[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: dune.jpg (151 KB, 1600x1167)
151 KB JPG
Is Dune by Frank Herbert adaptable?
>>
If you go back and watch Lynch's version you'll understand why Villeneuve did what he did with Alia. The psycho toddler running around stabbing people looks ridiculous onscreen, and I'm not sure there's a way to fix it.
>>
>>224324787
I saw a ballet adaptation of Dune a few years ago. It was surprisingly kino. Not sure what Villeneuve's excuse was for Dunc being slop.
>>
>>224324787
Yes, but no one alive in the industry has the ambition, integrity and care to attempt it properly.
>>
>>224324787
Yes, but I think it would have to be animated.
>>
>>224324787
It's been adapted 3 times with Joro almost making it 4
>>
File: 1711653807588248m.jpg (177 KB, 1024x1024)
177 KB JPG
>>224325117
I think the Japanese could do it justice, or maybe the french, if the could suspend their negrophilia for the duration of the production.
>>
>>224325186
only if the tits are gigantic
>>
>>224325186
This does look cool. A vampire hunter d animation of dune would be amazing.
>>
>>224325057
This. And don't fear the voice over, why modern creators are deathly afraid of monologs in the first person I'll never understand. Give me three ten episode seasons and I'll give you kino.
>>
File: 1779779801912463.png (339 KB, 1200x675)
339 KB PNG
>>224325186
>>224325941
yes
>>
>>224326178
>made by the french
>>
>>224326502
mmmmmwwaaaaahhhh the frennnscchh
>>
Why do people here pretend the new films aren’t good?
>>
>>224326534
Because they aren't just not good, they're utter shit
>>
>>224326534
I liked them. Im stolked for D3. I hope its not shit.
>>
>>224326178
Bit strange to make a dune porn game without pregnancy, given how, uh, preoccupied Frank Herbert was with the subject.
>>
>>224326534
this board is now just brown people baiting
>>
>>224327386
Saar you bloody benchode son of bastard bitch!!
>>
>>224327520
No, you are the bloody!

>>224324787
>Is Dune by Frank Herbert adaptable?
Apparently not.
>>
>>224325186
So…Toon?
>>
>>224326614
Poon?
>>
>>224326614
No one is stopping you from developing a Bene Gesserit breeding management game.
>>
>>224326602
They're good, just not great.
>>
File: europanachregemii.jpg (103 KB, 1151x416)
103 KB JPG
>>224324787
Yes and Lynch version is the best
>>
>>224325186
White men storytellers with Japanese artists could truly create some of the world's finest kinos.
>>
>>224324787
Not in a single film.
>>
>>224324787
Apparently not
>>
>>224326534
They arent
>>
>>224327386
>if you dont enjoy ugly boring unimaginative dogshit with terrible actors you're baiting
>>
>>224326534
Because they're soulless brown slop
>>
>>224329014
You can breed your own super-people in the various Crusader Kings games
>>
>>224329854
Really?
>>
File: file.png (345 KB, 736x736)
345 KB PNG
>>224326534
There's also the performative love for Lynch crap and the TV show. That's the most egregious part.

I guess Denis movies are just too universally liked and there's no real hot take in saying how great they are. That's why you see the vocal 2% here that hated the movies.
>>
>>224331421
I watch DVD rips of Stargate SG1 because i don't enjoy the DNR of the upscales.
I watch the open matte version of Jurassic Park despite its flaws because i get to see more of the facility sets.
Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow is one of my favorite movies.

There is a lot i love about Denis's movies, costume design is one, so are the sets. Yet it all feels as though it was designed by 1 mind. Whereas the sets and costumes in the TV version feel like an eclectic empire spanning multiple worlds with the different textures.
I made it through about 50 minutes of the Lynch movie before i deleted the file.

My enjoyment of things is my own, it isn't performative. If no other human existed on earth I'd still talk about movies the way i do, outwardly, because the process is meditative and arguing with myself about things i like more often than not grows my appreciation in general for the things i like. Even sometimes the things i don't like.

Denis's movies are definitely disliked by me in comparison to the TV movies. It will be a very rare rewatch once all 3 are out. Yet i appreciate them.
>>
>>224326534
Because liet kynes race&genderswap and brown girlboss chani stand out like a sore thumb.
>>
>>224331421
If anyone's performative it's Duncfags who don't even care about Dune or sci-fi and just pretend the movies aren't shit because Villememe directed them.
>>
God what a bunch of fucking pseuds and contrarians. Villeneuve Dune was great
>>
>>224332128
He's a hack. Paul and Chani never even got into much of an argument in the books. In the movie they are practically at each others throats.
>>
>>224332976
Kubrick must be a damn hack as well for not being 100% faithful to The shining
>>
The main characters' internal monologues and thought processes make them stand out, when you try to understand their psychology you get an idea how evolved they are as "human" beings. You don't get the philosophy, wisdom, and how they read people telepathically, and how they see the possible futures, onscreen.
>>
>>224333027
King’s The Shining is slop, it was necessary to change it to elevate it
>>
>>224331311
Yeah really.
It's nothing that complicated. You must make sure to marry off your people to other people with good traits, and then there is a good chance the children will have good traits
>>
>>224324787
It is, but it requires skill and talent the Hollyweird junkies don't have.
Dune was poorly written. Like, really poorly. There's barely any world building. You don't know if they have cars, electricity, how the warfare looks like, etc. You have to built a movie around a few scenes resembling a stage play with nothing between them.
>>
>>224331875
>who don't even care about Dune
Kek, these people.
Enlighten me, which near and dear part of Dune did Denis do dirty? Which scene exactly, subplot, core idea? Was it the murderous toddler with a poison needle running around?
The way I see it: Denis acted as an amazing editor to a great but flawed writer who wrote a fantastic book... with lots of filler, stupid shit, weird sexual pervert stuff, downright comical things and self repetition.
He then wrote an overly explanatory patronizing Messiah with shitty prose.
You people are eager to forget the shitty parts of the book graciously cut by Denis.
>>
>>224334811
>Frank Herbert
>a great but flawed writer who wrote a fantastic book
Hang yourself



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.