[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


Why should writers keep making prestige shows about complex deeply flawed human beings who do some awful things when every discourse around them boils down to "is he a good person or a bad person"?
>>
>>224287572
The voices in your head aren't every discourse tard.
>>
We're getting our fat burger asses kickes by people with black and white morality.
>>
>Boils down to “is he a good person or a bad person"?
I’d say more accurately it boils down to “is he a chud coded person or a woke coded person?” These days
>>
>>224287572
They just want to make characters and watch them hurt each other. They'll try and dress it up as deep or thought provoking. Its not. Its just torture porn, simple as
>>
Lord of the ring had an ending.
>>
>>224287735
Game of Thrones ended with the good guys teaming up to defeat an evil dark lord.
>>
>>224287572
>Why should writers keep making prestige shows about complex deeply flawed human beings who do some awful things
Because retards still think Breaking Bad was the best show ever
>>
>>224287750
>Game of Thrones ended
Did it? All I remember are fever dreams of two hacks.
>>
File: FELINE_COSTANZA.jpg (32 KB, 500x375)
32 KB JPG
>>224287572
>implying that either of the series in your pic is "prestige" television
>>
>>224287750
>an evil dark lord
You mean Cersei or Dany?
>>
File: j-r-r-tolkien-03.jpg (99 KB, 350x236)
99 KB JPG
>>224287572
What was Bran the Broken's tax policy?
>>
>>224287572

Martin's popularity is proof positive that the general population is fucking retarded, and are also bloodlust psychos with weird fetishes
>>
>>224287572
>let me go burn entire fields and murder almost the entire populace who works those fields
>why does everyone hate me now??
What was Tywin's tax policy?
>>
>>224287572
Being a good guy. An actual truly good man involves making a lot of "hard hard," decisions. Its not not selling your soul to the evils of the world. Doing what is right is often the hardest choice a man will ever make.


What the fuck is this fat fucking retard talking about?
>>
>>224288084
This 100% this.
>>
>Good economics is when you collect gold like a dragon
Thanks George very realistic
>>
>>224287572
Martin is hack, he can´t decide how to end his book series because he fears his "masterpiece" meeting rejection. He is not qualified to make an argument against Tolkien. As for your question OP the answer is no, we should unironically go back to simplicity in design and theatricality. Hollywood had 2 modes right now. It either rejects the magic of storytelling altogether by making things more grounded and mundane or it ridicules it and makes fun of the stories as if it was all meant to be a satire, which is absolutely dishonest and disgusting.

There is no path forward if we don´t embrace the magic and mysticism of storytelling again.
>>
>>224287715
Show me an emoji of a unicorn.
>>
>>224287572
To me, its weird how the books can be so good, but the guy who allegedly wrote them is such a god damn moron. Is it senility?
>>
>>224288857
Everything he writes is just a copy of something better. He’s a curator more than a creator
>>
>>224287796
He uses his x-ray vision to check if the farmers hid away money and if they did he has them hanged
ALL HAIL BRAN THE BROKEN
>>
>>224287572
Aragorn genocided the orcs after the war. Not just the orc men, but the orc women, and the orc children.
>>
>>224287572
fat fuck can't even write a book, only hard decision he makes is whether to order Dunkin donuts or Krispy Kreme
>>
>>224287572
Georges response to a good character is "Good character but he rapes a woman for some reason"
>>
>>224287572
His entire vision for the first book was "I want to see a 12 year old raped into Stockholm Syndrome by Genghis Khan" and "I want to see Aragorn being beheaded for being too nice". And people ate it up.
>>
Thats why he never finished it. His response to Tolkien completing it didnt sit right with him.
>>
>>224287572
>his answer to tolkien
what was the question?
>>
>>224289102
They were animals, and he slaughtered them like animals. He hated them.
>>
>>224289151
Something about tax policies.
>>
>>224287572
>"Tolkien does not write about the hard decisions a king must make"
>proceeds to not write like it, at no moment does any statesmen compromise on anything for the good of the kingdom or any stability, its all powergrabs, court intrigue and abuse.
Martin is a hack
>>
George’s best king in his lore is king jaehaerys, and he didn’t make any hard decisions, he was simply good and smart and had good advisors
>>
>>224287572
he needs to stop eating fast food
>>
I think im in the minority here. I unironically like House of Dragon because every character is a "bad person". In Game of Thrones, there are characters that could be considered good but all have flaws. I wonder if whether you really like this sort of thing comes down to how you view the core of humanity.
>>
>>224287572

Yeah, but the cool part was after the Balrog brings Gandalf down with him into the chasm and the remaining fellowship are escaping and Aragorn takes the easy decision to smote down, in anger, the Orc captain blocking their only path to escape Moria.
>>
>>224288158
What is king's landing food policy ?
>>
>>224294705
blockade = hunger
no blockade = no hunger
>>
>>224289120
When did Jon ever rape someone?
>>
>>224288857
It's very common for highly intelligent people to be very articulate in their writings but sound like idiots in non-rehersed conversation.


