Post movies that people pretend to like purely because they are scared to admit that the emperor has no clothes.
>>224288381It wasn't a great movie, but Tom was great.
>>224288404
>>224288409>It wasn't a great movie, but Tom was great.He is a great actor and would be great in anything, even a probiotic yoghurt commercial. This movie was a piece of shit. Three hours of absolutely nothing.
performance of the film was of course https://youtu.be/-w8ctRs2IW8
>>224288466Case in point: This guy pretending he “enjoys” a scene of an old sick man blubbering endlessly about his very common, unremarkable regrets because it’s “good acting”. You would never recommend this scene to a friend that you wanted to keep. This is a fake persona you are cultivating. It’s in the same category as pretending to like David Lynch’s Eraserhead.
>>224288466>10 fucking minutes of an old man laying in bed saying “I cheated on my wife once and am sad about it”This is how programmable the average human (cattle) is. If you instruct them to believe that something is “good” they will dutifully invest three hours of their life into it and pretend it was “good” because they are that desperate to fit in and be accepted by the hivemind
>>224288466Check out the comments on this YouTube video:>This movie. This scene. I had just finished college and was starting my first professional job out of school when this movie comes to my local art house theater. I remember driving home late at night after the movie with the stereo off -- just stunned. It had rained and the roads were wet.Note how he conspicuously includes references to “college” and “my local art house theatre”. That is what these “people” are. It’s 100% performative intellectual signalling.
>>224288381this movie is kino from start to finishhttps://youtu.be/7k0-pSCwcx4?si=fbsdQlp-rr2wmrPWhttps://youtu.be/RAM9jC0t-mE?si=V_KZ3SSo9iZCjK_4https://youtu.be/YfihdKC7A_w?si=qYBXLsDKKSVyJ79shttps://youtu.be/wvDSl4WB-Q4?si=XfDXv7SRFW3BfRZJhttps://youtu.be/xxScnMSVxIs?si=wH5q62TjbN-REqdE
>>224288750what I loved first about PTA was his camera move accuracy and editing, he clearly had the Martin Scorsese gift. It was hard for me to accept when he moved on from imitating Scorsese but I eventually fell in love with him again.
>>224288750Now explain why any of those scenes are good or what you liked about them. And don’t just say some pretentious cop out bullshit like “they are well acted scenes”. That’s like saying a song is good because the musicians can technically play their instruments very well
>>224288803>>224288803uhh its a great story about regret and finding yourself in the end. Also the smart kid is able to stop the cycle of failure from happening to him because he is so smart and thats neat.
>>224288892>3 hours of pretty ordinary human problems You aren’t “smart” for liking a movie, but you believed you were until this point
>>224288381Okay movie with a stupid ending.
>>224288965>>3 hours of pretty ordinary human problemssorry its not Marvel Slop
>>224288627>>224288526>>224288573Holy filtered. The movie is not even that deep, it's just very beautifully shot and packed with relatable emotions. It's also cool that it allows itself to be a bit whimsical and silly with the song and Tom's character. Don't overthink it my guy.
>>224288381i like it and i think pta should have been shot after the master i don't give a damn about his clothes
>>224289007What was “relatable” about 59 minutes of William H Macy talking about his teeth or whatever
>>224289007>filteredA term used exclusively by people who think that consuming certain media makes them “intelligent” (strangely these people never have any of the actual life accomplishments of a typical high IQ person)
>>224289007The song was such self indulgent dog shit. PTA just liked Aimee Mann songs so unrealistically wrote a scene where all these completely different characters happened to know the lyrics to that song and sing it to themselves. Mindblowing that people can be taken in by this stupidity
>Philip Seymour Hoffman stated during the deathbed scene, everything after Frank's "I'm not going to cry for you" was improvised by Tom Cruise.Wow! You mean the scene that doesn't fucking go anywhere and drags on forever and Tom Cruise is obviously rambling aimlessly and tripping over his words? Who woulda thunk.
>>224289166would you just stop with this trolling retard
>>224289085PTA is a retarded woman-brained simp. No one has ever argued against that
>>224289209That wasn’t me, that’s an independent objective third party who is also sentient enough to admit the movie sucked shit
>>224289209That was my first reply ITT. I'm 100% primed 24/7 to shit on this movie. This is the biggest piece of shit ever produced by the most talented powerhouse of a cast. Turn of the millenium, when nearly everything was solid gold.
