[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: rings of powah.jpg (144 KB, 1600x1200)
144 KB JPG
Maybe.... not all Orcs are evil??
>>
>>224316983
Yes they are, Morgoth made sure of that when he raped them. He kidnapped elves and raped them for centuries until they turned evil. Every single orc is evil by definition
>>
File: 1714321238583964.png (60 KB, 751x527)
60 KB PNG
>>
>>224317264
>what if, Le Bad, is actually, Le Good!?!?
>i am a genius
>>
>>224317201
poor rape victims
>>
By the end Galadriel will accept the orcs are damned and learn to stop seeking absolution for them as means of finding absolution for herself
>>
>>224316983
It’s always white women doing this shit
>>
>>224317302
There's a reason Muslims stone rape victims to death. Once they've been tainted by that kind of evil there is no fixing them
>>
>>224316983
it was really off putting when the orc looked directly at the camera and blamed gondor for air striking another hospital in mordor
>>
File: apu2.png (98 KB, 657x527)
98 KB PNG
>>224316983
Didn't they have a decent orc guy in 1st season that wanted to make a country where orcs are free from Sauron?
>>
>>224317766
That dude wisely chose to yeet himself from the project
>>
>>224317766
they did.
he's a senator in michigan now. put your phone down the next time you're watching a show, zoomer
>>
>>224317859
>put your phone down the next time you're watching a show, zoomer
I didn't watch it, just saw the wembs here. I also don't understand the amerimutt politics reference.
>>
>>224317766
You mean Israel?
>>
>>224317646
kek
I'm sure that material would be more interesting than the show.
>>
>>224316983
So she is saying he is one of the good ones and a credit to his race?
>>
>>224316983
>>
>>224317264
Modern everything - cinema, literature, gaming - tries its hardest to reach realism. This is absolute dogshit, because we experience realism everywhere, every day. Not to mention the ridiculous amount of resources this goose chase consumes and requires...
>>
>>224317264
Modern literature is coomer bullshit
GRRM is a big offender
>>
>>224317859
>he thinks voting matters
>>
>>224316983
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tolkien%27s_moral_dilemma
>>
>>224317264
The irony of these types of memes is that they're made by people who divide everyone into two groups: us the good ones, and nazis.
>>
>>224317264
Nice. Is Feanor good or evil?
>>
File: 1794088102491239.jpg (75 KB, 2160x1209)
75 KB JPG
>>224317264
>bitch like a little faggot when people don't like gray morals on a franchise that for 100 years was about black and white morals.
Also
>"I'm not watching it either, I just don't want evil nazi ghouls enjoying 100yo franchises!"
>>
>>224317201
>He kidnapped elves and raped them for centuries until they turned evil
this doesn't seem like a scalable solution
>>
File: Smug-meme-1.jpg (581 KB, 1536x1902)
581 KB JPG
>>224317264
>GFFM
>complex characters
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Reminder that Stannis burning his daughter is Fat Fuck's canon.
>>
>>224317894
Insallah.
>>
>>22431726
>Satan is just evil because... he just is ok??
Such hack writing
Where is the generational trauma? The realistic panic attacks? Had to put down my kindle and physically facepalm
>>
the irks from murder
>>
Tell me about the witchkang.
>>
>>224316983
Can’t wait till she gets ORCED
>>
maybe we'll finally find out their tax policy this season
>>
>>224320373
There's entire religious treatises on whether satan is evil or not
>>
File: 4944.png (396 KB, 950x1423)
396 KB PNG
>>
> https://rangs.ytmnd.com/
> https://rangs.ytmnd.com/
> https://rangs.ytmnd.com/
>>
>>224320274
He is goovil
>>
>>224320582
Funnily enough that one makes sense - most of the people that served Sauron are from Harad A.K.A. the Middle-East and Africa of the setting.
>>
File: Goblin_slayer_03.gif (2.86 MB, 480x270)
2.86 MB GIF
>>224316983
The only good orc is a dead orc. They are racially and irredeemably evil. As >>224317201 stated, the most common and widely accepted Orc origin (the canon is law) is that Morgoth took the elves and corrupted them beyond repair to mock Eru´s creation. Elves where made to take care of the world that Eru had created so, while free and even capable of falling, they are driven to create and do good. Orcs are the opposite, slaves driven by fear, hate and an urge for destruction. Not a single canon example of a good orc exists.

