Arthouse & ClassicsHermionedition>QotDMost /film/ic old broad?>BonusFavourite Gingold joint?>BonuserMost /film/ic female given name?Previous: >>224341093
Queen of /film/
>>224356449Fuck off, do you ever sleep?
>>224356476No.
>>224356495Great shot.
A is for AntonioniB is for BergmanC is for ChaplinD is for DreyerE is for EisensteinF is for FordG is for GodardH is for HawksI is for IchikawaJ is for JancsóK is for KeatonL is for LeoneM is for MalickN is for NaruseO is for OphülsP is for Powell & PressburgerQ is for QuaysR is for RayS is for ScolaT is for TarkovskyU is for UlmerV is for VertovW is for WellesX is for ???Y is for YangZ is for Zinnemann
>>224356495
>>224356449>>224356497Baused. Certainly the best ever use of having a 4chan pass
>>224356497It was a rhetorical question. I know you don't have a life
>>224356511>X is for ??Surely some chinese director?
>>224356555Lul!
>>224356580Fuck you!
>>224356495>>224356521https://youtu.be/RHFLJm7VXOwSome of the best dialogue in cinema. >Straight laced!
>>224356171 ..A condo.Have you ever lived in a condo or been in one? The view is decent if you’re visiting but living in a condo is a hell no.
>>224356511Don't know about B, D, F, T and S. Could be Bresson, Dumont, Fellini, Tourneur and Serra. Also, which of the Rays?
>>224356511One of the two “Xie”s
>>224356613Lal
Come on, keep posting the Cahiers lists please.
>>224356647>>224356511Muh europoo. There's more to cinema
>>224356647>Bresson, Dumont, Fellini, Tourneur and Serra>trying to be sneaky and insert a bum like noone notices
>>224356511>U is for UlmerBased.
>>224356674You haven't watched even two African films in your whole life
>>224356662
>>224356714what'd that homo Guiraudie have down
>>224356658Seriously, what is your problem dude? I expressed a valid complaint and now you take an honest man's opinion and instead of giving its respect whether you agree with it or not, you just joke? Do you take everything as a joke? Are you afraid of being serious for a moment? Very zoomer-code way of acting in life if you ask me.
>>224356723
>>224356674Anon literally has Japanese and even fucking American directors on his list. If anything, there's too few European directors on there.
>>224356511M is for MizoguchiO is for OzuR is for RivetteThank you!!!!!!!!!!!
>>224356638I live in one, but I was talking about the view.
>>224356754Yep, there's is more than 'murica and europoo. 2 asians, zero south american or africans is insane. Very narrow minded.
>>224356511L is for Lubitsch
>>224356751damn I'm clueless on most of these
>>224356778Give the L to this anon.
>>224356751The first movie doesn't exist. Never heard of it >>224356786
B is for Birkinfag, C is for Catunc, L is for Lloyd, the list goes on...
>>224356778Correct.
>>224356746holy lolzorz, like the caracs film
>>224356786How? Almodovar and Lynch are entry tier. Rocha is film school tier.
>>224356511Where are the women?????????
who tf is david lynch lol
>>224356844I've just never felt the desire to watch dudes named Pedro or Glauber
>>224356812Starring Delon, apparently. The beauty of these lists are the unknown pulls, in my opinion.
>>224356861A psuedo entry level director.
My Dinner With a Thick Femboy (2026)
Glauber Rocha had a short lived relationship with a /film/ waifu
>>224356867And I have it on my watchlist kek. I'm an idiot. Doesn't look that kino though
>>224356875Un suck est un suck.
>>224356861>>The references to David Lynch, I mean anytime you go to a family's house now it's David Lynch? I mean who the fuck is he, man? Who the fuck is he that he's the father of that genre? I own 6000 movies made before he made his first film, I mean who the fuck is he?
>>224356857Asking the important questions, THANKS. Akerman all the way, shits on antonioni on his own game too.
>>224356820Baufag(s) is the infinitely superior B
>>224356935That's Lloyd.
>>224356857Nowhere near any list of cinema greats, naturally
D is for Dingonation
DINGO NATION RISE!!!
