whats the worst thing he actually did on the show
>>224337903Not morally, but management-wise, telling a room full of all his top guys, "Fuck that honor and loyalty shit!" was beyond retarded and directly led to Carlo flipping on himhttps://youtu.be/IjSad5BDU8M?t=232
>>224337903cheating on his wife
>>224337903messing with the vipers
being fat (and bald, but you get a pash for that)
>>224337903Murdering people
bobby bball
Unironically, going to therapy. If you can’t sort out your mommy & daddy issues and learn to enjoy your family and giant house and lifestyle most can only dream about, you are a failure as a man.This is nothing against grief / trauma counseling. There are sudden, high-impact events that nobody can mentally prep for. But going to see a therapist because “I’m not happy, I keep fucking hoors and I don’t know why, boo hoo” is pathetic.
>>224337903Shot those ducks
>>224338087>t. Happy wanderer
>>224337903>Vito gets killed in an unsanctioned hit >Tony does fuck-all in response (remember the Fat Dom thing was just Syl going rogue)>gambles away all the money that was supposed to go to Vito’s family>cheaps out and sends Vito Jr to some hellish boarding school in Idaho to be beaten and probably raped
>>224337903Passing out randomly when stressed
>>224337903Chrissy was blood and in need of aid. I get it, he shot the younger gentleman as well.But that guy attempted murder of his family unprovoked. Chrissy situation was cold man. Went on to bang his girl afterwards as well.
>>224337903Ruining the life of that black cop for giving him a speeding ticket. He met an actual strong silent type, and it made him more petty than anything else in the show.The nice thing about Tony, compared to Chrissy and Paulie, is that he usually was considerate to civilians. This guy was the exception.
>>224337903Snitching on Feech LaManna.
>>224337903Probably killing Chrissy. Or maybe ruining T1000s life but he was a degenerate gambler.
>>224338249Cops aren't civilians
>>224338270It wasn't clean, but Feech was an insubordinate animal. Did you like him, or do you mean whacking him would have been the more honorable path?
>>224338321Fair enough, but it was still incredibly petty of Tony. The man was a traffic cop, not really a threat to him.
>>224337903sacre bleu where is me mama
>>224338373Unironically this. Tony saw Janice was actually beginning to cope and grow and he couldn't resist pulling her back down.
Killing Ralph
>>224338249What gets me about this one is that Tony has a rare attack of conscience and realizes he fucked the guy over but does nothing to fix it, out of pure spite and malice
>>224337903The time he stole Meadow's panties after her soccer game, put them over his face, and masturbated violently. That was a little out of line.
>>224338430Paulie was based for knowing the assignment during the visit at Chrissys
>>224338391if a line at dinner produces a knife, you haven't grown
>>224338404He tried getting him reinstated as a patrol officer but got talked out of it by the councilman, because apparently this guy was a giant turd nobody on the force liked so who gives a shit.
>>224338249to be fair, im sure there's body cam of that cop being a piece of shit to people.
Killing the guy's son just because he was putting in a bid for the garbage pick-up contract
>>224338201Vito knew the rules of the mob and he knew Tony was a piece of shit that couldn't be trusted to take care of him family. Phil didn't give her anything either. Vito could've avoided everything by being just a little more subtle
>>224338401Good Morning Sir
>>224339036>Vito could've avoided everything by being just a little more subtlehe was subtle. What else could he do?
>>224338496>2005>BodycamProbably not and he's probably not a bad cop considering he can't be bought.
>>224337903Kill ralphie, a top earner, because he couldn't handle his emotions.
>>224339086he could've not gone to a public gay club or sucked off security guards at a union work site
>>224339086>What else could he doNot go to gay clubs. Not blow random dudes on construction sites. Just get boy whores or something or go way out of state.
SACRE BLEU WHERE IS ME MAMA
>>224339152He probably never did a thing for Ralph's kid either. He's such a fucking asshole.
I honestly despise Carmela way more than Tony >No growth through the entire series >Acts holier than thou with muh Catholicism despite knowing what Tony has done >Forgets all inconveniences by being bribed with materials and money >Only gets back with Tony after realizing she can't get half his wealth and demands 600k for a spec house that she builds with faulty material >Towards the end of the series she doesn't give a shit about Tony ending up dead or in prison and now focused on her money
>>224339086not be gay at all (serious crime no matter who you ask)
>>224339153it.was.a.JOKE!
>>224339219I'd say they're both equally bad and their greed corrupted them. Carmella is just as childish as Tony. She picks and chooses what she's mad about and when. It's wild how annoying she gets when it's just her and Aj because she's bored and overbearing.
>>224338087cause he had blackout panic attacks even though in general i completely agree with you. the only caveat is mot having foundational strength/mental orderliness from ur parents that give you this concept of i can deal with anything
>>224339153>>224339154>>224339220so would you like it if you were not allowed to do anything with women whatsoever and just be celibate the rest of your life? Of course not. Viito had desires and he indulged in them in a low key matter.