He has the ability to write beautifully while being fairly insightful, but he can't come up with with it on the fly.
>>
>>224287572
Nothing he says matters until he explains with details what is Bran's tax policy.
>>
>>224287572
The most amazing irony to me is that liberals like him are so obsessed with irony in their creations, trying to ground works and bring people like Aragorn down to earth, and yet when it comes to their politics, their decisions are anything but based around reality, lovingly embracing their destruction through demographic replacement.

Just completely contemptible people.
>>
>>224296949
*obsessed with realism
my dyslexia strikes again...
>>
>>224287572
Aragorn rejected a seemingly reasonable peace offer and suicided his entire army just so Frodo (who might've already been dead) gets a chance at destroying the ring, I'd say that was a pretty hard decision.
>>
>>224288857
Being a good storyteller doesn't make you a good critic, just like being a good critic doesn't make you a good storyteller.
>>
>>224288857
I have been turning on the books as well
They are serviceable pulp fantasy, nothing more.
I'd put him on the same level as Piers Anthony, except less prolific and creative.
>>
>>224287795
it's funny that GRRM thought Cersei v Dany was somehow the equivalent of The Scouring Of The Shire chapters of LOTR.

like, one is a bunch of innocent hobbits fighting Sauron's second-in-command, the other is two women competing over who can commit the most warcrimes before both being murdered. GRRM really thought that would tie everything up.
>>
>>224297791
being a good critic doesn't make you able to have a career as a critic, because critics are really just paid marketing folk who intentionally review things according to how much/whether you pay them.
>>
>>224287572
>should I fight the literal embodiments of evil
>well, it's a hard decision
>>
>>224297868
There were men on Saurons side, whole tribes and nations.
>>
>>224297825
Tolkien was better at subverting expectations than Gurm was.
>>
>>224287572
what was the tax policy of westeros, anyway?
>>
>>224297917
>No scene where Cersei tries to have the books opened and the tax law is just so complex with overlapping fiefs, duties, tarrifs, and special exemptions that she just gives up.
>>
>>224287572
IDK but I'm kind of sick of antiheroes and morally gray bullshit. Give me an epic story with courageous heroes who inspire me. I've had enough of the edgy modern shit.
>>
>>224288857
George used to have an editor, but then he became too popular for his own good and started huffing his own farts.
>>
File: grrm_quote.jpg (85 KB, 850x400)
85 KB JPG
>>224290068
The characters in ASOIAF make hard decisions all the time, it's just that more often than not it fucks them over. Ned's entire story, Jaime being forever known as oathbreaker after killing the mad cunt he served, Robb dying as a consequence of breaking his bethrothal to preserve girl's honor, Jon getting assassinated for trying to do the right thing. The hard decisions is what undoes most of the characters while traditional fantasy heroes like Arya, Dany and Bran coast by on plot armor and hard work of others.
>>
>>224287572
Why do people compare LOTR to GOT
They have nothing in common except being superficially medieval fantasy
That's like comparing The assasination of Jesse James to Shanghai Noon because both of them have cowboys and horses in them
>>
>>224298226
Because Gurm himself did it.
If he hadn't opened his fat fish lipped mouth I would have left well alone.
>>
>>224287572
GRRMs approach explains the way France, Austria, Switzerland, Denmark, Poland, Czechoslovakia, Italy, Romania and Hungary dealt with Nazi Germany pre WW2. When you take a soft, self serving, morally relativistic approach with a totalitarian juggernaut you lose and get dominated.

Tolkien covers the US, UK, and Russian approach after the war broke out: you have to throw everything you have to stop the conquering enemy from taking over of the world since your very existence is at stake.

GRRM doesn’t have an ending to his crappy story since it literally ends in a lord of the rings scenario, which Tolkien already covered to perfection.
>>
File: MartinQuotes.png (213 KB, 841x383)
213 KB PNG
>>224298087
>>
>>224287572
>you had to make hard, hard decisions
Like what? The only decisions anyone makes in GOT is who and when to betray someone in their inner circle to gain power.
>>
>>224287795
Arya
>>
>>224287572
Tolkien:
>In later years, he would occasionally talk of being at the front: of the horrors of the first German gas attack, of the utter exhaustion and ominous quiet after a bombardment, of the whining scream of the shells, and the endless marching, always on foot, through a devastated landscape, sometimes carrying the men's equipment as well as his own to encourage them to keep going. ... Some remarkable relics survive from that time: a trench map he drew himself; pencil-written orders to carry bombs to the 'fighting line'.
Little George:
>Eligible for the draft during the Vietnam War, to which he objected, Martin applied for and obtained conscientious objector status. He instead did alternative service work for two years (1972–1974) as a VISTA volunteer, attached to the Cook County Legal Assistance Foundation.