This show is so ridiculous...
>>
>>224316983
>>224317264
so true, evil doesn't exist. let them in.
>>
>>224321200
The show exists to warp Tolkien’s classic work into something that fits better into globohomo sensibilities.
Look at Colbert’s involvement in the recent project.
Lots of boomers and people like him who grew up loving Tolkien pre-“Great Awokening” aren’t willing to give up the whole franchise to the Chuds. But the problem is Tolkien and his works are inherently Chud coded. You can’t get around that.
So they decide to flood the zone and create a massive homonigger tolkienesque extended universe with morally gray orcs and interracial same-sex dwarf-elf relationships and hope that by drowning us in this new progressivist-approved content linked to the Lord of the Rings™ that we’ll collectively decide we love the new and improved modern take on the classic work and just ignore all that icky original stuff that Tolkien clearly got wrong.
It’s neoliberal boomers attempting to have their cake and eat it too.
>>
>>224321200
>Not a single canon example of a good orc exists.
The same shit as the real world Turks and Mongols
>>
>>224320274
Good. He just wanted the jewelry back and it affected his judgement a bit.
>>
>>224321119
Most? That's hard to say. Easterlings may have made up larger numbers. And those were maybe more steppe based. Also, I an not aware if actually sub saharan black looking humans were ever mentioned. Yeah, there were troll men of Far Harad, but I am not sure if those were meant to be blacks or just another fantasy race. Haradrim were middle eastern inspired, so I suppose you could say notAfricans were in Far Harad.
>>
File: 1769909778754460.png (73 KB, 751x527)
73 KB PNG
>>224317264
>>
>>224316983
I liked Marnukh and I wish they had just let him betray the elves but no, we had to give Negrolas some character development 2 seconds before With King Theo kills him. Actor did a great job too.
>>
File: df342321.jpg (96 KB, 1904x1064)
96 KB JPG
WATCH MY SHOW YOU RACIST NEEEEERDS!!!!!!!!!
>>
File: south-park-indiana.png (216 KB, 559x348)
216 KB PNG
>>224316983
Amazon is raping the Tolkien Estate.
>>
>>224316983
ORCED
>>
>>224321661
shut the fuck up faggot
>>
>>224321743
it's not rape, they got paid. they're filthy whores.
>>
>>224316983
Morgothism is a religion of peace.
>>
>>224320301
After first elves turned evil he could outsource the rapes to them.
>>
>>224316983
>spend a bajillion dollars and piss off every Tolkein fan on Earth
>why?
>for 30+ episodes of "Orcs are good guys!" propaganda
What's the psy op here? Why the fuck would Jeff Bezos waste so much money trying to convince the world that orcs are actually not violent irredeemable psychopa- oh never mind i figured it out.
>>
>>224320582
Why didn’t they just keep their masks on so it wasn’t an issue? Also the naz’gul were much scarier when you didn’t know what they looked like besides ‘wraith’ phenotype. Bezos is such a fucking hack no wonder his rockets keep blowing up.
>>
>>224317264
True. What if Nazis are not truly evil. What a concept.
>>
>>224320582
>becomes eternal undead slave for Massa Sauron
>>
>>224321200
In fairness the orcs are the weakest part of Tolkien’s canon. He wrote so much about the setting but the orcs are a gigantic blank spots
>How did Morgoth create the orcs? Through corrupted elves, right? But in-universe it’s only speculated on and actually not as clearly defined in Tolkien's letters as you might think
>Are the orcs ireedemably evil? Tolkien actually didn’t think so, because ultimately they are part of the World, and the World is fundamentally good (he actually toyed with the idea of having Frodo and Sam meet good orcs on their journey but never went through). Tolkien was a war vet so making a race of pure evil probably didn’t sit right with him given the century he lived in (in fairness that aspect of his doesn’t show up much in his actual published book where all orcs are evil to a fault).
>If orcs are elves, where do they go when they die? The halls of Mandos like all the others? The Void where Morgoth is exiled? Never clarified.
>>
>>224321901
>no, not like that
>>
>>224321982
>Are Mongols irredeemably evil?
Irrelevant question. Those who signed up for the campaign either are or act as if they are.
>>
>>224321982
This question could be asked only if there were orc mercenaries willing to slaughter their own kin for Gondorian silver.
That PC game with sexy Shelob had some orc turncoats, but its status as canon compatible work is really low.
>>
>>224322140
>if there were orc mercenaries willing to slaughter their own kin for Gondorian silver
They would if there was any Gondorian willing to pay them. They would all pretend that it is only these other maggot orcs who do sobut do it anyway.
>>
>>224322140
>hire a lot of orcs to the army
>the fall of Rome, Middle- earth edition
Nope
>>
File: 1794447884083579.png (2.44 MB, 2592x1080)
2.44 MB PNG
>cuck your husband with Satan's best pal because he's hot
Why are white women like this?
>>
>>224322393
Could be worse.

Black RANGS girl cucked her husband just because and literally told him to his face "It wasn't that big a deal bro"
>>
>>224322462
And she seemed like the nicest person in the entire show, funny enough. AW HELL NAW
>>
>>224316983
>maybe there is some tall, good-looking ones
see you in lord of the rings: rings of power season 4
>>
File: IMG_0354.jpg (38 KB, 680x635)
38 KB JPG
>>224321695
It looks so ridiculous I wouldn’t even hate watch it.
>>
>>224321982
Even if Tolkien, as a christian, believed everyone could be redeemed the letters are ultimately a private matter. One can´t put that on the same level of something like the Silmarillion, which is a published work. A writer toys with many ideas, writes many versions of things but not all versions make it to the end. If he ultimately never wrote any example of orcs turning a new leaf then that´s that.