>>224289258>>224289274>>224289303>>224289085these are just some of your posts
>>224289402I wish we could drown you and PTA in oil
adaptation 2002
Literally every PTA movie. He makes tryhard soulless shit>dude everyone loves the opening of 2001 so i better do that in my movie>and ill end my super serious movie with a reddit joke
>>224289402How does that feel
>>224288381magnolia has plenty of detractors, and did even at the time of its release, it's just that it specifically appeals to a certain kind of idiot and so dissenting voices are a minority
>>224289303Keep fighting the good fight
>>224289521it was pretty funny for a while going to watch a PTA movie in the theater and seeing a line of dark haired men that all dressed like PTA waiting to go in. All of them were inferior to him, desperate to be him.
>>224288381Do people seriously pretend to like things? For what purpose? Anyways, I would say black people racism victim movies
Interstellar is really bad
Taxi Driver
>>224289541I'm compelled to.It's like directing a 2026 movie back in 1999. Can you imagine. The amount of wrong steps you would have to take. They'd amount to the berth of the equator. Prime, sexy Tom Cruise. PSH. Reilyl. Julianne Moore. Quite literally every single 'that guy'. In 1999. It's impossible how shit this movie is. The amount of prophetic foresight it took to fuck this up. People make unforgettable movies with the effort it took to shit this turd out of PTA's gay asshole.
>>224289554Many of them are in this thread
>>224288381If this movie didn’t make you feel something, you are genuinely severely autistic . The point of films isn’t always to make you feel warm and summery happy
>>224289702The first ten minutes make you think it’s going to be something fucked up and interesting like Boogie Nights but then it’s just 3 hours of literally NOTHING
>>224289715What did you feel watching this movie, and in what specific scene? Was it William H Macy acting incoherently gay in a bar, talking about NOTHING?
>>224289649This. I even went into the theater really anticipating enjoying it because I love Nolan but that movie was a steaming pile of what the fuck
>>224289577Only people who are themselves guilty of pretending to like things act like people don’t pretend to like things. You pretended to like Magnolia and hoped someone would notice.
>>224289764What does that have to do with what I even said? Retarded schizo. Magnolia is a bloated mess
>>224289751For one, Julianne Moore and her dying husband from whom she has been gold digging and then suddenly realizing the tremendous loss she’s facing and having a breakdown, the kid who is pushed to the limits of pissing his pants on live television by his domineering parents, Jon C Reilly having this sort of “meeting of destiny” with a chick who he finally has mutual attraction with but it’s actually just some burned out cokehead retardedly bitch but he doesn’t get that yet. It’s a series of strange tragedies, that’s what the entire movie is.
>>224289860The Julianne Moore plot was almost unwatchable. I couldn’t have possibly cared less about her melodramatic breakdown over her shitty relationship with no stakes whatsoever. And you didn’t care either. You were planning the conversations you would have about the movie as you watched it in real time.
you guys just dont get the movie yet because you arent old enough
>>224290238>when you’re more mature you can relate to being a narcissist who abandons their family or a suicidal slut or a drunk who molests his daughter
>>224289433I can be objective and say some of his movies are good butt Magnolia was just him sniffing his own farts for 3 hours
>>224288381Boogie nights is a better movie. My favourite PTA movie
>>224291784Yeah nobody would have pretended Magnolia was good if PTA didn’t establish himself as a “thinking man’s filmmaker” with Boogie Nights
>>224289806What movies DO you pretend to like then? Since you definitely do
>>224292480nta, but I pretend to like Metropolis, but it's actually kind of boring.
>>224292480There are no films that I pretend to like, the whole premise of this is very stupid. On the odd occasion I'm talking to someone irl about a movie I don't like I just say that it wasn't my thing. What films do you pretend to like?
>>224292616Does it ever pay off? Like do people ever react the way you hoped?
>>224288381I am firmly in the camp of people who don’t like this movie and I say that as someone who loves pretty much all of PTA’s other movies. This one is just way, way overtuned. When they all start singing at the end it’s hard to watch. But you can’t act like there isn’t real filmmaking creativity in the movie or some really great moments. The movie has its influence, “Weapons” from last year is basically one big tribute to it
>>224292863No you were caught red-handed trying to claim that pretentious people don’t exist and that nobody would ever pretend to like something to appear smart or cultured, which is just an egregious, shameful lie. All pseudo-intellectuals attempt this tactic as their first go-to defense, therefore you are a pseudo intellectualSo let me guess..David Lynch? You probably pretend to like Mulholland Drive or something like that
>>224292889the singing bit is what really dates it. Just feels weird. Like some 2000s ad for home insurance
>>224292889>But you can’t act like there isn’t real filmmaking creativity in the movie or some really great moments. Name one. Like name one scene you would actually vouch for and stake your credibility on to an objective stranger, say a Gen Z kid with no attention span or a “cool black guy” in a du rag who is generally dismissive toward white cultural tropes
>>224292899LOL. Pretentious people definitely exist. You are living proof of that!