sad to see actually
>>
>>224298087
>The characters in ASOIAF make hard decisions all the time, it's just that more often than not it fucks them over
That's what grrm chants when he jerks off to Rhaegar and Daemon
>>
>>224298462
So you're saying when faced with a hard choice . . . GRRM cucked the fuck out like a little bitch?
>>
>>224298462
Based GRRM
>>
>>224298465
The two guys who lost and died?
>>
>>224298014
This statement can be applied to 2 Georges.
>>
>>224287572
Maybe some day George will write something conclusive. He shits on everything so he must be a smart man, it should be easy for him.
>>
File: an670e0jm2e01.jpg (66 KB, 491x573)
66 KB JPG
>>224298087
Fat man has some kino quotes, i'll give him that.
>>
>>224287572
He was mad Tolkien didn't describe hobbit penises in detail
>>
>>224298287
I expected better from Tolkien fans.
>>
>>224287572
>>224298226
>>224287843
>What if I made my own Lord of the Rings but it's The War of the Roses with rape and diarrhea
>>
>>224287572
what is the Targaryens' tax policy? In fact, is tax policy ever discussed in any way in ASOIAF?
>>
>>224299279
Nah, George just wanted to impress people that will never read his books
>>
>>224287572
Is he dogwhistling good guys start wars +double down too
>>
>>224298087
Hard decisions, yes
But not as statesmen, theyre entirely self serving, none of them behave like their roles in the machine they take part in
>ibn4 thats real life
>>
>>224298287
He never said that.
>>
>>224299921
prove it
>>
>>224298792
>The two guys who lost
lmao
lol
>>
>>224299691
>But not as statesmen, theyre entirely self serving
Eddard resigning when Robert made clear he's gonna have Daenerys assassinated, condemning Tywin's top enforcer and giving Cersei a choice to take her kids and run was self-serving? Or Edmure allowing peasants into his castle? Jon's politiking in ADWD? Daenerys risking her entire campaign for the sake of the slaves she's freed?
>>
>>224300239
>Eddard resigning when Robert made clear he's gonna have Daenerys assassinated, condemning Tywin's top enforcer and giving Cersei a choice to take her kids and run was self-serving?
Yeah? He doomed the realm.
>>
>>224297917
shit like that never comes up. Anything technical boils down to
>you owe us money so do this
and
>it’s strategic for us to do this but fuck you Im petty
if you take a microscope to Westeros it doesn’t make any sense, the book is busy talking about family ties and bad blood, not the macroeconomics of the setting GRRM created.
>>
>>224287733
fpbp
>>
>>224287733
Jaime losing his hand was vital for his character development, same for Theon's imprisonment and torture. And it was mostly off-screen, with the narrative exploring the aftermath and the effect of unbearable pain on one's psyche rather than reveling in torture.
>>
>>224298792
it aint over yet...
>>
>>224287572
Everyone in his series was a bad person who didn't make any hard decisions
>>
>>224287572
>the Others are green people shadow babies and are leftover WMD's from the first war with the First Men/later Nightfort Ice Queen
>Bran the Builder is under Winterfell warg controlling them and needs to be fully killed because he went crazy after millenia and Nightfort Queen pussy, but it will end the Starks magical ordained control over the land
>Bran the Broken will end the 10K year Weirwood influence over the population by destroying the hivemind from the inside
Boom, stories over. There's your intended ending (that you won't be getting).
>>
File: George RAPE RAPE Martin.png (879 KB, 1008x1178)
879 KB PNG
>>224287572
what a fucking idiot, being a good guy is the hardest decision you'll ever make in your life, you fat fucking rape rape murderous evil relativist fetishist plagiarist hack
>>
>>224287572
The fat man of vice who was raised in America's final era of peace and abundance is going to lecture us on how nobility should work. Wonderful, I'm sure it will be very insightful.
>>
>>224289079
kek
>>
File deleted.
hard to take any criticism of GRRM itt seriously when it's obviously coming from posters that have only read the wiki and are still getting baited by the tax policy quote in current year
>>
File: 1773938554139696.png (1.33 MB, 1280x720)
1.33 MB PNG
>>224287623
post gunz, you dickless yurothirdie
>>224287572
>major theme in LotR is that if you do good things the Christian God will help you
for it was pity that stayed Bilbo's hand
>fatso doesn't understand the work he is criticizing
>>
>>224301448
>with the narrative exploring the aftermath and the effect of unbearable pain on one's psyche rather than reveling in torture.
feels like most people forget the worst torture in the books all happens off screen, last we see of Theon is getting knocked out in Winterfell then he shows up in his first Reek chapter in Dance
>>
>>224301692
>who was raised in America's final era of peace and abundance