>>224356957Shut up, incel
Nathan Fielder's long lost documentary feature Love and Cameras in America (2008) just got uploaded online.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJcSnpn8oMg
>>224356511Jakubisko for Jancsó
>>224356775>2 asiansI'm counting three.>zero south american or africans is insane.Not really. Africa and South American have a comparatively small insdustry, less of a filmmaking tradition, fewer good directors, fewer good actors and almost more importantly fewer experts on a multitude of technical skills. Particularly for Africa, you can count films that have decent production value on one hand or two.
>>224357014Right after you're six feet under, tranny
>>224356857A is for ACKermanC is for ChytilovaD is for DenisL is for LupinoM is for MayR is for RohrwacherS is for ShepitkoV is for VardaW is for Wertmuller
>>224356511Is Keaton really better than Kurosawa? Never cared to watch silent comedies
I thought this nigga said "right after you're six feet, tranny". Lookism!
>>224357082Yes.
>>224357060Edgy kid.
So far Carax and Serra are by far the best ones.
Speaking of edgy niggas, any of you fuck with Shining (the band).
>>224357129The saxofone black metal stuff?
>>224357081H is for Huillet
>>224356911Kek, based Gallo, the amount of stuff that gets called "lynchian" is insane.
>>224356786I hope you know all of these, though.
Have you noticed thatIII and Illaren't the same?Wild
>>224357145No, the progressive DSBM band.
Un après-midi de chien.
>>224357182A dog day afternoon?
>>224357171Oh, ok, you're talking about the swedish band, i was thinking of the norwegian band.
>>224357204An afternoon of dogs.
>>224357204Yeah.
>>224357050>They are bad cause they don't follow the europe traditions of cinema>muh actingI'd say that's part of the appeal. If I wanted to see a worse american then I would take a look at current korean garbage. No, when I put on a south american film I want to see they doing their own thing, asian hits different when they aren't trying to appeal to the western world. Same for africa. Why would you apply the same standards for different cultures that are coming from different backgrounds and influences? It's no surprise that the most revered asian filmmakers are the ones that catters the most to that same outdated canon.
>>224356511W for Wilder
>>224357211Yeah, I'm getting into their music, they got an interesting mix of boomer rock solos with progressive black metal parts, it's pretty interesting.
Slow thread.
>>224357050>I'm counting three.Four actually (Ray, a South Asian)
>>224357292Certainly that Ray is Nicholas.
IT'S A DOGGY DOG WORLD
Film for this feel?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjHtqH8QvXM
>>224357302It's clearly Man Ray.
>>224357332Why?
>>224357245>follow the europe traditionsKnowing how to light a scene properly, for example, is not a "tradition". It's a craft. Same for all the other aspects. And there's a correct way to do it. Not saying they can't experiment a bit. But, come on. If you celebrate incompetence, you might as well applaud Nolan and Villeneuve for their desatured shit.
>>224357370Bodied that freak
I hate rating movies with numbers, it's ruined the hobby for me>just stopI did, but I still compulsively rate them in my head
>>224357403Rate them with smiley faces instead.
>>224357403Men has always sought to organize and understand the world, it's as natural as breathing and walking upright.
>>224357433Apollonian ahh nigga.
>>224357370Sure, there is bad/failure filmmaking everywhere. When did I say otherwise? Not every film is trying to be the same thing, they should be met on their own terms, not by some standard set mostly by white europeans and americans on what's "good" and "bad". >>224357397You can only cheer others because you lack a brain to argue. Many such cases. Sad!
>>224357472>freak keeps the seething goinghaha
>buzzwords buzzword buzzwordThat'll teach him [giggling nervously]
>unironically going with le evil whitey stuff/film/...
nigghas getting smoked itt
>>224357472>they should be met on their own terms,What do you mean by that? If this is about having lower budgets, sure, that should be factored in. But that's not the main factor why most of their films look utterly unrefined. The problem is that they're approaching filmmaking like film students approach a mid-semester project: Calling their friends together to help them out rather than trying to find people with talent or experience.And, yeah, sure, that isn't as easy if you don't have the infrastructure for it. But they need to find a way to start doing that if they want to be taken seriously.
he's lowkey literally me
Andrew Garfield is fagging it up at levels never seen before.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufeJbTNq-BI
>don't you DARE say something that goes against the MOB ever again or you'll be meet with....... buzzwords!Silly me, hah.
>>224357619Based for choosing Coutinho and not the usual suspects.
