573Everyone, except the crows, serve the man in yellow.And we see him not wanting to kill everyone easily and fast because he prefers to torture them first.So the boy in white giving them false hope serves this purpose.
>>221272168She THINKS she can time travel. She's saying that she herself fell into delusions and it was only fucking with her head. Idiot.
Elgin might be the single dumbest fucker on the show
>>221272620What about that guy that opened the window?
>elgin is actually that stupidHoly fuck why couldn't Sara have just finished him off?
>>221272648He did it for love, dummy.
>>221272648He was dumb but manipulated. Elgin is dumb on his own
>>221272648How can you say noto that face.>>221272660my face between her legs
Julie was in the photo of Sophia that Elgin showed MiY?
No other show in a while made me this uncomfortable all throughout an entire episode. Gut wrenching. I fucking hate Elgin so fucking much he is so fucking retarded it's insaneAlso the most bitchy cliffhanger ever
>>221272128Is this show any good?I remember hearing about S1, but then I heard it was full of a bunch of characters making retarded decisions or not asking the obvious questions.Now I see it's on S4. Is it actually good? Or is it dumb fun?
>>221272769Yeah, isnt she(he) cute
>>221272212>posing next to a giant pooping buttwdsmbt?
>>221272831Comfy, dumb fun. If you are the impatient sort, dont bother.
>>221272128>>221272212>>221272221>>221272660Why is she sooo fucking hot? I want her
>>221272831Dude just watch it either you're obsessed like me and finish it in 2 days or it's meh, i feel there's no in between with this show. Most people who don't like it have been traumatized by Lost which I never watched so just try it. It's a great show with some flaws, but it has sovl.
>>221272573The Boy In White has never helped anyone in a way that doesn't go against the Man In Yellow. They're probably the same people.
>>221272877I saw her first.
>>221272809>my dumb ass sitting here thinking Elgin would be suspicious and immediately begin eavesdropping on Sophia and Klara's conversationI'm so glad MiY might just kill him.
>>221272769
>>221272911I think the writers trolled the audience here. Everyone figured he found out what Acosta was supposed to find all along, and the scene after the dumbass runs to MiY with the knowledge..... Absolute fucking retard.
>>221272877Would you let her in anon?
>>221272831Real answer: Seasons 1 and 2 are highly addicting, season 3 the pacing slows down and half the scenes become meaningless filler and season 4 has been almost entirely meaningless filler. It's become a slog. I'm only still watching for the memes, sunk cost and I really just want to know how it ends.
>>221272963Man, the whole series is like one old school season, why are people so impatient these days?
>>221272128widow's bay vs from is happening in the subreddit too
Can't stand BiW
>>221272877she is a midget. i don't want dwarf sons
>>221272910Nuh uh, I did >>221272953Let me think..>Big boobs>Pretty>Phycho/manipulatorYeah
>>221273009Also>old man in reality
>>221273004Bro isn't even a boy anymore, they have to wrap this shit up before the actor starts growing grey hairs
>>221273008It's called fun sized, if you are dwarf yourself then it can't be helped
Indians and Blacks love From for some reason
>>221273019Is the old man even the "true" form? I thought that was just the previous disguise because of the whole "I can only take the form of people who died here" thing. Don't know why it's the default costume and what the significance of the yellow suit actually is
>>221273000Yeah, I think their marketing team, identified Froms audience as one they could steal, as some are tired of the stalling, very different shows though, not even the same genre, not sure why they think it will work.
>>221272922I see her
>>221273043I do think it's his true form because he is particularly inhumane looking as the old man version, like he's been corrupted just like Fatima. Sophia is fresh.
>>221273042Which are you?
Unironically a lot of shit happened this episode, it was arguably too fast paced actually. They could have made some of it happen in previous episodes
>>221273085Mixed black
Is bitch natty or not?
>>221273070He just likes the man in yellow persona the best
>>221273087Yeah, they just rushed the bones run, somebody remembered to check the plot progression>>221273103Small cock with white skin or big cock with dark skin, this is impotant?
>>221272922>boyd and whats her facetime is a flat circle
>>221273123I was surprised the bones raid happened this episode.Victor isn't gonna try to stop it? Possibly getting interrupted by Henry trying to kill him? I was sure it was gonna happen but it's a bit late now.
