[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: superman.jpg (84 KB, 1650x825)
84 KB JPG
I don't get it. why do so many people here hate kindness and optimism?

https://youtu.be/Z_-PgIzDrEo
>>
>>224305737
cause I'm flop yes I am
>>
>>224305737
Not my superman
https://youtu.be/0LV7y_HnQr4?si=fzOLSOurswgAb12O
https://youtu.be/o23Noye5410?si=jQDqnRTvP04qJ6nK
https://youtu.be/Najsk2Y4hr0?si=n_dMO_7mawAonQVQ
>>
CAUSE I'M A FRANCHISE KILLER YES I AM
>>
>>224305766
>>224305834
Bovarian hands typed this
>>
>>224305850
*BovARYAN
>>
>>224305737
>why do so many people here hate kindness and optimism?
Because FUCK YOU, that's why
>>
File: 1759776287971735.webm (1.4 MB, 720x1280)
1.4 MB
1.4 MB WEBM
I cried Manly Tears when Punkrocker started playing
>>
>>224305932
hey, if the shoe fits.

btw, of course /tv/ would side with the clear stand in for the evil fascist government.
>>
>>224305952
Superman isn't a pussy. He's a good moral guy but that ain't him
>>
>>224305955
>painted nail
Shygddt
>>
>>224305737
Because in the real world you don’t get what you give, you just get invaded.
>>
File: IMG_3499.jpg (375 KB, 1320x2049)
375 KB JPG
/pol/ is scared of superman because he can undo all the poisonous nazi programming they have been corrupting people with
>>
>>224306010
>I have seen it
On the internet?
>>
>>224305737
Epstein's creation casts a long shadow and /pol is a mouthpiece
>>
>>224306010
Twitter and Letterboxd are abnormally obsessed with this movie. It makes no fucking sense. No one else cares about it, everyone else acknowledges it was middling. But these people treat it like it's some revolutionary masterpiece that changed the world.
>>
>>224306058
Because they want the left to own superman. so Americas superhero can be some gay whiny femmy loser who blows his lid over the gates most retarded shit
>>
>>224306058
None of my friends have even seen it. I didn't even tell them not to lol.
>>
>>224305737
WELL I'M A BOX OFFICE FLOP YES I AM
>>
>>224305737
You can't both have Superman be a symbol for classic male ideals and signal to young men to be selfsacrifical and hard working while simultaneously having him be a symbol for liberal troon politics
How kind of you to approve of a male wearing makeup and tight alternative fashion as his daily style just as long as theres mutilation involved while normally demanding that men wear plain baggy clothing as inofensive as possible like Clark Kent does
>>
>>224305955
reminds me of the 2017 charlies angels intro with random stock footage of girl scouts high fiving and rock climbing like its a tampon commercial
>>
>I-Is that a heckin needledrop?! James Gunn is a genius!
>>
>>224305955
I cried to The Wild Robot but not to this forced crap
>>
>>224305737
>>224305850
>>224305960
>>224306010
>WHY DO YOU HATE KINDNESS AND OPTIMISM?

This is what passes for film criticism among James Gunn's Reddit congregation?
Nobody hates kindness, you sanctimonious morons. They hate having basic human virtues spoon-fed to them through embarrassingly self-conscious dialogue, juvenile quipping, and manufactured emotional sincerity.
Superman embodied hope and compassion for nearly NINETY FUCKING YEARS before James Gunn arrived to have him announce that he loves, gets scared, and makes mistakes like he's delivering a motivational speech at a corporate sensitivity seminar.
And now apparently disliking the execution means you oppose the virtues themselves.
Then comes the even more hilarious claim that such a wimpy superman is going to defeat Nazi programming.

It's a superhero movie, not the Second Coming.
You people have turned a middling blockbuster into a political sacrament where enjoying James Gunn's writing demonstrates moral enlightenment and criticizing it exposes your secret ideological depravity.
Notice how neither of you defended a single scene, directorial choice, performance, or piece of writing.
You just announced that the movie represents GOOD THINGS, therefore anyone who dislikes it must represent BAD THINGS.
That's the intellectual sophistication of a fucking kindergarten morality chart.
And that's precisely why the performative kindness shtick is so obnoxious.

