[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 184623872341234.mp4 (1.56 MB, 1280x720)
1.56 MB
1.56 MB MP4
Did Galadriel really have wet dreams about Sauron in the books? Can LOTR/Silmarillion lorefags chime in?
>>
What a tremendous waste.
>>
>>224275338
Man, she is ugly. At least she seems to have a nice ass, do
>>
>>224275393
fuck you i wanted to be first to reply itt
>>
Millions spent on some idiots fan fiction for shipping.
>>
>>224275338
>Can LOTR/Silmarillion lorefags chime in?
>>
Why don't they make their own fantasy show with a Dark lord falling in love with the lady of the light instead?
>>
>>224275338
It's against the lore of Tolkien. Elves fall in love only once in their live time an marry that one love. The don't lust for other people.

The exception was Finwe who married Indis after Miriel, his first spouse who died after she had born Feanor. And Feanor is the dude who made the Silmaril which Sauron's master Melkor desires so much that it caused several wars and tragedies.

Compare "Morgoth's Ring", chapter "laws and costumes among the Eldar"
>>
Does the first season and the series get better? Almost fell asleep to the first episode. Galadriel was cool but couldn't relate to much else
>>
>>224275338
Why does she look like she just came up from a party prematurely ended by sudden fire? What's with the glittery top?
>>
>>224275338

No.
>>
Women turn everything into a Mexican novela
>>
>>224276295
It an utter fanfic about shipping Galadriel and Sauron: https://youtu.be/Nem9U_cB8ho
>>
>>224276485
yeap
and its good
>>
>>224275338
>Middleearth
>woman wearing pants and short sleeves, lying on a sofa
wtf
>>
>>224275338
why is she wearing normal modern clothes? Was this an isekai all along?
>>
>>224276178
>"laws and costumes among the Eldar"
what do their costumes look like?
>>
>>224276178
I'm sure exceptions can be made for maiar
>>
>>224276815
Kinda gay, ngl
>>
Yeah this fat, lesbian looking, Nintendo Switch enthusiast is a dark lord of Sauron's. Sure. And I'm Thor. I should literally be Thor in the next marvel movie
>>
File: marnukh.jpg (112 KB, 1920x800)
112 KB JPG
Based orc
>>
Do people actually watch this shit?
>>
File: 1794653883.jpg (427 KB, 1622x996)
427 KB JPG
>>224276994
we find him weird
but if they give him better styling as the plot progress to not look like a boy
which so far was required so that we could see it from black elf perspective.. the boy he knew once...
well if they do real styling on him he will be heartthrob evil guy that women would get wet over
>>
>>224276994
He just needs to lose some weight and he'll be fine
>>
>>224277006
S1 and S2 had good finales
the confrontations between sauron and galadriel were great
its not some amazing show, its not GoT or Breaking Bad or True Detective S1,...
but very very shows are good, so even mediocre stuff you like
but do tell which shows of the last 3 years you really recomend
>>
>>224277073
forgot to mention im trans
>>
File: 18246238237234.png (397 KB, 612x612)
397 KB PNG
>>224276994
This kid is supposed to be the Witch King? LMAO!
>>
>>224277073
>but do tell which shows of the last 3 years you really recomend
Suspicious defensive answer
>>
File: Fbyu2xCaIAAsesz.jpg (606 KB, 1896x2048)
606 KB JPG
>>224277097
its the truth... the show is not great but its watchable when you skip negro dwarf parts
but lot of mindless NPC raging in comments acting as if its total garbage have nothing really to say
and a simple question which shows of the last few years they liked completely utterly crashes their NPC programing
>>
>>224277127
you like rings of power = youre a gay retard
simple as that
>>
>>224277138
>>
>>224277152
time to go contemplate how you developed such shit taste
>>
>>224277138
I am gay but I'm not a retard
>>
>>224277152
If your only point is that everything else made in the last few years is just as bad, then even if you just take that as absolute truth that doesn't make a case for it. There's so much older shit to go through, and it's not like Rings of Power is something to talk to coworkers about on lunchbreak any more than some old series. You're actively contributing to everything being shit by encouraging people to watch this.
>>
>>224275338
îmagine watching this
>>
>>224275338
Haladriel nation.... we just keep winning!
>>
Wasn't Galadriel already married? Where's her husband?
>>
>>224275338
Is she wearing yoga pants? lmao
>>
>>224275338
we can't talk about you know who but you can talk about this fanfic garbage.
this is truly the darkest timeline.
>>
why the fuck is she wearing a shirt?
billions spent on this show for cartoon network live action tier costumes
>>
>>224277127
I just expected more.
They threw a billy dollars at the IP that is the backbone of an entire genre and what do we get?
The "epic battle" at the end of s1 all of the southlands is like a hundred people with 200 more from neumenor. The scale is too small for that money.
Then we get the ageless elf falling for a single mom.
And the cherry on top is the king of gondor getting thrown off boat team for not holding a rope then crying in public about it.
>>
>>224275338