>2+2 is 4AHHHHHH THE MOB, THE MOB IS PERSECUTING ME
>>224357615lal
>>224357615>>224357631What mob?
>>224357630Him choosing Coutinho (and specially Cabra) is the most obvious thing ever, as a Brazilian, a film critic and a huge leftist.
>>224357650not the best saBBAth album, stilll pretty good
>>224357660At least it's not Glauber.
>>224357464What does Purple Rain have to do with anything
Name one portuguese director worth it that is not JCM.
I'm done. I am done apologizing. I am done being persecuted for my strength. You people should be thanking Christ that I am who and what I am, because you need me. You need me to save you. You do. I am the only one who possibly can. You're not the real heroes. I'm the real hero. I'm the real hero.
>>224357693Costa.
>>224356857>>224357081N is for Nanako
Honor de cavalleria.
Humor de cachaçaria.
>>224357779You mean T.
>>224357779Tanaka?
>>224357779C(hika Araki) is for Nanako
>>224357698You’re nothing but someone from a place where everyone is unintelligent.
>>224357847Brazil?
A costarican shack made of bamboo.
>>224357847>>224357883You're a funneh nigga, das fo sho.I'm stronger, I'm smarter, I'm better! I AM BETTER! I am stronger than man, stronger than machine, I... I am an idea.
I feed the chicken.
>>224356511E is for Erice
I shine the charol shoes.
>>224357925I eat the egg.
>>224357693Reis & Cordeiro, Gomes, Sapinho>>224357808heh
heh
>>224357960Non-hack please.
Lh, talk, I wanna laugh.
>>224357997heh
>>224357997>anyone I don't like is a hackebin
man who was only watched My Darling Clementine: this shot recalls My Darling Clementine
>>224356603With Disney it would be statpadding, but Looney Tunes were a machine of kino, specially with Avery, Tashlin and peak Jones.
>>224358064You'd have to pay me to endure a reis cordeiro snoozefest.
Can anyone supply me with a link for T-Men (1947)?
Frfr, if u dont fw loony tunes ur a gay
>>224358107Okay. Here's 500 centavos.
>>224358137Ask harperfag
>>224358005Funny guy huh
Harperfag, can you supply me with a link for T-Men (1947)?
>>224356445>Favourite Gingold joint?Gigi is hard to beat but my personal favorite of hers is The Music Man. Balzac! Honorable mention: Bell Book and Candle. Pic: Sorry I don't have any caps of the Balzac moment so here's a nice shot of Marian the (eminently fuckable) Librarian.
Let it be know that everyone saying heh, huh, hah, lal all of a sudden (yeah, sure) are immature individuals, playing the same unfunny joke like a little child.
>>2243584238==========D
>>224358453And that goes right into your mouth's direction. You see? I can also play this stupid game. It's not hard, just childish.
>>224358468Oh yeah, talk dirty, engorge that bussy
>>224358468That was such a sick burn bro loooooooool.I. hehe xd
>>224358468you cornball.
>>224358137>>224358394https://archive.org/details/t-men-1947-restored-movie-720p-hd
Werzog deserve way more respect than what he gets around these parts.
I literally shat my pants. What does this mean? I'm highly autistic and I don't think it means what I think it means?
>>224358639True. Still it might be better to not have the respect of (many) of the people who post here
He's not all that
>>224358698Time to hurry up the rope
>>224358639yea, he doesn't give off mother vibes.
>>224358790The greatest German director after Murnau
>>224358805This is something I read on Twitter and letterboxd more than a few times. I'm not going to hang myself for not understanding some basic (I think?) knowledge.
lol lmao even
>>224358698It's like that Talking Heads song.Living in a shat don't shat in a grand automovile
How were you guys when you were 15? What was your favorite movie?
>>22435900315 was awesome iykwim
>>224359051No, I don't know what you mean, because I've had a tough life for as long as I can remember.
>>224359003Gone With The Wind, Moulin Rouge, Casablanca, Laura, The Graduate, Vertigo, U Turn, etc. By 15 I was already heavily into films.More than double that time later, I still like most of these, but none is a top favorite anymore.
>>224359003The Fly (1986)Fun fact: Ingmar had it in his personal collection.
>>224359097Why don't you name some of those you liked but now are embarrassed. You can't fool us
>>224359091You don’t need to say this every general
>>224359162This is my first time.
>>224359184First time this general, yeah.
