Why didn't Balrog just use his wings? Gandalf even told him to fly.
He can't fly inside of a cave. He's a balrog not a batrog
>>224305238theyre vestigial
>>224305238Zero media literacy strikes again. He wanted Gandalf to take his broken wings, to learn to fly again, to learn to live so free. That's why he showed Gandalf the majesty of the outer realms, or whatever.
>>224305238Why did they make the balrog some DnD monster and not just a 12ft humanoid black angel
>>224305238there's like debate in the text about the way Sauron's tower and the balrog looked because Tolkien was using flowery language. It has a "shadow about it reached out like two vast wings."Which some artists took to mean actual wings. Like how jackson made the eye a literal eye
>>224305238Gandalf told the Fellowship to "fly" which means "flee" or "run" or "vàmanos".
>>224305608Deep caves do get very cold. I can see why he'd want to wear a vest
>>224305238
>>224305709What do you think D&D devil and demons are based off, anon?
>>224305826Most kino scene in fantasy
>>224306845>>224305826Moria was the peak of LOTR. I wish they had spent more time in there really. Maybe in a bunch of deleted scenes. Their journey was three days through that dark, spooky place. Most of the other places they visit don't come close.
>>224305826>that cgi fire lmaoo
>>224306257>Vamos, Pendejos!
>>224306931You don't even understand what you're complaining about huh? You just see people mocking cgi so you parrot it and think you're saying something interesting.
>>224306907the majority of the movie is wasted on the opening of galadriel explaining the rings fucking providence like an episode of antiques roadshow, immediately to even more wasteful cgi spectacle of nonsensical shit like bilbos birthday party and smoking pipes, instead of actually telling the fucking better parts of the story. rankin & bass did it all better with cartoons over 40 years ago with cheap cartoons.
>>224305826Bro I can even hear the furnace fire sound effect on this fucking board with no sound
>>224306349Devil's and demons. If you mean a Baalor or Pit Fiend specifically there's a connection there (and they're pretty generic in terms of demon/devil design at the end of the day so there's probably a case to be made that Tolkien didn't have much to do with it other than one of them having a whip), but I really don't think you can credit Tolkien for demons in general
>>224307250>providence provenance.
The silliest part is that the Balrog is right at the exit. They made it through 99% of Moria just fine only to trigger the Balrog within running distance of the exit. What if they had made noise and the Balrog was a whole day's journey away deep inside the mountain? Or they could have made it aware but they still had half the journey to go to the exit
>>224306257>vàmanosIs that Tengwar? Or did the Istari speak Mexican? It explains a lot.
>>224306257And they fled in the friscalating dusklight.
>>224305747>Like how jackson made the eye a literal eyeIt was already literally an eye in other interpretations before Jackson got to it. There's plenty to complain about in the modern interpretation, but the balrog and a flaming eyeball aren't high on that list.
>>224306349the bible
>>224307067Just pointing out dated cgi No need to get your panties in a bunch
>>224306931It's called soul
>>224308846They'd just go through a narrow hallway and balrog can't follow because he's xbox hueg.
>>224309639kek. I kept going into the wrist watch thread on /fa/ and calling different watches >xbox hugeand some retard started having a spegfit over it
>>224307472Whoever's idea that was for that sound effect deserved an academy award.
>>224308846Just coincidence. Besides, if it hadn't shown up they would have been murdered by a billion goblins.
>>224305238Why did Gandalf stay there for so long after the balrog fell down? It's like he wanted to be dragged down by the whip
If you guys haven't played ze_LOTR_Mines_of_Moria you should at least once.Somehow these CS maps perfectly capture these iconic scenes in ways official game adaptations never could.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HkQeu4PN2y4
It's crazy how the amazon series fails to capture even just a fraction of the fantasy of the movies. Like the run time is much longer yet it says nothing of value, shows nothing grand or spectacular, it's just boring and lame.The first movie is 3 hours long and you have>the shire (lore exposition and dump in a new world)>frodo gets shived by Nazguls>black riders chase>council, characters and exposition, clear goal and call to dangersoadventure>cool travel and landscape>evil wizard cuts road>Moria>escape and elf encounter>fight at amon hen>death of Boromir and split up Like there is so much cool shit packed in one movie which also feels good to follow with all kind of moments, it's crazy
>>224306349people's imagination
>>224311184Forgot how annoying CS players are. Constantly twitching, jumping and moving likes spazzes
>>224305238He didn't fly so good.