No there is no relationship between galadrirl and sauron in the books
>>
>>224276178
>The exception was Finwe who married Indis after Miriel, his first spouse who died after she had born Feanor.

Not only that, for some unknown reason she also refused to be reincarnated.

For those of you who don't know: ALL Elves are immortal, not just biologically, but de facto. Even if you kill them, they spend some time in the Hall of Mandos and then come back to life. Miriel was the only Elf in history who refused that.

Personally I think it's the weakest part of Tolkien's lore since it removes the weight of any Elvish death.
>>
>>224277086
No, the witch king was a thing before nazgul
>>
>>224275338
I didnt know human beings could jump five feet in the air, amazing... I hope sauron wins
>>
>26 minutes of this
and I'm so fucking bored
>lame map animation
>extrmeely gay intro sequance for Celeborn
>garbage larping battle sequance with 10 guys and costumes that look like they came straight the factory
>galadriel fight where her leg isn't broken despite horse falling on it
I'm going to rewatch breaking bad for 5th time, I get more entertainment value from it
>>
morf sexo
>>
She's become a landwhale now lmao!
>>
>>224276485
No, even bad fanfic writers are fans of the material. RoP writers ain't fans.
>>
I'm still watching but it's really bad

>cart holding Elendil prisoner is shown racing away from Anarion, after an unexpected ambush
>somehow Anarion manages to not only catch up but prepare another ambush along the road

>implying you can't see the rugpull of the friendly orc only pretending to betray Galadriel and whats-his-face in the fortress
>>
File: 1793494114185863.jpg (240 KB, 720x594)
240 KB JPG
>>224277968
>Miriel was the only Elf in history who refused that.
Based chudette.
>>
>>224277127
>Rings of Power
>The Odyssey
What's the deal with such shitty cosplay-tier costumes these days? They're spending hundreds of millions of dollars on this shit, but can't even bother buying a properly made suit of armor for the star?

Like, just look at this shit! They've got Galadriel wearing chainmail-print yoga pants, and grey cloth gloves to try to hide that the "gauntlets" lack articulated joints.
>>
Please understand, Sauron is VERY sexy. Part of his immense powers is being very sexy.
>>
>>224276178
>>224277968
>she also refused to be reincarnated
So:
>this NEVER happens
>except for the time it did, under very similar circumstances
Galadriel has no reason to think Celeborn is locked up in Gundabad, as far as she knows he's just living that suite life with Mandos refusing to be reborn.
>>
>>224275338
>Did Galadriel really have wet dreams about Sauron in the books?
No. That's just Amazon raping Tolkien's corpse by doing whatever they want to his creation. Remember Tolkien said evil cannot create, and can only consume and mock what the forces of good create.
>>
>>224275338
dem rangs was made for wine aunts and single mothers who lust for evil men and are appeased knowing an angelic elf falls for an evil man too
>>
>>224279505
Anon, what Miriel did was such a shocking event the Valar gave her husband special permission to remarry. It hasn't happened before or since.