>>221272986Filler that's fun and is its own contained story within the larger story is one thing, filler that's just pointless meandering is something else entirely.
>>221273123No cock sorry my dude
>season has solved more mysteries in its first 8 episodes than the entire 3 seasons before combined>episode 9 has more plot than the entire rest of the season combinedHoly shit. I can't deal with the constant ramping up of things happening.
>tree that blocks people on the road is ripped from the root>they are now trying to rip the bottle tree from the roothmm
>>221273162Dont worry, cant be helped, I suppose
>>221273179whoa...
>>221272341Because he's a good, nice person. And he thought he'd found a funny coincidence that would lighten Sophia's day and make her a little less sad in this hell-town where her only family had died just a couple of days earlier.His crime wasn't stupidity. It was compassion
>>221272922That'd be cool. If it's her it makes Elgin even dumber
Boyd was right.If Boy in White wanted to help, he'd have told Victor, or Jade, or Ethan, how to dig up the bones in a safe way that didn't require uprooting the bottle tree.
>>221273154Truthfully I like the atmosphere and characters, not in any hurry and used to watching long series that drag on and on. So yeah, different perpective.
You think the monsters are blocked outside by the magic talisman and plastic door or they'll have no problem entering to then torture Jade and Tabitha in front of Boyd?
>>221273203>I can't tell if it's Julie>but if it is her and Elgin couldn't tell, that makes him dumblmao
>>221273179The answer is obviously to place the bottle tree further up the road so people can't even enter to begin with.
>>221273228Did Boyd ever criticize BiW? Based
>>221273247I actually happen to not have the pic with me unlike Elgin you dumdumb. We see some side profile with extreme low lighting while Elgin had the possibility to see it in full lighting.
>>221273242Are the monsters even interested in killing Jade and Tabitha? MIY clearly isn't, and they usually don't get killed by the monsters.I know Smiley killed Miranda, but it was a specific situation where she was trying to get to the lighthouse, and we know it was unusual already by the fact that Smiley ran which monsters usually don't do. Maybe the monsters are willing to break their own rules to prevent them from getting to the lighthouse.
>>221273268oooh, nice Easter Egg find, is she time travelling?
>>221272833That's not MIY, that's the actual Sophia
>>221272831Wait until the last season (supposedly the next one) is about over so you don't have to wait if you get into it.
>>221273239Fair enough.>used to watching long series that drag on and onSame, but I don't like enough of the characters to just sit with them and I've grown to actively hate some of them because their scenes are so tedious (Ellis and Fatima, the lesbians). If it was all Boyd, Jade and Not Paul Rudd (if he didn't fucking die) I wouldn't mind the pacing so much.
>>221273287I thought the same but the fact that MiY was clearly mad to learn that Jade & Tabitha went down, to me means they're in danger and his plan might be altered.
>>221273287>Are the monsters even interested in killing Jade and Tabitha? MIY clearly isn'tI guess the question is if MiY and the monsters are even governed by the same entity. Do the monsters act like animals on pure killing instinct or is MiY/another entity orchestrating their moves?
>>221273316Fair, Tabitha, annoys the hell out of me.
>>221273316This show is bad at making characters likeable. I didn't feel much when either the chinese grandma or Jim died. It's an art to make characters likeable clearly and really elevates a show
>>221273350Jim, was a cuck and the gramma death scene was epic
>>221273372>Jim, was a cuckWho was Tabitha's bull? I somehow missed this side plot
>>221273326He talked about rituals earlier and they figured it out, the bone extraction might actually work.
>>221273392Jade was her lover though time
I can't figure out MiY's motivation>wants Jade and Tabitha to live>doesn't want them to go through with the bone planWould be funny if MiY was actually trying to break the loop all along but the humans keep shooting themselves in the foot on each iteration
>>221273401Ohhh damn you're smart~~~~
>>221273401It was kind of dumb of him, not to plan for the kids letting her know, his first miss step.
>>221273350Victor is one that used to be likeable but he needs to have his "I'm not a little boy anymore" character arc moment already. He's starting to piss me off. Randall has potential but is currently relegated to Julie's bitch boy duty.Donna's okay as a den mother, but there's not a lot you can do with that role to make it very interesting.