>>224308846not silly at all, it was due to Gandalf careful preparing of the crew: 4 soft-feeted hobbits + Legolas' lightness ability + dwarf accustomed to walking in deep caves + Gandulf' magic > noisy humans
>>224307528 >>224309548 >>224312002>>224309548>the bibleThis was what I was implying.
>>224305238Dwarves stole his flight plan.
>>224309530>There's plenty to complain about in the modern interpretationLegolas on a surfing board?
>>224305238He didn't have a Red Bull™
>>224312544It's just their form of stimming. Running forward as you do in ze maps gets pretty boring.
>>224307250>the majority of the movie is wasted on the opening of galadriel explaining the ringsEither you don't know what "majority" means or you have a terrible sense of time
>>224311948>Like there is so much cool shit packed in one movieWhat you suggest here is very antisemitic and harmful to the business plan approved by all shareholders
>>224306931real fire, they used a miniatureback then doing fire sims was crazy hard and even the balrog sim was hard to do
>>224305238>Somehow, Gandalf returnedTolkien was such a hack
>>224313096>Sauronman living in a fortress called Orc-Tank works for the evil guyNo shit
>>224306907>Their journey was three daysImagine being an orc doing your round on patrol and you occasionally come across huge piles of steaming shit from roughly 9 people.
>>224311948What a waste. What was it $1Bn? They could have made 2-3 good, full-length movies out of that, with real actors instead of some noname wokefest.
>>224313387You shit less when you march all day and eat only to not collapse.But what an American fattie would know about it.
>>224313387They probably wouldn't think much of it. There's a thousand orcs down there always shitting. And the Hobbits could just shit over the side of all those dropoffs. Also, that's one reason the Balrog was so grumpy. The Dwarves toilets dropped streams of shit into his lair all the time
>>224306931>>224309563That fire animation was the most nice looking fire in the market during that time. I've seen worst uses of it in other movies, in this case it looks fine
>>224313531It's a gigantic waste yeah.I stopped the series after 4 episodes because it was so shit but I can safely bet there is not one scene out of the three seasons on the level of this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ruRRcSrLnF0With drones and shit it would even be easier to make it I guess, just 10 horses and trained riders and costumes, a bit of cgi at the end.Shameful
>>224313387t. GRRM
>>224313555They couldn't march; they had to be quiet and on their guard. It was a three-day journey to the other side.
>>224305747Frodo sees a literal eye at one point, maybe in the Palantir or somewhere else
>>224313864>frodo looks in the palantir
>>224313886Yeah I misremembered, prob the Galadriel mirror, it explicitly says he sees a cat like eye or something
>>224313927
>>224313832>uh ackshually they didn't move at fast pace And they were already on a weeks long mountain hiking trip
What does the balrog do with his time? He is a maia, so supposedly of similar intelligence to Gandalf and SauronWhat is there to do in a dark cave? I can get sleeping for hundreds of years but after a while it has to get old and he does walk around some apparently. Smaug's species was unnatural so maybe that was a desirable trait that was bred in and lizards seem content just sitting around for their whole life. Not to mention he could lie around gooning on his treasure pile like catnip.
>>224315934>What does the balrog do with his time?Fucking orc bitches and listening to black metal
>>224315934Any balrog would be more powerful being than Sauron. Balrogs were high rankers among the servants of Morgoth. Makes you wonder what the fuck was he doing in Moria instead of starting his own campaign of conquering the world.
>>224305238But who was "Yuful"? Is that the balrogs name? Fly yuful still has me thinking.