>>224339353No. I'm saying he should have been even lower key about it. I get he was in some club outside of NJ or something but it's one state over, that's not enough. Wear a gimp mask or something. Better yet, he has enough fucking money, get whores. It's unlikely that any of the crew would come to the site that early because they're all lazy but on the off chance one shows up he would have been fucked if it was anyone besides Finn that one time. He has money. Go to Vegas and rent a guy. Go into deep PA or more north or some place with ZERO guys who could recognize him. He knew what the punishment was and how big this secret was. I get it, he's been hiding this all his life and that must be an insane way to live but he knew the risks.
>>224339443Pretty sure he went to a club in NY and he was dressed in bondage gear so he's hard to recognize. He doesn't want to use whores because he likes picking up men who also like him.
>>224339567Ok. Go further away. He wasn't dressed up enough to where some guy who kinda knew him spotted him. He didn't do a good job of not being caught because he was fucking caught. He knows the world he's involved in. He knows what would happen if this ever came out. I don't disagree that this is all very fucked up but he's a willing participant in the world he knowingly joined. He didn't have to marry either or have kids.
>>224337903Beating up his driver
>>224339625he can't go too far away in case he gets called in by the family to do work. They're gonna ask him why he's a few states away. Also he has a life and driving hours often gets too much.>He didn't have to marry either or have kids.yes he did as boomers had a lot of pressure to marry and start families, especially if they were catholic.
>>224339086>>224339353>>224339567ny is absolutely not far enough from jersey, especially if you're doing business with guys from nyalso the problem with vito is that he got a second chance with jim in new hampshire but he was too fucking lazy to do real work
>>224339690>Had to marry Jr never married. >Can't go too farHe can go on vacations. It doesn't seem like these guys have strict schedules. Hell thinking about it he shouldn't have done those weight loss ads either. Some other fag could have seen it and spotted him and ratted him out or something. My point is that he wasn't secretive enough about this. He got too big and the veil started to fall. Hell he never even fucked his girlfriend, those cunts talk.
>>224339736That scene of him working is so fucking funny.
'Bout that prick's face when he saw the gyatt
>>224338087>>224339340>just be an unhappy sad sack of shit your entire life and never try to seek help because... because I said so!!Amazing advice as always from the retarded incels.
>>224339854>Neither of them said that>It's incredibly hard to be happy and healthy and not a greedy piece of shitBoohoo
>>224339774>He can go on vacations. It doesn't seem like these guys have strict schedules.he's a captain so he has to be around to watch over his guys and whatever things he has his hand in. Even so, he's not gonna go vacation every weekend just for some dick. Tony is gonna wonder why he's fucking off so much. Him going to NY was fine since it's a big enough city and the club where he got caught was super busy too. It was just unlucky for him. He was likely going there for 20 years without issue
He wore shorts.
>>224337903His biggest crime was the antisemitism.Israel is our best friend in the Middle East, and we should always cherish God's chosen people.
>>224339884Ok luck runs out. More people start to know him. Bro I don't get how you're not understanding that he clearly didn't do enough. He was caught, he was suspicious, he was cracking. He had options. He could have learned to control his urges and maybe do this every couple of months. You're acting like he had no choice but to join the mob. He could have been a regular schmuck like everyone else but no he had to have it all. That's why everyone goes down in this show. They try and take too much and it's bites them in the ass. Only Furio saw this.
>>224339908cute fit actually to be quite honest with you senpai
>>224338201>>cheaps out and sends Vito Jr to some hellish boarding school in Idaho to be beaten and probably rapedVito Jr. needed a few beatings to get out of that puerto rican goth phase. And while I don't approve of corrective rapings, it's been shown to work well enough in the Russian military.
>>224339934He's what woemen mean when they say "you look like your mother dressed you for school"
>>224339908>Muh Don never wears shorts>Son is retarded>Family splitters because he couldn't pick a successor properly>Does with egg salad in his mouth because he got too hotFuck Carmine. So fucking annoying.
>>224338249He was a nigger.
>>224339219>fucks school principal>tries to fuck handyman>tries to fuck priest>tries to fuck bodyguard>TONY'S CHEATIN ON MEH!!What did she mean by this?
He needed to spend more time with his mother instead of letting her die alone and forgotten in that hell hole of a retirement community
>>224340013They were split when she dated the principal. Tony was cheating first. They're both bad in that regard but Tony did say he would stop several times over and just didn't. >>224340052That place was insanely nice and he was paying big bucks to send her there. She was just an old bat. Tony should have known she was crazy and kept her away from jr.
For me it's how he did Christopher>have a family member who's 100% down and loyal for the crew and loyal to you as boss>to the point that he's willing to flip over his own love and fiance and let her get whacked>insist he go to rehab for his substance problems>he does so and gets clean>when he gets out, proceed to belittle him for staying clean and force him to drink and use again>he of course craters>proceed to hate and kill him for itThere is simply no justification it's pure hate and cruelty
>>224340083IT'S JUST A RACKET FOR THE JEWS!!!
