[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: images.jpg (43 KB, 783x392)
43 KB JPG
I finished the books recently and decided to rewatch the show and it kinda cemented how dumb the Starks actually are, both in the books and the show.
Ned was a retard for trusting Littlefinger and telling Cercei about him knowing that the kids were made from incest
Cat was dumb for letting Jamie go, thinking the Lannisters would do the honorable thing and let Sansa and Arya go in return
Robb was SO dumb for multiple reasons:
1. He sent Theon back to the Greyjoys
2. He never told Edmure about his plan to trap Tywin
3. He killed Rickard Karstark, basically making 50% of his army vanish overnight
4. He married Jeyne instead of the Frey girl because of ''her honor'' and such, eventually getting himself killed because of that

I really wanted to like the Starks, but they make so many dumb and foolish decisions I could not have cared less when they died.


Jon is still the GOAT tho
>>
>>224278826
The entire point of the Starks was to demonstrate how Medieval notions of honor and morality can't meaningfully persist in a world governed by realpolitiks. They're not retarded so much as delusional.
>>
>>224278826
wow, it's almost like hindsight is 20/20
>>
>>224278826
They just retconned Tony Stark in Vision quest where everything he ever made was cause of a proud black woman who invented his AI tech.
>>
>>224278993
you dont need hindsight to realise some of their decisions were retarded as hell, even IN UNIVERSE. Robbs men tell him to spare Karstark but he ignores them. EVERYONE thought Cat lost her mind because she freed Jamie. Littlefinger told Ned he shouldn't have trusted him
>>
>>224278935
not in the books
>>224278826
robb was like 14 and grieving for his worst decisions, also drugged
cat was a histrionic grieving woman (also not a stark)
ned didnt trust lf, he was just ok with getting killed and the only thing that screwed up his plans was sansa
>>
>>224278935
Wait, so I was just watching Don Quixote with more rape?
>>
>>224279039
no you were watching incoherent jewish fanfiction
>>
>>224278826
>3. He killed Rickard Karstark, basically making 50% of his army vanish overnight
he was 100% correct about killing Rickard. The Karstarks were going to betray him no matter what he did. They already did in the first place
>>
>>224278935
>Medieval notions of honor and morality can't meaningfully persist in a world governed by realpolitiks.
>>224278826
Except it doesn't work because of the egregious stupidity unrelated to "muh honor".

Catelyn should have been forcibly escorted back to Winterfell and thats that. Robb should have married a Northern woman, possibly Alys Karstark.

As far as Ned goes? He should have just left. Preferably the moment Catelyn makes her presence known. Bring her up to King Robert, tell him things up North need attending and you already disagreed with what was going on. If he insists, tell him you will share some of the details but only out in the field, with his Kingsguards near and no one else.

Not leaving the moment he had the notion to do so was his biggest mistake. Not ordering Stannis to come back was another one, as was not asking the Valemen who were on hand thanks to the tourney to join him. Ned made plenty of mistakes that weren't about honor, just being played like a fiddle.
>>
>>224278826
GRRM is a hack fraud weirdo his books are boring as shit
>>
>>224278826

Ned told cersei because he didn't want her kids to be killed
>>
>>224279075
>he was 100% correct about killing Rickard. The Karstarks were going to betray him no matter what he did. They already did in the first place
Idk, I find that a big part of them betraying Robb was him killing their lord. He could have just imprisoned him and the Karstarks WOULD have had to fight for Robb, unless they wanted their lord to die
>>
>>224279124
>GRRM is a hack fraud weirdo his books are boring as shit
to me, a storm of swords is one of the best books I have ever read. It's extremely entertaining and I finished it in like 10 days
>>
>>224278993
it's 2026 retard
holy shit you redditors are something else
>>
>>224278826
It's almost like the entire point of the Starks existence is to show doing the right and honourable thing in ASoIF gets you punished
>>
>>224279329
>It's almost like the entire point of the Starks existence is to
*produce Lyanna and Bran
>>
>>224278826
Ned never told anyone Jon Snows origin right? Not even Cat?
>>
>>224279496
The only other person who knows is Reed and not because he was told but because he was right there to witness it
>>
>>224279565
your Bloodraven?
>>
>>224278826
>Cat was dumb for letting Jamie go
It was less dumb than her starting whole war of the Five Kings by kidnapping Tyrion on a random hunch.
>>
File: D6-hqFnXYAYNrN9.jpg (62 KB, 1280x720)
62 KB JPG
>mfw i have to deal with my retarded sister and her dumbass kids
>>
>>224279565
>>224279496
>>224278826
there is also the chance that Jon Snow's mother is in fact Ashara Dayne, and that Lyanna's child was Daenerys. Or perhaps both Lyanna and rhaella had stillbirths and Dany is some dragonseed picked up off of Dragonstone and passed off as a princess.
>>
>>224278826
>I finished the books recently
Lol
What a retard
Lfmao, even
>>
>>224279278
Based. Storm of Swards is hands down the peak of the series.
>>
>>224279697
Edmure ''THE GOAT'' Tully
>>
>>224279721

