versus the movies edishI find it very weird that the students are chanting "dumbledore! dumbledore!". Fucking grim. He's PROFESSOR DUMBLEDORE. Or HEADMASTER. He's not one of the students! But the millennial women (and fags) who wrote this show do not understand the distinction between student and teacher, and have devolved the headmaster to one of the students.Also note the jab: "His nature is entirely his own". Most of you aren't leftist enough to see this as an anti-racism dogwhistle. This line is so aggressively anti-canon that it practically solidifies the show as a pile of doo-doo. They're not going to add everything from the books. The show is going to have drawn out heartfelt dialogue in which everyone talks like a millennial woman. Every villain (including voldy) will be half white and half black (cough. Ahem.) and will never be truly evil because we cant have a racist on tv in the yookay now can we love?
Also note the bathroom tiles, and the shitty lampsAnd the muttoids of course
I thought the Harry Potter spam would be bad but I didn't anticipate that it'd begin over a month before the show is even released.
at least wait until the show comes out before you have a mental breakdown over it.
>>224294948>>224294944Rs0.5 have been deposited in your account
>>224294962You think someone is paying me half a rupee to reply to your spam?Do you even realize how little money that is?
>>224295109Poo in loo ranshitjeet
>>224295154Spam in /trash/, retard.
>>224295168It's not spam, retard. It's a critique and it belongs here. Go fuck off and do damage control somewhere else.
All of it is so unnecessary. That remark about James and Mcgonogall's excitement over Harry choosing Gryffindor are such heavyhanded bullshit fluff for supposed depth, foreshadowing and exposition.
>>224295182Critique of a show nobody's even seen?Like this anon >>224294948 said, can't you at least save it?What is the point of this other than advertising?
>>224295109how about you stay the fuck away from /tv/ dikshit ramjeet. Pajeets need to be range banned today from the internet and from the real world.
>>224295299This almost seems like projection.Anyway, I wonder if anyone on this board actually believes that someone being paid to post ITT will actually quit because of insults.
>>224294924It's more accurate to the books
>>224294924>lights everywhere>everything is darkI fucking hate those people
>>224294929purebloods... in me hogwarts.... bloody shite rowling think about their rights of trans people they deserve to exist in 90s britain !!!!!!
>>224294924That's a funny way to start a Malfoid thread.
>>224294929>Also note the bathroom tilesIt's so Moaning Myrtle will feel at home in the Great Hall. That's my official headcanon now.
>>224295258Look at the webm, you fucking retard
>>224294924>TEAL ORANGEWhen will this cult die? It's all over media for almost 15 years now. No one has ever said they like it. At best they put up with ti or get used to it. If teal-orange is so essential how can they explain:1. All the bombs that use that color scheme?2. The wildly successful media that existed BEFORE the teal-orange cult?Bonus: Did you know that teal-orange is built around the assumption that your film stars WHITE people with light skin? It doesn't even produce a contrast when there are darkies.
>>224294924>modern "edukayshion"vs>proper educationGenuinely grim.
>>224294924lmaoing at the shitty ai looking effect they used to make the food appear. why is everything so fucking shit now
>>224294924jesus this board is gonna be borderline unusable when the show comes out
There are black and brown kids in the 2001 version
>>224294924>2026 remake of a beloved movie is garbagemore at 11!
So is he confirmed FTM?
>>224295575Why do you degenerate trans enabling freaks keep insisting Dominic is FtM?He's a normal prepubescent shota. Leave him alone.
>>224295575You get what you fucking deserve!
>>224295517Thankfully I'll be enjoying Christmas with my family at that point and so will be ignoring /tv/ but I fear this will continue well into February and possibly beyond.
>>224295534Only Lee Jordan and Dean Thomas. In the new one every frame has nons.
>>224295517We need a /hp/ boardswaglord make it happen
>>224295575Isn't harry supposed to be a Chad? This kid is obviously not going to age well he already looks uncanny. I guess it'll be funny in season 4 when harry is running around looking like an old lesbian.
>>224295594why does he look like a lesbian?
>>224295799He doesn't.
>>224295807 she does
>>224295787>Isn't harry supposed to be a Chad?WTF gave you that impression?
>>224295807He unironically does. Humans have been mastering the skill of recognizing another person's sex for thousands of years. Stop pretending you don't see it.
>>224295818I'm sorry something inside of you is broken to the extent you see a picture of a relatively average looking prepubescent boy and immediately think he's a lesbian.
>>224295854>>224295860
>>224294924>Original Dumbledore makes the feast appear gracefully on the table in a way that feels truly magical>TV show has the food bounce into existence like a cheap lootbox animation, half that shit falls on the groundLame
>>224295851The entire series? He's the youngest seeker in a century, defeats wizard hitler and becomes britain's top cop
>>224295787Just like they gave puberty blockers to Macauley and his brother, they can give the kid HGH to make him more manly between seasons
>>224294924colors?
>>224295860>>224295854Do we know what his dad looks like?
>>224295860I'm sorry you are face-blind.
Alright let's see start with things that are wrong with the new versionFirst of all Dumbledore would clap his hands if he uses magic in the great hallSecond of all there'd be no stupid chanting for the headmasters name, while he can be eccentric, he will project himself as wise and reserved and would've asked the crowd to pipe downAlso way too much focus on kids gorging food as some sort of magical thing and no ghost or floating candles, also chowing down on food is a ron thing mostlyMcGonagall would be way too professional to boast having Harry, she's the definition of a tense and curt teacher and she's very dry even in conversation to the headmaster, Dumbledore also woudnt explain the 'hes his own self thing) to her
>>224295860>prepubescent>those teeth
>>224295898I'm honestly not sure. I'll ask one of my friends later, he's decidedly "into" NuHarry - if the parents have any social media presence and pics he'll know.
>>224295917Most of the boys are blatantly prepubescent with the notable exception of Lox Pratt who absolutely towers over all of them.
>>224295888He's the protagonist in a children's book series.Maybe you and I have very different ideas of what a Chad is; I'm getting the impression that you might think Bill Gates is a Chad because he's so successful.
>>224295959>a scrawny jew becoming rich by stealing other peoples work is the same as a skilled athlete and courageous hero who saves his school and environment over and over again
>>224294924WE
>>224294924draco is icsh
>>224296121Explain your bastardization of this euphemism. He is so not icky.