You've confused a movie advertising compassion with a movie successfully dramatizing compassion, then confused your enjoyment of that movie with evidence of your own moral superiority.
Superman doesn't belong to James Gunn, Twitter, Letterboxd, Reddit, or your political tribe.
He's an aspirational American superhero, not your personal ideological participation trophy.

Criticizing Gunn's Superman isn't rejecting hope. It's rejecting your embarrassingly shallow imitation of it.
>>
>>224306010
>LEAD WITH KINDESS!
These faggots wouldn't know what kindness is if it hit them with a fucking bat, ironically. These are the same kind of men that applaud decisions made by Lindsay Clancy.
True kindness is a harsh mistress. Kindness is delivering a needed message, knowing that it is going to hurt the individual to hear it, but saying it anyway.
Fucking faggots just think kindness = being submissive and nice.
>>
File: punkrocker.png (722 KB, 700x600)
722 KB PNG
Cause I'm a Punkrocker, Yes I am!

Well I'm a Punkrocker, Yes I am!
>>
>>224307420
>>224307425
Holy fucking mindbroken poltroon, go dilate to kirk
>>
>>224307451
i accept your concession
>>
File: 1745850968987704.jpg (80 KB, 648x500)
80 KB JPG
This is what comes to mind every time you libshits go on about kindness
>>
>>224305737
Love the song
>Cuz I'm a box-office bomb,Yes I am
>Well I killed the entire DCU,Yes I did
>>
They see me flopping down the street
I look so fucking bad
>>
>>224305737
>The Kents are in maybe 3 scenes & for my personal preference, Pa Kent looks too much like some fat hick rather the comics so not enough is done to make having them in the ending feel much earned
>Happens minutes after Superman gets emasculated by Supergirl showing up drunk & just picking her shitty dysfunctional dog up
>Muh friend and wife are voicing two of the rights
>Punk rock song is clearly chosen because Gunn likes the genre & doesn’t match Superman as a character
It fucking sucks, it’s written for the type of people that think Hughie from the Boys is the ideal man.
>>
>>224305737
For some reason, having Supes relieving himself with happy memories makes you seethe and that shows just how miserable you guys are.
>>
>>224307843
or its just hacky filmmaking
>>
>>224307901
How? Serious question
>>
>>224307918
It's hacky because Gunn takes one of the most recognizable aspirational figures in American fiction and reduces his emotional interiority to a fucking slideshow.
Superman lies helplessly in a chair while adorable childhood memories are projected in front of him, accompanied by an aggressively curated licensed soundtrack, so the audience can experience the profound revelation that HE LOVES HIS PARENTS AND HAD A HAPPY CHILDHOOD.

Holy shit. Cinema.

There's no meaningful dramatic discovery here. No difficult choice. No revelation earned through character interaction. Just prepackaged nostalgia, childhood imagery, a cute dog, and a needle drop doing the emotional heavy lifting.
It's the filmmaking equivalent of holding up a photograph of a puppy and demanding applause for your compassion.

And that's Gunn's entire fucking problem.
He doesn't trust sincerity to emerge naturally through character, action, restraint, or visual storytelling. He has to manufacture these conspicuous little emotional showcases, then surround them with his usual quirky soundtrack selections and adorable comic relief.

Everything screams LOOK HOW HUMAN AND WHOLESOME THIS IS.
That's not emotional subtlety. That's sentimental exhibitionism.
And if somebody finds the execution cheap and manipulative, you immediately accuse them of hating happiness itself.

You're confusing recognizing the emotional intention of a scene with believing that intention was successfully realized.

Nobody objects to Superman loving his parents. They object to Gunn presenting that perfectly ordinary character trait like he's just discovered the fucking human condition.
A genuinely moving scene doesn't become moving merely because its subject matter is wholesome.
And a filmmaker doesn't demonstrate sincerity by repeatedly announcing, illustrating, and underlining how sincere he's being.

