Is making a DC universe genuinely that hard?Like, you've got all those comics and cartoons to work from. You've got the rights to all the characters. It seems like it should be an extremely easy thing to do.This post was originally much longer with a bunch of suggestions from me, but I deleted them because I realized I was just saying the same shit everybody else has said. What's the fucking issue?
yes it really is that hard for them it's that simple
>>224308801Nobody cares about DC outside Batman. Just because Superman is well known doesn’t mean he’s popular at the box office. He isn’t. Singer coming hot off the X Men couldn’t make Superman work. Nolan and Goyer coming off the Dark Knight couldn’t make him work. Gunn coming off Guardians couldn’t make him work. You could get James Cameron next and still won’t make Superman big at the box office
>>224308801It should not be that hard to make any comic book movies precisely because of what you said; they have hundreds of issues of source material. Just pick the 10 best stories and make your favorite, with some small changes to make it more adaptable to a film. If it were me, someone who has been reading comics for a long time, I would do the following:Start with Hal Jordan Green Lantern and have it end on Earth. Make a mid credit scene with a news story about a scientist named Barry Allen being in a lab accident whilst his lab is struck by lightning. The Flash movie is straight forward as well. There would be some kind of reference to the island of Themyscera or maybe not. Either way, the 3rd movie is Wonder Woman.These would all be produced concurrently, so there isn't long waits between movies, because I'm assuming they will be good and hit movies. I want extreme momentum going into the 4th movie.That would be where Superman shows up on Earth, and Justice League is formed because Brainiac is the main villain, he has followed Kal-El to Earth. Martian Manhunter also getsI'm not touching Batman yet for a couple reasons.There's the 2nd Pattinson movie on the way, and it will take him a while to become a team player.At the same time, I make a Batman Beyond movie with Michael Keaton as very old Bruce Wayne and someone under 23 as Terry. That would be it's own thing and never, ever connect.
>>224309244Nobody cars about this comic nerd boy. Nobody is going to see a Green Lantern movie no matter how good it is. Same way nobody showed up to see He Man
>>224308801>you've got all those comics and cartoons to work from.They keep hiring people who don't want to do that. Instead they want to do their own take on the characters because they think they can do better than almost a century of content that became a cornerstone of pop culture.
>>224309280He Man and Green Lantern are not even close to the same level of popularity. He-Man was fine for kids when it came out, but anybody with eyes could see that that movie was gonna be a shit show from the trailer. The show had plots shallower than a puddle. Before they made an Iron Man movie, he was the same level as Green Lantern. Iron Man comics fucking sucked and the only reason people cared was because of Ultimate Iron Man.
>>224308951>Just because Superman is well known doesn’t mean he’s popular at the box office. He isn’t.Man of Steel and Gunn's Superman both made 600+ mil. Superman Returns made almost 400 mil which while not amazing was still respectable by 2006 standards. In terms of raw ticket sales there's clearly still a large audience for Superman. The reason these movies are considered disappointing is because they all had out of control budgets that made it harder for Warners to turn a profit. Just get the finances under control.
>>224309436I agree but Gunn’s Superman making 600 million considered muh flop. Superman will never get much more than they today.
>>224308801we.must.re.ima.gine
>>224308801>Is making a DC universe genuinely that hard?Actually yeah. >Like, you've got all those comics and cartoons to work from.Anon, even in US comics industry makes a fucking pennies comparing to manga sales.Also, issue with DC is their retarded editorial policies that doesn't allow any new idea or concept to outshine founding members of the Justice League. And since founding members are just Silver Age relics it's very hard to sell them to the modern audience and if you began to adjust characters to the modern demand/standard you will run into bunch of retards screeching "not muh Superman". So in the end you have Heavy Hitters who have very weak communication with the wider audience and zero groundwork for their replacement.At this point you probably can make a Gwenpool movie and it will make more cash than WW or Supergirl.
>>224308801All of DC's best stories are solo runs and all their event comics are convoluted and suck ass. Marvel has both good solo runs and crossover ones. DC doesn't have a Civil War equivalent, Infinity War, Secret Wars, Etc. so a universe is pointless. Also Marvel enforcing their one canon has helped, DC in the comics has a ton of restarts and elseworlds shit so naturally that would infect their movies too.
>>224308801DCAU(2013-2020) is kino. I suggest you watch that.
>>224308801They keep trying to subvert the material since they are ashamed of it.
It's probably too late to set up a successful cinematic universe in general. DC missed the boat, Marvel was a one-time thing only possible in the 2010s. DC definitely had the material though, their heroes were more well known than Marvel's before the MCU boosted them.
If Marvel was like DC, they would've rebooted after Hulk or Iron Man 3, DC's fatal mistake is they think every release is going to be a hit. Marvel has had tons of flops but they just keep going anyway.
>>224309344Iron Man worked because of Robert Downey Jr being literally perfect for the role and the concept of some genius billionaire building a mech suit to fight crime being just as much standard sci-fi as a comic book film. People that never heard of Iron Man ever before could quote RDJ's lines to you because the character was just charismatic and appealing in a 2000s "I always speak my mind" dickhead way. The Green Lantern doesn't have that same basic sci-fi appeal and Hal Jordan doesn't have as fun of a personality as Tony Stark for some perfect casting to elevate.