>magical food does not appear all at once>the kids at the end of the table has to wait for everyone else to get their food>make the last kid blackBASED
>>224296169>ickythat's not what icsh means tho
>>224296226It either means 'icky' or 'In Case Shit Hits'.Explain this new meaning.
>>224295908You forget that Dumbledore would NEVER say some ridiculous snide remark like "Admit it, you're pleased he's in your house" to McGonagall like a some passive-aggressive woman from an American sitcom. What the fuck was that?
>>224294924Looks gay. Won't watch.
>>224294924kek at Lithgow sneering and sniveling like a rat when the kids starts chanting, wtf was that?
>>224294924KEK they take one bite then the food gets stolen? lmao!
>>224295575That’s uncanny scary shit. They do this on purpose. Last of Us, etc. Promoting only deformed ugliness to enforce this false narrative that humans are all these weird ugly things that you can’t even tell are from the same species.
>>224294924Smart of them to release this STEAMING PILE OF SHIT on Christmas Day / Boxing Day, when everyone is too fat and tired to do anything else and all the shops are shut so we’re gonna be forced to have some TV time.
>>224296364>Admit it, _________.Reads like a 4chan bait post,
>>224295575Why is that dyke baring her teeth?
>>224296503He's Barty Crouch Jr. in disguise
>>224295959>>224295851He's a Chad in looks (like his quarterback father) but he's a mentalcel
>>224294924top is suspiciously blue and orange
>>224295109>spamJust because you're seething about it doesn't make it spam. You're completely delusional if you think Harry Potter needs artificial push to get threads, even the people who claim they are actively boycotting the IP can't help but consooming it just like we saw with the trannies and Hogwarts Legacy.
>>224295575He's already losing the baby fat.
>>224294924this is now a malfoid thread
>>224296791Well I didn't say that OP's being paid; almost certainly this advertisement is unpaid.I'd still say it's spam.
>>224296840He'll still be mogged by Radcliffe.
>>224296955Can you give a definition for spam real quick?
>>224294924I fully expect Harry to have his own peach moment and learn the importance of douching.
>>224296840Looks like a my little cousin, very cute.I wish these kids were part of something better istg
>>224295799You got it reversedIt's Lesbians who look like little boysIt's the combination of short hair and feminine features
>>224295851Across the series he fucks Ching Chong and Ginny, two of the hottest girls on Hogwarts.Even Hermione calls him hot in the 5th book.
>>224294924>mutts everywhere>why muh show bombed?
>>224297102browns love harry potter
>>224296979Spam is posting the same shit to the same board repeatedly It doesn't have to be for any particular purpose.
>>224297204>repeatedlyAnd when did this happen? Note: having a thread for a recently released clip from the show doesn't meet this requirement.
The only thing I'll say is the original movie series has this cool thing where the movies get tonally and literally darker as they go on. The first movie feels very warm and cozy and then that begins to fade as Harry grows.New show seems to lack that warmth from the clips I've seen.
>>224296840They got him on ozempic already? Thank god.
>>224298206I think half of that was due to deteriorating movie standards, but it still works thematically.
>>224295502>TEAL ORANGEWhere, schizo? I don't see teal at the bottom.
>>224298137This isn't a court of law. It doesn't have to be the same materially. If you're making multiple threads about the upcoming show pretending it's critique then it's spam.
>>224298284I think there's a switch in cinematographers in the third and it keeps going from there. Maybe a switch from actual film to digital too. Intentional or not, it's one of the best parts of the movies.The other being Emma Watson's casting, if only because Hermoine becomes hot enough to become a tolerable character by the end.
>>224294924>food bounces into place, bouncing off the table in the processBravo, wizards
>>224296840pettigrew ass nigga
>>224296226>thoWhy do trannies, fags and pedos like this "word" so much?
>>224296840Now he needs only needs surgery to cut those fucking distracting ears short.
>>224295594>shotaFound the pedo faggot/tranny.
>>224294924Genuinely depressing.
>>224296968>5'5>1m65
>>224295437>>224296848Pathetic.
>>224294924They couldn't have tried to get the warm colour tone of the movies?
>>224298329>The other being Emma Watson's casting, if only because Hermoine becomes hot enough to become a tolerable character by the end.She was at her hottest in the third and fourth movies.
>>224299139>le edgy pedophileMost people like actual women and not a middle schooler who needs help with their algebra homework
>>224299167>NOOOO YOU CAN’T JUST FIND A FERTILE GIRL ATTRACTIVE WHAT WILL THE HAGS THINK?!
>>224295635Based
>>224299248Children are annoying, disgusting retards. Why you'd want to fuck one is beyond me.
>>224295908Yeah, ive got a bad feeling about it. Even if it does include things from the books that the movies missed and if it looks good, the writing might just miss the tone and mess up the characters completely. The book is from almost exclusively Harry's perspective. Having these little cheeky asides from the teachers when Harry isnt directly involved isnt right. And yea, the Dumbledore chanting is just totally wrong on every level.
>>224295908>>224299314Lol you actually read the books? Nerrrd. Not even the writers for the new show read the book. What are you, special needs?
>>224299310>annoying, disgusting retardsBut enough about hags.
I suddenly remembered that one edit of hermoine sitting cross legged behind a cauldron and now I have to jerk off, thanks a lot
>>224296503I will commend him on getting the role. Never thought theyd let an American get a role. I even think JKR made it explicit for her castings
>>224298537kek
>>224298403>Turkey knife dislodges in the process, flies through the hair and stabs malfoid in the eye
>>224299248>>224299421There's a middle-ground between hags and literal children.
>>224295466I just realized there is no way in hell Moaning Myrtle is going to be in the new show, and if she is she will be either heavily toned down or fat and black
Spic here.Realistically, why everything looks so off? Like, devoted of magic, mysticism and whatever the fuck the movies had?Is this the price to pay because autistic FAGGOTS were crying about "LE NOT BEING FAITHFUL TO THE BOOK" etc? I never read the book and I will never read them, but the movies were and still are infinitely better than at least, the current teasers. Will this change?