>>221273445He's getting rusty.
>>221273429Maybe the ritual traps them all there, he wants out into the real world.>>221273457Hes getting on in years, but still has a rockin bod and perky tits.
>>221273429I think him not wanting them to get the bones is just a red herring for the viewer, just like him appearing to be scared of the totems
>>221273429I figured he wanted the people to kill one another instead of actually progressing the main quest. What was it he said, the next part is where they tear each other apart? This iteration nobody wants to kill jade for being a reincarnation
>>221273350Oh, and Sara's also decent, but isn't being utilized enough. There's honestly too many characters. Some niggas gotta die soon.
>>221273275It's a polaroid. In the best of lighting it still wouldn't be any clearer than that screenshot.
I think Jade and Tabitha are gonna fuck up their escape plan and require someone else to help them escape, which will count as someone else performing the ritual with them thus the ritual will be done incorrectly
>>221273496He wanted them to mess up the ritual, which might unleash something else.
>>221273429I think the anon here >>221273401 is rightMiY doesn't want Jade and Tabitha to go down because them digging up the bones is actually the right way to do the rituals, he wanted the npcs to go down instead so they get slaughtered. The monsters have avoided Tabitha for sure, idk about Jade but both of them could be immune and their death should be later maybe according to MiY.
Boy in white grows up to be kingpin and break's MiY's back while saying "This is my town"
Can't wait until BiW has a meltdown and reveals his true evil form
>>221273268>>221273288>fatter jaw/chin>jewish noseNot her bros
>Another instance of MIY transmitting his blood to someoneGive me ONE reason to not think Martin was MIY. It's clear as day now. Fuck, the dancer is the same actress as Henry's nurse too.Martin and Ethan's force ghost Jim were both MIY. MIY confirmed this episode he can only shapeshift into dead people, and Jim had just died.Actually, if you look at his transformations sequences, both the first one and the new one, he puts a hand to his mouth first, because he transforms by plugging in someone's tooth, that's why he collects teeth.He said last episode he took a tooth from Jim.
>>221273558That would explain why he wants to stop the bone plan, but the easiest solution to that would be just killing Tabitha, which he could have easily done. There has to be some later ritual for which Jade and Tabitha are important but I guess we aren't supposed to know about that yet. Still wondering what the whole "the townsfolk turn on Jade when he figure out what he is" thing was about.
>>221272128I really really want to have sex > "just bang an escort bro"I want sex without condom so thats a no go
>>221273586For me it's the Victor reveal moment.>Spreads hands, head hanging low, legs becoming longer, claws appear from fingers, a wicked smile shines, horns grow>Do you think that I survived with the monsters because I was good at hiding?
>>221273627>the dancer is the same actress as Henry's nurse too.It's literally not but yeah they do look alike on purpose probably. So MiY gets trapped at some point and becomes Martin? I think Martin was genuinely there so idk explain
>>221273613Thanks for your work
>>221273627Fuck I completely forgot about Martin and the whole dungeon side plot. When does that become relevant again? This season hasn't visited that place at all right?
>>221273656>It's literally notReally? I was sure they were the same.>MiY gets trapped at some point and becomes Martin?I think he was just pretending to be trapped to bait Boyd into helping him. But it's possible Boyd actually unleashed him tooMaybe he gets trapped every cycle and eventually someone unleashes him?Unlikely though since Sara already had voices in S1. I think "Martin" was just bait
>>221273627If Jim isn't Jim then Kathri isn't Kathri and same for every ghost?
How different would this show be, had everyone received a 20 point IQ increase? How would the plot change?
>>221273677Just stole it from reddit, but your welcome
>>221273647Who gives a fuckNot you obviously kek xD
>>221273711MaybeAbby seems special though
>>221273613They might have just messed around with the image to make it more noticeable, but yeah good points.
why want victor dead after 40 yrs, does it have a 40 year cycle?
>Sara said by the end of season 2 that the voices were "mocking Boyd for bringing "it" back to townHMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
>>221273647Go to a South American country, they will charge extra though.
