Are these the worst adaptations ever? Not saying they’re bad films, not what I’m saying, but it’s as if they intentionally sidestepped adapting any of the substance in the original novel. No, this is not an opportunity for you to say the books are pseud shit. They just sucked it all out and made a totally flimsy Hollywood spectacle. It’s remarkable.
watch Rings of Power
>>224283078They only had the rights to the appendices.
I do like most of the visuals and music but they butchered the story and managed to fuck up the pacing for no good reason. I'll probably watch part 3 eventually when its streaming somewhere just to see what the navigators end up looking like and what not.
>>224283052>the substance in the original novelWhat exactly would you say that is?
>>224283052
Was reading Dune Messiah in preparation for the movie. Why did they change stuff so Zendaya could be angry at him? In the book Chani is just in love with him and dies in childbirth. Also Paul is more kingly and composed and not a screaming chud manlet.
>>224283052no i dont think so. but i tihnk the dunc threads on tv are some of the worst on this board now. i wish these movies came out 10 years ago when tv wasnt solely filled of retards
>>224283334Villenoob tried to adapt the books Herbie said he wanted to write instead of the books Herbie actually wrote. Unfortunately the books Herbie said he wanted to write are shit, especially compared to the ones he actually wrote.
>>224283380Because 95% of people haven’t read the books, and you’re unable to bullshit having read the books because all the online lore stuff is compromised by Brian Herbert.
>>224283052Villeneuve missed the point by a mile. >Paul can only stop the jihad by dying in his duel with Jamis.>in so doing, he will forfeit his life, his opportunity to avenge his House and father and be a forgotten footnote in history>or he can overthrow the entire system that was ruthless enough to exterminate a noble man like the Duke and his HouseAn easy enough decision, but Paul can see the jihad and the senseless death of innocents he himself will cause. Dune is the decision, Messiah is the consequences. That's all the story you need to focus on. Talking about stupid contemporary Wokeslop shit like "imperialism" and "colonialism" is meaningless in the brutal Dune universe.
>>224283111And they still butchered it.
>>224283052DV tried to streamline the politics among the different houses to pageantry (parading around in props/costumes) and a Romeo & Juliet type of "the young suffer a fate they were locked in by birth". But Zionlamay + Fashundaya don't have much chemistry in their whispery nothings, so everything just pads the runtime until battle scenes or Worm stuff.
>>224284401Butcher what? It was always going to be high budget fan fiction. Doesn’t qualify as a butchered adaptation.
>>224284401You can't 'butcher' the appendices. As far as I know all the names are spelled correctly. That's about all there is to it.
>>224283052nah not even close imo, though part 1 you can tell he was nervous about getting greenlit for a part 2 after BR2049 bombed, and Dune was notoriously known still as 'unfilmable', and its previous attempt was giant box office stinker. At times it feels almost like Part 1 was a concept demo meant to prove that Dune is filmable, especially without internal dialogue, rather than the fully confident vision you get in the sequel. The biggest issue Part 2 had imo was some of the casting, mainly Zendaya & Christopher Walken as the Emperor. Part 1 had the benefit of Zendaya's Chani being hardly in it and the flashes of her were dreamlike with no speaking lines
villeneuve is a weird director. he doesn't seem to care much about the story or themes. he mostly just seems to want a bunch of pretty shots.
>>224283052Dune wasn't that good of a book
>>224283052The Watch currently holds that title
>>224283052>but it’s as if they intentionally sidestepped adapting any of the substance in the original novelIsn't this the issue with lynch's version as well?