Dany is a random lyseni whore groomed into a ruse by illyrio and viserys
>>
>>224278826
Robb is like a 16 yo boy in the books, so green he pisses grass. He is not supposed to be all that smart, except as a battlefield commander where he is a bit of a prodigy. No wonder he starts fucking up when other kinds of tactics and scemes get involved.

Ned is less forgivable imo, but most of his mistakes are made in the first book and then he dies. In the first book asoiaf was still a quite simple subversion of classic fantasy tales (or just fantasy dune) and not this standalone, realistic and realpolitic infested fictional universe.

You can tell George tried to retconn the starks in fire and blood by making a lot of the historical starks scheming bastards. Cregan stark for example is one of the most cuttroat politicians in asoiaf history and the only real "winner" during the dance.
>>
File: 80848.jpg (118 KB, 860x821)
118 KB JPG
>mogs ASOIF

Nothing personnel, George.
>>
>>224279779
Cregan would have been better had he simply kidnapped the remaining Targaryens and took them home with him.
>>
>>224279721
>there is also the chance that Jon Snow's mother is in fact Ashara Dayne
"people" like this are the reason of scheming lesbo Elia btw
>>
>>224279745
Respectable, but for me it will always be feast for crows: the book that, over the years, managed to go from being my absolute least favorite to the soul of the series.
>>
>>224278826
At first it looks like Robb wins the battles but loses the war, but at the end of the ride a Stark sits on both northern and southern throne and even north beyond the wall, while Lannisters, Targaryan and Baratheons are all wiped out.

Starks just fail upward.
>>
>this animal is dumb and bad because despite its primacy in its natural habitat it performs poorly in its complete opposite habitat
bravo
>>
>>224278826
Honour cost them dearly but paid off in the end (even though that was very shit)
>>
>DARKSTAR, WHO OF THE NIGHT!
nice 'realistic' fantasy series, george!
>>
>>224280846
Except Bran is dead and his body is puppeted by Bloodraven as an immortal God-king. Sansa is queen of an empty wasteland. All towns and castles have been destroyed. All farms and families have been ravaged. Crops destroyed and no harvests ruined. All riches have been taken or or squandered. She is queen of ashes. She has no family, no husband, no heirs, and all her best, most experienced people are dead. As a new, fledgling kingdom, with no real army and nothing to offer, they will desperately need the southern kingdom's help and they will be gouged to hell and back. She was better off still being a part of the kingdom since it was in their best interest to help rebuild and repopulate it. Instead, any of the southern lords can ravage the north with impunity since who is going to stop them and they are not allies. It will also build massive unrest with all other lords since why did the sister get her own kingdom but places like the iron islands are still forced to remain under the boot. The whole thing is played off as a "good ending" simply because they have plot armor, magically regenerating armies, and nothing that happened on screen matters.
>>
File: IF.png (2.42 MB, 1440x1116)
2.42 MB PNG
>If Daemon had ridden over Gwayne Corbray...
>if Fireball had not been slain on the eve of battle...
>if Hightower and Tarbeck and Oakheart and Butterwell had lent us their full strength instead of trying to keep one foot in each camp...
>if Manfred Lothston had proved true instead of treacherous...
>if storms had not delayed Lord Bracken's sailing with the Myrish crossbowmen...
>if Quickfinger had not been caught with the stolen dragon's eggs...
>>
>>224281156
>She has no family, no husband, no heirs

Doesn't seem to stop the unsullied from starting their own house on deadly disease island.
>>
File: emptystomach.jpg (66 KB, 1280x720)
66 KB JPG
>>224279880
And then those COCKSUCKERS D&D RUINED MY JAMIE ARC!
>>
File: IMG_1575.jpg (68 KB, 417x800)
68 KB JPG
>>224281156
>Except Bran is dead and his body is puppeted by Bloodraven as an immortal God-king
Kill yourself targfaggot



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.