>1990s>"HARRY POTTER IS SATANIC WITCHCRAFT">2020s>"HARRY POTTER IS ANTIWHITE PROPAGANDA"
It's amazing that this shit is so bleak and depressing looking everyone collectively took a break from Malfoid posting to shit on it
>>224294924>Dumbledore is just like his dad>Appearances may be deceivingWhat's this supposed to mean? Is Dumbledore saying Harry may be evil or something? Isn't Dumbledore the first fucking guy who believes in Harry being as good as his dad was?
>>224300455it's a mature show for mature millennials that have finally started "ADULTING" in their mid to late 30s
I'm 100% convinced the Malfoid spam was paid marketing to generate hype for this shitpile.
>>224295807he does
>>224300481We get dumbledores dad?
>>224295872>>224295854
>>224300455Because the original was a theatrical movie directed by the guy who made 'Home Alone'This is "prestige television" with the showrunner from such hits as 'His Dark Materials' and 'Killing Eve'
>>224300508jesus christ these people always have the same look to them, it's like redditors are their own species
>Theater puts out 756th rendition of Macbeth>No one cares>Hollywood puts out 2nd rendition of harry potter>AAAHHHH IM GOING INSANNNNEE, SAVE ME NIGGERMAAAANNN
>>224300545kek. Even the dog is fat.
>>224300565nonsensical comparison
>>224300545>morbidly obese>brown kid >no dad>reddit The memes are off the charts
>>224294944kek
>>224295437>”and those are”>”that’s right Potter, supple f cup implants and face feminization surgery. Unlike some of us, my father can afford two month trips to Thailand”
>>224300545>it's like redditors are their own speciesWait until you see the /pol/ meetups
>>224300730Fucking kek
>>224300565>Theater puts out 756th rendition of Macbeth>No one caresActually the 1886th rendition of Romeo and Juliet caused a yearlong tantrum on this board
>>224300690Is she gonna eat that kid? I don't think he's going to satiate her hunger
>>224300754Like, where do people even buy pants like that, that can hold 80 lbs of fat?? We should able to charge people heavy fines for being that unhealthy
>>224294924Mcgonagall looks like a regency era governess or dominatrix, way too youngDumbledore looks goofy and lacks gravitas, if he gives Hogwarts favoritism nobody will buy it because of how silly he looks. Doesn’t look like he can cow the ministry into backing off.Harry looks like a lesbian and has way too much fat on the cheeks for a supposedly underfed and badly treated kid
>>224300545Would smash the Pink Floyd guy and the guy in the red shirt in the top right
>>224295908>no floating candles21 seconds.
>>224300281Yeah, they’re called teens.
>>224295575He's turning handsome and more masculine looking as he age look at his Chad jawline
>>224300690Imagine if you had the balls to mouth off to her in public, she'd get in your face and you wouldn't do shit but stutter and poop your pants.
>>224300831Seems like he wouldn't need to mouth off, just bring a hand mirror
>>224295851His dad is and his mom is beautiful. Good chance he's going to have chad qualities. Maybe Brad or Chad lite at least. I mean he's the boy who lived so thats already making bitches wet but he's definitely not a skinny dweeb by the end of it. Radcliffe ended up being a manlet but still pulled it off. This kid does not look like he will age well. Maybe casting directors looked at his family tree and figured he would. Im assuming thats something they do?
>>224300857and then everyone else in public dogpiles you for discriminating against a larger person
>>224300831Just tip the cow over and let gravity finish her off.
>>224295787Surprisingly he's aging quite well , look>>224296840>>224300830
>>224300831>she'd get in your face and you wouldn't do shit not much you can do when your skull has just been crushed
>>224300875More likely they’d just laugh.
>>224296121Draco's actor is also aging better than his movie counterpart he's already taller than Felton
>>224300941Damn this guy looks like he's gonna live the part.
>>224300993Yes Felton would probably k himself
>>224294929>And the muttoids of courseso many fkn muttbloods
>>224294929>shitty lampsThose lamps are cool
>>224294924for me its that disgustingly jewish kid from 0:02 to 0:04 overactingyou just KNOW he was the nephew of some fucking jew producer and thats the only reason hes therehe doesn't even look age appropriate
>>224294924Well seeing this shit, I really never gave it much thought but is the food being hauled from a kitchen with magic or is Dumbledore materializing it out of thin air?Because one of those puts him in a powerlevel close to jesus and raises the question of why doesn't he fix famine in the world if it's just a flick for himIsn't that also evil by omission?
>>224301071The house elves make the food in the kitchen
>>224300891you serious? he looks like a FtM trannyat least he doesn't look like an old lesbian anymore
>>224301071In the HP universe, food cannot be created from nothing. The food that appears in the Great Hall is magicked there from the kitchen where the house elves prepared it.
>>224299167Not even an edgy take, literally everyone thought so at the time. It was a bit on SNL.
>>224294924
>>224298403The last plate has Yorkshire puddings and only one actually stays on the plate. It looks like THREE hit the floor.
>>224294924There’s something off about the main actorMaybe it’s his teeth and mouth region. He looks like he has an adults giant teeth, along with nasolabial folds. So essentially a kid with an adults mouth and hair shopped in Honestly I blame all the SNL parodies where they had some short haired female acresss play a young boy
>>224301209I really don't understand this Malfoid shit. Is this what being an out-of-touch boomer is like?
>>224300831i keep seeing this angry reply made in defense of ugly or gross people
>>224300730lmfao
>>224300736you mean that one picture from like ten years ago?
They should have used the still living actors to reprise their parts. I want to see modern day Daniel Radcliffe's take on returning to the role.
>>224294924SOUL >We could show the splendor and joy of Harry's first night in Hogwarts by making it feel like a place where comfort and life's joys are finally available to him. The feast should feel warm and inviting, like a Christmas day feast with family and friends. We'll color grade the scene to be this kind of golden lighting to make it feel like an atmosphere of warm abundance. We'll shoot it at the eye level of the kids, with the food piling up in front of them to not only give the effect that they are literally disappearing behind the amount of food but that you, the audience, are invited to the feast as well! SOULESS>Just CGI the food appearing on the tables suddenly. >Ye not too much food because it's like SFX budge and shit >Also we have to shoot the room really dark because CGI looks like shit if you shoot it in any kind of clear lighting. >whatever I guess that looks good enough. Don't forget to fill the scene with some shots of Dumbledore and McGonagall talking about how they know Harry's dad. Audiences are dumb and can't infer that from subtext like they used to. We can't just show a guy who looks like Harry in future scenes, we gotta explain it to the audience multiple times, in case they have their phones out What a loss...If only you knew how comfy this series could be
>>224294924haven't seen this shit but can you write a review without all these internet buzzwords and phrases? I'd like to know what you think, anon. We value your input.