>>224292917>I happen to like this artist so I will work their music into my film as a song that people off all different age ranges and backgrounds somehow know and enjoy Shamelessly pathetic creative decision. He should actually be severely beaten for doing that. Just taking gravity bong rips of his own farts
>>224292924>no YOU are actually the one who is pretending to NOT like the movie! Haha!>I can’t actually outline the supposed psychological mechanism behind why you would do this, but I can baselessly SAY you’re doing it!People who just throw out “projection” as their go-to response in any argument are demonstrating a sub-90 IQ
>>224292918The opening montage sequence has some really cool filmmaking taking a cue from Citizen Kane. The insane black bitch was funny and right out of Boogie Nights. And Tom Cruise had a great character and performance that echoes today’s podcast hosts
>>224292948>>224292933>>224292918>>224292899LMAO. You lost and got raped by a shitty movie and now have to post wojaks
>>224291784I’m jealous of boogie nights. Nuts that a 25 year old made that movie and it has scenes in it that are better than anything today’s filmmakers would ever make
>>224292956>taking a cue from Citizen Kane.See what I mean? It’s all intellectual performatice fart sniffing >oh no you don’t get it, it’s actually a clever educated reference
>>224292963>started of trying to argue sincerely then pivoted to “ironic trolling xD” when that failed >second all caps fake laugh so far in the threadBrutal.
>>224289085He went too far with Magnolia but he recognized it and never approached this level of pretension again, Phantom Thread is like the polar opposite kind of movie. Very dignified and restrained but effective. He matured as an artist and deserves credit for it
>>224293018KEK
>>224290201Hell nah, John C Reilly and the little kid had by far the worst plots
>>224293058How does it compare to One Battle After Another?
Easily one of the worst movies ever created. Just two hours of "wypipo bad" slop
>>224294209I understand what you mean but nowhere near the same category. Have you actually watched Magnolia? It’s a movie where literally nothing happens
Manufactured, fake opinions
>>224288381
>>224294933Nobody has heard of that movie
>>224288381The intro promised some great coincidence, but there was none in the movie
>>224295011That was the worst part. It sets up such a huge expectation then gives you nothing. The characters sort of almost collide with each other in some ways, sometimes. That’s it’s
>>224288381What emeperor has no cloth mean?
>>224288381Slopsession
>>224288381the ninth gate
>>224288381I cry every time I see this movie. Multiple times. I love the music. I love the acting. I love everything, except that they cut out the black character.
>>224288381I really can’t stress enough how much I hated this piece of shit movie and hate Paul Thomas Anderson for making it. I was in such a bad mood and just wanted to relax with a good cinematic experience for a few hours. I heard this was a good movie. It promised so much and then delivered nothing, STEALING 3 hours from life. Truly, anyone who praises this film is subhuman and should be killed
>>224295306Every time I start this movie, I finish it. It has such addictive editing, the way it goes from scene to scenes but the score connects everything so well.
>>224295306Name one good scene and why you lying faggot
That's the case with all of Paul Thomas Anderson's movies with the exception of Boogie Nights.He makes gorgeous, luxurious, and completely empty flicks.
I think the movie is alright, but when they start to simultaneously sing along to the radio I check out completely. What a weird creative choice. Same for the kid rapping to the police officer.
>>224288381It's a bit indulgent and not quite on par with his best work but it's still fucking great for what it is, a nice big budget freak out.
>>224295315You do this just so you can tell people you do it. There are no good scenes in the movie. It isn’t funny or interesting or entertaining or gripping. It’s just a few loosely interconnected vignettes of wholly unremarkable, uninteresting characters whining about their first world misery
>>224295367>Same for the kid rapping to the police officer.Nooooo don’t you get it the kid outlines the whole plot of the movie in his rap before it even happens! That’s GENIUS for reasons that I can’t actually articulate!
>>224295370What’s one “great” thing about the movie? What is ONE scene where if a friend was in the room with you, you would point to the screen like “dude watch this part it’s so good!” and stand by it without embarrassment?
>>224295097It means you pretend to seee the “brilliance” of something because you’re commanded to by social decree, when no such brilliance actually exists. Based on the allegory of people pretending to see the emperors invisible clothes when he’s actually naked
>>224295306>>224295370Explain the William H Macy storyline and what was “good” about it(Watch this, everyone)
>>224295332>He makes gorgeous, luxurious, and completely empty flicks."Completely empty" is a bit harsh but I get what you're saying. In TWBB the emptiness works and Punch-Drunk Love and Phantom Thread have some heart to them.
