[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: images (3).jpg (39 KB, 452x678)
39 KB JPG
There's a lot of retarded shit in this movie but I'm not sure I'd call it boring
>>
>>224302263
Nah, it's pretty boring. The film really needed a crack editor, like with the original.
>>
>>224302307
editor on crack?
>>
Grow the fuck up. You have 3 days to leave my house
>>
>>224302329
You'd still get better results. The film needed a kick in the ass somewhere along the way of its production.
>>
>>224302263
>star wars comeback after 16 years
>make it about a trade war
wut
>>
>>224302565
>regurgitate opinions from RLM instead of forming my own opinion
You're the reason this franchise is literal baby shit now.
>>
>>224302592
what the fuck is rlm you retarded schizo
>>
I can accept that the podrace would be boring if you really want to watch lightsaber fights
>>
>>224302705
Good news. In the Phantom Menace, both are boring.
>>
>>224302263
the epitome of
>visually stunning
>>
>>224302592
>It mentioned taxes and trade disputes! That means it's automatically smart.
Retard retard retard retard.
>>
I enjoyed the prequel series back in the day and no amount of contrarian faggotry and shit podcast YouTubers will ever diminish the fun I had watching them.
>>
File: frog_cheers_you.jpg (22 KB, 360x360)
22 KB JPG
>>224303053
>>
>>224303050
Strawmanning quite a bit. You're the one complaining about it.
>>
>>224303050
>it mentions taxes and trade disputes, that means the movie is about taxes and trade disputes!
>>
>>224303209
the first one literally was? and the second was about building armies to fight each other.
>>
>>224303236
The Phantom Menace is about a Queen pushed from her kingdom during a mysterious coup and her intermingling with commoners to build an army to fight to reclaim the throne.
Star Wars (1977) happens because the galactic senate is dissolved. It is not about the politics of senate.
>>
>>224303375
amidala is not a main character
>>
>>224303666
Padme Amidala is a prota-gonist of The Phantom Menace
>>
>>224302263
its shit but its still the best of the prequels
>>
>>224302263
The movie had some cool scenes in it but the storyline tying it together was pretty bland. Really Hayden should have played Anakin in the first film
>>
>>224302263
the most retarded shit is
> there were no sith for billion years
> let's send the mediocre jedi and his boy to deal with him
>>
>>224303236
no
they were about (((him))) creating and orchestrating two sides and others having to choose one
>>
>>224302992
>>visually stunning
>>
>>224305306
yeah, they came up with all the weird alien designs except the jewish alien and ET and that devil guy probably
>>
>>224302263
For me it's 6>4>3>5>1>2
>>
>>224302565
>establishing movie in a space fantasy franchise
>make it about a whiny moisture farmer
wut
>>
>>224303053
Based, fuck the angry faggots here
>>
>>224303375
>changes her clothes every scene
why didnt they just sell her fucking wardrobe to get a new hyperdrive?
>>
>>224302307
George Lucas was still the primary creative force behind the edit for A New Hope.

>>224302565
It could have been decent. It wasn't, but simply being about a trade war isn't inherently a problem, the problem was the execution. A far bigger problem was doing the entire movie with Anakin Skywalker as a child. Establishing his backstory could have been done in a prologue or flashbacks. Hell maybe even a dual-timeline movie. Then you could have Obi-Wan meet Anakin as a teen, when he was already an actual good pilot. No need to have baby Anakin "spinning, that's a good trick." You could make the rules about the Jedi training age less extreme. Wouldn't need to depict Anakin slaughtering 8 year olds in the final episode.

>>224302592
Low-IQ posters like you, who think lazy greentext sarcasm is the peak of humor, are the reason why this board sucks now
>>
>>224302643
There's a large faction of idiot zoomers who think that a YouTube channel run by a couple of fatsos and a cringy asexual is singularly responsible for people hating the prequels and for Disney hiring JJ Abrams to ruin the sequel trilogy.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxKtZmQgxrI
You can see there's some good points but also extremely dishonest ones. The video ends with a simple exercise comparing OT to PT characters:
>Describe these Star Wars characters without referring to their appearance, profession or role in the movie
But it's clear the responses and edits are not honest. Even a cheap-O AI can come up with a reasonable (if somewhat faggy) answer. I'm sure anyone who has seen the prequels immediately knows which character this is:

