[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: images (75).jpg (25 KB, 490x624)
25 KB JPG
They made one actual intellectual horror icon and he is about to set the record for mainline entries for a horror series with 11. Seems to be working out for him.
>>
>>224329922
Jigsaw is the Worst Horror Movie Villain of All Time.
>>
>>224330019
You just outed yourself as not being that smart.
>>
is that him?
>>
>>224330497
It's him. You're not wrong.
>>
>>224330497
John Kramer, aka Jigsaw?
>>
>>224330583
I think he has been going by JigC since 2011.
>>
It's crazy how much more terrifying intellectual horror icons are compared to normal ones. Even Freddy who is more cerebral than most slashers is much scarier than them because of it.
>>
>>224330088
>smart
You are those retards who think playing smarmy word games makes him deeply philosophical when he just comes off a teenager trying to do mental gymnastics of obvious cruelty which he is responsible. He would not walk free, if there would not be specific law made they would use him as example to make new ones.
>>
>>224331322
>"if there would not be specific law made they would use him as example to make new ones"
>calls smart people retards
>literally doesn't understand ex posto facto laws
>>
>>224331304
That’s why demon/devil shit hits hard. There is a design and brain behind it
>>
>>224331485
Yep.
>>
>>224330697
You’re not wrong.
>>
>>224331304
That's why Biden is so scary
>>
>>224329922
No, he is not the only intellectual horror icon, maybe if you said intellectual slasher icon instead, you would have a valid point.
>>
>>224331599
Name the other ones then and provide ratings based on their intelligence.
>>
>>224331322
It's a rehabilitation program. He's not trying to change the laws. He's fixing very specific people's problems he sees that need rehabilitation.
>>
>>224329922
>intellectual
Yeah sure, they all are.
>>
>>224331781
I don't know about "ratings" but some genius horror villains include Dr. Frankenstein, The invisible Man, Damien Thorn from The Omen franchise, Actually as I think about it even villains like Hannibal Lector, Patrick Bateman, Sweeney Todd, Mick Taylor from Wolf Creek, Jack from The House that Jack Built, and John Doe from Se7en are intellectual slashers, so I changed my mind and OP is even wrong about that.
>>
>>224331920
Literally not a single one of these satisfies any necessary parameters. Some are just laughably bad suggestions.
>>
>>224331962
They do and you wouldn't name a specific one because you know they do and that their tricks and traps are more intelligent than any jigsaw trap or trick.
>>
>>224332002
>Dr. Frankenstein and Invisible Man don't count as horror villain icons. Frankenstein isn't a villain, and Invisible Man is a Universal Monster (different designation) with no history or mainline sequels to speak of.
>Damien is supernatural more so than intellectual.
>Hannibal is suspense/thriller and not even the villain in his only movies of note
>Patrick Bateman and Sweeney Todd aren't even close to being considerable as horror villain icons. Bateman is the protagonist in a dark comedy and is made fun of as a pseudointellectual within the form, and Sweeney Todd is a protagonist in a musical.
>Mick Taylor doesn't have icon status and is crafty rather than intellectual.
>Jack, not an icon and actually a pseudointellectual.
>John Doe, not a horror icon and certainly not a slasher. Seven is a suspense thriller.
>>
>>224332098
They do count and have been remade far more times than there are saw films.
Supernatural intelligence is still intelligence.
If you mean Silence of the Lambs, it appears in many top horror lists and its pretty much the only Hannibal Lector movie where he isn't the main villain.
Musicals and Comedy can be Horror, Saw franchise also became a dark comedy when he stood up and left at the end and especially when the franchise started to become about ironic traps.
You know who they are, they have extended universes and multiple sequels, they are icons.
John Doe certainly slashed up people and left a train of gore, he is definitely a slasher horror villain.

Your entire list is still just No True Scotsman fallacies.
>>
>>224329922
How is he a "horroc" icon? He quite literally hasnt done anything bad?
>>
>>224332287
No one ever said he was a horroc icon.
>>
>>224332287
wtf are you talking about? he did loads of bad shit
he just never did anything technically illegal
>>
>>224332209
Supernatural intelligence is still intelligence but it's not what anyone thinks of as "intellectual." Hannibal is only the main villain in the movie that is literally called Hannibal. Your rebuttals are terrible and the only value they have is bringing me joy because everyone will read them and see that I bested you in the field of public debate.
>>
>>224332303
if you cant prove it in court, its not bad
>>
>>224332316
Intellectual refers to the actions not the inspirations.
That is a Hannibal movie of note, so I accept your concession, he was also the main villain in his tv shows and jigsaw isn't even iconic enough to have a tv show.