>>224295456It's fucking kino and funniest part of the movie, you plotfag.
>>224295415I don't have friends.
>>224295498>it’s kinoWHY?>it’s funny WHY?Don’t just tell me it’s good because you’ve been instructed to say so. Show that you have sentient thoughts.
>>224295524Notice how you bailed and immediately tried to resort to self deprecating humor when challenged to actually defend the film in objective terms
>>224295557Magnolia is a cinematic masterpiece that masterfully explores the complexities of the human condition through its interconnected narratives, emotionally compelling performances, and profound thematic depth. Director Paul Thomas Anderson seamlessly weaves together themes of trauma, regret, forgiveness, and the interconnectedness of human existence. Its innovative storytelling, exceptional cinematography, and powerful soundtrack create a deeply immersive experience that resonates with audiences on both an emotional and intellectual level. Ultimately, Magnolia transcends conventional filmmaking to deliver a thought-provoking meditation on what it truly means to be human.
Fucking BASED Burt Reynolds. I wish he had actually shattered PTA’s jaw. Then he would have been too psychologically broken to ever attempt this self indulgent piece of shit film
>>224294933The ending ruins the entire movie. The fact that the director wasted my time for something that could have come from a student short film is criminal.
>>224295590>lol I ironically got AI to answer for me as some kind of profound joke >hopefully this will convincingly cover for my inability to say what’s good about the movie
>>224295557if he laughed at it, that means it's funny. laughter is not a rational response and demanding that people logically explain their laughter or else they must be faking it is some extreme autist shit.
>>224295734Amazing performances and characters, good pacing, well shot, relatable themes, poignant, fantastic score. I'm sorry that you can't appreciate a good movie.
>>224288381PTA has talent, clearly, but he's a piece of shit whose scale of values is so utterly screwed up that his films will always leave a nasty taste in the mouth.He's the Thomas Pynchon of filmmakers. What he thinks is evil is not evil and what he thinks is good is most certainly not good. (No surprise he filmed IV.)
>>224295456He used to be smart. He used to be quiz kid like the quiz kid in the present. His dad took all his money. LA is filled with these washed up people has-beens who do nothing but blame other people for why their life sucks. There is an emotional arc when the kid asks his dad to treat him better, hopefully he won't end up like quiz kid donny smith. If you ever had abusive parents this can be relatable. He desperately thinks he needs one things (braces) and then he'll get what he wants. Everyone has felt that before. Just need this new jacket, new car, new job, new shampoo and then people will like me. It's good cause it's human. It's artful because of how it connects to other characters. Even the policeman, who feels useless because he lost his gun but is able to help this man.
>>224295796>if he laughed at it, that means it's funny. And I’m saying he didn’t laugh at it. He’s pretending he did. People who actually find something funny have no trouble explaining why they found it funny or what was funny about it
>>224295832>He used to be smart. He used to be quiz kid like the quiz kid in the present. His dad took all his money. LA is filled with these washed up people has-beens who do nothing but blame other people for why their life sucks. There is an emotional arc when the kid asks his dad to treat him better, hopefully he won't end up like quiz kid donny smith. If you ever had abusive parents this can be relatable.He desperately thinks he needs one things (braces) and then he'll get what he wants. Everyone has felt that before. Just need this new jacket, new car, new job, new shampoo and then people will like me.…….HAHAHAHAHAHA?????
>>224295832All of that sucks
the godfather
While Magnolia (1999) is widely praised by cinephiles, critics who dislike Paul Thomas Anderson’s three-hour epic often argue that the film is an exhausting, self-indulgent exercise in melodrama that prioritizes stylistic bravado over coherent storytelling.From the perspective of its detractors, the movie fails in several key areas:1. Bloated Runtime and Self-Indulgence• Excessive Length: At 188 minutes, critics argue the film lacks discipline and a firm editorial hand. Many subplots feel padded, dragging out emotional beats far past their natural conclusion.• Director Ego: Detractors often view the movie as a textbook example of a young auteur given too much freedom after a breakout hit (Boogie Nights). The constant moving camera, booming soundtrack, and high-volume acting can feel less like storytelling and more like the director showing off.2. Relentless Melodrama and Misery• Emotional Exhaustion: Nearly every character is in a state of extreme crisis, weeping, screaming, or confessing dark secrets. Critics point out that when everything is dialed up to eleven for three straight hours, the audience becomes numb rather than moved.• Manipulative Tone: Rather than letting drama build naturally, the film relies heavily on Aimee Mann’s music and sweeping camera zooms to tell the audience how to feel. To detractors, this feels heavy-handed and emotionally manipulative.3. Contrived Connections and "Deep" Themes• Forced Coincidences: The film weaves together nine separate storylines in the San Fernando Valley, relying on extreme coincidences to tie them together. Critics argue these connections feel artificial rather than organic.• Pseudo-Profundity: Detractors frequently criticize the film’s overarching themes of regret, forgiveness, and chance as shallow. They argue that dressing up basic soap-opera tropes in stylish filmmaking tricks viewers into thinking the movie is deeper than it actually is.
