> he's just comically evilTolkien is just a shit writer after all?
He's a "smith". Which is just code for "engineer". Have you ever met an engineer in real life? They're psycho. Emotionally detached, hyper fixated on optimization. Ironically lacking communication skills, compounded with self-pride. To be fair, in the First Age, he had this island of werewolves which was pretty cool. He took "evil spirits" and found a use for them. But that's the problem with his machinations; it's just a zero-sum system of exploitation that falls apart should anyone do something self-sacrificing and virtuous. Ending violence instead of perpetuating it.
>>224290862Tolkien was a Christian so his entire concept of evil is based on Bible verses.
>>224290862he’s literally me
>>224291612He's basically a high fantasy tech bro, yeah.
>>224290862Comically evil people who were just born twisted exist in real life. These are the people who have 40 felony arrests under their belt and just keep wracking them up until they finally murder someone because their idea of fun is brutalizing the vulnerable and tyrannizing the local populace.The narrative that everything is a socio-economic factors is one of the main reasons civilization is imploding. The violent criminal that the woke judge won't lock away for life is the socio-economic factor that's oppressing the locals.
>>224290862He is a fallen angel of science and the arts that started following the universes Satan because he found the using extensions of evils will allowed him to place his will upon the world faster and more efficientlyAfter the war between good and evil in the first age he is offered a pardon but he is too afraid/ashamed to take it so he stays behind in arda. At first working to heal the world of the scars he helped make, but after a while he comes to think god abandoned the world because it is such a shitty place. So he starts corrupting and enslaving people to his will to do what he pleases with it. There is some implication in the unpublished Morgoth ring cycle that Morgoth(devil) himself corrupted physical reality with his nihilism and hate for any mind outside his own existing and sauron when he forged the ring tapped into this morgoth element and damned himself.
>>224290862He's a cat and all cats are assholes. But it's not their fault.
>>224293410he’s actually a werewolf shapeshifter, so closer to a dog actually
>>224293447No in the first version of the story Beren and Lúthien Tolkien wrote Sauron was a cat, he became the werewolf in a later draft but there is a whole plot of escaping a cat castle and i like it better
I suspect Luthien killing, Thuringwethil, his goth mommy batlady second in command and skinning her to steal the shape shifting powers might be a reason he hates the Westernesse
>>224293472earlier drafts don’t count, the latest drafts are what is canon. I’m a writer, I’d be horrified if people decided my rough drafts were canon and completely ignored the changes I deliberately made for good reasons
>>224290862watch the show and find out ;)
>>224293596The first draft got him in ediths pussy during ww1, i suspect it has more impact than the later drafts his son liked better, neither were published by him.
>>224291612
>>224293642trust me, as a writer, I’d be horrified if people read my first drafts, and even more horrified if people decided my earlier drafts were canon rather than accepting the changes I had made. He would not have made newer drafts if he was satisfied with the originals.
>>224293652You can be wrong about your own creation. His earlier works are better written as narratives go and have a vitality of youth that sitting around reading Old English historical writng and learning Finnish ruined
>>224293684Opinions are not objective, you can’t be “wrong” about an opinion.A writer cannot, however, be wrong about which draft they decide is canon. A writer has full authority to decide what is canon and what isn’t, and he obviously preferred the new drafts or he wouldn’t have written them,
>>224293702My opinion is objectively right tho. He never published either so we will go with the better version.
>>224293715logic dictates you would go with the latest version.I currently have an unpublished book that has gone through several revisions and I can guarantee that if I died, or if any writer died, they’d want their latest drafts to be canon. You don’t know what you’re talking about
>>224293740you are "writer" so is everyone. Doesn't give you any insight I don't have. I'm not going to keep wasting my time on your autistic fixation with chronology and your own personal preference.
>>224293781it’s fucking obvious that the latest drafts are canon because nobody would write new drafts if they were happy with the originals. It’s just basic logic, you’re a dumbass
>>224293827The 1917 draft was the only version ever completed into a full narrative, if you have scraps around with ideas but only finish one. Its canon.
>>224290862Tolkien is a very good fantasy writer, but he has his weak points, characters being one of them. None of the characters really have any personality at all beyond good or evil.
>>224293867he wouldn’t have spent his life trying to finish his new drafts if he considered the originals to be canon.Face it fuckface, Tolkien gets to decide what is canon about his book, and he spent his whole life writing new drafts for the silmarillion because he decided his original drafts weren’t canon. I bet you think the original hobbit draft is canon too, what a loser
>>224290862He's just an autist, not evil.
making the little retarded faggot mystery meat kid the witch king is egregious
>>224293123>Leaf with a EU commission nameCan't get more pozzed than that
>>224293879For having "weak" characters, he still manages to have quite cool character moments. Eowyn facing the Nazgul for example. Or Sam talking about how there's still good in the world worth fighting for at the end of their journey.Granted, most of his characters feel more like stand ins for concepts but I think that's mainly because he's inspired by old sagas and the like.
>>224294275meh, he doesn't look THAT out of place
>>224293213The violent born evil monsters who are destroying the world are in the halls of power. The retard next door is easily dealt with. The billionaire who believes in the death of all people who don't bow to them as if they are demigods are the ones you have to look out for.
>>224294336ok homo now post the quasi down syndrome actor
>>224290862Hell, at least have him shave instead of looking like a hobo with a grill on his head.
>>224290862He wants to genocide brown poopjeets like you
>>224293879>t GRR Shartin subhuman grey le character
>>224291612He was Aule CEO saar
>>224293879>None of the characters really have any personality at all beyond good or evilt. never read the damn thing
>>224293652Tolkein respected oral tradition and the mythmaking process. I think he would appreciate chris releasing the other drafts and discussions of the changes in the books of lost tales etc from a historical perspective. Stories exist over time, not in a definitive single version.
>>224293123I would use this ring to shitpost and jack off, but through me it would wield a power too terrible to imagine.
>>224293123Why would I listen to a pedo on bluesky
>>224293879They are meant to be characters out of a legend
>>224292953*Catholic
>>224290862Too white for Middle Earth.>>224293123Wtf is a techbro? Someone who likes "technology" but doesn't know how it works?
>>224294275worse than this?
>>224293879Bilbo and Tom Bombadil have distinct personalities not defined by morality alone. Possibly we could say the same of Treebeard.
>>224293879That's because LOTR isnt like subsequent fantasy, for example Dungeons & Dragons. This leans far more into mythology, thus into black and white good vs evil. This isn't a bug, It's an essential feature of what Tolkien tried to convey.
Hail Suaron, amirite lads?
>>224298458And Pippin, and Gollum and Denethor. Even Boromir.
>>224294275>>224298450If the Ring-Servants were all white men, then you faggots would complain that it was woke anti-white messaging. "Oh only the white men are evil, right? Days without jewish tricks, etc."
>>224293123I don't even know what the fuck people were trying to do with the Ring it's such a shitty greed and temptation metaphor because for like 99.9% of the population it does nothing but turn you invisible and get spectral hunters immediately on your assI get people like Galadriel who could probably draw out what it was actually capable of but like what the fuck is Boromir gonna do with it?
>>224298450holy shit a Nigzul just stole my bike!
>>224291612true
>>224293472Yeah, and he also called the Noldor "gnomes".