Its actually kino
>>224281700First one is goodSecond one was okayThird one is a mess
>>224281798
>>224281700They're all good, the book isn't any better.
They’re better than the books.
>>224281700I like how the extended version of That Battle of Five Armies got an R rating.
Is the fan edit worth watching?
>>224282175>fan edits>ever worth watching (unless they’re YouTube memes played off as a joke)Nginmuh
>>224282122The Marvel team up at Dol Guldur was so fucking stupid
>>224282089>>224282110
>>224282122HOLY KINO
>>224281798fpbp>>224282175depends on how much of a book purist you want to befor me the only part of the trilogy i disliked was forcing in the she-elf bullshit since it was a complete fabrication, an oc donut situation. otherwise i enjoyed peter adding in appendices shit to pad the runtime since the studio demanded another trilogyl, like the white council going to face the necromancer at dol goldur, that shit was tight.but if you want it to be as close to the book as possible then yes one of those four hour "tolkien edition" edits is worth a go, just watch whatever the most popular or newest version is.
>>224281798First one is trash.Second one is trash.Third one is trash.
>>224282122
>>224282432I might check it out. The white council stuff was fun tho
>>224282276I loved that shitThey saved mithrandir :')
>reusing nazgúl theme for thoron charging>go pro river (coming to a theme park near you!)>elf chick>legolas??>you must meet an 8 year old ranger, my son..>mario jumping>lava statue attack>reusing galadriel yelling effect>"because it's real">not! grima takes up more screentime than most characters>saruman kung-fu fighting ghosts with his staff>that fucking cgi goblin king>twirly bird ballista stopping a single wave of arrows and the elves just stop>DUNC worms bursting out like a fucking nydus network>orc jumping up through ice like he just double tapped Bthere's so many other things but i don't feel like writing more
>>224282674LEAVE SAURON TO ME
>>224282482You have low IQ>>224282674You have VERY low IQ
>>224282122>the whole 20 minutes of this shit>the Goblin King scene>the barrel-riding scene>the tactical bear drop
>>224282674>air dropping bjorn like it's TBC WoW feral druid>"there could be anything down there">gandalf's staff charge ran out like it's skyrim>dwarf shield wall? fuck that WE ELVES LET'S GOOOO>gandalf wants to fuck galadriel (dont blame him)>bat taxi killing spree>tokyo drift war wagons lmao
>>224282122>The Battle Of The Five Hoursholy fuck that shit went on waaaaay too long
>>224282862All those scenes are pure kino
>>224283888ok buddy
I don't get the hate The Hobbit trilogy gets. It's not LOTR, but it's not in any way bad, it's at LEAST a 7/10.
>>224281798Even the first one has too much filler, cringe comedy, and cartoony CGI action scenes. Only good scene was the riddle contest with Gollum.
>>224284050Why should I watch a Marvel-ized version of Lord of the Rings?
>>224284236I can't imagine unironically hating these movies. It's not the best thing, but it's pretty fucking good. There's no filler that's unwatchable and terrible, or cringe you wouldn't normally encounter in a movie.
>>224284269No one is forcing you to watch anything anon. "Marvel-ized" makes no sense beyond the memes, it's just a nice movie, stop looking at everything in black and white.
I thought the first one was really good, felt like a good DnD movie. Maybe it can all be edited down to a good 2 and half hour movie.
>>224284277>I have low standards so this slop tastes good>>224284295It's a boring and embarrassing movie. Peter Jackson phoned it in and should be ashamed.
>>224284277it's not hate really, just eye roll inducing and cringe for myself. studio greed ruined it by stretching it out and making it need a bunch of filler because the filler stuff was not good. also the bloom filter over everything is a drain
>>224284325Who are quoting, my brown friend?
>>224284325>It's a boring and embarrassing movie.It's not. It's pretty enjoyable, but has its flaws. Not seeing nuance is what constitutes low standards.>>224284350Some filler stuff is perfectly fine and enjoyable. It's great to see characters interact more with each other.