>>2242960774. The Infamous Frog Ending• Tonal Whiplash: The climax, in which thousands of frogs literally rain from the sky, is the biggest sticking point for critics. Detractors view it as a bizarre, unearned gimmick that breaks the grounded reality of the characters' struggles.• A Cop-Out Resolution: Instead of resolving the complex emotional knots he spent three hours tying, Anderson uses a literal act of God to shock the characters into changing. To many, this feels like a cheap shortcut because the writer couldn't figure out a realistic way to conclude the stories.5. Over-the-Top Performances• Histrionic Acting: While the cast is undeniably talented, detractors argue that the direction encourages theatrical screaming and sobbing over nuance. Characters like Julianne Moore’s Linda Partridge and Tom Cruise’s Frank T.J. Mackey are often cited as bordering on caricature.
>>224295805Go watch it again then faggot (you won’t)
>>224295940>People who actually find something funny have no trouble explaining why they found it funnyi don't think you talk to human beings much.
>>224288381ONE
>>224288381I agree with you completely OP, I also feel this way about 2001
>>224288381hey fuck you I liked itI've seen it twice and it holds upperhaps your attention span is too short for a 3 hour movie
>>224294209You must be a zoomer who didnt pay attention during the movie.The theme was CLEARLY anti globohomo, NOT anti white.White people were portrayed as the first victims of globohomo (vampirism)The sympathetic and handsome white "villain" was just a guy who was forced to become a vampire, cursed to live forever and infect others, losing his identity, memories and roots in the process. He was a cultural drifter who desperately tried to rekindle the connection with his ancestors by using blacks and their music as a channeling rod.It was ultimately a desperate act , a losing fight against the globohomo that sustains him but also takes away his cultural and personal identity.If "white people bad" is the only thing you take away from this, then I will assume you have brain damage
>>224288381Agreed, OP. Thanks for making this thread. Magnolia was a huge letdown. Boogie Nights and Punch-Drunk Love are good though. TWBB and Inherent Vice are ok.
>>224296176You didn’t find his character’s scenes funny and that dawned on you when I challenged you on it, causing this avoidant shame response we are seeing now.
I saw Magnolia on free TV when I was like ten or eleven and I instantly liked the movie, I didn't have anyone influencing me to like the movie and I had no business even watching it really being so young. It's a great flick with some brutal flaws (the singing bit) but nothing worthy of the hate it gets and this weird delusion where people act like they can't form their own opinions on things and need others to tell them something is great.
>>224296268>I personally like the movie so I will try to dishonestly twist it into something not cucked which is completely different from the directors actual stated intent People like you should be kept in cages and a forced to perform labor, or just killed and used as biolfuel
>>22429639610 year olds frequently pretend to like things because they think it’s “adult”. You almost certainly did this because you were far too young to understand the themes
>>224296129I've watched the movie 4 times.
>>224296410Nah, I mostly remember enjoying the pacing and the performances. It's not like I was relating with the characters. It's just a strange movie. The acting felt really over the top to me and in a good way, I hadn't really seen anything like that before and it was the beginning of my journey into "independent" movies (it was aired on IFC).
>>224288381Is this board just 100% bait now?
>>224296452People here just prioritize nihilism over everything else.
>>224296443And each time you vividly mapped out the future conversations you would have telling people how smart you are for liking it, waiting for a social payoff that never actually manifests
>>224296506Magnolia is a nihilistic movie that humanises molestors, sluts and addicts. Nobody who likes Magnoilia has any moral character. Nobody who likes Magnolia can perform even ten push-ups. Most of them drink and smoke.
Most of the people who like Magnolia probably listen to alternative and indie rock
>>224296452What was a good scene in Magnolia
>>224288381>le sing-a-long sequence
>>224296678https://youtu.be/G2y6zxvMtPE?si=bDSJhEovPFHhZym7
>>224288381I like Magnolia even though its not a very good movie.
>>224296720Why is this good? It establishes the basis of his character. He’s an Andrew Tate type scammer. So what?
>>224296723Nothing happens in the movie. It’s 3 hours of establishing characters and setting up a plot that never resolves
>>224288381What if the eneporer has no clothes
Magnolia sucks
Utterly bizarre thread.