>>224338445Paulie was a panty sniffing connoisseur. I'm sure he had stolen panties belonging to Carmella, Meadow, Charmaine, and Angie among others in flavor saving ziplock bags to take out and enjoy the taste and aroma any damn time he so chooses.
>>224337903>whats the worst thing he actually did on the showHe did protect Tracy
>>224340113didnt
>>224339219Yeah, Tony makes some sincere efforts to change himself as a person even though he always backslides eventually. For a goombah mobster going to therapy is itself a fairly impressive step. The biggest change Carm makes is performatively “divorcing” Tony while keeping his house and living on his blood money
Probably yelling at his wife.
>>224340141Kek, brother he wasn't there to change himself. No one who goes to therapy is. Did you miss the part where the other therapist tells Melfi at the end that she probably spent all that time simply indulging in self pity and enablement for a narcissistic sociopath?
>>224340175There was also the jew therapist who gets exactly 1 scene he just tells Carmela he knows she will never actually leave tony so there is no point. He just refuses to keep seeing her.
Why did Tony setup Melfi's rape to record it in 8k ultra HD with multiple camera crews and microphones setup in various hidden locations
>>224340108Everything he did to Chris was wrong but he made the right choice in killing him. Chris wasn't right for this world. He just caused pain. It wasn't totally his fault, he was born to this awful shit. But he was going to get his wife and child killed.
>>224338249Tony was right to do it in this case. Not morally or anything like that, but if he has to flex this shit to uphold his image. The Don of New Jersey doesn't get a speeding ticket. He had to be an example to the rest.
>>224340279Nobody knew about this. He didn't have to do anything. He could have just gotten it waived thanks to his connections. He's a spiteful bitch.
>>224339219That one scene with the old Jew therapist perfectly encapsulated Carmela's entire character.>tries to act like the unwilling victim of her unfaithful criminal husband>tries to use her faith to justify her not leaving Tony as he cheats on her nonstop>gets told straight to her face that she is at worst an accomplice to his crimes and at best an enabler>the only thing she can do is leave him, never accept a dime, keep the kids away from him, and urge him to turn himself in>does the complete opposite of that, goes back to Tony, takes even more of his money, and stops caring entirely On a first watch my retarded ass thought they tried to paint Carmella as a victim. Upon rewatch I realized how wrong I was. She was just a scummy mob wife, that's all she is, was, and will be.
>>224340198Didn't he even refuse to take her money because it was dirty money? Fucking ruthless
>>224337980that was the most based thing he did in the show
>>224340343It's a little of both. As the Don of Jersey, you're not supposed to deal with this shit at all. The cops are supposed to know not to fuck with you. This guy had a hard on for Tony, and Tony had a hard on back for him, with one being in a position to do way more damage than the other. Of course Tony is a spiteful fuck, too.
>>224337903the curb stomping not that Coco didn't deserve it,bit it's still the most violent form of aggression other than being set on fire. I'd much rather be smoked by gunshots for once than getting curb stomped
He had a shine lookong after his own mother.
>>224338485I think he had a change of heart about the cop since Meadows bicycle had just gotten stolen by an african-american. (Imagine that)
>>224340501That was based. He should have curb stomped that fucker AND lit him on fire.
>>224337903Borrowed money from Hesh and then bullied Hesh over it.
>>224340368Contrast her with Nicole, that wonderful woman
>>224340141>Tony makes some sincere efforts to change himselfall predicated on bullshit
>>224339567>He doesn't want to use whores because he likes picking up men who also like him.Yeah man that invitation to Finn after being caught wasn't supposed to be threatening or anything like that, sure dude.Your argument also fails because he was given slack about him being seen at a club and the car BJ with Finn telling them was the final straw.
>>224339152Ralphie was on a path of atonement Tony could never take; then when the stress and emotion levels rise in the kitchen he said the trigger word that first makes Tony pass out, then after Melfi, kill.
>>224339219>No growth through entire seriesDid you even watch the fucking show? She's in constant battle with herself, she hates her kids and turns that around too.
>>224337903killing christopher was pretty bad. he had been loyale to his capo
>>224340750Pretty well this.Chrissy was a fuckup junkie but his loyalty was beyond.
>>224338087he went because they couldnt find the source of his black outs. and melfi was a psychologist, which are just drug peddlers. an actual therapist or hypnotist would have been fine and his sessions never put the business in jeopardy so he at least knew not to speak unnecessarily
>>224338445>knowing the assignment >sniffing clean pantiesthe fuck?
>>224340750yeah Chrissy let tony kill his wife, he deserved to be killed by tony, and tony deserved to be dont stop beleivin
>>224340501It's not really bad if he deserved it. He fucked with the man's daughter. It was so bad Butchie didn't even seek any compensation for it afterwards. Coco deserved it, he got it, it ended right there.