>>224359204heh
Thoughts on my top films from each year in the 1970s, guys? :-) I finally found a good one from 1970 so I can finally make this list. It's my 29th birthday today BTW ^_^1970- Five Easy Pieces (dir. Bob Rafelson)1971- Throw Away Your Books, Rally in the Streets (dir. Shuji Terayama)1972- Deliverance (dir. John Boorman)1973- The Holy Mountain (dir. Alejandro Jodorowsky)1974- Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia (dir. Sam Peckinpah)1975- One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (dir. Miloš Forman)1976- Taxi Driver (dir. Martin Scorsese)1977- 3 Women (dir. Robert Altman)1978- In a Year with 13 Moons (dir. Rainer Werner Fassbinder)1979- Scum (dir. Alan Clarke)
>>224359218Fuck you
>>224359232lul
>>224359225heh
>>224359225Cool. Two masterpieces there, 71 and 73
>>224358416>Music Man>MarianBased taste.
>>224359225Happy birthday, anon.
>>224359232You are not me? Is this some sort of sick joke? You are all a bunch of sad bullies, really. I said enough and had enough.
>>224359225Happy birthday anon, I'll refrain myself for today.
>>224359051Why? My faves were Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Suspiria and Halloween.At that time I was getting to know my first gf, she was an italian exchange student, she gave me my first blowjob while I was sitting on a rock in a park.>>224359097Casablanca is still a banger... I think I started getting into movies when my mom bought some Welles classics on DVD when I was 14, the first film that really rocked my shit was The Third Man.Though now that I think of it, renting VHS tapes and DVDs as a kid probably set me on that path. I watched many horror classics because of the nerdy fat dude that worked there.
>>224359225>Terayama green
>>224359225Scum mogs the rest of the (very good) scum you posted.
for me>for meit's1970 Adelheid (Vlacil)1971 Walkabout (Roeg)1972 Brother Sun, Sister Moon (Zeffirelli)1973 Amarcord (Fellini)1974 Lancelot du lac (Bresson)1975 Zerkalo (Tarkovsky)1976 The Killing of a Chinese Bookie (Cassavetes)1977 The American Friend (Wenders)1978 Perceval (Rohmer)1979 Vengeance is Mine (Imamura)
>>224359584heh
Kino
Shout out Daffy Duck, shout out Bugs, Lola (my balls...), and MJ
>>224359390?
>>224359584>1978 Perceval (Rohmer)>1979 Vengeance is Mine (Imamura)Very nice, anon, very nice.
>>224359638>Shout out Daffy DuckDuck Amuck is high level brechtian kino.
>>224359003Heaven's Gate.
>>224359669Duck Dodgers is where it's at. The animation was ahead of its time.
>>224359638Daffy Duck is committed to a long term psychiatric care facility like Chinatown because he went insane due to being on of the Acme test subjects
>>224359695Sad! He also helped in defeating Hitler, he's a veteran.
>>224359626Indeed, enjoyed bigly
>>224359639Are you dense? Seriously stop.
I can't tell if these niggas are on some high level trolling or legitimately getting trolled
>>224359225Happy birthday and neat list (esp. Alfredo Garcia)!For me1970 - Peau d'âne (Demy)1971 - A New Leaf (May)1972 - Aguirre, The Wrath of God (Herzog)1973 - F For Fake (Welles)1974 - Edvard Munch (Watkins)1975 - Love and Death (Allen)1976 - That’s Entertainment, Part II (Kelly)1977 - House (Obayashi)1978 - Gates of Heaven (Morris)1979 - Dirty Ho (Lau)
>>224359801I don't know if people actually think Gummo is good or if they're just sheltered suburbanite breeders.
>>224360170heh
>>224360174It's actually good, great even, goated, even.
>>224360179It is quite a mirthful list, yes.
>>224360197Mirthful with notes of documentary and /wacky/.
Louis Jourdan > Alain Delon
>>224360179Stop that
>>224360197>mirthfulDid your Letterboxd friends teach you this word?
>>224360306Bro likes to spam his emotes, it's a tism thing.
>>224360306Are you new here?
>>224360362Let him cook, this mirth shit is gay.
>>224360387It is a /film/ic institution.
>>224360197>>224360232stop spamming your emotes!
>>224360392Many would say it's gay as fuck, thoughbeit.