But more to the point the show writers are being malicious in nature, they grasp at straws about anything that suits them like how they decided to make Galadriel a girl boss over the Nerwen thing. She explicitly rejects that path and name is spite of her proficiency with the blade, she chooses the path of magic and politics and becomes a cold calculating witch that nobody can read. Even Sauron can´t trick her or read her mind and yet the show gave us a hot blooded warrior that screams her mind at anyone willing to listen and is totally into that setzy Sauron.
And him? They take a moment of weakness he had while processing the shock of Morgoth´s defeat and say "lets make him honestly sorry and vulnerable". A thing by itself may not constitute ill intent but there is an obvious pattern here.
>>
>>224317264
He will never finish the series.
>>
>>224317264
Chuds always praise LOTR for being a simple black and white story of good vs. evil, with no moral grayness or complexity.
JRR Tolkien has spoken out against the Chud reading of his work, emphasizing that moral complexity and its tragic consequences are the most moving part of the story for him. Referring to the claim that the matter of good and evil is rather simple in LOTR he stated:
>"But of course, as a matter of fact it isn't really, is it? You see evil on the good side. It isn't just blacks against whites, or the goodies against baddies, as they call it modern parlance."
>"People have often asked me what moves me most. I think the most tragic point in the whole story is the terrible irony that good often does evil. The most tragic moment is when Sam in his protectiveness says, 'Take your hands off.' And therefore defeats Gollum's repentance. Because that seems to be very true to life."

Tolkien's statements have reportedly left chuds in absolute shambles, endlessly spamming 'evil can never create' memes and claiming that 'if Tolkien lived in the modern UK, he would be a nazi with a simplistic worldview like me!'

https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260918-the-most-tragic-moment-in-the-lord-of-the-rings
>>
>>224324444
>One can´t put that on the same level of something like the Silmarillion, which is a published work
No its not, you fucking lorelet. Its assembled by his son from tons of mutually contradictory notes his father never published or prepared for publication. Hence there's like a dozen volumes of "unfinished tales" which are just those notes which his son decided to not put into the "official" Silmarillion.
>>224324539
You literally put "unfinished tales" under "he finished all of it", mongoloid
>>
>>224317201
hot as fuck
>>
>>224316983
>he's one of the good ones
>>
>>224316983
#NotAllOrcs
>>
File: 1563648919292.jpg (45 KB, 570x487)
45 KB JPG
>>224324539
sar did the needful
>>
File: loreletchud.png (284 KB, 878x894)
284 KB PNG
>>224316983
>>224317300
still having a meltie over this, lorelets?
>>
https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ag_AFraxj-4
>>
>>224316983
maybe orcs write... le poetry and shit
>>
>>224316983
God, I love her. I'd do anything to change out the straw in her cage and refill her water bottle.
>>
File: 49311.jpg (51 KB, 340x314)
51 KB JPG
>>224324978
>>
>>224324844
It's Illúvatar's world that is good, not the orcs.

Get better reading skills.
>>
>>224321695
>GIVE GIVE ME YOUR WARPSTONE
>>
>>224321119
harad is based on the aethiopia. they should have cast a nubian or ethiopian person rather than this western african man
>>
>>224325058
>It's Illúvatar's world that is good
Orcs are part of Illuvarar's world.

Get better reading skills, chuddie.
>>
File: Hand over the cheese.jpg (29 KB, 513x513)
29 KB JPG
>>224321695
>>
>>224317264
>what if everything was just the same gay slop and bad people are actually heckin damagedrino
>>
this show will end with an interracial orc baby
>>
>>224324539
>unironically sullying tolkiens memory and name with this indian pigshite
kys ASAP
>>
>>224324539
>finished. all of it
>unfinished tales
what did Sir Tolkien mean by this?
>>
>>224321695
I torrented the first season and deleted everything two episodes in fuck this trash
>>
File: 6jlmq4499u1i1.jpg (68 KB, 1480x816)
68 KB JPG
>>224320301
It is. The raped Elves become Orcs and they go on to rape more Elves, themselves. It becomes self sustaining after the third generation of rapists.

What I can't explain is how this is a Dwarf
>>
>>224316983
They should just say "orcs = nazis" and avoid any controversary.
>>
>>224320582
I can barely see anything and this isn't even a joke about him being black.
>>
>>224317264
Tolkien made Sauron an angel whose motivation was to order a world corrupted by the meddling of gods beneath the true god. His chief followers were the devoted of gods and a messenger of the true god.
His deeds defined him but so did Golems. Mercy.
>>
>>224321695
Cheesed to meet you.
>>
>>224317201
Morgoth was the greatest of the Ainur but you think him lesser than Aule or Yavanna? Cope
Orcs were made in mockery of Elves. He could not make something truly new but corrupted the idea of another just as the rings echo the reality of the silmarils. Don't be a reddit retard misquoting Tolkien
>>
>>224326671
Shut up
>>
>and then one day, for no reason at all, Eru sang reality into existence
>>
>>224322140
>That PC game with sexy Shelob had some orc turncoats, but its status as canon compatible work is really low.
It wouldn't even matter if it was canon (it's not) because the ones working for (You) are fucking mind raped by ghost-ring-magic-bullshit
>>
>>224321525
feanor is easily top 3 most evil elf in the whole lore. His only competition is Maeglin, the guy who betrayed Gondolin, and Saeros, the guy who tried to kill Turin.
Feanor did the kinslaying, he betrayed the Valar, he betrayed his brother, forced an oath on his children that doomed the Noldor, and is very proud and arrogant, which are traits that Tolkien describes all his worst characters with.
He might be morally grey, but he’s definitely more evil than he is good.
>>
File: 1773625773153191.gif (2.99 MB, 480x320)
2.99 MB GIF
>>224324978
>>
>>224321661
I thought it was interesting that he didn’t betray them, because you’re expecting the whole time that he’s going to double cross them but then it’s surprising when he doesn’t. They shouldn’t have killed him off honestly, he was fun
>>
>>224325305
>Orcs are part of Illuvarar's world.
In the sense that evil exists to make good look good? But evil is still evil That's why when the end times come Eru will create universe 2.0 with all the bugfixes after collecting issue reports from beta testers humans and elves. I shit you not that's exactly what Tolkien says.
>>
>>224327450
>Turin
That's a city in Italy. Tolkien is a faggot hack.
>>
>>224327544
in retrospect, literally zero of the dudes in that gif were funny. like, at all.
>>
>>224327553
>God knows all, God is perfection, God does not make mistakes
>God will create a second, better, corrected universe (with none of the current problems( once this one has run its course

