When did it fall off? Like 8-9 when they stsrted doing many personal episodes?Idk.
>>224299981When Hotch and Morgan each left it nosedived because there was no masculine core, I have absolutely zero motivation to watch a bunch of menopausal women, a 75 year old Joe Mantegna and le quirk chungus human computer Spencer.The real kicker was when they turned several serial killers into 'archnemesis' types who just kept recurring across multiple seasons, Mr Scratch was the one that started that godawful trend.
>>224300066I've not even got to that point yet.
>>224299981Bump
>>224299981I only watched to jerk off to Garcia but it started being annoying that she doesn't have hairy forearms or armpits or anything so I stopped. And she was really obnoxious as a character later on.
when they introduced that elias voit guy and kept him multi season villain
>>224299981Probably when they killed off Mandy Patinkin's character off-screen, years after he'd left the show.Firing Thomas Gibson for getting into a tussle with a shitty writer was the final nail in the coffin for me.>>224300066>The real kicker was when they turned several serial killers into 'archnemesis' types who just kept recurring across multiple seasons, Mr Scratch was the one that started that godawful trend.Yeah, I hate that phenomenon in police procedurals in general. Seems like nearly every major series in the last 20 years (other than maybe Law & Order) has fallen victim to it at some point, and it just kills the suspension of disbelief for me, especially when they start targeting the detectives/agents hunting them, because that shit just doesn't happen IRL, and if it did they'd have to assign new people to the case because conflict-of-interest issues and a bunch of CYA legal shit.
No Gideon no watch simple as
>>224299981It dropped off around 5 or so then became unwatchable when Jeanne Tripplehorn came in. It probably got worse after that but I didn't get that far.
>>224299981There were major tonal shifts when picrels left. The show become incredibly formulaic under Rossi, but it was still watchable for a while. Like you said, around the end of season 9 is when it's time to just let it go.I also agree with >>224300066
When Gideon left
>>224299981Never watched this show, was it good or is it just generic procedural crap
Damn the actor who played Hotch really fell on some hard times. Does Cameos now for 200 bucks a pop since he got no work after he wass fired
>>224303718>$200,000 per episode (roughly $5 million per year)>He earned an additional $150,000 per episode for the episodes he directed.>In addition to his base salary, he earned backend profits and residuals from syndication.I don't feel sorry for him
>>224303782Honestly its kinda strange he never got any work after that. Either he pissed off the wrong jew and got blacklisted or he just realized he had enough money and fucked off from Hollywood
>>224303813I expect a lot of people don't even remember why he was fired and just assume it was a #metoo thing because it happened not too long before that blew up.
>>224304018Didn't he like literally kick someone on the set
>>224304080Yes. In the shin, IIRC. It was some writer who was also the episode director. Started as a creative disagreement and got physical.
>>224303332>other than maybe Law & OrderThe main show hasn't (I think) but SVU and Criminal Intent have both definitely done it, as has Chicago PD.
>Hey you fat fucking bi- I mean baby girl
>>224304357Is Criminal Intent even still a thing? SVU became totally unwatchable after Stabler left, so I wouldn't know much about that.
>>224304611>SVU became totally unwatchable after Stabler leftOnly for like the first 2 seasons after he left. Criminal Intent ended years ago but they recently had a new show with Stabler for a few seasons called Organized Crime. It had seasonal arcs and the first season is about a sort of nemesis for Stabler. He's been doing cross-over episodes with SVU and the main show.
>>224304611Criminal Intent ended in around 2010, but they had a blonde Aussie serial killer woman who was obsessed with D'Onofrio and recurred over multiple seasons.SVU had some edgelord murderer played by Pablo Schreiber who kept cropping up endlessly Chicago PD had some dollarstore Hannibal Lecter guy who also turned up in SVU crossovers (picrel)
>>224303813>got blacklistedOf course he got blacklisted. He assaulted an executive producer.And before that, he assaulted someone else. He's known to be a hothead>This incident was not isolated. Gibson had previously been ordered to attend anger management counseling after a 2010 altercation where he allegedly shoved an assistant director.
>>224303332>killed off Mandy Patinkin's character off-screen, years after he'd left the show.Wasn't implied that he committed suicide when he left?I stopped watching after Mandy Patinkin's character left the show.
>>224303332>Firing Thomas Gibson for getting into a tussle with a shitty writer was the final nail in the coffin for me.Why are you simping so hard for this guy and downplaying the details? Are you him?
>>224304758Nah, Patinkin quit after Season 2 and never showed up again.He eventually gets murdered off-screen all the way in Season 10 by some serial killer he was hunting. At no point in the episode do we ever see Patinkin, just a younger version of Gideon played by a twentysomething actor in flashback scenes.
>>224304715>SVU had some edgelord murderer played by Pablo Schreiber who kept cropping up endlessly >Chicago PDHis character existed solely to steer the L&O audience into watching the Chicago shows. >a blonde Aussie serial killer woman C'mon now, put some respect on Olivia d'Abo's name.
>>224304849I mean in his departure on season 2, he does so with a letter that kinda makes it seem like he committed suicide.
>>224304380Did she 'zempic herself after I stopped watching? Ugh.
>>224304873Not really no
>>224304892Ah well, it was a long time ago, so I'm probably wrong. That's just the feeling I remember getting from that episode/scene.
>>224304801No, I'm just sick of relatively minor (the guy wasn't seriously injured) physical confrontations automatically leading to people getting fired. Same shit as Jeremy Clarkson, IMO. People are too soft these days.
>>224305101idk, anon. It's kinda fucked to get kicked by your boss. If that had happened to me, I'd definitely make a stink.
>>224305154You're a millennial crybaby
>>224305317It's not your fault, anon.
>>224305154>bossGibson wasn't his boss, though. The guy was a writer.
>>224305101>>224305317This is still simping btw. The man was ordered to take anger management classes long before that for prior offenses. And the man he kicked was a co-executive producer on top of being a writer, so of course news is going to travel farther. It also doesn't make sense why you keep replying that he was 'just some writer' like a damn parrot, as if that matters.
>>224299981Honestly still disappointed that Pantinkin left.It's funny how he was sick of violence of TV and then went on to that Homeland show lmao.
>>224305647Because I wasn't aware that he was a co-EP. All I'd seen listed was writer and episode director. I could probably just as easily ask why you're simping for them to be so hung up on the fact that they weren't "just" a writer. Like, who cares? So they had a co-EP title on a show with a dozen or more co-EPs. You still don't throw away a popular character on a hit TV show because of something as minor as simple battery. Not because the actor should be entitled to behave that way, but because it's bad business. The witer/exec/whateverthefuck should just suck it up and take one for the team.In any case, I guess I'd need to know more details about the prior incidents. I don't think kicking someone in the shin is that big of a deal to where it should have to result in someone getting fired. It's wrong, obviously, but it's not like you're going to seriously hurt someone doing it. That shit and worse happens in locker rooms all the time, but I guess nancy boy theater kids can't just move on like real men do.And >>224305317 wasn't me, BTW.
>>224306546>Like, who cares?You do apparently.
>>224303608>There were major tonal shifts when picrels left.I completely agree with you, and could watch Lola Glaudini with her pretty face and her enormous bouncing tits all day long. But I have to admit she never felt like an actual government agent.
>>224303708Both I guess.Extremely formulaic but was a pretty addicting formula and fun to watch.>>224304380That guy was always so ridiculous. Is there such thing as intentionally unintentional humor?
>>224308179What was unintentional about it?