Remember when Stannis burned his only daughter and last surviving heir at the stake cuz reasons?Good times.
Visuals are the most important part of film, but when the plot is so pants-on-head retarded that it detracts from the viewing experience, you know you've fucked up
Remember when Sansa was sold off to Ramesay for reasons. It was beautiful, the rape.
>>224309908SALSA PLS
>>224309889I cant make a choice, its either the whacky adventure north of the wall or Jaime and Bronns adventures with sand sneks.
>>224309889Biggest character assassination award goes to Stannis
>>224309951I really do like the ending plot points but the executions of them are terrible. Bran is basically a lowkey eldritch God.Can control people, beasts, time travel among other things
>>224310352But what's his tax policy?
>>224310352Yeah, the execution wasn't the greatest of all time.Don't even get me started on Arya somehow magically being the snownigger killer when it was foretold that Johnny Snew would be the one to do it. But hey, here we are.
>>224309889No, I don't remember, since i went book only after season 2.
>>224309889Females are not heirs.
>>224309889The actress who played Shireen looks so stereotypically British. Almost every picture on her Instagram is of her holding an alcoholic drink. In pic related she's holding two beers in one hand.
I've wondered if George had the plan for her to die, or that was a DD thing. I can't see Stannis doing it, even if the red woman told him explicitly there would be no way to win the war otherwise. I could see his wife agreeing to do it behind his back, but not this. It would also do better for the story. Stannis doesn't do the ritual, keeps his integrity, but he still loses the battle and his wife and daughter are slaughtered in the process.
>>224310290He literally killed his own brother with dark magic.He was ALWAYS gonna do literally anything thats necessary to secure his throne. Stannisfags never saw the writing on the wall that hes a ruthless piece of shit.Hes the literary answer to the trope of how far you can or should go in forcing what is rightfully yours, he decided to go all in and, predictably, lost everything due to his stubbornness
>>224311670of course it was planned from the beginning, its a delicious tragedy since stannis has to do the one thing he never ever wanted to do if he wants the throne.
>>224310352
>>224309906>filtered
>>224311655>The actress who played Shireen looks so stereotypically British. Almost every picture on her Instagram is of her holding an alcoholic drink.You are aware Britbongs are alcoholics, right?
>>224312299That can't be true, they told me it's all medicinal.
>>224312309You have a lot of catching up to do.
>>224309889War is hard...
>>224310290What character assassination? Only Dany has a valid claim to the throne
>>224311830If the books are finished (lol, lmao), Stannis presumably would burn her for higher stakes than the weather being a bit chilly.
Sometimes I read a thread and it hits me all over again just how fucking retarded the average poster on this board is.
>>224311830>He literally killed his own brother with dark magicRenly was a legitimate target. The brother tried to usurp the throne and steal Stannis' rightful crown all because "I'm more popular and well-liked than Stannis". If Renly hadn't done that, they'd have been united and easily stomped all others. Instead, Renly split their forces, threw everything into chaos, and gave the enemy their chance to triumph. Stannis was in the right to assassinate only Renly and cause as little harm to loyal Baratheon forces as possible. Shireen is obviously different. An innocent child that did nothing wrong. And her potential death was not gaining him much.
>>224312463Yeah, him believing to be Azor Ahai reborn always meant that he would sacrifice the person he loves the most for the higher good. Which would be nothing less than stopping the Long Night, not using cheat codes to defeat a random bastard lord no one ultimately gives a fuck about.
>>224309951It was beautiful
Will he do it in the books too?
>>224311830>>224312883In the books he tells his men that if he dies they should fight to the death to put his daughter on the Iron Throne. Burning her is completely out of character.
>>224309908
>>224311670In the books Shireen and Stannis aren't even together, he didn't take her with him on his march.