So is God's creation perfect or not
>>
>>224327032
That was such a fun game. Imagine Saurons surprise?
>An army of WHAT is attacking me? From INSIDE Mordor?? Its lead by WHO?!?! WHAT THE FUCK?
Surprise, bitch. Nice evil fortress ya got there, ill take it. I liked storming castles solo in number 2 so I dont lose any of my troops. Just charge in and boot the door down like a bad ass and mindrape everyone who stands before me.
>Ya dare stand against da great Sauron! Who'dya think ya arr?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-TmdfPtxPl4
>>
>>224327788
It’s a shame that the endgame of 2 is so repetitive and gets boring fast. I never ended up actually getting through it because I was so sick of storming fortresses and fighting ludicrously OP bosses with every immunity imaginable
>>
>>224327646
God is perfect so whatever his design is at the moment is also perfect. If he changes it later, its also perfect because he chose to do it. Duhhh
>>
>>224316983
>If not all orcs are evil... then is it possible... that some black people have feeelings?
>>
>>224327811
>fighting ludicrously OP bosses with every immunity imaginable
Yeah, that was gay. I wonder if theres any mods that take away immunities? Im an old man, I just want to beat and mindrape orcs with ease and in peace without having to be a sweatlord.
>>
Do orcs and Urukai get to go to Erus "Men only" afterlife?
>>
>>224327829
That’s a contradiction though. Something perfect can’t be improved by definition, so if heaven is an improvement over the earth, then the earth isn’t perfect. You can’t half two different worlds that are perfect, only one of them can be perfect, because any difference from a perfect world would be an imperfection.
Let me guess, you’re going to do the classic philbro defense of
>god is contradictory
Or
>human minds can’t comprehend how it’s actually not a contradiction from god’s perspective
>>
>>224327884
>Something perfect can’t be improved by definition
hes not improving it, hes changing it. One perfect thing changed into another perfect thing. theres no contradiction.
>>
>>224327640
I have always and will always find Louie funny. I understand the arguments of those who don't.
>>
>>224327902
It’s like you didn’t even read the second half of my post. You can’t have two different things that are perfect, there can only be one perfect thing, because any difference from perfection would be imperfect.
>>
>>224317201
How does sex make you evil over time?
>>
>>224327646

"even orcs would become part of the World, which is god's and ultimately good"

Ultimately good does not mean perfect. It means thanks to the design of the world, a society of living creatures cannot sustain the sort of evil an evil ghost that lives in the Outer Dark or whatever can. Some of them like their children, or their comrades, or their riding-wolves. They sing songs, make art, etc.

This is important theologically but does not change the military practicalities as far as Rohan and Gondor are concerned.
>>
>>224327927
I perfectly understood your post was wrong and didnt need to read the second half. World 1 is perfect because it was made by a perfect being, God changes perfect world 1 into perfect world 2 so its still perfect.
I dont know why you dont understand this.
>>
>>224328233
Either world 1 is perfect or world 2 is perfect, they can’t both be perfect, because any difference would be imperfect.
You are basically arguing that
A=C
and
B=C
therefore
A=/=B
It’s logically incoherent
thanks for confirming that you are, in fact, an illiterate dumbass
>>
File: dkj8moh02rph1.jpg (97 KB, 1084x812)
97 KB JPG
>>224317264
lol
>>
I'm closely following this season while the polcels seethe endlessly as per usual
>>
>>224328330
a b and c are all different though
>>
>>224328330
Youre a fucking retard. 1 perfect thing being changed into a still perfect thing means its still perfect. Your fedoras too tight, take it off and let some blood flow to your brain. The state of perfection never changes because its being done by a perfect being.
>>
>>224328464
The only way that both A and B can equal C is if A=B. Your position is mathematically and logically incoherent.
>>224328459
If A does not equal B, then A and B cannot both equal C
It’s actually fascinating how retarded christians are. your brain has been turned into mush
>>
File: 1707141925561686.jpg (59 KB, 1080x922)
59 KB JPG
>>224317264
Yes, yes, well done HOWEVER
>>
>>224328509
why are you putting the alphabet in math
>>
>>224328546
it’s like you’ve never taken a math class past elementary school
it’s philosophy
>>
>>224328509
Your entire argument is flawed. Its some retarded "What If" pile of bullshit. The world is perfect, if God changes it, its also perfect. You can try dance around the reality of the situation all you like but it doesnt change (haha) the fact that whatever God does is perfect and correct because if it wasnt then God wouldnt be God. Knowing that God is, in fact, God, its perfect.

