[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


Was Pinochet really that bad?
>>
>>224332344
Only if you were a communist faggot (redundant, I know), and I'm guessing it'll have all of the subtlety of Three Billboards.
>>
>>224332344
>commie Hollywood makes movie about how bad anti-communism is
Nothing new on the western front
>>
>>224332344
>Was Pinochet really that bad?
Yes
https://www.dw.com/en/chile-germany-establish-colonia-dignidad-commission/a-39682775
>>
Everyone villainizes the anti commies, but I don't see anyone making movies praising the glorious leadership of East Germany or the success Ukraine saw under USSR rule
No, instead we get shit about the heckin evil Stasi and Chernobyl
>>
>>224332344
>>224333746
liberals are sneaky and evil shitheads who refuse to own up to anything their side does
>>
>>224332344
Yeah everyone who isn't American is evil and also in America everyone who isn't non-White is evil, hth.
>>
>>224333746
Whenever they portray something like the Stasi or KGB negatively, the implication is always that they're evil because they're white and militaristic = nazis. That's the subtext. It's never that their ideology itself is bad
>>
>>224332344
>I really wanna go to Easter Island, how can I make this tax deductible
>>
>>224332873
>about how bad
you literally masturbate to him because he was bad. That's the only reason. You do the same with Hitler or Franco. You don't like them because you genuinely think they were good. You like them because they are bad and you're a bitter nihilistic chud full of resentment against normies
>>
>>224334035
Mao killed SIXTY MILLION fucking people.
Supporting post war anti-communist because they were the objective lesser evil does not fucking make us mother fucking Nazis.
It's no different than giving aid to Stalin for the moral absolute greater good.
>>
"Fascists" are just guys who go and do the actual needful and fix everything by force and commies never forgive them for that

Bukele is the latest, in 40 years there will be textbooks saying he was a bloodthirsty vampire
>>
>>224334035
KILLING GENOCIDAL COMMUNIST IS NOT FUCKING BAD IN ANYWAY.
Them being too indiscriminate was bad but killing actual proven communist was a factual moral good.
>>
No Ivan this doesn't make me want a authoritarian government either.
>>
>>224334435
>do the actual needful
Fuck off ranjeet
>>
>>224334035
No that's what your shitlib brain categorizes it as because you genuinely can only think of anyone CNN tells you is "fascist" is Evil personified, and you think people are just being edgy.
Fucking hell, did you just wake up from a coma since 2016 or something
>>
Ranking US supported Cold War dictators from best/most justified to worst/least.

> Park Chung-hee (zero massacres of note under his rule, economy skyrocketed)
small gap
> The Shah
large gap
> Syngman Rhee
gap
> The South Vietnamese leaders
gap
> Chun Doo-hwan
large gap
> Efraín Ríos Montt
gap
> Pinochet
large gap
> Hissène Habré

Rhee & Hwan are hard to rank as Hwan killed less people than Rhee but Rhee had better justification. Rhee: It was morally correct to crack down on the Jeju uprising (they killed 200+ police officers and started holding Maoist show trials for landlords) but were far too indiscriminate. The Bodo League massacre was less justified and probably killed far more innocents but it was in the midst of a apocalyptic war for survival and the North did in fact send troops across pretending to be refugees.
Also Rhee had his moments of mercy/compassion with him releasing into the South 27,000 born again anti-communist POWs from the North whom the North demanded the return of so they could murder them.
Hwan had basically no justification for Gwangju and the good he did had almost all already been started/set in motion by Park Chun-Hee.

I put Montt above Pinochet as he had a more valid enemy force to fight against than Pino did.
>>
>>224334478

That's the joke you stupid marxist faggot
>>
>>224334621
Nobody asked, redditor
>>
>>224334621
Rhee's strongest positive is that he was mostly ineffective at mass murdering his rivals.
>>
File: images.jpg (29 KB, 386x518)
29 KB JPG
>>224334621
I forgot I would add Batista beneath the Shah.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNvVw4XZxZQ
I watched the above Casual Historian video on the lead up to the Cuban Revolution and he list the following statistics that contradict the narrative that Batista was nothing but a puppet for American business interest and that countless Cubans were slaving away in the fields.
> In the 1930s 80% of Cuba's sugar industry was owned by American companies. By 1958 that went down to 35%. This was a result of Cubanization of the economy with loans & other incentives given for Cubans to buy American assets.
> By 1954 Sugar was only a quarter of Cuba's economy and only 44% of the labor force was in agriculture.
> By 1959 Cuba had the 4th highest per-capita income in Latin America & the 31st highest in the world (today it is at 82nd)

Is that inaccurate?

Also while he agrees Batista was certainly corrupt the actual mass enabling/weaponization of gangs and the Mafia was done by Ramon Grau not Batista.
And he list a bunch of progressive positions Batista had at least during his original lawful presidency such as woman's suffrage.
>>
One of these days, and it won't be long :)
>>
>>224334621
>>224334720
Wikipedia says about Batista's body count...
> However, the figure of 20,000 deaths is disputed by several historians, who consider it "propaganda". According to French historian Jeannine Verdès-Leroux: Intellectuals and journalists have endlessly hammered home the falsified figure of 20,000 deaths. Castro only spoke, in his report to the 1st Congress of the Cuban Communist Party, of an "incalculable" number of victims. Specialists agree to conclude that the figure of 2,000 deaths is a high maximum.

And my concern with these numbers is it does not separate justified vs unjustified killings. If the death toll genuinely is closer to the lower end then I think there is a actual genuine possibility the majority of those killed were legitimate communist rebels/gang members and not innocent non-combatants.

The Batista regime was so lenient that Castro was offered clemency 1 year into his 13 year sentence if he would simply publicly promise not to try and overthrow the government again which he refused (Batista would eventually pardon Castro and other rebels anyway)
>>
No he was quite a jovial fella. Really loved his whirly birds
>>
Pardoning the Unit 731 mad scientist and ignoring the Bangladesh genocide are the worst things America did in the Cold War.
Agree?
>>
>>224334621
What about Noriega and Galtieri?
>>
Was he actually as based as the movie tried to portray him?
>>
>>224332344
Communist retards mostly deserve suppression, even if not as brutal, because their utopian ideology turns people into serfs.
Democratic socialism? Whatever, I guess we can just compare them to neoliberal states. But commies GOTTA GO. But then, it's latin america. Nothing is stable there.
>>
>>224335226
bump
>>
New normieslop for imbeciles to feel smart dropped
>>
Commies rnt human
>>
>>224332344
basic rule of thumb: if commies say someone is bad, he's actually probably good, or at least should be given the benefit of the doubt. commies, socialists and their sympathizers are liars by nature
>>
>>224332344
All of latin america, post ww2, basically bounced back and forth between socialism and fascism
Each regime was extermely unstable, and likely to be taken out by their enemies at any point, with lots of chaos and violence
Someone like pinochet killed a few thousand communists who were looking to overthrow him, and somehow this makes him the worst monster in history. I don't get it. This is nothing compared to the death tolls of most socialist governments.

>>224334621
Meanwhile, the american left was supporting stalin, pol pot, etc
>>
>>224336273
Such a person is generally "bad" for opposing communism or stopping communists from taking power. Communism being the most murderous and evil ideology ever devised



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.