>>224301433They tried to do that but Radcliffe had to be escorted off set when he saw the new Snape actor.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DTmGlZW6HyM
>>224301313It's the right finally finding a way to have trans fantasies
>>224301446>i know im stupid and defeated but what if i just act smug about it?
>>224301469malfoid isnt a tranny shes a real girltaking the idea of a character concept and flipping the gender has nothing to do with trannies unless you feel the political need to give that to them which still makes no sense
>>224301418Game of thrones reactions were 10 years ago
>>224301439Having the food pop out and do the bouncy animation as the plate lands really does make them feel like lifeless model home props, and the dim lighting sucks the holiday cheer out of it. Almost looks like those cold, sterile bank teller lamps
>>224294924Shitty ass lightning. Where is the style and magic?
>>224301483>malfoid isn't a tranny!>we're just fantasizing that Harry's bully is suddenly a woman and secretly loves him!
>>224301484theres many candid images showcasing what the beardfat legbeard troon libtard brigade looks like and like 2 pics of pol meet ups from 2016
>>224301494>suddenly a womanmalfoid was born a womanwhen you have to make things up and twist them it makes your point fall apartjust like a trannies gender identityyou just want to ruin something that people you hate like admit it loser
>>224301483>>224301469It’s not really a tranny thing but it’s weird watching zoomoid alpha males act like 12 year old girls in 2005.
>>224300831
>>224301494Nice try maulding tranny. YWNBAW like Malfoid.No real man will ever look at you with anything but disgust.
>>224301533immaculate webm to post in response
>>224301533This gif made my day. Thank you anon.
>>224301537Do any actual artists participate in this retarded trend or is it just ai anime slop
The future is now, /tv/.Imagine being a billion dollar studio, with armies of people to handle specific tasks, only to get shat on by anonymous people on social media pumping out AI fanfcition for a tiny fraction of the cost. On top of that it has more soul than their latest production.
>>224300281>>224300821There's a difference between adult women, milfs and hags but chuds aren't ready for that conversation.
>>224301537You can't even afford a modern iphone anonno actual women is going to look at you with anything but disgust too
>>224301469but why do trans "people" hate it so much?
>Claim a TV series is needed to properly adapt the books>It's less accurate to the books than the movies
>>224298206The Harry Potter movies really, REALLY lucked out by having (almost by pure coincidences) directors and visions that managed to fit the growing audience.Movie 1-2 are clearly aimed at young children and they set up Hogwart's mystical, whimsy tone very well.Movie 3 does an hard drift into something less proper and more rebellious, exactly like a teen growing through property.Movie 4 course corrects and in a way feels more like an evolution from the first two movies rather than the third, with the dark elements of the sotry really starting off.Movie 5-8 are fully aimed at teens / young adults, and sure they are darker than the original but they're still very feelgood, friendship-first moviesEven stuff that happened completely randomly ended up fitting. They ended up having to recast Dumbledore because the original actor died, which is just as well because Dumbledore had to take a more active role in the story starting from book 5. Even the wand they designed for him, way, WAY before they knew about the Elden Wand ended up perfectly fitting. If you were born between 1991 and 1998, the movies were really, REALLY adapted what most of your generation wanted to see at the theaters, no wonder they ended up doing so well.I have zero hope for the tv show partly because I know that even if they manage to adapt the whole thing, they will try to make season 7 looks as close to possible to season 1, and that's just not going to hold people's interest as much as the original adaptation.
>>224300821this>>224301596we are literally having that conversation right now you moron what do you mean
>>224301584Would that you have used that AI to make something more interesting than your embarassing rule 63 fanfics.
>>224301601what kind of phone does he havei have an iphone se 2nd gen and i have a blonde gf
>>224301601>actually believing owning a faggot iPhone, or any gay Apple product for that matter, is some badge of honour or status symbol>plebbit tranny confirmed
>>224301643it's not embarrassing you just have to say that because you hate it and hate that we enjoy it
>Severus Snoop>jeet HermioneHow much worse will it get? Negress Luna Lovegood?
>>224301654>whew thank god i got the new iphone so my sex havers license can be renewed phew i was almost an incel for a second
>>224295787In Year one he's supposed to be short and skinny, but very fast due to his mistreatment.
>>224301663>Severus Snoophahaha wtf
>>224301606Yep the argument was it was going to be more canon, then they hired a black snape, and then said they will add more new scenes.... uh that's not canon.
very progressive of them to have the school be in america instead
>>224301637You refuse to accept that a woman old enough to drink can be attractive. Posts like these >>224299248 >>224299421 set up this false dichotomy where you're either a proud pedo or a disgusting hag lover.
>>224301730no i think if a woman is hot shes hoti dont care what age she isi dont let anything dictate my boner for me whether its made up laws or made up 4chan posts
>>224301643If anyone should be embarrassed, its HBO.
>>224301749most retarded post award
>>224301659They're mostly derivative of anime and romcoms. Maybe embarrassing is not the right word but it's not high art either.
>>224301749Most based post award.
>>224301663Professor 'Ape
>>224300831She’d run out of breath in 2 seconds
>>224301663one of the marauders has to be black so it doesn't look like as if the KKK was trying to lynch a black person
"dumbledore!" they cheered calmly
>>224301533Cow tipping should be legal
>>224300509I have never seen a Malfoid poster encourage anyone to see the new series, in fact I always see them doing the opposite
>>224301770oh no its not high art somebody call the police
>>224301821Professor N-ape
>>224300509>paid marketing for a character that doesn't even exist in what HBO is makingWhat type of sorcery is this?
>>224301841It'll be Peter.
Such an iconic piece of British boarding school imagery to have all the students pounding the table like amerimutts at a UT game o algo.