Keep grasping at straws. Your flailing is amusing.
>>
>>224320728
Classic Faelith and Modern Pollyanna for me.
>>
File: 1649681794999.jpg (406 KB, 1750x1750)
406 KB JPG
>>224328512
Tolkien was the first sjw
>>
File: 1765931753604593.gif (3 MB, 345x315)
3 MB GIF
>>224328512
Both are awful. 3rd option is always the best.
>>
>>224320728
At least I would both versions of Pollyanna
>>
>>224328610
>The world is perfect, if God changes it, it’s also perfect.
That is logically incoherent. You are irrational.
>the reality of the situation
there is nothing real about your Jewish mythology
>whatever God does is perfect and correct
that’s your claim, but in your holy book, he changes his mind multiple times, regrets things, and makes a world which is imperfect by definition.
>if it wasnt then God wouldnt be God.
it’s actually hilarious to me that you can’t comprehend a reality where a creator deity isn’t perfect. The idea of a flawed god is anathema to you because you’ve been indoctrinated, but there’s no reason to assume that if a god exists, it must be perfect
You are completely and utterly retarded and it’s terminal
>>
>>224328766
You dont understand the concept of God and are feverishly grasping at straws. This entire argument and concepts like "Perfection" are beyond you.
>>
>>224328809
I understand that your concept of god is completely irrational, just like your concept of perfection.
You have no response to the philosophical challenge I have presented.
If A=C and B=C then A must equal B. It’s basic logic. You are hopelessly retarded and dishonest
>>
>>224328850
Nta but A=B doesn't make sense, that's just A=A or B=B.
>>
>>224328873
if
A=1
and
B=1
therefore
1=1 and A=B
I’m sorry you didn’t graduate middle school, the job market must be hard for you
>>
>>224328850
>I understand that your concept of god
No you dont lol

You dont even understand the concept of God and you act like a know it all faggot. Hoky, anon. You are retarded.
>>
>>224328929
>still no response to my argument
>pure grandstanding and declarations of victory
lmao
>>
>>224328968
Its a statement, not an argument. Id live to have an argument but you dont understand the foundational basics of what we were supposed to be arguing. Youre like a little blind kid screaming the sky is neon green. Figure it out, bud.
>>
>>224325305
>chuddie
tranny detected, opinion discarded
>>
>>224329004
>still no response to my argument
lol
Your argument is A=C and B=C but A does not equal B.
you have no counter to this irrefutable logical fact, now you’re just desperately responding and declaring victory in the hope that I’ll get bored and you’ll get the last word.
you’re unbelievably pathetic
>>
>>224329116
>Your argument is
No, my argument is that you dont know what "God" is. Your every post proves me right.
>>
File: 1766592729442203.webm (3 MB, 800x800)
3 MB
3 MB WEBM
If she would have became Saurons personal onahole it would have been a better show.
>>
>>224320582
>Immediately start serving Sauron after getting the ring instead of being corrupted over decades
>Even refer to themselves as ring servants
They're just pissing on the corpse of the lore at this point
>>
>>224316983
Pretty sure there is an NTR hentai game about this exact concept, except the orc was just manipulating the queen to turn her into a breeding sex slave for more orcs
>>
>>224317264
>Complex characters
I am gay!
>Moral gayness
Maybe the child molesters aren't the bad guys?

Yeah nah
>>
>>224324668
Okay so LOTR is morally Gray? Isn't that the opposite of what that 'meme' image is saying?
>>
>>224329329
Seeds of Chaos?
>>
>>224329210
your argument is illogical and you have no response
lol. lmao even.
>>
>>224317201
This orc is evil too he just doesnt want to die in Israel I mean Saurons wars
>>
>>224329455
The queen who adopted a goblin
>>
>>224321695
LAWDY DEM RANGZ
>>
How is this series going now guys? I hatewatched the first season(pirated), but completely forgot about it afterwards.
>>224317766
There's a dialogue like that in the LOTR:ROTK books too between two orcs.
>>
>>224329886
I'm on episode 4 of season 2 and so far it is better than season 1.
>>
>Elves/Orcs are an analogy for Angels/Demons
>Maybe this demon isnt so bad...
>>
>>224321119
uhh...no?
>>224327450
I don't think the other two is on the level of Feanor's evil. Maeglin was just an Oreimo fan and Saeros' attempted murder isn't really that evil in the grand scheme of things, in that case Turin and Hurin are also evil. iirc what about those two sons of Feanor, the ones that tried to kidnap Luthien and caused all sorts of mischief, iirc Caranthir and Curufin. And several elves also spied for Morgoth after being buckbroken. I'm sure they could be considered worse.
>>
>>224324539
you're not wrong but you deserve to spend the rest of your days with grrm for posting aislop
>>
>>224329472
>political hack trying to instrumentalize tolkien for his retarded agenda
GTFO
>>
>>224329329
NTRMAN game, right? I forgot but she makes a cameo in another NTRMAN game too.
>>
>>224328509
This is a perfect hammer.
Now I need a screwdriver.
Magic stuff
Now I have a perfect screwdriver.