>>224339219tony was retarded for not giving her little projects to keep her busy. half the issues with her would have been avoided if he let her out the house for more than hanging out with other mob wives. her failing wouldnt even matter. just use money meant to be laundered
>>224339792>when he finally looks at his watch and it's like 10:00that scene hits hard
>>224339792>>224341070Also interesting how it's the only scene in the show where we get to hear a character's inner monologue. and it's fucking Vito
>>224337903Fat
>>224337948you might be illiterate but he was basically saying the other guy didn't do what he did because of honor or loyalty, he was doing it because he knew he fucked up
>>224338087>ive never had panic attacks. I have no idea what i'm talking about.Yes, we can tell.
>>224341262Lmao genetic dead end
>>224338249Forgot about that bit. That was fucked up.
>>224338401This is a sopranos discussion. Nobody here watches shounen anime, dude.
>>224341319>>224338401I mean, that meme makes no fucking sense unless you watch whatever cartoon that is referencing.
>>224340601That scene where Carmine Jr. tells Tony about the dream he had about his father just wanting him to be happy, and his wife wanting him to stop hit Tony so hard. Carmine Jr. has an incredible life, got out, and has a wife that just wants to be with him. Tony knows his father would never tell him to leave the mafia and be happy, and Carmella would never push him away from what makes the most money.
>>224341329
>>224339219Agreed
>>224338087Those were good for him? The reason she quit on him was because he was using it to be a better/ more efficient sociothpath. Although she was a giant cunt about it, he was ready to move on from her and get the actual type of help he needed. But he made her pussy wet so she wouldn't let him go. >>224337903Taking advantage of civilian friends is really the only bad thing he did. He was an addict for taking advantage of people and was playing chess with them before they even realized a game was being played. For kills he did they all deserved it
>>224341239He was still saying he didn't give a shit about the "honor and loyalty" of his subordinates
>>224339219Every time me and my dad talk about the Sopranos, he makes sure to insist that Carmella is by far the most evil character and the source of everything that goes wrong for the characters.
>>224341658Carmella definitely didn't that deserve that title, she was a dumb cunt. But did not cause any real issues. The main catalyst for issues was an intense duel between Paulie being a petty retard and Chrissy being a junkie retard.
>>224339219it wasn't built with faulty material it just wasn't the material that the local HOA president was invested in.
>>224340813Psychologists can't prescribe drugs
>>224340488You are thinking of 1920s shit. By the 1990s/early 2000s you really don't want every traffic cop to be able to recognize you, unless of course you are a massive egotist.
>>224338087the only right answer
Not going ahead & putting A.J. in military school
>>224340864Exactly. Paulie isn’t an unapologetic perv he just wanted to know what fabric softener Chrissy & Adrianna use.
>>224341319Crissy probably watched some anime during his drug binges
>>224341932It's not about recognizing you by face. It's about recognizing what you are. Tony was trying to pull cards and drop names to give him the hint of who and what he is. The cop just either wasn't buying it, was legitimately ignorant of who he was, or was deliberately fucking with him knowing who he was. Either scenario Tony has to make an example of him.
>>224337903Acting like a bitch over paying Hesh back for the loan he took out
Tearing that steak recipe out of Melfie's magazine was very inconsiderate of him
>>224340368while that scene was very good for dressing down carmella for being a hypocritical accomplice it was wildly retarded from a "real" advice standpoint>dude just leave your entire life behind with your kids it's that easy, tony totally won't come after you or try to find you like maybe .5% of people would actually take that advice so it's a bit counterproductive if you want people to actually do something instead of get on the moral high horse
>>224342556It was impractical because of how big a hole she dug herself. She cultivated no skills to be independent, she had no work ethic, she didn't care about feeding herself or her children with blood money, and she knowingly and willingly dated, married, and bred with (x2) a member of organized crime. There is no "practical" or "real" advice. Of course Tony wouldn't turn himself in, but there's nothing she could do besides that. Also Tony wouldn't hurt her or the kids if she just up and left. These guys don't murder their ex wives and hunt down their children unless they're threatening to flip. That's why it was only practical to tell her to tell Tony to turn himself in. He didn't tell her to flip on him, not that she knew enough anyway. He just laid it out>You're with an unfaithful, sociopathic, murdering mafia boss. You've been an active accomplice or enabler of his horrible lifestyle for decades now. The only thing you can do to ever have any shot at redemption, or show any genuine remorse at being a part of this and feeding your children with blood money is to separate from him now and never accept a single cent of his money for you or your kids ever again. Anything short of this, shut the fuck up and live with it.
>>224342413He pulled a police benevolent fund card, the type they pass out to random rich guys and friends of friends. A guy who was thinking clearly would have just taken the ticket, paid it, and moved on. Tony makes it a whole thing and starts calling in favors.