>>224360392Where do you think you are?
>>224360387Mirthful is an adjective that means full of, expressing, or producing laughter, joy, and merriment
>>224360442/film/
>>224360463Gay!
one of the good ones
>>224360489heh
Find a worse popular review section on a /film/ https://letterboxd.com/film/breathless/reviews/by/activity/
>>224360571Life lessons from Jean-Luc Godard: It's ok to hate women as long as you’re French.
>>224360658I am French then
>>224358139True, I'm straight as an arrow and I want Bugs Bunny in Marilyn Monroe drag to fuck me in the ass. Then I want him to take off the Marilyn Monroe drag and force me to wear it 24/7 and make me his "girlfriend" and fuck me in the ass daily.
>>224360571what the hell is wrong with women
>>224361179Realest shit ever said.
>>224361179Kek, i remember you.
>>224361276No you don't.
REMEMBER YESTERDAYLOVE LETTERS IN THE SANDI REMEMBER YOUuuuuu
>>224356445>Favourite Gingold jointIn truth it's hard to keep up with you. I have no idea who Gingold and there is simply no keeping up at a reasonable pace. I'm trying to understand what the thread does but there are so many motherfucking films to see and directors to watch. Slow down you cunts.
>>224361871heh
>>224361871https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hermione_Gingold
>>224361871Just pretend you know everything like the others do
>>224362058heh
>>224361364Yeah, i do, you've talked about this before, and almost word for word.
loleposting really broke that one anon's mind, didn't it?
>>224362085And what are you going to do about it?
>>224362136Nothing, why would i do anything about it? It doesn't bother me at all that you want to be fucked by Bugs Bunny but it's not like i can help it happen, so how can i do anything about it?
>>224362085I did in other threads. Did I talk about this ITT too? I don't recall. Early onset dementia maybe.
>>224362219Yes, and i mentioned Crumb being attracted to Bugs Bunny too and asked if you had seen the doc about him.
I feel a bit suicidal, what should I watch?
>>224359314Marian the Librarian is a fun musical number but I think my favorite scene in that film is when she meets him at the soda counter and lets him buy her drink. Sweet.
>>224362299
>>224362299I'm Thinking of Ending ThingsLilya 4-EverNaked
>>224362299The Brown BunnySonatineStroszek
Watch Toxic (2024)It's Gummo with girls!
I don't like watching films about bullying
>>224362654Name one single film that isn't about bullying.
>>2243627303 Bad Men
>watched chungking express 5 years ago>didn't think i enjoyed it>has never left my mind and regularly think about itwhat the fug
>>224362754Literally everyone in that one bullies everyone else: Some gangsters bully the lead girl and her father, the sheriff bullies the one guy's sister and practically the whole town, and then the three bad men bully the sheriff and his men.
>>224356511Antionioni is a borinng retard (great visuals though), swap him out with Altman
>>224362730Come to think of it films are based around bullying. Someone tries living their life their way and there's always some wanker making them feel bad one way or another. Tokyo Story has generational bullying. Freddy Got Fingered has generational bullying. Au hasard Balthazar has animal (and dame) bullying. The list goes on
>>224362730Bully 2011
>>224362840>Antionioni is a borinng retardThis is not /movies/ is it
>>224362809>Literally everyone in that one bullies everyone elseThat doesn't mean that it's about bullying.
>>224362878It absolutely does.
>>224356511T is for Torneur mothafocka
>>224362880No it doesn't (by that line of thinking any film could plausibly be said to be about anything that takes place in it). And what's more, you're deliberately using "bullying" in a wider (and essentially trivial) sense than is usually understood to make your point.
>>224362798The cream rises to the top
>>224362872I decided to watch "The Passenger" one day because I love Jack Nicholson and I had never seen an Antonioni film....the premise sounds like an action film, but it's the exact opposite...it's TWO HOURS of Jack Nicholson just going from place to place, waling around, doindg...things, and then leaving. Rinse and repeat, until (spoilers) he dies in the end. I thought it was going to be Antonioni's take on Pirandello's "Il fu Mattia Pascal" (the premise sounds very similar) but it's just a big bundle of....nothing, nothing fucking happens in this film!But I decided to give him another chance and I watched "L'avventura"....to really sum it up (because there's a lot to say about it), terrific visuals (besu use of the 1,85:1 ratio that I've ever seen), but again, brealy anything fucking happens in the film. It's intriguing enough until the girl goes missing, then it becomes this monolithic portrayal of a failing relationship, but nothing ever happens to make us understand what the characters are going through, it's like we're supposed to read their minds or something.His films are pretentious slogs where barely anything happens. I may give him a THIRD chance and watch "L'eclisse" or whatever it's called just because Alain Delon is in it, but I already know it's going to be slower than a sloth taking a shit. andf not a whole lot is going to happen in it.