Different worlds, different tools but each one is perfect for what it needs to do.
>>
>>224328905
A and B can't be the same thing or else they wouldn't be different letters
>>
>>224320778
Have a (You).
>>
>>224330117
a perfect hammer would also function as a screw driver. A tool that can only do one thing isn’t perfect. If it’s incapable of doing something, then it isn’t perfect. A perfect tool could achieve any possible task.
The screwdriver and the hammer are part of the same world and neither tool is perfect.
>>
>>224321447
>we’ll collectively decide we love the new and improved modern take
No, the red paint will go up and the statues will go down. No one wants this but this is the new past, present and future of Tolkien and if you don't like it "RACIST" will appear at the top of your LinkedIn in bold & flashing letters. Be a shame if you couldn't make a mortgage payment, eh?
>>
>>224329892
>better than season 1
that's like saying the second shit you took after taco bell had more structure

is it actually good or just less aggressively insulting?
>>
The world is black and white and not morally gray. People only try to sell you on subjective morality to justify evil
>>
S1 is the weakest, I've liked the 4 episodes quite a good deal so far. S2 was a massive improvement from 1, Charlie as Annatar and the whole Celebrimbor plot was the best LOTR since the trilogy.
>>
>>224331437
>The world is black and white and not morally gray.
proof?
>>
>>224317264
>one didn't finish the books
>one did

Tolkien wins by default.
>>
>>224332768
leave your basement, sheltered loser
>>
>>224317264
Tolkien didn’t even believe that orcs were evil. Near the end of his life he said they would go to the halls of mandos for deprogramming
>>
>>224332845
I mean Morgoth is supposed to come back eventually with his army of evil for the final battle, if he can’t have his orcs it’s going to he what, twelve Balrogs and a bunch of dragons?
>>
>>224332845
Not really. He never could decide if they were actually elves since it doesn't really make sense. But he also wanted to say Evil couldn't create yet has its own force infinite, ultra loyal minions that seemingly come from nowhere. He wanted to eat his cake and have it too. Like after Sauron was defeated, were there still a billion Elves that were constantly captured and tortured over the next few thousand years to become Sauron's new army? Absolutely not. The initial orcs could have been captured elves to start but they've long since become their own little race of creatures that breed normally and aren't anywhere near immortal
>>
>>224317264
I like this bait because by some awful universe mistake there are real breathing people who "think" like this
>>
>>224333175
>The initial orcs could have been captured elves to start but they've long since become their own little race of creatures that breed normally and aren't anywhere near immortal
I think this is what he meant, not all orcs are corrupted elves, but the first orcs were. Supposedly the first trolls are corrupted ents too but that always seemed to me like trying to hammer everything into the same hole
>>
>>224317201
>>224321200
Tolkien himself objected to them being irredeemable, why are you so obsessed with being wrong about everything?
>>
>>224333122
Dont forget those Volcanos. Id take 1 angry volcano over a million man or elf army any day.
>>
>>224317264
Evil exists.
>>
>>224329458
Uh Oh! MeltyYyy
>>
>>224331341
>that's like saying the second shit you took after taco bell had more structure
hahaha
Thats such a good anal-ogy for this series.
Man, they should have cut out 90% of the characters and just made it about Sauron tricking retards. They also need to make Sauron not be a crybaby.
>I have many names....
Yeah, and one of them is Pussy!
The show is total garbage but I giggle over Sauron fucking with people. idk, it reminds me of Palpatine fucking with anny.
>You know, Anakin. The Sith could save their pregnant wives from dying due to complications in childbirth. Sorry, what were you saying about those bad dreams you were having? Tell me all about them, old friend.
>>
>>224333333
Based sexts of truth
>>
>>224333333
Absolutely, abysmally wasted
>>
>>224316983
Big orc kawk.
>>
>>224316983
We should really stop generalizing and see the war for what it is: Saurons war! We should welcome every orc refugee and offer them all the rights and help we can give them.
>>
The interior of Mordor being some amazing land with farms tended by Orcs around the sea of Nurn is sort of a hole in Tolkien's work. For something like five thousand years humans never expanded into Mordor and took over those fertile lands for themselves? Those Orcs must have had little cities, communities, towns, led by people and desiring trade or could be subjugated by the strong Men of the West after Sauron's fall
>>
>>224317300
Let's be fair here, the train of logic goes:
>they are not inherently evil just misguided
>this makes them victims of deception
>being a victim makes you good under the slave morality we established in mainstream society
>hence evil-doers are good and morally above non-evil doers.
>>
>>224333535
Orcs can eat stuff humans can't. "Fertile" is relative.
>>
>>224333535
>>224333563
iirc weren't those places actually farmed by slave humans? Aragorn granted them those lands after the war ended.
>>
File: 1507410180153.jpg (81 KB, 540x523)
81 KB JPG
Get an Orcposting thread going before i piss myself.
>>
>>224333333
can't argue with those digits desu
>>
>>224333584
Nope, it was all orcs and goblins tilling the fields. The only humans were people from lands way further east
>>
>>224326671
Except when Aule made the dwarves, they were just automatons with no free will until Eru gave it. Orcs demonstrate free will often.

So, either orcs were made fresh by Morgoth and Eru secretly gave them sapience as well, or orcs are corrupted versions of what already exists with free will. The canon version is the descendants of tortured elves and men, which would make sense considering half-orcs can exist (half-elves were possible, half-dwarves weren't).
>>
>>224333333
God gave you his signage, dont waste it
>>
>>224324668
JRR Tolkien didn't know what a chud is because he lived before reddit zoomer speech and he would have despised you for embracing the destruction of the English language.
>>
>>224333740
And elf and a human produce an orc, then an orc and a human becomes more human?
>>
>>224321200
>The only good orc is a dead orc. They are racially and irredeemably evil. As >>224317201 stated, the most common and widely accepted Orc origin (the canon is law) is that Morgoth took the elves and corrupted them beyond repair to mock Eru´s creation. Elves where made to take care of the world that Eru had created so, while free and even capable of falling, they are driven to create and do good. Orcs are the opposite, slaves driven by fear, hate and an urge for destruction. Not a single canon example of a good orc exists.
Tolkien himself had like 5 different versions of the Orc origin and retconned himself multiple times because he was desperately trying to solve the "if God exists, why did he make/allow someone to make Evil creatures" which is obviously a theological issue way above his paygrade. He himself struggled with basically the D&D Paladin issue (kill all Orc babies and remain LG) and why genocide against Orcs isn't Evil or should it be Evil or is it Good or why don't the heroes do it and why don't they become Evil if they do it in war and so on.