>>224340249>Chris wasn't right for this world. He just caused pain.That's not how humans work. We have free will. He could have changed. He did change plenty. It was Tony who held him back and made him the worst version of himself he could be.
It could be a long list. the biggest move that exposed Tony as an actual piece of shit, when Janice was getting comfortable around Bobby's kids, where Tony decides to bring up Harpo, her son she lost to the streets of Montreal,really showed how he truly was Olivia's son. Feeling the need to drag his family and friends down into a deep, sad hole, making himself feel better by making the people around him feel worse
>>224341239>I don't understand how somebody mocking honor can appear like mocking honor
>>224342637>These guys don't murder their ex wives and hunt down their children unless they're threatening to flip.kids of course not but carm would absolutely be fair game. this is tony we're talking about a petty spiteful fuck you think he'd take being abandoned and losing contact with his kids well?and again like yeah it's impractical because of her own actions but if you're a therapist genuinely seeking to help her you'd give her an option somewhere between leave immediately with little chance for success or stay. like of course carmela would choose to stay when you put it like that kek.like I said initially it works really well as a tv scene because carmela is confronted with her hypocrisy in the open and we see her choice reflecting her character always choosing the easy path of comfort, but it's melfi tier bad therapy from a realistic perspective
>>224342881That whole scene was just Tony not wanting to accept people can change. Janice is trying to be more calm and less angry, whether it's a show or not is to be determined, and Tony just pokes and prods her thinking "this is bullshit, show me who you really are". Anyone improving themselves is a threat to a sociopath like Tony, because it means that change is possible, so if he's a piece of shit it's genuinely his fault. That's why he breaks down anyone trying to change. To reinforce the notion that people (he) can't.
>>224342909>but it's melfi tier bad therapy from a realistic perspectiveThe issue is this is Carmella's only option. She is too deep in this hole to take softball solutions or half measures. She needs to acknowledge her complicity in Tony's crimes and infidelity. The Jew therapist doesn't want her money, so he's not going to string her along with bullshit platitudes. "Do what's hard or stop bitching". That's it. Also since the kids are adults, Carmella can't control whether or not they see their father or accept his money. Not anymore. She can only control what she does. Tony wouldn't just fucking murder her for leaving him. Yes he's a petty, vindictive sociopath, but he didn't even lay a hand on her when he thought they were getting divorced.
>>224337903Him personally? Aside from ordering murders, extortion, theft, burglary, selling drugs and infidelity he never had the makings of a varsity athlete.
>>224342917>>224342917Accurate. I've heard a video on a break down on Tony's dream in the car with Ralph, who had a caterpillar on his head which changes into a moth/butterfly, representing personal growth/change in his character, reaffirming this from stories from Carmella telling that Ralph was making donations and repenting for his sins, trying to become a better person making right of the suffering of his son in the hospital.
>>224342999if I'm already complicit in taking blood money why don't I get him to pay for me learning skills I can use when I leave him in a year or take some of his money? a bit odd to cut off the money the moment I could actually use it for a positive end for once. the therapist would have her leave immediately without any planning presumably to leave for somewhere she's never known which is just doomed to fail. I don't think that was her only option but chase was channeling a very catholic morality into the moment>Also since the kids are adultsAJ was still technically a child at the time IIRC, and mind you as the post I originally replied to said the therapist was basically telling her to cut off her kids from tony so either you take him at face value, in which case that is the one thing tony would genuinely hurt carm over, or he's being unrealistic in his moral lecture. I know in getting stuck down in the realism weeds that the show hardly sticks to it in any other circumstance, but people tend to act like the dude was giving genuine good advice rather than terrible advice though it served as a useful dressing down of carmela in universe, she wasn't going to make a breakthrough just like virtually no one else in the show could
>>224342917janice is his red rag. and can we honestly having obviously digested the show that she wasn't a sociopath as much as any of them were? so, i mean, your 'take' or whatever is totally on point if this were a tony - civilian interaction or even fucking tony and bobby, he had more humanity than janice and he was still a full blown mobster.people do try to be more calm etc, but janice had to make a performance of it, and sit on the fence on whether she's pathological, that's what Tony attacked, whatever janice does, it must be a show. she wasn't earnest with her growth at all.
Did people pick up on signs of the last episode being a dream? I rewatched it recently and there's a lot of stuff that gives a lot of credibility to that theory
>>224343428I don’t think giving Carm realistic advice was even his goal. He clocked almost immediately how delusional and in denial she was and knew she was beyond saving
>>224343607Tony Soprano is the dream, he’s Kevin Finnerty
>>224338087I find it interesting how therapists being terrible is a theme on the show. They all fucking suck, even Melfi
>>224343607yep... the language of cinema shows it plain as day
>>224338321They are in fact. (Despite cops pretending otherwise.)Civilian refers to non-MILITARY, not non-law enforcement. Law enforcement are civilians.
