[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: zzst61.jpg (52 KB, 770x480)
52 KB JPG
>We'll have to separate the children so that Vader can never find them.
>Leia can go be a princess on Alderaan, and Luke... uhh, fuck it, he can live on some desert planet tinkering with scraps
>>
>dishonest
>>
The daughter was raised as the mother was, and the son was raised as the father was. It makes sense.
>>
>>223477046
Anakin grew up as a slave though. Luke didn't.
It may have rhymed to George Lucas but it doesn't make sense
>>
>>223476987
the assumption was that luke will be force sensitive and hiding it in the single planet vader would never want to visit was perfectly reasonable
and leia being royalty would inevitably come into contact with imperial administration
>>
>>223477116
Didn't anyone tell these chuds that the force was female?
>>
>>223476987
There are like milion planets in the universe. They put Leia on a planet that made her a rebel leader and she directly led them to Luke because of Obi Wan.
Pretty shitty plan.
>>
>>223476987
Lucas knew what a straight white man will have to endure in 30 years.

like poetry.
>>
The thing that doesn't make sense is that they don't really even hide Leia. They literally make her a space princess and just change her name and apparently that's enough. So why not just put Luke there too and change his name? Too much of a burden on the family to take a second kid too?
>>
>>223477046
Uncle Owen treated Luke like a slave. You can tell he didn't see the slaves as his equals. Just like American whites didn't start treating blacks as equals when slavery was abolished.
>>
>>223477243

Because Leia was not Luke’s sister when Ep4 and 4 were made, it’s a retcon of Ep6, Lucas never planned "I am your father" and "Leia is my sister"
>>
>>223477243
theory is that Skywalker is a common name.
>>
>>223476987
>"I will take the child and watch over him"
>stops watching him and goes on an adventure cross the galaxy

Disney Star Wars, what else...
>>
Luke was placed in an environment that would facilitate his growth into eventually becoming a Jedi. Leia was placed in an environment that would facilitate her becoming a political operative against the Empire. Both served these purposes well and placing either in the other's position would have undermined that.
>>
>>223477248
Because they are not equal
>>
>>223477503
How did Obi-Wan know their natural talents and dispositions when they were newborn babies?

>the force showed him

Fuck off.
>>
>>223477243
Bail Organa wanted a daughter, that's literally it.
>>
>>223477243
I think people forget that almost everyone in Star Wars lives in different solar systems. Its stupid easy to hide something or someone in that world you could put them anywhere in the galaxy and go lifetimes never getting anywhere near them in a search unless you had their exact location. This is why they added that tracker thin in the Mando show otherwise it would just be too bs to assume he could just batman every target and find someone in another spiral arm.
>>
>>223477623
>Bail, can you help me hide the Skywalker twins?
>Certainly. I'll take the little girl :)

Maybe Luke was the lucky one after all.
>>
>i'll hide the boy with Anakins only living relatives, he'll never think of looking there
>>
>>223477578
>the force showed him
>Fuck off.
I mean sensing that someone is strong in the force is more than established throughout the series, otherwise it's hardly a huge gamble that the male child would be the better bet for becoming a powerful warrior while the girl goes into deceitful politics
>>
Guys nobody was looking. Everyone thought the kids were dead. Am I the only one here that watched Star Wars?
>>
>>223477578
I donn't think it's necessary that Obi-Wan knew in advance. Luke was the boy so it was obvious he would be more fit to be a warrior, which left Leia with the other position
>>
>>223477088
>Anakin grew up as a slave though.
Did he?

>Is raised by his mother
>In a huge multi-room house, with no oversight whatsoever
>Can invite guests into his house
>Has the free time to assemble a droid and a racing pod, and for whatever reason they count as his property, not Watto's
>Has lots of friends.
>His "slave labor" is working as an apprentice in a junk shop. Irregularly, because we have plenty of scenes of him just being by himself and doing whatever he wants during the daytime.
>No mention of any physical abuse he or his mother has received
>In fact, his mother's misfortunes have started after she became a free woman

Anakin had it better than a lot of children in the galaxy, and definitely had the best life any slave in the galaxy. I am not confident Luke had it better than his father.
>>
>>223476987
I've unironically ripped off the Obi-Wan poster I had up on my wall since 2007 because of this piece of shit show
>>
>>223477921
you had an Obi Wan poster on your wall for almost two whole decades?
>>
>>223477489
why do people even waste time with disney slop? how many times do they need to spit on the source material?
>>
>>223477993
That's how much I couldn't be bothered with redecorating the walls of my man-cave until this little turd hits the screens
>>
>>223478031
Just in time to fill that empty space in your wall with a brand new Episode X Rey poster anon!
>>
This show could have been good or at least decent if not for the Lil' Leia/Darth Shawonda shit. It only needed to arrange a simple grudge match between Obi and Vader, and that would have satisfied PT fans and I think a good amount of OT fans too. But no, you can't have that, Star Wars must be bad because that's what the new rulebook says.
>>
>>223477451
That's very nice headcanon for little babies. It's literally called The Skywalker Saga. This shit isn't like "oh there's a bajillion of them! It's just like being called Smith or Gonzales!" No, when someone says Skywalker, they know exactly who is meant. Stop making excuses for retarded retcon writing and just accept that it's terrible



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.