At least you are adding non sequiturs and personal attacks to your no true scotsman fallacy.
>>
>>224332352
Have you even seen the Hannibal movie? If you think that's a horror movie you are even more braindead than the man that Hannibal feeds his own brains to in the movie Hannibal. You have also ironically committed the fallacy fallacy, but we won't make anything of it because you are still clearly learning the art of debate as well as basic definitions and confines of genre and the pitfalls of trying to reframe the meaning of a word like intellectual when everyone can publicly witness you squirming and contorting to avoid conceding defeat when an opponent has bested you.
>>
>>224332382
congratulations on making that kid a junior in the art of debate
>>
>>224332382
Sure, nothing horror about a villain who exposes people's brains and make them eat them based on a horror novel and scored by someone specifically scoring a horror movie.

You have the best fallacies ITT, congrats.
>>
>>224331920
>American Psycho
>Sweeney Todd
>horror movies
>>
>>224332509
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Psycho_(film)
>2000 horror conedy film

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweeney_Todd:_The_Demon_Barber_of_Fleet_Street_(2007_film)
>a 2007 Gothic musical slasher film

It must be that everyone else is wrong but you.
>>
>>224332481
Elements of the horrific do not in and of themselves a horror movie make. Whether you are being intentionally dishonest or are simple grossly misinformed, my hope is that you will strive to improve if you truly want to be a participant in intellectual pursuits and the art of debate.
>>
>>224332564
They do, a horror film is a film that tries to elicit fear and disgust using dark subject matters often filled with shock and gore, even the wiki pages say they are horror and Lecter is often listed as one of the top horror villains of all time.
>>
>>224332546
>slasher
Slasher does not equal horror as mentioned in this brilliant post: >>224331599
>>
>>224332618
>even the wiki pages say
You are clearly either still very young, unsophisticated in your understanding of art and the world, or simply very disingenuous.
>>
>>224332657
I originally called Sweeney Todd a slasher film anyway, but you are still wrong since that is how subgenres work all subgenres (slashers) are part of the genre (horror), but not all genre films (horror) are part of the subgenre (slashers).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slasher_film
>A slasher film is a subgenre of horror films involving a killer or a group of killers stalking and murdering a group of people, often by use of bladed or sharp tools
>>
>>224332667
>The experts and consensus are all wrong, not me and my hot take.
>>
>>224332710
Yes, Trust the Science. Sweeney Todd is a horror movie. Protect Our Democracy.
>>
>>224332774
Yes, you won't show it to your young children because you know it will frighten and disgust them because you know its a slasher and you know slasher is a subgenre of horror.
>>
>>224332808
If you specifically told your date who likes horror movies that you were putting on a horror movie and then put on Sweeney Todd, they would immediately get a very accurate impression of you.
>>
>>224332855
Same as if you put any kinda gay horror film on, but that doesn't make it not horror, it makes it kinda gay horror and if you tried to show your friends young child that film, they would get mad at you for trying to give them nightmares with a horror film.
>>
>>224332886
Your stated definition of a horror movie seems to be any film that has elements of darkness and the macabre. The same tenets you've expressed could be used to disingenuously argue that Nightmare Before Christmas is a horror film because it might be too dark for some young children.
>Hannibal is a 2001 American thriller film co-produced and directed by Ridley Scott; source: Wikipedia
You also selectively and disingenuously appeal to Wikipedia to make your case and ignore other instances where it contradicts your premise. Based on how you approach debate, I find it very hard to believe that you managed to not look that one up for validation. But then again, your arguments are so lacking in intellectual quality and rigor that it's within the realm of possibility that your lack of thoroughness just so happened to deal you a lucky hand when appealing to your sources of truth and definitive knowledge, that being Wikipedia editors.
>>
File: lsossnqr.png (682 KB, 1200x630)
682 KB PNG
>>
>>224332980
Thriller and horror are not mutually exclusive, there is no contradiction, some sources also call Hostel a thriller despite obviously also being a horror by most measures.

>has elements of darkness and the macabre
No, the definition I gave only considers those elements horror if they are in service to creating a general atmosphere of disgust and fear.