>>224343528Tony, Janice and Meadow were all Livia's offspring.Tony hit the nail on the head when he told Janice, she was gonna do to Bobby what their mom did to their father. Slowly wearing him down,using their little influence to take control over him.Janice tried it with RIchie Aprille, to get her own brother killed and having him become boss.She was truly Olivia's daughter
>>224343608His whole scene is best thought of as a plot device, it pushes Carmela back from the brink back into the lifestyle, it lays her faults bare for the viewer that confronted with her complicity she'll choose to slink back to it over hardship, and it's Chase baring his feelings on therapy that we see especially borne out with the Tony/Melfi plotline. Much like law enforcement's incompetence in the Sopranos universe you chalk it up to the nature of the show rather than anything resembling realism.
>>224343695Police are civilians, except when the government tells them to shoot and arrest civs, which is what they would always do given the orders. You have to be severely underage or severely mentally retarded to consider the boys in blue as civilians
>>224343710>His whole scene is best thought of as a plot devicehow bout dathow bout dat
>>224343677that one jew who wouldn't take blood money was cool
>>224337903Probably killing Christopher. Yeah, yeah, you can say Christopher had it coming, but there's actually something fucked up about a surrogate dad who has failed his surrogate son and then wiping his hands clean of his own mistake.
>>224343985Wrong. Melfi's family councilor, during their group session, casually dropping a little fun fact how his uncle was part of a group closely related to Murder Incorporated responsible for dozens of murders
>>224340813Melfi was a psychiatrist, she went to med school
>>224338087NVCLEAR TRVTH NVKE
Ruining his childhood friend's life because the opportunity to wring him for everything he was worth just happened to show up in front of him
>>224344310He warned him multiple times to not get involved but he wouldn't listen, plus he stole 45 boxes of ziti out from under Tony during the game. It was all the T1000's fault.
>>224344310>degenerate gambler explicitly borrowed more than tony planned to let him, while secretly being in debt to richie already, and lost everything like a fuckupnah one of the few times in the series tony did nothing wrong. except with the car that was just retarded when meadow would know where it came from
>>224344310Davey brought that on himselfHe literally showed up at the game and begged Tony to just lend him 5 grand while he took 40 more when he was asleep and then when he can't pay him back he says with a smug smile "Im tapped". That guy deserved everything he got
>>224344310It's not even in the top 20 evil things Tony did throughout the show
>>224344353>>224344382>>224344418>>224344873Gamblers are the most persecuted race in society, 4 instant replies shitting on us
>>224337903Supporting Christopher, who was a good-for-nothing junkie fuckup, over his much more capable guys like Patsy and Sil
>>224344892I like playing poker and other gamesdegenerate gamblers like davey are disgraziata and deserve all they get
>>224344310>>224344382>being in debt to richie alreadyHis dept to Tony was all in large amount on borrowed money. At this point, he had already lost his sons college fund, which is maybe why he tried to get into the Executive game, trying to win it all back
>>224337903The point of no return for Tony was killing Blundetto
>>224344353Tony all but says later on that he could have stopped Richie if he wanted to but didn't because he wanted to fuck him over for his own personal gain.
>>224337903When he gave Fleech la Mana the cold shoulder and did petty shit like making fun of him when Fleech reminded him of the money he owed him.
>>224338087He went to therapy because he saw Melfi as a motherly figure he could relate with and talk freely on personal issues. In the first few seasons Melfi was actually pretty instrumental in providing Tony with good advice on subverting his uncle into becoming the boss of his New Jersey outfit. . Part of the reason Melfi kept Tony as a patient all those years, I think, was because she had her own Italian heritage she wasn't allowed to embrace or celebrate. Married to an ex-husband with Italians roots, who appeared to more embarrassed by the stereotypes, little pride in their heritage. Complete opposite of how Tony presented himself.
>>224345080he slipped
>>224337903How many of you anons think you could take Tony Soprano on in a fight?
>>224340108Chris couldn't be an average nobody. He only flips when he sees that guy living out of a car and realizes he could be the one eating egg noodles and ketchup while he gets to live the rest of his life as a shnook.
>>224337903he was fat
>>224345433season 1 or season 6? very different tony
>>224339854and yet you're the one with reading comprehension problemscurious!
>>224344310this guy 100% deserved what he got
>>224339977okay, now this is based
No one in the Sopranos is morally good except for one character and that's Nucci. Who, coincidentally, is the only character who consistently gets shit on.
>>224340108Agreed. The way he kills Chris is possibly the most chilling, he does it seemingly on a whim.
>>224340368>>224342556His advice was for Carmela to get Tony to read Crime & Punishment and turn himself in. This is someone who hasn't read a single classic novel in his life. It was absurd and that jew shrink was just a self-indulgent moralizer.
>>224343698>>224343528Janice was definitely as bad, but she was at least making progress with the anger management thing.Tony also fucked up AJ by sending him to be some fuckboy movie producer instead of joining the military and learning arabic to make a difference like he wanted to.