>>224297351Name one good scene from Magnolia that you enjoy rewatching and would recommend to someone in your life
>>224297624I haven't even seen the movie at all as I have no interest in PTA's farts but you sure are hellbent on catching people "pretending" to like the movie for some reason
>>224288381I liked it and I've only met one other person who did. If anything, my reality was the opposite of what you've said.
>>224288381I actually hesitated to watch this movie for a long time for how highly praised and hyped, fearing I would have the emperor has no clothes reaction. It ended up being a top PTA film for me, competing with Boogie Nights, mainly because it is a film so driven by sentimentality that the actor's performances are the front and center appeal. With the cast that it has, the ensemble work becomes so emotionally fulfilling. It is actually better that the separate stories only sometimes intersect at times and in other places not at all because it feels less like someone trying to make this epic singular story that contains all these big personalities, but rather explore the idea of each person's life can be a tragedy or otherwise compelling narrative that is worthy of a dramatic performance and made for cinema. I fear that people who actively hate this film are either emotionally stunted or instead just as broken as these characters and has a hard time processing that.
>>224297624Not that anon but the scene where it starts raining frogs and the little kid recognises it as a real paranormal phenomenon was great. It gave me chills. I don't rewatch it or recommend it though because I don't generally do that.
>>224297624could you give an example of what you're looking for? pick a movie you like, a scene you like in it, and explain why it's good in a way you would consider sufficient proof that you really like it and are not pretending.
>>224296854>It establishes the basis of his character. yeah, and it does that well, and people remember it as a notable cruise performance a quarter of a century later. why is it not good? what's wrong with it?
>>224296854Do you still want people to answer your question after you answered it yourself?
>>224297772In Kill Bill Michael Madsen’s character Bud is the only villain who acknowledges the wrongs of what he did to the Bride and refuses protection from her, saying that she has a right to try and kill him. He is also the only villain who she can’t kill and he gets the jump on her. This is actually good filmmaking with depth because it shows he is a true “warrior”, that martial competence and character go hand in handSee how easy that is? When you actually like something and aren’t pretending you have no problem showing your work
>>224297962Establishing a character isn’t a filmmaking achievement, it’s one of the basic fundamental requirements of even having a story. Every single film that exists establishes its characters. You showed your hand by grasping at this so desperately and opportunistically when I said it.
>>224297984Why is that good? He acknowledges his past mistakes. So what?
>>224297934It’s nothing. It goes nowhere. Yeah he’s a cringe pickup artist who is mad at his dad for leaving him. And? What does the movie do with that? Nothing.
>>224298033I already explained what it does, you deliberately pretended I didn’t, very pathetically at that, and nobody is falling for it.
>>224288381Magnolia is one of the worst movies ever made, its unspeakably bad.
>>224297984>>224298036>In Kill Bill Michael Madsen’s character Budit's nothing. it's goes nowhere. yeah he's a true warrior who acknowledges the wrongs of what he did to the bride. and? what does the movie do with that? nothing.do you see? why is establishing madsen as a true warrior good, and establishing cruise as an insecure pua guy not good? what's the difference? why is communicating a character's nature good in the movie you like and "nothing" in the movie you don't like?
>>224298061It genuinely killed my love for movies a little bit. Like from now on I will forever be more hesitant to watch a movie and look forward to the joy of cinema because it might be another huge, empty disappointment like Magnolia. Everyone in this thread praising it deserves to be beaten and raped.
>>224298010Fair point. I retract my snide implication. To answer your question, I liked it because it's a compelling performance that evokes complex emotions about an original character.
>>224298120I said >This is actually good filmmaking with depth because it shows he is a true “warrior”, that martial competence and character go hand in handThe plot and character development serve a function. A guy hating his dad shows nothing. A man molesting his daughter shows nothing. A woman cheating on her dying husband shows nothing. There is no narrative purpose of any of these things
>>224298146On your mothers life your brain actually released dopamine when you watched Magnolia?
The Venn diagram of people who praise Magnolia and also this pedophilic nihilist film is a perfect circle
>>224298196Yes, I enjoyed watching it. I wouldn't rewatch it because much of the movies appeal is in its unpredictability, and the anticipation of more unusual and interesting characters and ideas, which it delivers on. I wouldn't recommend it to everyone, and I wouldn't say it's PTA's best, but I can honestly say I liked it.
i’m going to watch magnolia again because>i liked it the first time i watched it>to spite the contrarian assholes in this thread
>>224298235I liked Magnolia, and disliked Happiness so much that I didn't even finish it.