>>224362942All films are people going to places and doing things
>>224362917The whole film's plot relies on those instances of bullying, anon. Without them, nothing happens at all. It's not just something that happens on the side. So, yes, it absoultely is about those conflicts, i.e. bullying.>deliberately using "bullying" in a wider (and essentially trivial) sense than is usually understood to make your point.Wikipedia: "Bullying is the use of force, aggression, coercion, hurtful teasing, comments, or threats, in order to abuse, dominate, or intimidate one or more others."Oxford Learner's Dictionaries: "the use of strength or power to frighten or hurt weaker people"Merriam Webster: "abuse and mistreatment of someone vulnerable by someone stronger, more powerful, etc. : the actions and behavior of a bully"Everything I described is covered by these definitions.
>>224362942In all these moments you say nothing was happening, everything was happening. The art, the beauty, the style, the vision, what makes cinema worthwhile rather than plot points.L'Avventura, specially, is a masterpiece
>>224362951But they have to be interesting things, not going to Paris, looking around, walking around, collecting an item and leaving in a scene that could last a minute that ends up going on for at least 10.I mean, I get what he's going for, he's trying to show us that "liminal space" between emotional states, like in "L'avventura", and he's trying to be artsy about it by having it be really slow and quiet, but it's like he went overboard and just made it dull. He's like one of those directors people pretend to lik so that they don't get shunned by the film-enthusiast community or whatever.
>>224362972wait until you watch Tsaislop>3 hours of LITERALLY walking around
>>224362967Well, you may be okay with just staring at a pretty shot for 2 hours...I'm not like that, I need something to be going on in the story or it's hard for me to get invested.And I love me a slow burner film, even a really slow one like a Yasujiro Ozu film, but even he had a lot more going on than Antonioni ever did. Things actually happen in his films.I loved the style, it was a very beautiful film to look at, but like I've said, you need SOME SORT of cue to make you understand what character are going through on an emotional level because last time I checked I wasn't a mind-reader. Monica Vitti just looking pensive and sad while just sitting there is not enough. even the very sophisticated technical aspects of the film become trite after a while.
>>224362956>So, yes, it absoultely is about those conflicts, i.e. bullying.No, it merely depicts them.>Everything I described is covered by these definitionsYou're omitting the context in which the various acts that could be so described took place. If you speak of say, an actual mugging as an act of bullying you will rightly be accused of being obtuse and/or pedantic.
>>224362984I don't even know who that is lmao. I hate pretentious bullshit so I stay away from most arthouse cinema.
>>224363024>I don't even know who that isEpic, that's the kind of quality people the /film/ general needs
>>224363024
>>224363090Good night, /film/.(i will be asleep before this webm is over)
>>224363023>it merely depicts them.It depicts them as major plot points without which the whole plot would collapse. They are pivotal.This is not the same as just depicting something in the background, in which case you can argue that it's not what the story is about. I.e. Star Wars is not about making cantina music, even though cantina music is depicted, but Star Wars is absolutely about a farmboy finding a secret message in a robot's memory (and about several instances of bullying).>You're omitting the contextSo do all definitions of the term. And, yes, an actual mugging includes an act of bullying.
>>224363087I KNEW someone was going to say this! Sorry for not knowing every filmmaker who ever lived, Anon.
>>224363090...okay, this might be worse than Antonioni LMAOAnd with a tenth of the budget, too. I'm not so sorry I've been missing out on such masterpieces. No offense but some people really need to get a real job.
>>224363241>It depicts them as major plot points without which the whole plot would collapse. They are pivotal.They are not pivotal under the description of bullying. And they themselves are dependent on context.>Star Wars is absolutely about a farmboy finding a secret message in a robot's memoryThis is a decent pithy description of the plot of Star Wars: note that even if this restricted sense of being about that the mention of bullying is parenthetical and that you've provided no such equivalent for 3 Bad Men.>So do all definitions of the termAnd therein lies the problem with abuse of definitions. Note that your first definition from Wikipedia is quickly followed by a qualification about "social power" being required to distinguish bullying from mere conflict. And note also that in spite of having a section on military bullying, war is not mentioned on the page once.