>>224345433tony always loses whenever he doesnt get the first punch so all you gotta do is get him first
>>224337948yeah, this was pretty bad, especially given it was his response to Carlo's praising of Bobby for still delivering his weekly envelope after getting concrete blasted into his eye by a bullet ricochet. his rude and petulant handling of his 100k debt to Hesh was pretty bad too. i'm pretty sure he was admonishing his guys for not being able to bring in as much money as Vito just because he was gambling it all away at that point.
>>224341239that's a very superficial reading of the line, given the ways concepts like honor and loyalty are used throughout the show.
>>224338087while i'm almost ashamed to say i admit to part of your sentiment, Tony started seeing a therapist because he was having panic attacks that were adversely affecting his life and he had no idea how to deal with them, why he was getting them, and how to stop them. what would you have done?
>>224346553>what would you have done?microdosed LSD
>>224339908Damn, he looks so comparatively thin in the first season.
>>224344310This doesn't even come close to the worst thing Tony's ever done. He warned him multiple times about what he was getting into. He even tried to protect him from Ritchie, as much as he reasonably could.
>>224345652>This is someone who hasn't read a single classic novel in his life.No offense, but Tony has an IQ of 136. It's been tested.
>>224337903killing ralph was a dick move
>>224346631Tony was definitely smart but it just gave him a kind of low cunning. He had basically no learning or wisdom
>>224346553yeah like if you're having legit blackout panic attacks that's a time to see a therapist. The issue with therapy exemplified in the show - leaving aside incompetence from therapists like the cunt handling Janice - is that you need to be willing to tackle the deep psychological hurdles that get raised. Tony's trouble time and again was his inability to fully face his demons. The climax being when Melfi finally explicitly outlines "hey your dad was a piece of shit who you've been idolizing for years when you shouldn't have and its a source of a lot of your issues" and he just completely shut down and went into denial and a nihilistic spiral that is season 6
>>224337903Beat his politician friend over a hoar he discarded
>>224346583The Scatino sporting goods bust out shows how ruthless they are in getting a return on their debts. How their entire social circle benefits from it. Free sneakers, fishing rods and ordering cases of Ramlosa mineral water, which gets moved trough Artie's restaurant, which he serves to Carmella and, ironically, Davey's wife, telling them he got a great deal on it.
>>224345484Chris was sympathetic to me up until then. He saw married with kids in an affordable car and thought he'd rather sign his girlfriend's execution than endure that fate. Everything after that he had coming.
>>224338087>Tony Soprano speech bubbleYou unironically need therapy as well, you fragile poser.
>>224337903Throw the gabagool sandwich to the trash bin
Tony became so worthless by the last season. Hope he died
>>224339219the tragedy of tony and carmela is that in the end she turned out to be the smart one
>>224337903allow his daughter to date a nigger, should have kicked her out and cut off all her credit cards
The way he treated Georgie at every chance
>>224337903Got too sentimental for his own good. Tony was smart, but the cost of his intelligence is greed and selfishness and worst is his sentimentality. He shouldn't have killed Ralphie over a fucking hoah and a horse.Nor should he have tolerated Vito's faggotry.
>>224338201This was it for me, along with him telling Carmela that her spec house would collapse and kill an innocent family in the same episode.
>>224337903Didn't murder Vito with a hammer as soon as he found it he was a cocksucker.
>>224337903Hard to say what was the worst thing, but the darkest one was definitely killing Chrissy, the way he did it and the way how he acted afterwards.
>>224339152wasn't that ralph's own hhorse
>>224346801I agree. Only a faggot would think Ralphie deserved to die over a fucking nag and a whooah. Tony lost control of his emotions like a woman. He brought shame to this thing of ours.
>>224337903Murder.
>>224346553lose weight and exercise if I were as fat as him for one.
>>224338249Tony killed like 10 people. Someone losing their job doesn't even make the top 10. But if we exclude murders then I would still say what he did to Georgie was worse than what he did to the cop. Georgie lost his job and vision in one eye
>>224337903making Bobby kill someone for the first time just because he was mad at him
>>224337903Making Chrissy his nr.2 in the crewEveryone in the crew knew it was plain nepotism because of Chris's ascociation with Tony and the legacy of his father.Any self respecting mob boss would have wacked Chrissy the moment he started talking about flipping for Hollywood, he was a liability from day 1 with his drug abuse and general lack of intelect (going back to the crime scene would be reason 2 to have him clipped) and his rise to power angered the guys in Jersey who were still working up but had good things going for them like Patsy.Hell come to think of it, Chrissy shouldnt have even been made, and his bitchfits he constantly threw about it in season 1 would be shot down immediately
>>224348570What was the point of this scene? It's almost like a dream.>>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_VcM16NfJCY
>>224340501This was actually one of the more justified of Tony's violent outbursts. It was poorly timed as New Jersey was already in conflict with Brooklyn. But the Shah of Iran began their cycle of using violence to settle disputes.I imagine if he made those comments to a daughter of any New York Boss or Capo, Coco would have lost more than his teeth
>>224348549Georgie and Sal Virtro were truly some of the biggest victims of the show
>>224340108A druggie is always bad for buisness. A druggie talks when they shouldn't. If tony didn't favor chris, he would have died a long time ago.