America will outlast the dickless subhuman tranny nations of yurop and brazil by a thousand years
>>
>>224298777
anon the Vietnam war was very very gay
>>
>>224302003
As either New India, New Africa, or a new caliphate.
>>
Nothing anyone says in this thread matters. Game of Thrones is beloved by countless people out there and rightfully considered a masterpiece. LotR is ancient boomer garbage from like 20 years ago that your millenial uncle puts on and tries to tell you isn't confusing boring moralfag garbage (it is).
>>
>>224302098
Yeah, sure, whatever you say George.
>>
File: 1793650189354641.jpg (87 KB, 1024x576)
87 KB JPG
>>224302270
nope, that's yurop and brazil.
yurop and brazil are basically the same as india
>>
>>224302417
Who's the mayor of New York City?
>>
File: 1778434782075924.png (462 KB, 1220x748)
462 KB PNG
>>224302632
>>
>>224300155
Blacktard or Blackfyretard? Either way your guy lost lmao
>>
>>224302003
Dumb nigger, Brazil is the blueprint for the USA's future
>>
>>224287572
Why would a good person not make good judgements?
>>
File: 1765967489817064.jpg (164 KB, 550x1024)
164 KB JPG
>>224304275
a jewish run brown state? you're thinking of yurop, fatso. they're already most of the way there
>>
>>224287572
>You had to make the hard decision of having the same mentality of a moody teenager
>>
>>224287572
>Nihilistic lazy fat fuck who will never finish his own book
Wow really showed him
>>
>>224287572
tolkien won btw
>>
>>224287572
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZqo4OZ0Pqs
>>
>>224287572
Aragorn had to make hard decision though.
He had to be the face of hope of for mankind mantling a lost kingship.
He had to march on the black gates as a distraction for Frodo.
He had to keep fighting everyday with giving up contrasted completely to Denethor who lost the will to fight due to what he saw in the palantir in which Aragorn instead decided to fight against Sauron's will.
>>
>>224287572
how do you make good decisions if you're not a good person?
>>
>>224304615
good people are forced to make "bad" decisions all the time is the point I think
>>
>>224287733
>They just want to make characters and watch them hurt each other. They'll try and dress it up as deep or thought provoking. Its not. Its just torture porn, simple as
Basically. Georgie porgie writes soap operas, tolkien wrote literature.
>>
File: 1365629022866.png (351 KB, 544x377)
351 KB PNG
what is it about GRRM that makes tolkienfags seethe so much are they really so insecure that nobody talks about their uncslop anymore?
>>
>>224287572
...
Nigga what the fuck?
Part of discussion of media with "grey" characters or "deep complex" characters is their morality and if they are ultimately a good or bad person.
>>
>>224301932
Case in point, these >>224287733 >224290068 >>224298319 >224299691 >>224301578 >224304720 nincompoops.
>>
the GRRMfatties are here
>>
>>224305054
We never left. GRRM board, GRRM thread.
>>
>>224304578
And he had to give up Arwen's elfussy to go hiking around with some faggy hobbits.
>>
>>224298253
>When you take a soft, self serving, morally relativistic approach with a totalitarian juggernaut you lose and get dominated.
That's why Hitler lost: should've bombed London into oblivion. He didn't know just how powerful the jews were at the time.
>>
>>224287572
I like it because in real life people aren't perfect. people do fucked up shit and good shit.
>>
>>224287572
>LOTR DIDN'T HAVE ENOUGH RAPE ANS SHITTING. LET ME WRITE SOME BOOKS WITH MY PANTS OFF
>>
>>224287572

>"My answer to objective good and evil is a shit load of grey morality."

Fucking genius, truly the modern Tolkien. What a fat faggot. Finish the book already, dipshit
>>
>>224304366
Burgers were literally kneeling for niggers during the summer of love, your bravado is easily seen trough, cuckold.
You have the tools and the rights, yet you refuse to do anything because you're a pussy ass nigger.
>>
>>224308537
yurotroons were kneeling, thirdie. yurotroons invented blacked and trannies. the king of spain gave 1 million africans citizenships by royal decree you third world troon
>>
>>224287572
Cool. But LotR had an ending.
>>
>>224308641
>>
File: really.jpg (31 KB, 468x286)
31 KB JPG
>>224301932
I started reading the series when it came out. I remember reading Dany getting her army and thinking this is peak. By the time we got a Dance with Dragons, I realised he will never finish the series. What a fucking disappointment. Rothfuss is comparable in his absolute contempt for his readers. Both made a promise to their fanbase, and in retrospect had no intention of fulfilling that promise.
>>
>>224309093
i wasn't trying to defend his slow writing, that goes without saying it's just much less interesting to talk about
>>
>>224287572
More importantly: Why should people entertain this obese faggot's opinions?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.