>>224316385>Any balrog would be more powerful being than Sauron.lies ofc
>>224305709Because Tolkien's actual description of it is kind of vague>"Something was coming up behind them. What it was could not be seen: it was like a great shadow, in the middle of which was a dark form, of man-shape maybe, yet greater; and a power and terror seemed to be in it and to go before it.">"It came to the edge of the fire and the light faded as if a cloud had bent over it. Then with a rush it leaped across the fissure. The flames roared up to greet it, and wreathed about it; and a black smoke swirled in the air. Its streaming mane kindled, and blazed behind it. In its right hand was a blade like a stabbing tongue of fire; in its left it held a whip of many thongs.">''His enemy halted again, facing him, and the shadow about it reached out like two vast wings. It raised the whip, and the thongs whined and cracked. Fire came from its nostrils.">"The Balrog made no answer. The fire in it seemed to die, but the darkness grew. It stepped forward slowly on to the bridge, and suddenly it drew itself up to a great height, and its wings were spread from wall to wall..."
>>224317480That is Balrog in Adunaic which was the language of the Numenorians. Gandalf was using the long dead language to demonstrate that he was on equal footing with Balrog. A slight flex without fully lifting the veil. I believe this is mentioned in one of the History of Middle Earth volumes.
>>224316385>Balrogs were high rankers among the servants of Morgoth. Sauron was Morgoth's #2 stupid.
>>224305238Bane?
>>224317848So it's a DEX-based dark angel made of smoke. This would make anime kino.
>>224317848It's good to be kind of vague when describing a supernatural horror
>>224306907Yep. It also heavily influenced video games in the early 2000's. World of Warcraft's Blackrock Mountain is straight up Moria, where they rip off the main Dwarven Hall and its first raid boss was a giant fire demon reminiscent of the Balrog.No one gave a shit about ripping off Hollywood at the time because it was cool. Same with CoD and Band of Brothers/Enemy at the Gates.
>>224305409OP staying awfully quiet about this FPBP…
>>224305409>He didn't fly so good
>>224318604final fantasy 16 rips off the balrog entirely for one of their boss fight summon things. even does the falling into underground/water sequence. its fucking retardedly blatant.
>>224305409But balrogs have bat-like wings.
>>224317961In the military hierarchy established by Morgoth, not in terms of who would get fucked by whom in 1v1.
>>224317848The description of the Balrog has similarities with the wraiths as described in the books. They're both like the "shadow people" that some schizophrenics claim to see.
Why was there no Balrog-kal? I don't think Jackson actually read the comics.
>is a lore-faithful balrog in your path>*quakes you*
>>224315934>balrog do with his time?I unironically think the Balrog's inaction is the result of depression. Morgoth lost, the Balrog is the last of his kind, it's so fucking Joever. Sauron seeks to rally the forces of darkness under a new banner, but he probably looks like a pathetic nonentity to a Balrog who once served an actual God. So the Balrog just sulks in his underground lair, totally demotivated and apathetic as he waits for the end of time. He will take action if provoked, however.
>>224318915>Biblically-accurate Balrogs
>>224318804Tolkien didn't equate power with fighting prowess. Yes Sauron was a jobber and he'd probably lose to any Balrog 1v1 but insofar as his true influence was concerned he was vastly more powerful than any of them were.
The Mother of dungeon crawlers
>>224319159Too small. Moria is supposed to take three days to walk through horizontally. It's an entire country underground.
>>224318968Finding out the Fellowship Balrog is literally me was not on my agenda for today
>>224319200
>>224319159>redhorn lobesCaradhras was like 15 miles away from moria.
>>224305826How come the balrog scenes looked so kino and why on earth have we never seen their equal in anything ever again? I'm exaggerating of course, but why is modern Hollywood so much worse than 20 years ago and how come only this board and some parts of twitter/X openly admit it?
>>224313096Kino
>>224319480>can't into amazon's $100,000,000,000 Rings of Powerngmi
>>224319939Correct, I can't into it despite their humongous budget.
>>224319939Nobody cares about your fanfic Jeff