Now explain why the scene is artistically successful without telling me what kind of person I must be for disliking it.
>>
>>224307843
>For some reason, the 2016 Ghostbusters saving the city & getting funding to continue catching ghosts makes you guys seethe & shows how miserable you all are
That’s how much of a faggot you sound like
>>
>>224308031
>Now explain why the scene is artistically successful without telling me what kind of person I must be for disliking it.
Why Would I? I'm not a gunntard lol
>>
>>224308082
You also seethed at 2016 Ghostbusters? You guys are fragile as fuck kek
>>
>>224308123
>i like bad movies and people who know this are whatever word i can think of to make myself feel better
>>
>>224308123
Of course you’re too low iq to understand the point
>>
>>224308143
I never said I liked Fembusters, I said that (you) faggots get worked easily by some movies.
>>
>Is that a woman catching ghosts?
>AIIEEE SAVE ME BILL MURRAY
>>
>>224308178
you're being worked rn
>>
>>224308195
sure buddy
>>
>>224308194
>>224308207
ok we get it you were personally invested in a bad movie suceeding and never got over it failing
>>
>>224308178
Anon could’ve used any dogshit movie with a happy ending, it’s making fun of you for trying to be a disingenuous mong putting an emotional significance on the ending & then branding anyone who doesn’t like it as whatever you need to so you can discredit what they say.
>>
>>224305737
>everyone still loves Superman 1978
>"WHY YOU HATE KINDNESS AND OPTIMISM?!"
Is this a troll thread? I can't tell anymore.
>>224305955
... that really is the most embarrassing shit I've seen in awhile. Like that rosey cheeked faggot cooming over one of the star wars sequel's trailer.
>I play thrash metal, yes I do
>*electronic backing rhythms*
>Cause I play thrash metal, yes I do
>*sampled beat and 7-notes on a keyboard repeated throughout song*
If you have to say it, you're not. If you say it while doing the opposite, you're a giant faggot.
>>
superman has never had a great movie, there's no point in arguing whether this one or that one is a 6/10 or a 7/10
>>
>>224308471
man of steel at least tried to be great
>>
>>224308506
MoS tried to be a lot of things, a good adaptation wasn't one of them.
>>
>>224308684
again, at least it tried
>>
>>224308306
You still got worked by some stupid remake of Ghosbusters
>>
>>224308734
>>
File: 1769664325643933.png (337 KB, 512x497)
337 KB PNG
lol is this how /tv/ really is or are these just some kinda edge-lord hate bots?
>>224307346
>>224307420
>>224308031
>>
Kindness and optimism were from both his Kryptonoan and adoptive Earth family. Gunn nuked any morals from Krypton. He turned them into fucking Saiyens.
Plus Gunn didn't earn that message in the film. Superman barely did anything of note in this Superman film. The James Gunn Justice Gang solved the problem in the non specific fictional country. Even his clone was almost defeated by accident.
And if you look at Gunn's attitude about superheroes overall, and the sequel film Supergirl, it betrays that whole scene.
So fuck that scene.
>>
>>224308812
wheres the lie
>>
>>224305955
I gave up wearing my Superman / Superboy black logo shirt after the shitty Snyder films. I certainly would never buy Gunn's awful knockoff Kingdom Come logo shirt.
>>
>>224306010
>undoing years of grime and pessimism in superhero media
>the Gunn doubles and triples down on that shit in Supergirl and Lanterns
Yeah. His Superman was a fucking hollow lie. I don't think he meant any of it.
>>
>>224308835
No lies, but still, your posts make you look like some kind of faggot obsessed schizo.
>>
>>224308878
uh oh its the self appointed vibe police from reddit whatever shall i do
>>
File: superman 1978 poster.jpg (150 KB, 480x1241)
150 KB JPG
>>224308471
If you don't think the 3-hour cut of Superman is great, you got filtered by kino.
>>
>>224305737
Why is Superman so obsessed with his Kryptonian parents?
Why did Gunn make Jor El evil so Superman isn't different at all from characters he influenced like Goku and Invincible?
Why is the ending Superman appreciating the Kents more when he always loved them more than his Kryptonian parents?
>>
>>224308894
>whatever shall I do
Kill yourself is an option
You can livestream it even
>>
>>224309000
i seem to have struck a nerve perhaps o algo
>>
>>224305955
Whoever these guys are, they are fags, but shit like this hits different when both your parents are dead
>>
File: clark kent.png (1.76 MB, 868x1248)
1.76 MB PNG
>>224308969
Because Gunn is a massive retard who just thought
>What if Brightburn decided to be good instead of bad?
>>
>>224305955
all of the videos superman is watching need to be replaced with the plane scene
>>
>>224309010
>o algo
Kill yourself spic
>>
I don't understand this viral marketing
>>
I like the ending just fine even though it's kind of a rehash of GOTG2's and I didnt really like the movie overall. Snyder's was the more interesting take on the character imo but then again I was never a fan of superman to begin with
>>
The Gunnverse lasted 2 years.