>>224289649Normalfags are literally terrified of criticizing any Nolan movie because he’s somehow earned a reputation as a highbrow director
>>224298169okay, and in magnolia the next scene with cruise is the interview where the journalist asks probing questions about his past and he starts going to pieces. so>this is actually good filmmaking with depth because it shows he is a narcissist, that his charismatic public performance is driven by deep internal anxiety about being exposedwhy does establishing that martial competence goes hand in hand with character a "function" but establishing that charismatic figures are driven by anxiety not a "function" but "nothing"? it's the same kind of point, made in a very similar way.
>>224298279It’s the same movie: Humanising shitty people as “art” for shitty people who themselves had bad consciences. If you have moral character there’s no appeal in Magnolia and you can’t relate to any of the characters or care about them
>>224298317But it goes without saying that he’s a narcissist. The fact that it’s a false shield for an insecure person is implied in his presentation. Digging into that over half an hour with an actual interview going into his backstory establishes nothing
>>224298359no, it doesn't go without saying. you might already have this intuition about pua gurus but other people might not, in particular viewers back in 1999, before this kind of grifter became mainstream. what's being established being already known to you is different from nothing being established. if i watched kill bill already believing that "martial competence and character go hand in hand" that wouldn't mean the relevant scenes establish nothing, would it?
>>224298515Now do William H Macy’s character sitting in the bar talking about the bartender with braces and chatting it up with an older gay man
>IF YOU LIKE A MOVIE I DON’T LIKE YOU SHOULD BE KILLED!!!>brings up moral characterSchizophrenia is funny.
>>224298626Moral character doesn’t mean altruism, it means your values. The Romans were pitiless and cruel but had very strong morals. I expect an insensate Magnolia-loving NPC like you to misunderstand this though
>>224298331I can't comment on Happiness, having not finished it, but Magnolia portraying morally complex human characters isn't inherently immoral. Humans are morally complex in reality. Magnolia doesn't present bad behaviour as good, it presents it as having human consequences. It shows people suffering because of their bad behaviour. Anyone can relate to the feeling of regret, even if it's not for those particular misdeeds.
>>224298277Look how far soulless pretentious people will go to protect their fake, cultivated identities. Punishing himself for another 3 hours to protect his frail sunk cost fallacy mindset
>>224298573why are you changing the subject?
>>224298689lotta projection from this anon
>>224298678Maybe this is just a “pineapple on pizza” type of thing. Best of luck to you I guess
>>224298660What were the strong morals of the Romans?
>>224298697Because it’s clear we’re not going to agree and we’re going around in circles, and William H Macy’s character was the more egregiously bad part of the movie that you will find it impossible to defend, which is why you didn’t even attempt to. Thanks for proving my point for me
>>224298740Gravitas and severitas among others. Did you really think I wouldn’t have an answer to this just because you yourself haven’t personally researched the topic, dumbass?
>>224298726You don’t like Magnolia
>>224298331>>224298660does your moral character include the capacity to admit you were wrong? you asked for a defense of a scene in magnolia, i provided one that matched the standard you established with the kill bill example, you have failed to find any fault in it, and yet i don't see you admitting it. i see you trying to avoid the subject.>>224298759we are not going in circles at all, we have reached the clear conclusion that the sequence in magnolia matches the standard of "deep filmmaking" you've established yourself. now it turns out i have to do this for every scene in the movie? there's no circle, you just realized you were wrong and now you're trying to change the subject to another scene to conceal it. you are a dishonest, cowardly person.
This is the black kids rap that is supposed to have a “profound” mesn in in the movie and predict the rest of the plot by the way:>Presence! With the double-ass-meaning gifts I bestow, With my riff and my flow, But you don't hear me, though, Think fast, catch me, yo, 'Cause I throw what I know, With a resonance, For your trouble-ass fiend In weaning yourself, Off of the back of the shelf, Jackass crackers, body-stackers, Dick-tooting niggers, Masturbating your triggers. Living to get older, With a chip on your shoulder, Except you think you got a grip, 'Cause your hip got a holster, Ain't no confessor, so, buster, you better just shut the fuck up, Try to listen and learn. Check that ego, Come off it, I'm the prophet, The professor, I'm gonna teach you about the Worm, Who eventually turned to catch wreck, With the neck of a long-time oppressor, And he's running from the devil, But the debt is always gaining, And if he's worth being hurt, He's worth bringing pain in...A total and utter piece of shit of a movie and anyone who likes it is a diarrhea drinking retard
>>224298871Says the guy who adores Tarantino slop, the most embarrassing niggerlover crap in the world
>>224298854> does your moral character include the capacity to admit you were wrong? you asked for a defense of a scene in magnolia, i provided one that matched the standard you established with the kill bill example, you have failed to find any fault in it, and yet i don't see you admitting it. i see you trying to avoid the subject.Your argument rested on the ridiculous notion that people didn’t know narcissistic arrogant people were secretly insecure until the 2010s or so, which is a viewpoint you just made up on the spot as a cope for this threadAnd no you don’t have to defend every scene in the movie. Just explain why William H Macy sitting in a bar and talking about getting braces to an older gay man was “good”.You won’t because you know it sucked, and you were waiting for the movie to be over so you could pretentiously tell people you liked it
>>224298915I don’t even like Tarantino films that much. But yeah liberal cuck PTA isn’t a nigger lover at all
>>224298920And yet you think your example of “strong warrior with strong character” from Kill Bill was something amazingly profound and not something that’s been in storytelling for fucking hundreds of years? What a retarded schizo you are
>>224298915Defend the black kid rapping scene.