>>224298812Daniel facemogs
>>224300509Nay, shan't be watching. It has the same aesthetic as rangz of power and yidsney star wars.
>>224301921My thoughts exactly. Zoomtards wouldn't even get that reference, or that the houses and point system are a method of control and group punishment indicative of that old British system. Back in my day sonny, if Ron fucked up and lost Gryffindor 10 points, Dumbledore would be ordering a 'Code Red' and Fred and George would be carrying it out.
>>224301537>>224301870>>224301976See, none of you can answer exactly why are you so enamored with the idea of making an entitled nazi youth into a cute girl and having our hero hook up with her.
>>224302045I just find the concept of Malfoid boring. It's just a generic tsundere anime characterEven fucking Ginny has more character, let alone Herms or LunaIt's just a dull idea, if I wanted generic tsundere I'd read Nagatoro
>>224302073dogshit fake opinion
>>224302073>If I reduce something to basic components, I win.
>>224302044Is the British boarding school culture dead?
I have to pee>zzp!>pssshh-psssssssshhhhshshsshhhhssssssssshhhsssssssssssssshshshhhsssssssshssshhssssshhhsss-psshshsh-psssssWoah momma, had too much soda pop!
>>224302045It doesn't require explanation for anyone who isn't a gay faggot.
>>224302096What else does Malfoid have faggotIt's just tsundere, maybe some vague racism, generic relationship with Harry, AIslop, and that's itThe character genuinely has nothing going for it, it's not even close to the real Draco, it's just a non-character.
>>224302073I despise it completely not for what it is or because it's rule 63, but because it originated on Twitter, ergo anyone posting it here is human shit that does not have the right to access the internet.If the EXACT same thing had actually originated here organically I'd be totally fine with it, but I'm tired of normalfags revealing they use social media on here and the mods not punishing them for it.
>>224302131>i am forced to assert that this thing people love has nothing going for it because im politically opposed to them enjoying something
>>224302144You do not have the right to enjoy it because it came from Twitter. You are a cultural invader that does not have the right to speak here.
>>224302144Nigger I'm far more racist and traditionalist than 90% of the people in this threadBut I, you know, like characters that are characters and not flat generic anime girl stereotypes
>>224302162>>224302167you can't convince me not to enjoy iti like how simple it isromance doesn't have to be complex or brand new in conceptit just has to be satisfying, and it is
>>224302128Why do you want Harry to end up with a piece of shit Death Eeater in the making? Why do you want to see said piece of shit redeemed? Why do you use Malfoy for that instead of established canon character like Pansy?
>>224302187you're overthinking it
>>224302185State the site it originated from and then apologize for speaking about it here.
Requesting {{masterpiece}}, malfoid, gore, beheaded at slytherin tribunal, students cheering, video 1:15s, dumbledore pissing on the corpse
>>224301663Worse... a virgin Luna Lovegood!
>>224302201i don't care if it came from kiwifarms or tumblr or /co/ or /a/ or /lgbt/its kino
>>224301520>malfoid was born a womanThen why does she have the EXACT mind and identity as Draco Malfoy?
>>224302242because harry potter is shallow character writing and you can swap these things without having to change much
>>224302187Someone can't follow along due to their intense desire to suck other men's dicks. Like I said, your lack of understanding reveals more about you than anyone posting Malfoid. Keep talking faggot, and dig the hole deeper.Not that your questions are at all genuine anyway, but either way you lose homo. Nice try.
>>224302213Egads!
>>224302045Don’t be retarded, it’s not just a chud trend. Women of the bootok/ao3 variety watch it from the angsty kdrama angle and the female demographic is much larger than chud weebs. You’re just a terminally online tranny
Everyone's talking about the visuals but no one is mentioning the downgrade in the soundtrack. John Williams' score was an essential part to creating the atmosphere of the originals and they completely missed the mark in the show. https://youtu.be/osTcYcYmf0o
>>224302185Enjoy it if you want retardBut I think romance works best when the woman actually does something instead of being a non-present entity>>224302242There is literally nothing similar between Draco and MalfoidDraco, as generic a character as he is, is still a character with aspirations, ideals, beliefs, opinionsMalfoid is literally nothing, she's Nagatoro but even lesser because at least Nagatoro as shallow as she is still has the other characters to contrast her and the whole cat thing, Malfoid has nothing
>>224302262>>224302275>Y-you're gay!!>Y-you're a tranny!!I'm a straight man but keep seething. Your fad is gonna be forgotten in two months top lmao
I don't think school kids would be THAT excited for their principal lolDoesn't feel natural and it wasn't in the booksSeems like a scene put in as an audience [soiface here] moment
>>224302350I mean their principal it's the greatest wizard in story this is not a regular school
>>224301663She’ll be cute and always have her feet out so it’ll be okay
>>224302311>>224302314You're so ideologically mind-broken that you can't even comprehend why people might enjoy a simple romantic fantasy without immediately subjecting it to some fucking feminist character-development audit.>She's a non-present entity! Where are her aspirations? Her beliefs? Her independent narrative agency?Holy shit, it's a fucking meme.The entire appeal of Malfoid is that she likes Harry. That's it. Uncomplicated, enthusiastic female attraction without the guy having to complete a twelve-stage self-improvement program to qualify for affection.No moneymaxxing, statusmaxxing, looksmaxxing, performative confidence, or endless demonstrations of his utility. Just a girl who actually wants the guy.And apparently even that is enough to trigger another lecture about what a female character is supposed to represent.You're evaluating a romantic meme as though somebody submitted it for a fucking screenwriting fellowship. Nobody claimed Malfoid was a Shakespearean character. The emotional premise is the attraction itself.People can enjoy seeing a white boy and white girl in a sweet, uncomplicated romantic dynamic without demanding another miserable A24-style relationship autopsy in which intimacy is treated as a prison and affection inevitably curdles into resentment.The fantasy isn't complicated. That's precisely why it works.Not every depiction of romance needs to be a referendum on female independence, male inadequacy, or the supposed psychological defects of people who enjoy traditional affection.You can criticize the characterization all you want. But pretending that the simplicity of her affection makes the entire concept worthless just demonstrates that you're evaluating something completely different from what its audience is enjoying.Sometimes the girl just likes the guy.Apparently that's become a radical enough concept to require an ideological intervention.