Besides, if Galadriel ACTUALLY thought her husband was killed she would've travelled to Valinor and check whether he has reincarnated or is still in the Halls.

Remember that during the Second Age they could travel freely to and from Valinor.
>>
>the rings of power are already evil despite the fact that sauron hasn't even made the master ring yet
They're throwing all the logic overboard just to have their gay climax at the end where he finally forges the one ring
>>
>>224277731
>I can believe in mithril shirts but can't believe in lycra
ngm
>>
>>224279556
>she would've travelled to Valinor and check whether he has reincarnated or is still in the Halls.
She only left Valinor a few years ago in the show. Celeborn's been considered dead in the show since the First Age, he was thought to have died in the Great War against Morgoth. She knows he's been dead for a very long time and hasn't been reborn, and you can't just go and have a look around the halls to see who's in there. The only sensible conclusion is that he's biding his time awaiting judgement.

I admit that the plot of the show has some problems for me. Marnukh says that Gundabad has been reopened after having been abandoned, in which case who's been keeping Celeborn prisoner all this time? But I don't question Galadriel falling in love with Sauron, a Maia whose whole thing is deception, corruption and spiritual domination.
>>
>>224277085
That was obvious, as always
>>
File: images (1).jpg (33 KB, 519x385)
33 KB JPG
>>224277086
>>So, Witch King was never young?
>Nope!
>>
>>224279695
>Celeborn's been considered dead in the show since the First Age, he was thought to have died in the Great War against Morgoth. She knows he's been dead for a very long time and hasn't been reborn, and you can't just go and have a look around the halls to see who's in there.

No, but you can ask literally any of the Valar present, or the recently reincarnated Elves, whether Teleporno Dearest is there.

The only Elf in the Halls who is unapproachable is Feanor, after all, whose spirit burns so hot nobody can get close.
>>
>>224278115
>I'm going to rewatch breaking bad for 5th time, I get more entertainment value from it
I bet you do. I bet you can quote whole scenes to yourself.
>>
>>224279928
no
In fact, I seem to have terrible sense of timing scenes.
Like scene where Hank arrests the mexican clearer, I thought was in very early season 1, but it actually mid season 2
>>
>>224277182
I've been watching Barney Miller
>>
>>224277073
Just imagine this being applied to literally anything else.
>Eh, it's not an amazing beer, but so very few beers are good afterall. I'll keep drinking it.
>>
>>224277127
...as you post gym leggings with armor painted onto them.
>>
File: 1794554617944385.gif (393 KB, 640x360)
393 KB GIF
>>224275338
>untold billions spent on the shittiest AO3 tier fanfic slop for middle aged frumpy women to fingerblast their putrid front holes too...
No wonder JRR Tolkein's kids are fucking pissed at the way they've handled this.
>>
I'm rewatching all the LotR "Making of" docs and it's amazing how much pride and effort went into every single piece of those movies.
>>
>>224276994
they'll introduce Morgoth as a shota in the next season
>>
>>224280506
That's literally why Budweiser not only exists but was for two decades until recently the most widely consumed beer in America
>>
>>224280627
>until recently
You can't even maintain your point long enough for a compound sentence. Yeah, Lord of the Rings used to be a universally beloved franchise....until recently.
>>
File: 1785068010428934.png (1.51 MB, 1850x1163)
1.51 MB PNG
>>224277086
No it's going to be this nigga on the right count on it
>>
>>224280639
By "recently" I mean this time last year, and the parts about "last two decades" and "most widely consumed beer in America" are still true, and still prove your point wrong.
>>
>>224280656
Is there a huge times kip between season 2 and 3?
>>
>>224280681
McDonald's must be the best food ever.
>>
>>224280735
5 years lol
>>
>>224280735
5 years, which is not much in elftime but a decent chunk for everyone else
>>
>>224280786
Morf spent those 5 years eating pizzas
>>
>>224280814
Women generally put on weight after a bad breakup so that part is realistic
>>
File: 20261114_172521.jpg (1.66 MB, 4000x1848)
1.66 MB JPG
I want to turn this shit off already, is there any point continuing?
>>
>>224280784
5 years in normal time is 5 centuries in Tolkien time
>>
>>224280954
The nigga elf dies trying to save a good orc
>>
>>224280954
...what? If you don't like it go watch NASCAR or something, who cares its just tv
>>
>>224280746
No, it's just fine, but a lot of people eat it
here's a little reminder of what your point is supposed to be, since you keep forgetting
>>
>>224281482
Yes, I'm well aware of what my point was. Let me clarify it for you: you come across as a very weird person saying the shit you say. Imagine sitting down at a bar and someone orders a Bud and they feel so insecure about their choice they feel an explanation to justify it is necessary.
>>
>>224277968
If I remember correctly there were two reasons - she was either too tired after giving birth to Feanor and wanted to rest in the gardens of Lorien forever or she refused to come back because Finwe would have ended up having two wives which would have been awkward. I can't remember which reason Tolkien chose in the end.
>>
>>224281501
I mean, that's not what your point says, but OK. I'll let you pretend. It's very usual for people to drink a beer and say something like "wow, that's terrible". "Wow, this stuff tastes like piss". It's very common at parties and social events, especially in circumstances where the beer is warm. It's something people say to each other. I was just at a birthday party a few weeks ago, when I came in the host offered me a trendy IPA from the fridge, then said something along the lines of "when this stuff runs out, there's a slab of shit beer out in the garage" (it was Michelob). The point is, people can and do frequently make decisions through the lens of the mindset that something is not great, but it's not terrible, and it's available and I want something like it, so I'll take it. It's very, very common.
>>
>>224281608
Maybe you should just consume what you actually enjoy?
>>
>>224280954
No, you've already given Amazon a viewer metric they can use to pretend anyone's watching this trash.
>>
>>224281617
You can't always get what you want
You can't always get what you want
You can't always get what you want
But if you try sometimes
You just might find
You get what you need

