Adapting horror games into movies should be like the easiest thing in the world?how come it fails?
>>224281718It works fine story wise but the gameplay is a burnt in aspect for anyone who is a fan so it always sucks. I do remember some 00s and 10s movies where they actually tried to lift the dynamics or a bunch of series had their insta video game companion.
Paul Anderson said it really well on the RE movie commentary tracks. Playing game over many hours or days is a different experience than watching a 90-120min movie and to make that work you need to change things.
>>224281718The people adapting things feel the need to make massive changes. Resident Evil 1 has a simple structure that's easy to follow but PTA added a bunch of extra shit that didn't matter. There are a ton of movies that take place in a house but he added Alice and some retarded AI plot. Same goes with Silent Hill. The game was based off of western horror movies and they decided to change almost everything.
>>224281718The people making movies don't play video games and if they do, they're retards who don't understand it. The same thing applies to books. Some of the best movies are adaptations of books, but they're extremely rare and were created by intelligent people. Video games are still seen as a hobby for children or losers despite the fact that 9/10 people play them. It would take a talented director to make a good adaptation and they won't go near this stuff. The movies aren't bad because they're an adaptation of a video game, they're bad because the director is bad. The people that make video game films don't have any good films.
>>224281718I never played the first one. My parents couldn't stop fucking so I grew up in poverty. My oldest brother who was in his mid twenties bought us a PlayStation, Resident Evil 2, and Final Fantasy 7 for Christmas. Once a week I was able to get an ~hour of playing time. Never finished either of those games in two years. We never got anymore games. Except for a preview disc with Metal Gear Solid that went as fast as crawling through a ventilation shaft. Yippy ki yay.
>>224282040No one wants to hear about your sad childhood.
>>224282040>that went as fast as crawlingAs *far. Fuck you spell check engineers. Stop being bad at your job.
>>224282077It wasn't sad though. I grew up in a rural area. I spent most of my days in the woods. If I wanted to hang out with somebody other than my siblings, I'd drive my lawnmower that I rebuilt from a junkyard over to my friend's house a mile down the gravel road.
>>224281718Nowadays a lot of people don't really understand horror. It's not about someone winning or learning or surviving, it's more like a mentos mori, it's a vibe. This is why Zeggers Resident Evil is so good. It's got a guy who thinks he is a videogame end up in the middle of a horror.
>>224282077I don't understand posters like this. If people didn't share anecdotes or change the topic of the thread to something else related to it, there would be no purpose in having a discussion of any kind. Are you upset that he reminded you of your even worse childhood?
>>224281800This is retarded, make the movie like the cube with zombies and have them stumble unto the lab below. That is already more true to the games than whatever slop they push with the name attached to it
>>224282188OK but what if I saw the new Resident Evil and didn't jump once or even felt apprehensive at any moment?The movie wasn't scary, and it didn't have a satisfying ending. In fact so unsatisfying I will be avoiding the director going forward. I've seen Soviet films about WW2 that were less nihilistic.
>>224281718because video games are less developed forms of storytelling
Films just cant compete. I would argue that films are a huge downgrade in terms of what a game is capable of.You play a game like Resident Evil and you're not just watching someone experience the horrors of the mansion, you are quite literally experiencing it yourself and you make the decisions that alter the course of what happens throughout the game. You're engrossed in a bigger, boarder setting with potentially better character development for far longer than a 2-3 hour film.Resident Evil, Metal Gear Solid, Halo, Silent Hill and many other games are just never going to be able to work in films or shows.
>>224282270Yeah, I hated the film, too. I should have known after Weapons, but I'm a retarded consumer who saw the name "Resident Evil" and fell for it. At least I didn't spend any money.
>>224282358Personally, horror video games are infinitely more terrifying than horror films. Something about controlling the character and making decisions (even if there’s only a single path to advance the plot) freaks me out
>>224282394There's more agency involved, I think it tricks your brain into thinking its you that's experiencing it.I felt it from Dying Light: The Beast, which is barely horror, was clearing a house and a few zombies were still in there that I missed, they jumped me, I killed them in a panic.
>>224282394What are some good horror games? I've only played Resident Evil, Silent Hill and Alien: Isolation, which I thought was horrible. Video game adaptations of movies might be worse than the opposite.
>>224282456Dead SpaceStasisIf you cant handle body horror then Fear, System Shock, and BioShock
>>224282576I forgot all about Fear. I did play the second one when I was a teenager. I'll check out the rest and Dead Space always seemed like it would be fun. Thanks, anon.
>>224281718I quite liked the resident evil movie.The lab scene is a bit annoying but aside that it was fun
hard to sustain a 90 minute move wandering around a mansion trying to find a fucking key shaped like a club
>>224282748Movies can make a singular room work, why does everyone go full retard with resident evil? A zombie filled mansion with puzzles isn't a hard concept to make a movie about
>>224281718Because video games are bad.
>>224282748I'd love to see an adaptation of the Silent Hill 2 coin puzzle where I walked around for 2 days searching the entire town because I didn't realize your character's head turns to look at objects you can pick up or the retarded Shakespeare puzzle in Silent Hill 3 where I had to look up the answer.
>>224281718The first Resident Evil is actually a difficult one because the story is sparse to the point of barely existing and it is mostly a hunt for old keys and gems in a maze of rooms.