If he didn't write so much shit about it in Silmarillion sketches and his letters, none of this idiocy would be happenning "canonically" at least.
>>
>>224333799
>he would have despised you for embracing the destruction of the English language
The opposite, kek. He was such an autistic nerd about language that he despised that everyone was becoming more agreed on one singular language and more of the world was speaking English. He said if it were his choice, he'd make the entirety of the world go back to speaking vastly different languages and not understanding each other without rigorously studying each new language encountered. Doesn't mean all languages are beautiful, but he loved everyone speaking their own
>>
>>224333333
God's chosen hexad
>>
>>224317201
Uhhhh did you just victim blame the poor things?
>>
>>224333809
>And elf and a human produce an orc
... they don't.
>then an orc and a human becomes more human?
Well, yeah, a half-orc is "more human" than an orc.
>>
>>224333930
They wouldn't be since orcs are already half human. There is no "pure orc". You're dumb.
>>
>>224333961
>They wouldn't be since orcs are already half human.
Why do you think orcs are half human?
>There is no "pure orc".
Yes, they're is. They're called orcs.
>You're dumb.
This will not end well for you.
>>
Long story short:

Warcraft III came out on July 3, 2002, and already featured good orcs.

The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall (1996) also featured orcs who weren't inherently evil, including King Gortwog.

Additionally, Babylon 5 (1994) had its own version of space orcs: the Narn, who were portrayed sympathetically.
Plot-wise, Warcraft III basically follows a very similar storyline to Babylon 5.

Star Trek also had good space orcs (the Klingons) as early as 1987, with Worf in The Next Generation.

Hell, even Mortal Kombat: Deadly Alliance (2002) had Bo' Rai Cho and Li Mei, two good-aligned characters from Outworld.

Now, regarding Tolkien, since y'all apparently don't read books, he famously struggled with the morality of orcs.
He even wrote about two orcs, Shagrat and Gorbag, who discussed deserting Sauron's army and living independently, away from their overlords.
>>
>>224333975
Shagrat and Gorbag wanted to loot and rape independently on their own. I guess since you see orcs as niggers, looting and raping is good and natural behavior to you.
>>
>>224316983
>>the female gaze
maybe this dirty rotten rapist is actually a romantic lover

western civilization has collapsed because women want their slutty wet cunts satisfied by orcs
>>
>>224334060
looting and raping was common source of income during medieval era.
Every state did that, even good aligned ones
>>
>>224334165
Hey Gurm. Finish the books you fat fuck. Shows are shit.
>>
>>224327902
Why change perfection?
Doesn't that imply that it's imperfect?
Wouldn't something perfect have absolutely no doubts that it's perfect so the very act of changing it proves that it's not perfect?
>>
>>224334097
>western civilization has collapsed because women want their slutty wet cunts satisfied by orcs
This. And jews.
>>
>>224334314
Something can be perfect for one situation but not for another.
>>
>>224316983
maybe they just need some girlboss to have sex with them
>>
>>224328656
Retarded poopjeet
>>
>>224316983
this is just racemixing propaganda, isn't it?
>>
>>224335719
>where is my hobbit sex???
He really can't grasp the idea of staying on track and finishing a plotline
>>
>>224335719
Sunset found her squatting in tall grass, as she drank shat.
>>
>>224335719
>DUDE SEX LMAO - Grrm
>>
>>224316983
Smart good orc that wants to coexist < Smart evil orc that wants break away from his masters and burn the world at their own will
>>
>>224334556
God's perfection is conditional? So he is not omnipotent?
>>
>>224336262
In Tolkien's work, Eru made a universe that was marred by Morgoth, but in that marring created "beauty unlooked for". Seems to be that Eru intentionally made things that way, and since he did it, it's his perfect vision.
>>
>>224316983
They're corrupt, they'll only find resolution in death.
>>
File: tolkien.jpg (249 KB, 824x1172)
249 KB JPG
>>224328656
>>
>>224316983
Then they would be elves...
>>
>>224328809
>>224328929
>>224329004
You will never be religious, nor will you ever understand anything about theology, chud.
>>
>>224327551
We were expecting it because orcs are evil and that’s what orcs do. I wanted them to go the route of some orcs are smarter and more cunning, but no we got some orcs are good
>>
>>224333260
Tolkien went back and forth on it in his private letters, it NEVER made its way into his actual works
>>
>>224336308
Ah, God is an asshole then. Thanks.
At least Lovecraft was honest when he portrayed his outer gods as these unfathomable alien creatures that just. don't give a shit about human suffering.
>>
>>224336798
>it NEVER made its way into his actual works
do you know what the Silmarillion is, chuddie?
>>
>>224327871
Orcs most certainly not, as they're either corrupted elves or animals that have been transformed into beastfolk. Urukhai is an interesting one, as they're potentially half-orcs, so perhaps a part of their soul is 'mannish' enough to enter paradise, but uncertain.
>>
>>224327990
Didn't Morgoth inherently render the whole of Middle Earth as 'evil' due to him channeling his malice into it?
>"Just as Sauron concentrated his power in the One Ring, Morgoth dispersed his power into the very matter of Arda, thus the whole of Middle-earth was Morgoth's Ring".
Renders Middle Earth a 'corrupted' world, only to be saved by death (humans) or entering the Halls of Mandos (Elven).
>>
>>224336964
and God is chill with it
>>
File: 44767458.jpg (553 KB, 599x900)
553 KB JPG
Daily reminder that Tolkien's most hated book is pic related. Guess why?
>>
>>224337026
Eru doesn't really 'care' about Middle Earth that would be comprehensible to mortals. All that is in Arda is of Eru, so for him it's just like watching a simulation go by that he created in a porgramme that is also a part of himself. Morgoth is of Eru, Gandalf is of Eru, etc.
After the Music of the Ainur, Eru noticed the discordance of Morgoth and, whilst yes pointing it out, didn't punish Morgoth for it. He just went with it (wryly from what I remember) understanding that the discordance would actually be of some benefit to his creation.
Everyone dies in the end anyway after Dagor Dagorath, and Eru will create a new-world with his children (Men). Probably the Kingdom of Heaven on Earth.
It's been a while since I've read the Silmarillion and the extended histories, so this is just my rusty opinion on the matter. It's fascinating stuff though.
>>
>>224337171
by 'Arda' i meant 'Eä', whoops.
>>
>>224335719
>or should be
KEK
>>
>>224337171
>Eru doesn't really 'care'
Yeah we know. Same problems as the christian god, he's an asshole.
>>
>>224337105
Because Tolkien was a sincere Catholic whereas Frank Herbert was a lapsed-Catholic-turned-atheist who believed religion was fake and gay and a tool to get the masses to be compliant with their own exploitation

