ITT: Adaptations that aren't faithful to the source material but are still enjoyable
fuck I've been meaning to watch this for like twenty years
all of them?
>>224282856
>>224282890ive watched this every year for like twenty years
>>224282856the shining
That describes every good adaptation. There's little point in attempting the impossible task of a 1:1 adaptation except shallow spectacle.
>>224282856Shaggy shamus novels seem to adapt well to film.
the Ghost int the Machine movie with Scarlett johansen
>>224282938>>224283482No Country For Old Men is like 90% from the novel. There are a few omissions and some stuff is changed, but the vast majority of what is in the movie is in the book. You could argue the tone is a little more serious too in the book, but still I'd bump the rating down another 5 or 10% for that for how 1 to 1 adaptation it is.
>>224282938>>224283482Very faithful good adaptations, from what I remember:Gone With The WindThe Maltese FalconThe Nun's StoryThe Day Of The Jackal (1973)Murder On The Orient Express (1974)DeliveranceThe Age Of InnocenceThe Talented Mr RipleyThe Assassination of Jesse James (2007)True Grit (2010)
>>224282890i went decades without watching it and it was a big disappointment, the book is top level for genre fic. as a movie i prefered Busting 1974
this is a stealth adaptation of lolita. think about it
>>224282943
>>224283793Wasn't that originally written as a screenplay?
>>224282856DUNC
>>224283973I should have been more careful with my words. I would say that's MOST good adaptations, not necessarily all. Some adaptations are faithful while still using the medium to offer something you can't get from the source material, which is perfectly fine.
>>224282856Jurassic ParkShinningWho Framed Roger Rabit
>>224282856Elliott Gould has anti-charisma + now i realized it's just aggressively Juice.
>>224282856Wuthering Heights 1939 version
>>224284599Roger Rabbit was so good that even the original author thought it mogged his original version and retconned everything in his sequel book to conform to the movie.
Having read the books I really appreciated how they handled this adaptation. The pacing is a lot better and I like how they ended the movie by looping back to the climax of the first book.
>>224282856What was the cat's problem?
>>224284626He was perfect as Marlowe. I agree as he aged the kike in him made him unwatchable
>>224282856written by a feminist btw.