Have critics always been hacks?
>>221841766Yes, but now it's even worse because they exclusively judge on how woke it is.
>no the Troy movie is bad cause the Gods are not in it>the Odyssey movie is actually good cause it does not have the Gods in it and its all his imagination from PTSD critics should be shot
>>221841766Ellen Page is seriously Achilles? The half-God legendary warrior Achilles?
>>221841766troy had uttertly terrible dialogue written by the retard jews that made got
It's a fundamentally unserious job, and when the big studios says jump, they'll ask how high.If they don't play ball, they simply won't be invited to any future premiers or industry parties.
>>221841872I remember Ebert had issues with Troy depicting Achilles being introspective and broody for a Greek hero.I guess it's a good thing he never got to see Nolan's Odyssey.
>>221841766The Greeks still appreciate kino>>221841904
>>221841814fpbp. Troy wasn't the best movie in the world, but it was during a time when we got a lot of great movies and adaptations.
>>221841814/Thread
>>221841766I am not pretending Troy is not a shit film.
>>221841814>>221841943Where was all this literally a week ago when Supergirl got bad reviews?
>>221841766Bro I don't care how bad the odyssey is we are not going to go back and say troy was a good movie.
>>221841882but she isnt
>>221841766>>221843861Troy has a lot of problems as a film and it's an unfaithful adaptationnuOdyssey does too, and is also unfaithfulbut ultimately, Troy at least has a few immortal memes, and is a more enjoyable film
>>221843861
>>221844058Troy was not an adaption, it was an imaginaning of how real events took place upon which the homeric tradition was written.
im so sick and tired of chuds and woke retardsfuck all of you
>>221841766It's wild how terrible the armor looks
>>221842998CHUDS ignore evidence against their positions. They’re not intellectuals like we socialists.
>>221841766How is Nolan's Odyssey SO ugly? I don't understand how you even manage to make something that visually repulsive.
>>221841766bottom left should be Hector or another Trojan soldier, not Achilles, if the images are supposed to mirror each other
>>221844937meaningless logomachy, since obviously The Iliad was its main source and not historical/archaeological materials
>>221841766>pretending troy was goodgtfo
>>221841882She's an OC donut steel Mary Sue that replaces Achilles for "reasons"
>>221844937>umm AKSHULLY it was a two week war but also still had the Trojan Horse from the Odyssey