This isn't exactly rocket appliances
>>
>>224337272
>Frank Herbert was a lapsed-Catholic-turned-atheist who believed religion was fake and gay and a tool to get the masses to be compliant with their own exploitation
Herbert was right.
>>
>>224336262
>>224336874
If you aren't Catholic, or at least understand Catholicism on an academic level, you'll never understand Lord of the Rings
>>
>>224324844
>>224325305
>>224327646
>>224327884
>fallacy of division
Why are leftists so stupid?
>>
>>224337292
you can understand it fine just being Christian tbhdesu, there's not much other 'muh sekrit papist lore' that makes it incomprehensible to the average Christ enjoyer.
>>
File: 1716733986047228.png (163 KB, 716x714)
163 KB PNG
>>224324844
No, I am quite okay with leftists and their Amazon megacorporation burning a billion dollars on something nobody watches.
>>
>>224337292
I understand it fine, it's the same bullshit I've heard from priests all my life. Never convinced me.
>>
File: 1662515141557167.png (535 KB, 840x2178)
535 KB PNG
>>224337292
>>
File: 1789241977236246.jpg (76 KB, 720x640)
76 KB JPG
>>224329032
>>
>>224337415
No chud has EVER been able to point out even ONE fundamentally catholic element in the LotR books.
>>
>>224337415
>People aren't ever influenced by their cultural, religious, social, or economic upbringing and exist in a vacuum
>>
>>224337415
t. Peter Hackson fan who needs to dismantle Tolkien to defend his fanfic movies
>>
>>224337447
name one fundamentally catholic element in the LotR books.
>>
>>224337463
see: >>224337464
>>
File: file.png (1.7 MB, 931x1200)
1.7 MB PNG
I like the Rings of Power.
>>
>>224337105
now that's a kino cover
>>
>>224337464
Anti-suicide rhetoric because only God can give life, only God can take it, you don't order your own death
>>
>>224337512
>only Catholics are against suicide
now this is some desperate cope. when is there even any "anti suicide rhetoric" in LotR?
>>
>>224337464
That suffering is an integral part of human existence, that God cannot help you directly because he can't interfere with free will but he will help you in subtle ways as long as you trust in what you know is right, that martial power isn't a virtue in and of itself (Peter Hackson fans wouldn't understand this because his films worship violence) and the meek are often the most powerful of all, Frodo, Aragorn, and Gandalf are three aspects of Christ (the passion, Christ as King, Christ as Prophet) etc

>>224337547
The entire character of Denethor is someone who loses faith in god and tries to kill himself because seeking out knowledge rather than trusting divine providence drove him insane. Of course Hackson fans wouldn't know this because the movies write Denethor as just a kookoo banana brains crazy person who's evil for no reason
>>
>>224337492
based
>>
>>224337507
Yeah, the new ACE covers are the best hardcover designs of Dune if you aren't willing to shell out for the absolute premium stuff like Folio.

This Heretics of Dune cover is sick
>>
cheesed to meet you
>>
>>224337580
>>224337464
There's a creator god who seems to care a lot about his people, there's demi-gods who are middle men who wander around and help out his creation, and then there's clearly allusions to an after life. The universe has a clear moral direction. There's no analogous figure to Jesus or a Messiah though. Not super Christian, like 1:1, but it's clearly building on mythology that leans more Christian than say, pre-christian or Greco-Roman.
>>
>>224316983
next season shes going to fuck an orc....



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.