They had it but they kept fighting it.
>>224310472Iron Man 3 made over a billion
>>224310415thats the DCAMU the DCAU are the Paul Dino/Bruce Timm cartoons
>>224308801The problem is that DC isn't in the universe business, their responsibility is mainly subservience to Batman. You can't overthink how subconsciously vital good Batman movies are to America. And Batman is not a team player. Nor is he a god. Batman is important because modern America has no god, no salvation, he needs to be fighting evil off the streets. Superman is just some rabbi story doused in Germanic shampoo. DC could also have its own R rated Star Wars franchise if they properly developed Lobo and sock it to Disney but they try to DEI the character too hard.
>>224310520people love Kyle Chandler as GL, doing what they did with him was just another stupid DC mistake. Also having Gunn running the universe was a bad idea. He's a creative, so all the releases were samey. Feige is just a numbers guy, that's who should be in charge, with different directors so there are different styles across different movies.
>>224310548pic unrelated, obviouslythat was dogshit
>>224308801DC comics spent ages trying to reshape their characters and universe into something they aren't. It never worked, but they keep insisting. Do you think people who make movies would be able to bypass that trend? Do you think they would be able to understand what those characters should be unless there were long time fans with extensive knowledge among them?Good luck with that
>>224308951>Just because Superman is well known doesn’t mean he’s popular at the box office.Circular reasoning.he isn't popular because he doesn't get good movies and they always try to change him. he doesn't get good movies and they always try to change him because he's unpopular.Easy solution would be sticking to the iconic version and make a good movie about that, but those people are always a source of problems, not solutions
>>224310587Context tho?
DC is not impossible, but the problem lies in the mythos of every character.With Superman, you get Krypton. With Wonder Woman, you get Thermosyclea or whatever, with Aquaman, Atlanits etc.These are usually something that must be established to understand the concept and the core values of that character. However, I would love to see more 'human condition' stories in these. Aquaman a king of a kingdom he knows nothing about, learns about himself and his people. Superman becoming a son of two planets (Snyder actually kinda did this already and thats why MoS is the best capeshit) and so on and so on.Superman particularly is, for me, the most interesting character not only on DC but he washes Marvel too.The stories are there, and in a way, today's studios expect a lot from the audience, like how Gunn's Superman didn't even bother with the origin story, I liked that.t. screenwriter
>>224310730If you liked Man of Shit you don't have opinions worth listening to
>>224308801If Marvel could become one of the biggest franchises ever then DC surely could.DC just doesn't have very smart people at the helm.Snyderverse moved too quickly, there should have been a Batman movie before BvS. It's weird, it's like they slowly gave up on the Snyderverse after BvS.Hiring Gunn seemed like a good idea at the time, but they learned the hard way that Gunn is only interested in rehashing Guardians of the Galaxy over and over and over again.What they should do now is take a step back and actually plan out something. No more just winging it. They should consider using some elements of the Absolute universe also, those comics sell very well.
>>224310730shut the fuck up, everybody already know these characters and anyone who doesn't can get up to speed within 5 seconds of watching anything with these characters in it. These characters have been in plenty of episodic shows which were already built in such a way anyone could tune into, they should just make the movies the same way. If something is directly relevant to the plot of the movie then yes it should be established but that doesn't mean we need 2.5 hour backstories for everyone.
They were way too late when they started. The MCU worked because it was a novelty, and the payoff of the first Avengers movie had already come out when DC was scrambling for their also-ran. They were NEVER going to get the same excitement etc from the masses. The right move for them was to just continue in the vein of Nolan's Batman, make standalone "prestige" movies that'd get a following. Anyone could see all their blunders coming.
>>224311101Snyderverse was too shit, had no redeeming qualities and dying was the best thing it could doAgree about Gunn>absolute shitkys with that crap. nu52 2.0
>>224310935It's the best capeshit, with Batman Begins.Winter Soldier is up there also; Endgame is pretty good - but it only works as a final act of an overall arc.Man of Steel is highly misunderstood film; it's not perfect tho.>>224311358Audience knows who Superman is, but they do not know what 'makes' him Superman. Krypton and Jol-El are both important in *making* him Supe. If we do not have the pretense knowing he is an alien from another planet, it dulls some of the uniqueness of the character... and he is *the* most interesting superhero character.Also you vastly over-estimate audience of today.t. screenwriter
>>224311949>They were NEVER going to get the same excitement etc from the massesnah, it would've worked if they'd stuck to their guns. instead they confused everybody about what was canon and what wasn't and it looks like they're going to continue doing that. they also made the same mistake Marvel did with getting into TV.
>>224310548>Everyone woefully miscast>Shit writing>Shit director (both Whedon and Snyder)It's amazing how it's terrible in every aspect
>>224309244
>>224308801>Is making a DC universe genuinely that hard?No, you only need Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman and not even that, you can go with the Justice League first too.
>>224308801satan wont allow them to make the movies too good because it would turn people away from evil. if you piss people off it makes them angry and more likely to think good is gay and evil is cool.