>>224300941The left probably already have hormones and a surgeon on set when they try to turn him in to a bastardized tranny version of Malfoid for when the ratings tank.
>>224302432lmfao
>>224294924>dumbledore, dumbledore, dumbledorewhat did the kids mean by this?
>>224302045>>224302187It's rather simple: they want to self-insert but they feel like the canonical options like Ginny, Cho or even Hermione aren't good enough to be "worthy" of them. So they invent this safe edgy girl to larp the enemy to lovers trope with and they force this character into relevance in their rewritten canon despite original Malfoy never being all that important.
>>224302476And now we've graduated from "Malfoid isn't a real character" to "everyone who likes Malfoid secretly thinks Hermione and Ginny aren't worthy of them."Holy fucking shit. Is there any harmless romantic fantasy you people can encounter without immediately inventing a psychological disorder to explain its popularity?Nobody needs to believe they're superior to Hermione to enjoy seeing a girl enthusiastically attracted to Harry. That's an entire imaginary motivation you've pulled out of your ass because apparently the concept of uncomplicated female affection is too difficult to process.And since when did inventing alternative romantic pairings become some sinister act of entitlement? That's practically the foundation of fanfiction.People aren't submitting Malfoid for your approval as a replacement for Shakespeare. They're enjoying a cute romantic dynamic where the girl actually likes the guy without the relationship becoming another miserable exercise in proving his worth.Your first complaint was that she lacks independent characterization. Now you're claiming her fans have pathological standards for fictional girlfriends.Notice how the criticism keeps changing, but the conclusion never does: the people enjoying something you dislike must be defective.That's not literary analysis. That's retroactively manufacturing reasons to feel superior to an audience whose enjoyment you can't understand.Sometimes a fictional girl likes a fictional boy, and people think it's cute.You don't need to conduct a fucking psychiatric evaluation of everyone who smiles at it.
>>224294924where da lightingi cant see shit
>>224302476To be fair, Draco is more interesting than most of the supporting cast >>224302501thinking your bully wants to fuck you isn’t harmless, it’s pretty pathetic
horrid
>>224302425I'm not a feminist retard. Nor do I care about muh incel seething or muh female independence.But I do like women doing something to me, because unlike incels I understand that there is no purpose to having a woman unless, you know, she has enjoyable traits to provide. Otherwise it's just a generic pair of tits with nothing to it.You can like it if you want, but I'd kill myself if I had to deal with a chick with literally zero character or entertaining attributes. I have higher standards than that.
>>224302425>>224302501First of all, me (>>224302187, >224302476) and >>224302167 >>224302311 are not the same person schizo-kun. Second, weren't all those Malfoid posters in their general claiming that their fanfiction is so much better than canon and Malfoid has this deep story and motivations and tension with Harry? Now you're gonna claim that it's all simple ackshually and we don't have to overthink it?
It is a school and he is a headteacher. Kids don't fucking chant for their headteachers. Perheps later on they see him as a great guy, but as kids?
>>224302522
>>224302522We're never gonna go back to 2001... Bros, i'm so cold...
>>224302280Blow my flute you homo lmao.
>>224302212>>224302584>Kids don't fucking chant for their headteachers. Perheps later on they see him as a great guy, but as kids?
>>224302614Well I think you're hot! :3
>>224302584He’s also the head of the magic United Nations and a once in a generation genius.
>>224302501Notice how you focused on the first sentence and not the>So they invent this safe edgy girl to larp the enemy to lovers trope with and they force this character into relevance in their rewritten canon despite original Malfoy never being all that importantWhich is 100% true and indisputable.
>>224302311>>224302549Now you're just being disingenuous. Malfoid is pretty fun as a character and most of her fans try to come up with a good story for her - even if it's invariably revolves around Harry and is mostly limited to remaking Draco's story beat by beat.
>>224302549What the fuck is this shit hahaha
>>224302045Im going to need you to explain why you worded your question in such a bizarre way
>>224302733What story? Literally every Malfoidslop I've seen is the exact same thing: Malfoid is acting all high and mighty, but is secretly in love with Harry or gets defeated by him and falls in love with him.She has no traits similar to Draco. If pureblood racism is referenced, it's always comically or merely in passing rather than it being an intrinsic part of her character. There's none of the cunning, the distaste, the violent side. A real "Malfoid" would just be Bellatrix.Like I said, literally just Nagatoro but without the few things that make Nagatoro tolerable. Sometimes they'll also genderbend Ron who does nothing, but I guess seeing more tits is impressive to coomers or something.>>224302769Having basic fucking standards? I don't want a chick who has nothing to her beyond "OMG I hate you (but secretly love you) whom I can't talk about anything with or do anything withThat's why nobody likes bimbos in romantic ways, they're sex toys basically, they're too retarded to be an actual partner
Zero fucking soul. Zero. Looks like it was shot in IKEA.
>>224302549it's funny because you just described Ginny (movie version and most of the book version) and her relationship with Harry.
>>224302476It's even simpler: they don't want to admit that Tom Felton makes their weewees feel funny and cope by going the societally approved route of making Malfoy a girl.
>>224302821All the soul is contained in Black Snape’s scenes
WHERE IS COLORWHERE IS IT
>>224300690I feel sorry for the niglet.
>>224302837Which is why nobody likes Ginny, not even bookfagsShe was created to give Harry a girl fast because Rowling had planned for Hermione to be the girl but changed it last minute because Ron represented her ex which she still had the hots for
>>224302837>>224302881Maybe it’s just my yellow fever talking but I think Cho could have stuck around longer
>>224302869They added all the color to Snape. Also, the shooting ambience is dark so they can easily convert it to a horror show when the ratings go down and then release a bunch of magic immune ghasts where they rip the flesh from everyone at Hogwarts to end it quickly.
>>224302869Unironically would have looked ok with warm lighting but it has to be cold tinted garbage to hide shit CGI.
>>224302869Top has more colors than the bottom
I greatly underestimated just how popular Harry Potter is worlwide.
>>224302869Fuck you buddy!