>>224363338Honestly, it doesn't seem you're actually interested to explore cinema beyond what you're already familiar with. This notion >>224362972 that people could only praise or enjoy names like Antonioni or Tsai by pretending is pure philistinism.Not a crime to be into movies only for storytelling, but there's way more to the medium.
>>224363340>They are not pivotal under the description of bullying.They are pivotal as plot points. And they are instances of bullying according to all commoin definitions of the term.>And they themselves are dependent on context.What context? There's nothing about the context that makes bullying not-bullying.>description of the plot of Star WarsIt's not a description of the plot as a whole at all, it's naming one singular plotpoint, ergo one of several things that the plot of Star Wars is about.>the mention of bullying is parenthetical The mention of bullying is not about the farmboy finding the message at all. It refers to many other events: Vader bullying his daughter, Javas bullying robots, Alec Guinness bullying sand people, Vader bullying generals, Van Helsing bullying Vader's daughter, Vader bullying Obi-Wan, the farmboy bullying the Death Star, just to name a few.>you've provided no such equivalent for 3 Bad Men.I literally gave you three major instances of bullying in its plot.>abuse of definitionsBullshit.>your first definition from Wikipedia is quickly followed by a qualification about "social power" being requiredFalse. Wikipedia says "One essential prerequisite is the perception (by the bully or by others) that an imbalance of physical or social power exists or is currently present.". So not only is it not an actual power difference that is needed - the mere perception one does suffice. But said difference also does not need to be one of social power (as absolutely it is in the sheriff's case, by the way), it could also be one of physical power or force, i.e. having weapons when the ones being bullied do not. Are you intentionally omitting everything that does not fit your argument and therefore being intellectually dishonest, or are you simply too stupid to understand simple sentences, which would mean you're intellectually challenged?Mind you, I wouldn't accuse you of dishonesty if you hadn't just accused me first for no reason.
>>224363338>might be
>>224363389>Honestly, it doesn't seem you're actually interested to explore cinema beyond what you're already familiar with.I've seen all sorts of films. Whether I LIKED them or not is a different story.>people could only praise or enjoy names like Antonioni or Tsai by pretending is pure philistinismFirst of all Antonioni and this Tsai guy who just walks around the city at a snail's pace are on a completely different level. Second, of course there are people who enjoy watching a guy walk around for an hour, but there's also people who enjoy things like "Wavelength" or those Andy Warhol experimental films, which are the film equivalent of taping a banana to a wall. Is that really quality "art"?>but there's way more to the medium.I still have to find a filmmaker who'd be able to prove that to me, to be honest.
>>224363405>What context? There's nothing about the context that makes bullying not-bullyingHow about you read a brief synopsis or two of the film the get an idea as to how some of the acts could be otherwise and more properly described.>False.My mistake. Doesn't change the crux of the argument though.>Are you intentionally omitting everything that does not fit your argument and therefore being intellectually dishonestNo, I'm taking issue with you stretching the word "bullying" to breaking point to fit the Procrustean bed for your point that naming a single film that isn't about bullying is some kind of feat. I think that it's a bit rich to accuse me of intellectual dishonesty when your response to this line is a combination of ignoring it and simply saying "bullshit" and begging the question in favour of definitions. And I made no accusation of dishonesty; I merely noted some things from your own source that I take to militate against the point you're making. Whether it was carelessness, dishonesty or something else I neither said outright nor implied.
>>224363494>how some of the acts could be otherwise and more properly described.It doesn't matter how they could be described. There are infinitely many different ways of describing any event. Thousands of people attending a Madonna concert could be described as: A gathering, a party, a music listening event, a convention of Madonna fans, a noise hazard for the neighbourhood, a money-printing mechanism for the music industry, and on and on. All of those are legitimate, becuase they are accurate descripitions according to the definition of all those things.That you might not like one as much as another does not invalidate it.>Doesn't change the crux of the argument though.It does, because it shows that your whole argument is built on assumptions of additional restrictions that are not actually substantial to the definiton that we're supposed to use here.>you stretching the word "bullying" to breaking point Once again, I'm stretching nothing. I'm taking the very basic definiton and applying it. While you try to artificially limit that definition to very specific cases, mostly based on what you call "context". I.e. the same event taking place on a farm in 19th century America should be treated differently than when it takes place in a school in the 21st century. But that neither makes sense, nor is it supported by any reasonable definiton of the term.