>He is a maverick and independent thinker who prioritizes the Living Force and immediate reality over the rigid, dogmatic protocols of the Jedi Council. His philosophy emphasizes instinct and intuition, famously advising to "feel, don't think," which often puts him at odds with more conservative authorities despite his high competence.
>He is portrayed as compassionate, humble, and patient, treating all sentient beings with respect and showing a willingness to defy established rules to help those in need. He possesses a defiant streak, calmly rejecting unnecessary commands from royalty or superiors, and is driven by a deep, almost prophetic belief in the potential of others, specifically identifying a young slave as the Chosen One.
>>
>>224306869
No one cares about your rankings, nigger.
>>
>>224307336
they said it was not enough
>>
>>224302263
All the prequels are boring as well as stupid.
>>
>>224302263
Rewatched it yesterday and liked it very much.
>>
File: 1766393725729914.jpg (16 KB, 268x348)
16 KB JPG
>>224302263
<33
>>
>>224302263
btw since when drones became autonomous and not requiring drone control station
>>
>>224305306
jesus I forgot how primitive this looks
>>
>>224302263
watch the RLM reviews
>>
>>224305306
kek
>>
>>224303053
Based and same.
>>
>>224303053
you enjoyed that shit because you were 6 and you defend that shit now because your mind is still 6
you are just pathetic
>>
>>224311438
nta but here;s the thing. you are a massive cum guzzling kike
>>
>>224303053
Based, god bless.
>>
>>224311489
QED
you are mentally ill and still 6, even if your body is grown into a pathetic adult wreck

And prequelshit is forever shit
>>
Problem with Star Wars is that Force users are not that special and would just get wasted by all the sci fi tech.
They needed to be actual space wizards.
>>
as a brainless 90s summer action movie it ain't the worst thing in the world
>>
File: 1794827391335595.jpg (945 KB, 1920x1756)
945 KB JPG
>>
>>224311973
>Force users are not that special and would just get wasted by all the sci fi t-ACK!
>>
>>224312468
Nice screen from a "Legends" game. Meanwhile in canon, the Jedi got wiped out by a bunch of Django Fett clones.
>>
>>224312468
Yeah, but that's in the game or whatever. I am talking about movies.
>>
>>224312503
legends is canon
>>
>>224312665
"No!"
>>
>>224312503
1. They were caught by surprise and distracted by the deaths of so many other Jedi at the same time.
2. The clones were the best soldiers in the galaxy and overwhelmed them with large numbers.
3. Many Jedi tried defending themselves non-lethally or focused on escaping instead of fighting the clones with everything they had.
4. Many Jedi in the temple were killed by Anakin personally. It's possible they could have fended off the clones if it wasn't for him.
>>
File: 1620606523593.jpg (65 KB, 1200x675)
65 KB JPG
>>224312725
THEY ARE CANON TO ME!
>>
File: image.jpg (152 KB, 2048x1024)
152 KB JPG
>>224312725
> "No!"
>>
>>224312746
>They were caught by surprise
Which is ridiculous by itself since the Force works like a spidey sense
>>
>>224312819
The clones had no harmful intentions before their MK Ultra programming was activated. The Jedi were distracted trying to figure out what the fuck was going on when they felt the pain of so many Jedi dying at the same time.
>>
>>224312819
it was prophesized, ok
the force wanted them to die
>>
>>224312746
As usual, autism-tier explanations miss the bigger narrative picture. Imagine how awesome a serious, extended epic conflict between Palpatine and the Jedi would have been. Instead Sheev uses one weird trick to wipe them all out in a single scene. OK technically two tricks, counting Anakin's seduction, but you get the point. Just because you can make up a valid excuse to do something lame, doesn't make the thing not lame. The lame thing is now just a lame thing with some cheap in-world excuses and maybe a vague thematic justification.
>>
>>224313481
weird? that trick to backstab that many jedi in one moment with others hands is super cool
>>
>>224313548
I suppose there's no accounting for taste.
>>
File: 1702623588630490.png (507 KB, 1024x776)
507 KB PNG
>>224302263

I liked the part where they took a submarine until the planet's surface as a shortcut and got chased by a monster.
>>
>>224309560
Everything would be fine if he spoke like a normal man, not a goofy retard.
The first 100% CGI character ruined by Lucas and his boomer sense of humor. Or rather the lack of it.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.