>>221273627makes sense, I'm not sure about martin but the rest fits
>>221273714It'd just be way shorter because they would communicate. Also Jasmine would've stayed outside
>>221272487Whoa whoa WHOA
>>221273644I'm pretty sure it's a 'game' of some variety.So my guess is that he's not 'allowed' to kill Tabitha or Jade himself. Probably why he also considers Tabitha/Miranda a friend.
>>221272746what happened to this monster. hasn't made an appearance since season 1
>>221273714Smart people tend to pull in different directions, theres a reason most successful civilisations had sheep been lead by a strong man.
>>221273809Pregnant and settled down
Actually, maybe Martin wasn't MIY himself but got contaminated by MIY, like Clara passed on his blood to Fatima this episode.The reason why i'm doubting Martin is because he seemed to switch back and forth between "huh who are you are you real are you from town" and "hey what if abby was right oh hey julie give boyd the rope pls"His knowledge is inconsistentBut maybe MIY was controlling him at some points which would explain itHe either had multiple personalities somehow or was fucking with Boyd
>>221272176And everything last season negated the events of season 2.
>>221273809She was the one who was playing dead to stop the ambulance i'm pretty sure
is it confirmd MiY/Sophia dies in the end of S4?
>>221273867No, you're thinking of a different one
>>221273878Can he even die
>>221273895Someone says after the bones are dug up the boss of MiY shows up and kills MiY - but I haven't seen this in the leaks.
>>221273926Stop discussing leak shit retard, nobody cares
What's with the people here sperging out about a simple bikini picture? Why does it make them so ridiculously angry? Are they new to 4chan? Are they from reddit, where they shut down any discussion about the attractiveness of female characters and call any discussion about beauty to be "porn addict talk"? Why?
>>221273943I think people are just sick of seeing the same shit posted every thread
>>221273841I like the MiY controlling him with his blood theory. But at some point Martin says "when you go through the trees, that's when 'they' get you". What was he talking about? I hope the Martin case gets answered and wasn't just random improvised writing.
>>221273943The monsters pretending to be sexy to lure men is part of the show , I guess there are some viewers who like to pretend that this part of the show doesn't exist.
>>221273749MiY is not Martin nor was he never not around. He was on the radio, he was calling the phones, and he was around when Klara arrived to make a deal with her.
So MIY wants the bones to be uncovered, as he told Tabitha himself, but not by Tabitha and Jade? Assuming the reason is "ritual done right", he tried to scare Tabitha away by telling her that they might unleash a new evil, but on the other side he went along with Boyd's plan, maybe not just to send the wrong people to die in the tunnels, but also because the destruction of the bottle tree might be his real goal (BiW sperging might hint at that).
>>221274002Martin is from a time that isn't the present. Boyd in that dungeon was in the past.
>>221273973It has also consistently be shown in all of human history that people get horny, when confronted with death and horror. Not for that of course, but they flee into the arms of a lover to comfort them and follow their biological instinct to replace the family lost with their own. We see this in the Colony House in the first season, but then it's just dropped. From is strangely devoid of sex, romance and jealousy. No one is dating. No one is interested in anyone. Kenny used to be, but that was shut down.The result is a horror atmosphere, which is strangely sterile.
People have theorized shit about this character for a while, even though she has hardly any screentime. I think the writers just decided to take the ideas others were posting and go with it
Questions are answered like never before.
>>221274070But are they though?
>>221274065She went from expendable but likeable fatty to simply expendable fatty
>>221274065fatso didn't seem necessarythe troon in yellow could've just handed over the drink herself or had someone else do it for her without telling them about the blood
>>221274137wat you mean, shes getting out, unless MIY breaks his deals.
>>221274065yea I remember a lot of posting about her being a mole or agent some time back
>>221274207Same with the old lady from seasons 2-3 that came on the bus that fatima stabbed with the shears last season
>>221274206Be funny if she gets it like the fat girl in the walking dead
Is sophia gonna kill elgin
>>221274064Imagine coming to town in the 60s and having wild fear of death free love hippy sex with original Sophia lol
>>221274279I do not fear death, fighting the monsters in glorious combat and dying would gain me a nice place in the afterlife.
>>221274297see you in valhalla my friend
>>221274206Is there one (1) single deal MiY has respected? No.
>>221274279Disgusting. How about "natural slut, who was raised Christian, but finally gets into a relationship and can have as much sex as she wants without any fear of guilt" sex?