You must live in either a very wonderful world where the things you enjoy are always readily on offer or a very ascetic one in which until something that appeals strongly to you comes along you just sit cross-legged in silence, waiting.
>>
>>224281608
I don't know what kind of subhuman trogs you hang out with, but usually when people say those things about something they're consuming they STOP consuming it and go look for something better. I don't think I've ever seen someone say "this beer tastes like piss" and keep slurping away at it unless they were already so drunk they could barely stand - is that your argument, that anyone who actively consumes Dem Rangz is mentally impaired at the same kind of retard levels as someone who's falling-down drunk?
>>
>>224281608
Do you live in a dry county or something? Maybe I'm just very fortunate because there are like 100 places near me I could get a wide selection of beer.
>>
>>224277127
>the show is not great but its watchable
Why watch it if it's not great? Are your hours on earth not precious to you?
>>
s3e1 fucking sucked

does it get any better?
>>
>>224281574
>she was either too tired after giving birth to Feanor and wanted to rest

That was the reason she chose to die and go to the Halls in the first place. We don't know why she then refused to ever come back, even though both the Halls AND Valinor itself have a regenerative effect on an Elve's fea (spirit).

>she refused to come back because Finwe would have ended up having two wives
No, Finwe was allowed to remarry via a special proclamation when his first wife made it clear she will never come back.
>>
File: 18234672384223.mp4 (1.68 MB, 1280x640)
1.68 MB
1.68 MB MP4
>>224279555
What I don't get is why didn't they just make their own romance fantasy franchise with Amazon's money instead of desacrating Tolkiens work?
>>
>>224282202
Because anything LOTR can sit on streaming services next to the movies for the next 50 years and get clicks unlike groggbog the slawglok slayer
>>
>>224281806
no
>>
>>224276994
The numenorian gulag that his character has spent for the past 5 years apparently fed him well.
He probably wouldn't have looked all that bad and dorky if the actor had put in the effort to have a lean face.
>>
File: 1793976891109360.jpg (98 KB, 960x720)
98 KB JPG
>>224276295
>Galadriel was cool



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.