It was nothing but flops.
>>
>>224305737
1-Snydertards' death scream because they finally had to face replacement of their shit
2-It wasn't very good
>>
>>224309586
And he deserved to flop, just like snyder deserved to flop, have no career and forever be used as a negative example
>>
>>224308031
Based AIChad voicing the thoughts I never knew I had
>>
>>224308031
>Everything screams LOOK HOW HUMAN AND WHOLESOME THIS IS.
I know this is probably a shitpost but this is genuinely a perfect description for the issues with stuff like this. It's performative.
>>
>>224305737
/tv/ even got its own scene
>>
>>224305737
Everyone who dislikes this movie is a jew
>>
>>224305737
YOU LOST LOL!
>>
>>224309586
Truth.
>>
>>224305737
It didn't break my brain. But the thing is, Superman should stand for good not because it's counter cultural but because it's the right thing to do. It's deonotology, Kantianism, whatever you want to fucking call it. The guy cannot be hurt, he is not affected by stupid concerns. That's what makes the anxious millennial messaging insincere. It's not in line with the characterisation. Superman is a force of nature and an inherently paternalistic figure. He's like Santa Claus.
>>
>>224308969
>so Superman isn't different at all from characters he influenced like Goku and Invincible?
Because Invincible is workable version of the Superman.
>>
>>224305737
Was nothing happening anywhere else in the world during this scene, which was clearly masturbatory in nature?
>>
Someone post all the bad CGI scenes.
>>
>>224305737
That's a really great scene, why ruin it with that music?
This guy did the second suicide squad movie right? That had great music choices.
>>
>>224305737
I think it was a bold but good choice to have pa kent as a fat older guy who isn't particularly handsome, full normie. Better than him being the noble savage of farming where he's both hot and wise.
>>
>>224311888
Aye, punk is always in response to society
>>
>>224312103
Yeah no shit, Superman is not a fucking victim of society. That's what makes it cringe. That's what makes it a fucking put on. I mean get a grip you invincble mother fucker.
>>
>>224311699
I'm gonna tell you right now, jews hate me. And I fucking hated the movie. I will not mention why, but I have fucking put my body on the line to piss them off.
>>
>>224308812
You didn't even read
Its time you libshits decide if Superman should push for conservative classic male ideals or liberal troon politics, you can't have both
>>
>>224305995
This. Even in the movie Superman's kindness is an invitation to be trampled on and disrespected. It sends a message to young boys and girls that being a misanthropic jackass is the key to success.
>>
1. The punk rawker reels made me hate the people who enjoy this slop and therefore also the slop, vicariously, even if it wasnt that bad.

2. Dont make your movie about conquering alien superman and then claim it's a message about immigration rights. That's fucking retarded, Gunn.
>>
>>224312188
How fucking ironic Gunn's past films are misanthropic
Have you seen Super?
>>
>>224305737
>kindness and optimism
Because it's insincere coming from that creepy cunt Gunn
>>
Superman 2026 envmcourages simping for young men
To do hard work so women and troons can play around in life
Responsibility without autority is slavery
>>
Being the selfsacrifical gentleman isnt rewarding in 2026
>>
>>224305955
Link to original youtube clip?
>>
Why is James Gunn a hypocritical sexist asshole?
>>
>>224305737
>I don't get it. why do so many people here hate kindness and optimism?
This movie's optimism is equivalent to the "empathy" of those hinged twitterfaggots who think they are better than you, but they take all kinds of pills and drugs for their terminal mental illness and also have an onlyfans account
>>
>>224309022
How did he manage to defecate something like that while wearing the suit?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.