>>224312883The theme of stannis character isthe question of how far you can or should go in enforcing your rights.Renly, it can be argued was a traitor and had it coming, yet stannis was still slaying your own kin. A moral grey area at best, murder at worse.Mance rayder was a "technically innocent" and unrelated person Stannis burned all the same for his own goals.And shireen was just the logical next conclusion, stannis was convinced a sacrifice was necessary in order to win the north, so he did what was necessary from his point of view.He will burn her in the books as well, having him be tricked by his wife or the red priestess would defeat his entire character arc.His entire story is literally just the question of how far you should go when you are "technically correct" (he is the legitimate heir of robert after all) or if theres a point where moral considerations should take precedent over your own rights. (The people dont want him, he keeps losing, the price of victory becomes too high)
guarantee stannis would do it in the books as well, I mean I think the main reason GRRM has not finished this shit outside of being a fatfuck is that the general outline of what happens in the show is what happens in the books, and he realized how much people hated it and it caused an existential crisis and now he can never actually finish it.
>>224313937100% its obvious. He should have NEVER given them any direction on where the series goes and should have done a Full Metal Alchemist way. Make the show come up with its own 2nd half. Instead now he's stuck, like really stuck. Cause people liked parts of the show. Jon and Dany for example. If he doesn't do that, people who want it are upset, if he does do it, people who don't want it are upset. He fucked himself hard, cause he cares too much what people think and now the story is out of his hands.
I'm like 90% sure GRRM did say in some interview that Stannis WILL burn Shireen in the books as well, he just didn't say when.>Robert was the true steel. Stannis is pure iron, black and hard and strong, yes, but brittle, the way iron gets. He'll break before he bends.I think the end of this quote is what counts, something so bad to his efforts to claim the throne happens that finally breaks him completely and he resorts to burning Shireen as his Nissa Nissa in a final desperate effort to gain power.Where the books have left off he's not in a position to burn her though, so he first has to somehow get back to Castle Black and I don't see him making it over hundreds of miles of deep snow if he loses to the Boltons.Unless George cucks out because of the bad reception the show got and changes his plans and has Melisandre burn Shireen to resurrect Jon.
>>224311655I have no problem with this.
>>224314082>cause he cares too much what people thinknot based>now the story is out of his handsmeh, you can't please everyone all the time, the fat bastard has lived long enough and heard all the online criticism to realize that. He just needs to finish the fucking books because there are still quite a few differences between the show and books
>>224313937some things are so different between the books and the show that it would make no sense for both to end in the same way if not vaguely, so it would be incredibly retarded to take offence from the negative reaction to the show's ending even if it covered some of his planned plot points.The more realistic explanation is that his "gardener" method made the plot grow out of control and tying all the loose ends is just too much work for a lazy old fatass, plus the show outpacing him made him lose steam.
>>224314315I know there's such major differences between the books and shows to the point so much from the books is completely absent from the show, but the general plot I think is probably very similar. I wouldn't even be surprised if GRRM had Bran ending up on the throne as well, he's not the kind of guy that would end the story with Jon / Dany in that position. But I agree with the gardener stuff. The books just have way too much secondary and tertiary plots going on and he has to weave them all together and get everything settled in a way that doesn't leave plot holes and wraps up all these hundreds of characters stories where as the tv show just has you dealing with a few main characters really. He's probably just given up realizing the task is too much time and effort at his age and it's easier to enjoy his millions while he is still kicking. I mean even if he ended up finishing TWOW eventually, that's not even the conclusion to the series and there's no way in hell he would ever finish the final book if he's having this much trouble finishing up the penultimate novel.
>>224314646he wants to write another dozen Dunk & Egg novellas too, and despite their diminished length and scope I doubt that he'll do even half of those
>>224309889*hits pipe* Stannis, is there anything more cucked than having a daughter?
>>224314795It took him almost 3 decades to write 3 dunk and egg novellas and it's been 16 years since the last one lol. I know he was primarily working on GoT at the time but still. History is repeating itself. AKotSK only has 3 novellas to base the story off and they already finished one.