>>224303018Why are you lying on 4chan
>>224303018*coloredtrue
>>224302881I thought book Ginny was fine, could've been explored more as "one of the boys" and made into a powerhouse she was stated to be to make a difference in the finale. Making Harry suddenly have the hots for her never sat right with me however. Same for Cho's character assasination in the fifth book.
>>224303074Making Ginny a town's bike in the same book that made her the protagonist's love interest was certainly a choice.
>>224303052What color is the dress?
>>224302073No one actually likes Ginny.
>>224295109>Immediately know R is rupeeSomeone flush the turd, its been sitting out to long
>DUMBLEDORE DUMBLEDORE DUMBLEDORE DUMBLEDORE DUMBLEDORE Why is this so cringe?
>>224303481I actually had to look it up. Anyway, it's funny that you didn't think anything of the fact that OP immediately knew what it meant since he's the one who posted it.
the original has just as many non-whites in a 1 minute scene.
>>224302666and kids care about that? Would kids chant for António Guterres?
>>224303941
>>224304107those are all in the backgroundin the new one they are central to every shot
>>224302519>>224302549>>224302574>>224302675Your Honor, the prosecution has now submitted approximately seventeen paragraphs of evidence that a fucking gender-swapped Harry Potter meme isn't a psychologically complex literary masterpiece.Congratulations. Nobody was arguing otherwise.First Malfoid was supposedly worthless because she lacks independent characterization. Then her fans were entitled narcissists who consider Hermione and Ginny beneath them. Then enjoying enemies-to-lovers became evidence of pathetic sexual fantasies. Now we're conducting a forensic examination of Draco Malfoy's blood-purity ideology.All to avoid the embarrassingly simple observation that people enjoy the fantasy of a girl enthusiastically liking a guy.And the funniest part is that your supposedly devastating evidence actually explains the appeal. Yes, fans have softened Draco's nastier characteristics to create a romantic fantasy. That's what romantic reinterpretations DO, you fucking genius.>She's not faithful to canon!NO SHIT. IT'S A FAN-CREATED ALTERNATE UNIVERSE.You can dislike the trope. You can call the writing repetitive. You can complain that Malfoid isn't sufficiently racist, cunning, or violent to qualify as Draco.What you haven't demonstrated is why anyone enjoying this harmless fantasy must be psychologically defective.You keep confusing your personal distaste with an objective indictment of everyone else's enjoyment.And declaring your own speculation "100% true and indisputable" doesn't magically transform it into evidence.The prosecution has successfully established that Malfoid isn't canon Draco. The defense would like to congratulate you on solving the mystery of why she's called MALFOID.Case dismissed.
>>224300508Do zoomers not realize age generations? Millennials are 45-31 (1981-1995). In my opinion the start should be 1984 depending where you were born (the Midwest was always 3-4 years behind in pop culture and tech compared to coasts and big cities before broadband internet, in terms of stores/infrastructure/anything new).I'm almost 40 and I'm smack in the middle of my generation.Just to end on, I think it's worth to give the entire range, not say most are mid 30s. The Gen X crowd were the ones in all those Games of Throne bar and reaction videos from a decade ago; they're now in their late 40s and early 50s (like my insufferable manager who has been a female alcoholic her whole life, vapes, has tattoos, votes Democrat and is on SSRIs and now thyroid medication, and no I'm not making any of this shit up. I need a new career/job)Also, just popped into this thread, I have zero desire to watch this. Like everyone else, it looks completely flat and dull, terribly miscast, and attempts to ape the movies while having it's cake as "more book accurate" (obviously not true).I watched and read the OGs 20 years ago, I'm good now, I have other things to do (like physical therapy to unfuck my knees and back, I hit 37 two years ago and it seems like I literally started falling apart, it will happen to you)Tldr everything sucks because everything is by committee and no one is ever held accountable for anything. Just like the malaise mood the shitty TV trailer gives, a race to the bottom.
>>224302314>Your fad is gonna be forgotten in two months top lmaoUnless you outright ban all AI worldwide, its not happening. Same goes for the Anakin thing.
Even if everything looked good, why would this be the scene they chose for an early clip to get people hyped? Were they trying to defend against the people making fun of the food in this shot?
>>224295575I legitimately thought this was an exaggerated AI picture to make fun of him
>>224302464>white passingnope
>>224301663>Sirius BLACKfucking pic one
>>224294924>Also note the jab: "His nature is entirely his own". Most of you aren't leftist enough to see this as an anti-racism dogwhistle.The entire point is that Harry chooses Griffyndor over Slytherin, you dolt
>>224300749you mean that cage fight looking promo with Holland and that burly Negress, 10x bigger man-jaw than his?yeah, that was funny
>>224304248>First Malfoid was supposedly worthless because she lacks independent characterization. Then her fans were entitled narcissists who consider Hermione and Ginny beneath them. Then enjoying enemies-to-lovers became evidence of pathetic sexual fantasies. Now we're conducting a forensic examination of Draco Malfoy's blood-purity ideology.Or those were all different points from different people and your schizo wall of text is unwarranted. You do you desu.
>>224295851He's LITERALLY a jock in the novels.>Very good at sports.>Poor at most academics.>Wants to become a cop.>Hot-headed and quick to act, but also resort to violence.>Heavy emphasis on getting along with people and having friends.
>>224304248>>224304910Also nobody was calling you defective. Quit it with self-victimizing.
Why are modern films and television so horribly lit? The Mandalorian has the same problem, everythings so desaturated and lifeless. The old Hogwarts looks like a warm, magical, inviting place. The new one looks like a crypt or dungeon.
>>224304910>>224304957i accept your concession as always my unfuckable feminist retard friend
>>224304954He’s a beta. He got butterflies in his stomach around Cho and waited until the last possible moment to ask her out even though she was clearly interested in him
>>224304973You can't even refute this >>224302574 my autistic hypocrite buddy.