>>224281718WHAT IF???....... BADASS WOMAN!!! BUT ALSO.... WHESKER IS FROM THE MATRICKS... HAHA... WE SELL ROTS OF MOVIES NOW!!
>>224282216Cool you've got like 2-3 scenes until that becomes redundantly formulaic
>You either have to autistically copy everything from the game or it's ok to make a resident evil movie where they file taxes while sipping a martini on the beachThere is clearly no way they can make a big spooky mansion filled with monsters and traps work. What an outrageous concept.
>>224281800There is only a kernel of truth to that. He didn't even try to adapt the characters at all. For the first game you would need to jury rig two alternative plots involving Jill and Chris but he didn't even do that. He only adapted the premise, not the work.
>>224282900Why are you playing dumb?
>>224282748Jill a cute.
because it just wouldn't work. There isn't even a canon version of the events. I was outlining this shit as a movie as I know screenwriting and it's going to die a death after like 20 minutes because of how repetitious it would be to find the next key, etc. Like the underground would be boring as fuck. The lab too. There's not much plot and discovering the lore is fun in a game, not in a movie. this idea of doing a 90 minute movie of Jill shuffling through the mansion, it's just not going to work. You could do it cause you can film anything but it will suck.
>>224283043There is enough story to just ignore the gameplay elements. And the alternate plots can be combined. Movie dialog can be slower and more fleshed out because you don't need to rush it to get to gameplay. Wesker, Barry, Jill and Chris can enter the mansion together. It's not a story about the gameplay. It is about Jill, Chris and Barry surviving the zombies, finding Kenneth dead, looking for Wesker, finding Rebecca, saving Richard, watching him die, finding the lab, being betrayed and fighting the tyrant.
Video games are carried by their gameplay and uniformly have mediocre/bad writing and storytelling. They don't make interesting films, the gameplay is what makes them interesting. An adaptation like Cregger's Resident Evil works because it isn't trying to offer an experience it can't provide with the medium and does something different but fun instead.
>>224283163You don’t need those ins and outs eventhe plot is really just>special ops are deployed on secret mission and attacked>they find a mansion filled with zombies >eventually find out it’s a corporate conspiracy and are betrayed by one of their owna lot of the blanks can be filled in pretty easily. The crescendo from mystery mansion to corporate conspiracy is what makes it great and it’s just a matter of connecting the dotsNo reason it couldn’t be a <2:00 horror film
>>224283583>uniformly have mediocre/bad writing and storytellinglol what
>>224281718Because those games are a mishmash of horror movies in the first place, so translating them back into a movie just gets you a pale, watered down imitation of the superior things they ripped off.
>>224283609You cutting out the iconic parts and then "filling in the blanks" was already done in the first Resident Evil movie.
>>224281800No shit you need to change things, but those things shouldn't be the story and characters.
>>224283686There is not one game on the planet that has writing equivalent to the best writing in other mediums.
>>224281718>how come it fails?Because Hollywood producers and directors always have to alter the source material to make it "for wider audiences" and so they can legally copyright their own legally-distinct version.
>>224281800>movies and games are differentWow. What insightful commentary.
>>224283813Care to elaborate?What are some of these 'the best writing in other mediums.' examples?
>>224283733lol no way. The first movie spends like 5 seconds in the mansion, goes straight to the lab but then adds in too much random shit. It’s more an action movie than a survival horror but also with bad CGI and a very “early 2000s” feelI like it but it’s a Resident Evil movie in the same way the Creggar film is which is to say…not really
>>224281718How did Resident Evil gain a fame that other horror games don't have?
>>224283609>>eventually find out it’s a corporate conspiracy and are betrayed by one of their ownYeah I bet audiences will be shocked right out of their seats when they find out the sketchy dude in black wearing sunglasses in the middle of the night is actually a traitor. What a twist!
>>224284075I mean this question would require an absurdly broad answer and I would assume most people are aware of the most fundamental pillars of the Western writing tradition. There is no equivalent to Hamlet in video games. The video game medium is narrowly focused on entertainment, which is fine, but people treat some video games as though their writing is something special and it never is. There are definitely some interesting minds at work here and there, but I wouldn't say the writing goes beyond any of the more remarkable works of pulp/genre fiction authors or filmmakers.
>>224282744this sucks, i want a whiny jew and paul anderson's wife
>>224282911people who say it cant work are cregger shills
>>224282941what do you mean
>>224285605Ada a cute.
>>224284550>There is no equivalent to Hamlet in video games.>why are we still here? >just to suffer? >they played us like a damn fiddle
>>224281718Even Romero realized you have to pad the roster out with some cannon fodder to show off the cool kills. That's half the fun of the games, but you can't just restart the movie when a Hunter tears Chris's head off and shits down his neck.
>>224282040
>>224285715I love MGS, but I wouldn't call it good writing and it's certainly not equivalent to Shakespeare. It was a game I had in mind when I said there were some interesting minds at work in the medium, though. I'd love to see a movie of it, but I wouldn't want to see a "faithful" adaptation.
Because directors and writers are egotistical faggots who think they're the REAL artists, and they need to put there creative vision into it to elevate it from a stupid game story into a REAL piece of cinema.
>>224281718>its another capcuck seething at cregger threadits getting tiresome