>>224284402(you)>>224284414>nuanceI see nothing of value. Comparing it to Lord of the Rings the difference in quality is night and day.
>>224284454>I see nothing of value.That's a (You) issue. LoTR is a masterpiece and The Hobbit doesn't come close, that doesn't mean it's bad. It's still better than vast majority of movies, and certainly enjoyable for what it is.
>>224281700This trilogy was better than the original.
>>224284414i respectfully disagree that the filler stuff was enjoyable in these movies, it bloated it and added nothing of value
>>224281700Peter jackson had to sue new line to get the money he was owed for LOTR.imagine having to do that to get your reward for delivering a billion dollars worth of kino LOTR movies.So i do wonder how much money he demanded, up front, for taking over the hobbit project.3 years of stress and constant work, basically making things up as he went as there was no time to plan anything.Its amazing the films are any good at all.If Jackson diddnt have some kind of disease that made him go bigger on the action and show-off antics for every movie then they could have been brilliant.and he decided to shoot 3D and 48FPS as well.no wonder he hasnt directed since, he probably broke himself on this task.
>>224281798First half of first one was better than LOTRSecond half of first one was a messSecond one was a non-movieThird one was okay
>>224281700>Now it's time for the multiple running away from thing slapstick fight sequence
.
>>224281798That's more or less how I remember it. The first one was mostly good, the smaug stuff in part 2 was cool, and the third was just a video game noise festival like >>224282122
Why the fuck was Alfrid a thing. Did the actor blackmail on somebody? Why the fuck was he in TWO of the movies?
>>224281700Mogged by a 78 min cartoon made 50 years ago
>>224281700>3 hours of gay ass midgets
>>224286489Alfrid was kino>>224286551>le obscure animated movie for childrenYou're a midwit
>>224281798Fan edit that combines all the movies into one is far superior
>>224289031Was about to say this. It is faithful to the book and is on par with the original trilogy. Pic related, I'm watching it now.
>>224289095It's legitimately good and faithful to the original. So much better than the three moviesStill quite long but has an interlude half way which is comfy
>>224289154It's 4:15 and has an intervention, like all epic movies. It isn't too long or short, you just have either a low IQ or ADHD.
>>224289279>Can't spell words properly >Thinks over 4 hours isn't a long movie>Has the gall to try talk about ittard harder fuckwit
>>224289031does it edit out Martin Freeman?
>>224289279are you fucjing retarded? the dude wasnt even complaining about it lmao
>>224281700First one is actually comfy kino. Second and third are legitimately bad.
>>224288131>obscurezoomer...
First one is good.2nd extended is good3rd one extended is the superior version but too many ridiculous shots.Im still convinced to this day the original 2 film structure would have been pure kino. First film was supposed to end right before they go to Laketown. Imagine the 2nd movie being a non stop action kino including Smaug and the Battle, with none of the extra padding
An Unexpected Journey has horrendous pacing. The first 90 minutes of the movie is constant flashbacks and exposition dump.
>>224290528>>224291556the first one is NOT good, ehy did they use the fucking nazgúl theme for thorin charging at the orcs? when all the dwarves were hiding in trees while grand(elf) threw flaming pinecone AAAAAGHHHHHHHH
>>224282122We don't need little Timmy riding around in his battle chariot decapitating a half dozen ogres in our streets.
>>224286551Love it.I can watch this and then still have time to get a blowjob from OPs dad>>224291605>did they use the fucking nazgúl theme for thorin charging at the orcs?yah it was bizarre. also they made the Beorn scene overly retarded.Mirkwood was neat, but would have been better if it was more book accurate. It seems like they're only in there for an afternoon instead of the week it was in the book.In the book, their biggest fear was running out of provisions and having to leave the path to find more. It added some suspense.
>>224291605>ehy did they use the fucking nazgúl theme for thorin charging at the orcs?For 'memberberries. Howard Shore made an original track for that scene but was told to just adapt "Flight to the Ford" (Nazgul theme) into it instead.
>>224282122cgi slop with atrocious lighting
looks like ps3 game