>lacking in rigor
Not as lacking in rigor as you simply trying to erase the existence and legitimacy of wikipedia because it refutes you.
>>
>>224333044
Did you miss the part where Wikipedia refutes you when it comes to Hannibal being a horror movie? You seem eager to confirm to your audience that you are disingenuous and not interested in having a good faith discussion.
>>
>>224333077
I saw where you incorrectly stated that exciting is mutually exclusive with fearful, but then I corrected you since thriller and horror are not actually mutually exclusive since the emotions they are meant to evoke are not. Do you see that the quintessential slasher movie Halloween is also called a thriller?
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0077651
>psychological horror
>psychological thriller
>>
>>224333146
Really trying to dodge being exposed on that Wikipedia thing aren't you?
>>
>>224333194
You really are too brown to understand that being a thriller doesn't refute being a horror aren't you?
>>
>>224333243
Sure, sure. And Hannibal being listed as a thriller had nothing to do with you excluding it from your Wikipedia sourcing, right?
>>
>>224333453
Correct, I specifically cited the Wikipedia page in regards to Hannibal being scored based on it being a horror about horror icon Hannibal Lector, so the page mentioning thriller had no relation to this >>224332509 not mentioning Hannibal when I >>224332546 cited wikipedia about horror/slasher movies.
>>
>>224333491
This is exactly what convoluted flailing looks like.
>>
>>224333614
Agreed, you continuing to talk about how it is also a thriller when being a thriller doesn't refute being a horror while ignoring how the music was specifically selected because it was a horror is what convoluted flailing looks like.
Also you thinking that being both a thriller and horror is too convoluted for you to understand proves how stupid you are.
>>
>>224333663
Got a Wikipedia source to back that up, bud?
>>
>>224333681
You complained about Wikipedia, so I already backed it up with an IMDB source.
>>
>>224333742
Maybe you'd like to post what Wikipedia says about Seven in the first sentence for us?
>>
>>224331304
>im going to murder you!
>lmao thats goofy and not even scary
>im going to murder you with an elaborate ballcrushing machine because you laughed at an ugly gypsy woman when you were 12!
>OMG THIS INTELLECTUAL HORROR IS SO SCARY BROS!!!!
>>
>>224333769
Sure, as long as we are talking about the same wikipedia page that atributes the success of the movie to its blending of horror, police procedural, and urban noir, as well as its tendency to suggest rather than explicitly depict much of the violence, leaving it to the audience's imagination, thriller still doesn't refute horror, no matter how dense your waterlogged smooth brown brain is.
>>
>>224333806
Yeah, great. Would you please post the first sentence for us?
>>
>>224329922
are all the replies in this thread a joke? he crushed a guy because he smoked cigarettes. any time I feel like watching saw I just rewatch Donny Whalbergs scene with him in the factory then turn it off
>>
>>224333822
Sure, the first sentence says Seven (often stylized as Se7en)[1] is a 1995 American crime thriller film and a later sentence says this was one of the few horror films in 1995 that didn't underperform, so the wiki page itself demonstrates that being a thriller doesn't refute being a horror.

Now do you understand why thriller doesn't refute horror or your smooth soggy brain still doesn't quite get it?
>>
>>224333869
You went to Wikipedia to source your genre claims. When that was called out as a weak basis, you said it was ignoring experts amd consensus. When a quick search revealed that you had selectively chose which movies you cited based on whether they agreed with your genre premise, the reaponse was nothing but word salad and attempts to drag things into the weeds. A sad display. Again, movies like the Indiana Jones series have horror elements but that doesn't make them horror and it's a terrible argument for characters therein being horror icons.
>>
>>224334162
>When a quick search revealed that you had selectively chose which movies you cited based on whether they agreed with your genre premise,
No, I cited >>224332546 every single movie that was in the post I responded to >>224332509.

>word salad and attempts to drag things into the weeds
So you admit you are too dumb to understand that being a thriller (trying to elicit excitement) doesn't refute being horror (trying to elicit fear) and any attempt to explain it will just appear like gibberish to your 80 verbal IQ brain?

The sad part of the discussion is that you are obviously just making retarded arguments to bump your retarded thread now that you have decided to wait until the thread is off page 1 to reply.
>>
>>224332303
it is illegal thoughever
>>
>>224329922
>200 IQ mastermind genius
>gets scammed by a bunch of mexicans
>>
>>224334229
That was a different person you responded to. I posted a reply to you stating it was stupid to treat Wikipedia as some kind of definitive source and you responded by saying it was me prioritizing my hot take over the "experts and consensus" from the good old editors at Wikipedia. I then pointed out that many of the other films/series we're discussing aren't primarily listed as horror genre movies on Wikipedia, and you tried to divert attention away from that by saying that Wikipedia says they have horror elements or that people cited within Wikipedia compared aspects of them to horror movies. The Indiana Jones movies have horror elements. King Kong: Skull Island has horror elements, but they aren't definitionally horror movies and no amount of disingenuous arguments about definitions will make them such.
>>
>>224334614
>I then pointed out that many of the other films/series we're discussing aren't primarily listed as horror genre movies on Wikipedia
>primarily
I accept your concession at least now you are admitting with your language that being a thriller doesn't "refute" being a horror, it will just take a while for your actual cortex to catch up.
>>
>>224334679
In typical fashion for people like you, your arguments suck so you construct caricaturized versions of your adversaries that will be easier for you to address. Even then, you do a poor job.
>>
File: hp423aa2j4551 (1).jpg (95 KB, 1242x692)
95 KB JPG
Jigsaw disciples showing up in a big way in this thread. A lot of other characters getting exposed pretty hard. Not surprising that his fans have a far more intellectual bent.
>>
>>224331818
This to be hones
>>
>>224329922
he deserves it, hope 11 is actually coming out



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.