>>224298969So you forfeit and concede that the William H Macy character and scenes absolutely sucked shit and were pointless. Cool, thank you for doing that.
>>224298920>Your argument rested on the ridiculous notion that people didn’t know narcissistic arrogant people were secretly insecure until the 2010s or sono, that's not what my arguments rests on. it rests on the fact that you happening to find the insight of the movie boring does not mean the movie has no insight, just like me finding the insight in kill bill boring does not mean it has no insight. also, incidentally, most people do not understand how narcissism actually works even today.>Just explain why William H Macy no. you explicitly, multiple times, demanded a defense of one good scene, i delivered it, and like the faggot weasel you are you moved the goalpost to something else. if you had one ounce of honesty in your faggot weasel body you would bring yourself to type "okay you were right," but your faggot weasel character compels you to keep squirming away. if i defended the william h macy part you'd just go "okay now the rapping part" and so on. get fucked.
>>224296617Well, yeah, so?
Durrr we need data and workers :)
>>224299149It just shows that you’re a liberal minded person who isn’t fundamentally connected to truth, reality or human nature, and is in fact hostile in your denial of those things, and this informs your tastes. For example liking simply love songs and being a sensitive beta with women because you don’t understand from an evolutionary psychology standpoint women cannot biologically be attracted to that behavior. That is the kind of person who appreciates Magnolia; someone who fundamentally exists as wrong and incorrect
>>224288381It was good, but the part where they are all singing was fucking cringe.
>>224299144>no. you explicitly, multiple times, demanded a defense of one good scene, i delivered it, and like the faggot weasel you are you moved the goalpost to something else. if you had one ounce of honesty in your faggot weasel body you would bring yourself to type "okay you were right," but your faggot weasel character compels you to keep squirming away. if i defended the william h macy part you'd just go "okay now the rapping part" and so on. get fucked.Whoever said that liberal creative types trying to use the word faggot is like someone wincing when they fire a gun for the first time was so right
>>224299300He absolutely destroyed you in that post lmao
You people are pathetic
>>224299319No he didn’t. I addressed all his points, he just ignored them and simply stated that I didn’t
>>224299401That’s literally what you just did lol you have actual brain worms
>>224299144>>224299319>being this mentally shattered by the forced realisation that the William H Macy scenes were actually shit>like inexplicably bizarre and surreal in how shit they were and how much they sucked>so much so that it hurts you>a lot
>replied to the same post twiceHoly fuck this dude is crumbling lol
If you like the "respect the cock" scenes you should read the screenplay, there is even more dialogue that was cut.
>I COULD explain why the William H Macy scenes were shit, I’m just CHOOSING not to because I’m above this conversation>not so above it that I will continue entering multiple capchas and typing multiple paragraphs about other shit though
>>224299455What’s the fake laugh count up to in this thread now? Is that like your 7th? A sure sign of confidence and self assurance
>>224299485*weren’t shit
>bringing out the wojaks now LOL
>>224299547Fake laugh #8, really let’s people know you’re confident in what you’re saying (x8)
>>224299659now type that again, this time without crying
>>224299712>without crying Like you did when you realised you were indeed pretending to like the William H Macy scenes all along?
>>224299840no, like when you made that post and you were holding back tears
>>224299858You will always be gun shy when talking about Magnolia from now on because of this thread. You know people are on to you and see through the act.
>>224300141>bawwww bawwwwwwwchin up soldier, you'll get over it
>>224300141It’s funny how obvious it is that you don’t interact with real people because you think most normal people would have even heard of this movie at all
>>224288466The Oscar winner was when that woman starts crying about all the cocks she's sucked.
>>224288526You're more pretentious than the people you're seething about.
>>224298871so cringe
>>224290684>soijak niggerYou proved his point lol