>>224337903he never had the makings of a varsity athleteonce I found this it my respect for him as a man fucking plumeted
>>224349024It blows my mind that the testimonies of opiate addicts are accepted by courts. A fiending junkie will fellate his own father for a fix. >Oh but they wouldn't commit perjury just because the prosecution gave them enough money to stay high for a year...
>>224349024is that why everyone mocked him and bullied him even harder when he went straight edge?
>>224345677>she was at least making progressin learning all the motions and mantras of therapy and performing them for her audience, yes.
>>224338321Civilian in this context just means person who isn't involved in organized crime
>>224345484its rather odd because in the first few episodes he threatened tony he'd flip and just sell his mob stories to movies and tv shows, i dont get how he'd get the idea he'd be some average schmoe.It would have made more sense if he flipped because he saw the guys kids, Adriana being barren was a big turning point for him in his relation
>>224346816>learning or wisdomunless those are counties or boroughs or something then i don't think NJ is home to them.
How about tha pricks face when he saw tha gatt
>>224349259because chrissy is sub normal>We're already in the 21st century, T.He had all these moves and pieces (delusional) in mind of how his route to screenplay and being a player in the movie biz would work out. None of them would or were going to work. And even a fool like chris can discern the difference between being on the back foot, in a compromised position, no resource, no plans, no stepping stones. nothing vs prudent planning. He'd have been above average materially through his predatory pathology but I doubt a warrantied camry is what he had in mind. Materialist empty headed beasts.
>>224340108You mean loyle?
>>224339152This is probably the best answer. Tony didn't care that Ralph's kid was in hospital and almost died (even though he feigned concern earlier at the Bing when Paulie said 'who gives a shit'). And Tony went through this really weird wannabe ownership of the horse.>collects money from Ralph when Pie O My wins>goes to visit horse when sick>gets a painting made of him and the horse>tells Hugh "did you hear about my horse?"Real crazy guy territory.
>>224345641He does it after seeing the child seat, knowing that if his daughter was with him she would have died.
Wanting to kill Furio.>Furio disappears>Carmella tells Tony she loves Furio>Tony wants Furio deadGuy did nothing wrong. If Tony confronted Furio he could have just said "Hey a'Tony I like a my girls my age"
>>224349428>He does it after seeing the child seat, knowing that if his daughter was with him she would have died.Tony was going to kill Chris no matter what. The child seat was him using it as a justification. At the wake he tells the movie director about the car seat.
>>224349413Towards the end of the series, Chase started to put it out there heavily Tony being a Sociopath
>>224349445He does it to enact disgust like "oh fuck that guy, what a monster, glad he died before his daughter got hurt" but he didn't get the reaction he was fishing for. He was looking for vindication.
>>224349413>Tony didn't care that Ralph's kidSame way Ralph didn't care about the whoah's kid?
>>224349436That whole plot was bad.
>>224349484>Same way Ralph didn't care about the whoah's kid?Good point, but Ralph would have wanted an abortion and I'm sure everyone in the crew paid for at least 1 abortion.
>>224349445Part of the reason for Tony to kill Chris could be because Chris was fucking the real estate agent Tony wanted to get with. I considered the reason Ralphie burned down Pie-O-My's stable right after Tony told him he was dating his Ex girlfriend Valentina
>>224339353this in response to a post talking about how he had gay oral sex in public
>>224340108Loyalty meant nothing to Tony in the end. I mean he was considering whacking Paulie too, based on, in modern parlance, "vibes".
>>224338087Yeah therapy is a joke. Just read Jung or M. Scott Peck's distillation of Jung in The Road Less Traveled.
>>224346513No it's not
>>224341502He wasn't though was he. It can be interpreted that way doesn't mean that was what he was saying
>>224349413>Real crazy guy territory.>This thing of ours? This thing of mine!
>>224342451Not just that but tanking his whole lifelong friendship with hesh over an ego trip
>>224343684Wait, was this during his coma phase? DId he predict his death? I swear I've never seen that scene
>>224344418THe game was rigged against him though, they made that clear in the show. They cheat the games to guarantee the house wins.
I FUKEN HAITI THIS GUY
>>224338087imagine writing all of this bullshit and you don't even know the actual reason why he went to therapy. sounds like you're the one that has issues
>>224350001>whole lifelong friendshipT is pathological. He has strategic partnerships. The facade of friendship feeds his ego (Attention).
Making fun of that Janice/Harpo thing, whateva happened there. Janice is an annoying piece of shit but as someone with a sister, there is something really dark about that.
>>224349927That's how everyone else in the room would've interpreted it, autist