>>224305109Holy fucking shit, you actually think "this is better than canon" and "the fundamental appeal is simple" are contradictory statements?Are you genuinely incapable of distinguishing QUALITY from COMPLEXITY?Something can be better precisely BECAUSE it's simpler, you absolute midwit. A straightforward romantic premise can be more satisfying than a convoluted one. Complexity isn't automatically quality, and simplicity isn't automatically inferiority.And when I say the central appeal is that Malfoid genuinely likes Harry, I'm identifying the emotional foundation of the fantasy, not declaring that every fanfiction featuring her is incapable of having additional characterization, conflict, or narrative depth.Those things aren't mutually exclusive.Furthermore, why the fuck am I suddenly responsible for defending every statement made by every anonymous poster in a Malfoid general?Somebody else supposedly said their fanfiction was deeper than canon, therefore MY explanation of its appeal is invalid?That's guilt by association masquerading as an argument.You keep doing the same thing: inventing increasingly elaborate standards that nobody agreed to, then congratulating yourself when your opponents don't satisfy them.First people enjoying Malfoid were pathetic self-inserters. Then they were incapable of appreciating complex women. Then Malfoid wasn't sufficiently faithful to Draco's racism and cruelty. Now apparently liking something more than canon obligates you to produce a doctoral dissertation on its narrative sophistication.You're not exposing a contradiction. You're manufacturing one by pretending "simple," "good," and "better" are mutually exclusive concepts.And the fact that you needed this explained while calling other people autistic is fucking hilarious.
>>224305158>Are you genuinely incapable of distinguishing QUALITY from COMPLEXITY?Don't try to wiggle your way out of this. You malfoiders pretend that your fanfiction is some sophisticated shakespearean story until it no longer suits you.>Furthermore, why the fuck am I suddenly responsible for defending every statement made by every anonymous poster in a Malfoid general?I dunno, why do you keep defending them?>And when I say the central appeal is that Malfoid genuinely likes Harry, I'm identifying the emotional foundation of the fantasy, not declaring that every fanfiction featuring her is incapable of having additional characterization, conflict, or narrative depthThe central appeal is the toxic bad boy being turned into cute tsundere girl. Everything else is cope. You have entire female cast to make fanfiction with yet you go for rule 63 and other such faggotry.>You keep doing the same thing: inventing increasingly elaborate standards that nobody agreed to, then congratulating yourself when your opponents don't satisfy themAnd you keep pretending that all of this>First people enjoying Malfoid were pathetic self-inserters. Then they were incapable of appreciating complex women. Then Malfoid wasn't sufficiently faithful to Draco's racism and cruelty. Now apparently liking something more than canon obligates you to produce a doctoral dissertation on its narrative sophisticationCame from one person.>And the fact that you needed this explained while calling other people autistic is fucking hilarious.That's rich coming from you. Did you have all this >>224302425 >>224302501 >>224304248 shit typed out waiting to be copypasted?
>>224294924WHO THE FUCK IS IN CHARGE OF THE LIGHTING IN MODERN MOVIES?THIS LOOKS LIKE ABSOLUTE SHITAAAAAAAAAAA
>>224305327That's what happens when you're afraid of muggle electricity and light a castle with candles
>>224305307another wall of text without identifying a single contradiction in my argument.>The central appeal is turning the toxic bad boy into a cute tsundere girl!YES, YOU FUCKING GENIUS. And what does that cute tsundere girl do? SHE LIKES HARRY.You've just described the same romantic fantasy from a different angle and declared yourself victorious because apparently two complementary explanations cannot coexist inside your skull.now we're back to "YOU MALFOIDERS CLAIM YOUR FANFICTION IS SHAKESPEARE!"Who? Which claims? Why am I responsible for defending every anonymous fan's opinion?>I dunno, why do you keep defending them?Because defending someone's enjoyment of a fictional romance doesn't mean endorsing every literary claim they've ever made, you intellectually dishonest clown.Then comes the brilliant revelation that Harry Potter already has female characters.NO SHIT.Apparently the existence of Hermione and Ginny means nobody is allowed to enjoy an alternative romantic pairing. Somebody better inform the entire fucking fanfiction community that imaginative reinterpretation is now prohibited because the original author already supplied enough girls.And "everything else is cope" isn't an argument. It's what you say when you've run out of reasoning and want your personal interpretation treated as divine revelation.As for whether these anonymous posts came from one person or five, the logical defects don't magically disappear depending on how many keyboards produced them.If the arguments are wrong, demonstrate it. Their length and composition history are irrelevant.Your entire case amounts to "I dislike this fantasy, therefore its fans must be psychologically defective, and any explanation of its appeal that I don't personally approve of is cope."That's not criticism. That's an inability to distinguish your own preferences from objective reality, dressed up as literary analysis.
>>224301613I did a watch through recently, still holds up. I like all the movies even DH p1 despite the meandering and teen relationship drama. I love the portrayal of Voldemort. I love this nigga. I can't see it being topped unless they bring back the same actor
>>224305399>You've just described the same romantic fantasy from a different angle and declared yourself victorious because apparently two complementary explanations cannot coexist inside your skullActually i implied that your ship is rooted in homosexuality. >Your entire case amounts to "I dislike this fantasy, therefore its fans must be psychologically defectiveI never said that.>another wall of textAhahahaha.
>>224305527So we've gone from "Malfoid has no characterization" to "Malfoid fans are entitled self-inserters" to "actually your heterosexual gender-swapped romance is secretly gay."Holy fucking shit. That's your final argument?And after demanding I address your points, you're now laughing because I addressed them in detail.You demanded substance, got substance, and retreated into playground insinuations and word-count complaints.The moment you abandoned literary criticism for "ur gay lol" was the moment this stopped being a debate.Thanks for the closing statement, xir counselor.
I like Malfoid better.Fuck the booksFuck HBOkek
>>224305374I DON'T GIVE A FUCK ABOUT REALISM OR VERISIMILITUDE JUST PUT BIG ASS LIGHTS EVERYWHERE SO I CAN FUCKING SEE WHAT IS HAPPENING YOU KNOW LIKE A MOVIE SHIT
>>224305578See ya, chump ;)
>>224305724you would have been better off not replying if you were going to do thisthis reply is the sound of my cock pulling out and hearing your anus prolapse as it gushes out my cumjuice
>>224305656WHY IS EVERYTHING SO BLUE??
>>224305764You're adorable.
>>224305632Why does Dobby get so punished in the series?
>>224305971well i reject you
>>224306025Can't be too careful, anon. Never relax.
>>224306092Is he the abuse goblin? The ALBUSE goblin, even?