>>221274347yeah, thinking about it, he screwed over Sara
>>221274272The fat retard probably gonna get stabbed badly, manage to overpower sophia, escape, then in last pathetic breath yell that sophia is bad. Too late, Sophia activates MiY and kills whoever has been alerted.
>>221274355g-go on...
>>221273887I'd open a window for that one
>>221272212why would MIY choose to take the form of the daintiest girl that ever was there?anyone in fromville can overpower and have his way with her
>>221274465She still has her MIY strength and powers
>>221274279This is the only image of her straight men are allowed to lust forEverything else is A MAN
>>221274297this. I would make a homemade gladius and armor and go beast mode on night then get all the pussy in colony house for the glory and my name would echo in fromville for eternity
>>221274378What people say about her afterwards: "Hmm, I wonder why she is in such a good mood now constantly, when she was such a bitch before."
How many millions do i have to pay to be able to lick her body just once?
>>221274614just invite her to a casting call
>>221274630>listens to all the filth she has to do with the director to get the role
>>221274544Yeah, those slim thighs and perky breasts are so gay.
>>221274659I am the director
>>221274630I'd invite her to the casrtng couch if you catch my whiff
>>221273809>what happened to this monster
>>221274699I am the casting couch, if you catch MY drift.
>>221274614The BiW doesn't want you to know this but the women in Fromville are free; you can just take them
>I have Fatima doing a jigsaw puzzle>I told her it was a cognitive test was I not supposed to bust out laughing? this is like the first line in the episode
>>221274279So, was the real Sophia an adult?
>>221274665in-universe dudeyou are GAY
>>221274792it's a reference to a particularly dumb famous person but that probably flew over your head
>>221274758least not gay irl, like you.
>>221274822I'm only gay on the internet mind you
I am going to put a Talisman around Sophia's neck to stop her from transforming back and to take her powers, then I am going to strip her down and put her in specially prepared glorywall box, where her ass is hanging out and can be used by the towns people to satiate their lust and pay her back for what she has done.
>>221274860Someone starts spanking her and suddenly she turns into the old man again.
Thread started high IQ and is now at a complete brown state
>>221274065She looks like a female version of Jonah hill
>>221274822>>221274814meant for you
>>221274817I don't think that tweet came out before they wrote that episode man
>>221273740His time is up. Ethan is supposed to be the new Victor, the only survivor who gets to alone for years until new people show up and the cycle starts again.
>>221274699>>221274741
>>221274982Be funny, new spin off series, and a family drives into town, and Ethan is there older and Julie back from screwing up time traveling is smoking her weed, with a bunch of their kids
>>221272212damn she's got some nice calves
>>221274923cope all you want
>>221272341Is it really stupidity? Keep in mind the towns people talk about nothing. They never keep each other updated. If he knew that:>someone was in Tabitha's house>someone was in the sheriff's station and stole the clothes of the MIY>the MIY met with Tabitha>etcthen maybe something would have clicked. But he doesn't have access to any information, which would make him even suspect there could be an imposter in town.And that is exactly why communication is so important in these situations. You can't ever beat Secret Hitler or Mafia, if the good people don't honestly share information with each other.
>>221275096go back to your isekai anime nerd
So is this just another LOST or does it go anywhere?
>>221275137Who is even watching out for the new tight underage ass in town, nobody seems concerned, what shes up to, after she recently lost her dad, she just does whatever she wants.
>>221275278that's what elgin shoulda been doing. useless pig
>>221275275just watch it retard
All this horny posting is embarrassing get a hold of yourself it's an attractive woman calm down we don't need to obsess about it every single thread for months
>>221275275s4 has had lots of plots1-3 has barely any though so you'd have to struggle through that i guess
>>221275356go back to r/FromSeries, if you hate heterosexuality so much
>>221275351If it's another LOST then I don't want to
>>221275207Again, cope all you want. That is a man, in-universe. This is the only woman version >>221274279
>>221275275It's nothing like LOST
>>221275207>animeGODS out of the blue
>>221275459wgaf
>>221275481From would be better if it was CGDCT
I don't get why they are always in a rush. We don't even see the monsters anymore, they have protection and food
Is Elgin just gonna die or does MIY have something darker in store for him