>>224363621>>224363494I love this sort of long-form argument, let me chin-check you two real quick. What are your thoughts on Metropolis the movie, old and new?
>>224363621>It doesn't matter how they could be described.>All of those are legitimate, becuase they are accurate descripitions according to the definition of all those things. That you might not like one as much as another does not invalidate it.Truth is not the only norm governing communication. You're violating Grice's maxims to engage in some "Erm, Die Hard is a Christmas movie full of featherless bipeds" sophistry. We both know that if you yourself were interested in recommendations for "films about bullying" as that phrase would typically be understood, you would almost certainly be unimpressed by 3 Bad Men and Star Wars being given regardless of how creative the pitch for them was.>It doesNo, the point is that in spite of you accusing me of doing this, you're the one arbitrarily restricting the authority of language to suit your point. Why is war not mentioned in the encyclopedia page under the military bullying heading or at all despite many if not most wars fitting the definition given? Do you think that the lexicographers think that the have the authority over communication that you're ascribing to them to overrule the common man who will rightly accuse you of obtuseness and pedantry for speaking of mugging as "including an act of bullying (what is the difference between including and being here?)?
>>224363692The "old" one is great. Visually, as well as its themes.Also, a lot of socio-structural buillying in that one.Not sure what you mean by "new". I think there's an anime based on Lang's film to an extent, but I haven't seen that one.>>224363753>Truth is not the only norm governing communication.No, but it's what ultimately matters.>You're violating Grice's maximsSays literally the guy who dismissed every initial point I made by applying artificially narrowed definitions.>if you yourself were interested in recommendations for "films about bullying" as that phrase would typically be understoodI'll give you one thing here: There are certainly films that are more about bullying than others, revolve around it more, have more focus on it. But that doesn't mean that those that only include it to a lesser extent aren't about it at all. It's all a sliding scale. And of course, if someone asked you for a recommendation regarding one particular topic, you'd try to find something that makes that topic stand out significantly more, compared to those others. This is not what we were doing though, is it?>you're the one arbitrarily restricting the authority of language to suit your point. I did not restrict any definitons. In fact, you earlier accused me of widening the definitions, which I have demonstrated to be false.>Why is war not mentioned in the encyclopedia page under the military bullyingBecause wikipedia articles do not claim to be extensive on their subject. In fact, go to any of their discussion pages for longer articles, and you'll see that they intentionally exclude facts and examples for the sake of brevity if they don't consider them remarkable enough. Go to Donald Trump's page, for example, and you'll see that almost all arguments they have are about whether something that guy did or said is relevant enough long-term to be included in the already massive article. Same thing here. You can't give ALL examples for bullying.
>>224363861>No, but it's what ultimately mattersNot at all true and especially misguided when speaking of art. And this is all a moot point anyway because your "truth" is just "this is how the word's been defined" with no concern for stress testing the definition, considered whether bullying is an essentially contested concept, etc. >Says literally the guy who dismissed every initial point I made by applying artificially narrowed definitionsI've not applied a single definition! My whole point is that looking to definitions in isolation is a mistake!>I'll give you one thing here: There are certainly films that are more about bullying than others, revolve around it more, have more focus on it. But that doesn't mean that those that only include it to a lesser extent aren't about it at all.On the thematic understanding of "being about" I'd argue that bullying has essentially no salience (there is no real dwelling on or interrogation of bullying as a concept): to mention bullying alongside redemption, mercy, camaraderie, sacrifice, etc. is simply willful perversity. Even restricting it to the plot understanding, you basically run into the problem of triviality right away (is it not the case that every film is ultimately about communication (especially films about bullying)? Is it not the case that Star Wars is ultimately about makingcantina music a little bit?)>I did not restrict any definitonsI didn't accuse you of restricting definitions, I accused you of restricting the authority of language (focusing on definitions to the exclusion of everything else).>if they don't consider them remarkable enoughAnd why would it be that they'd not consider war to be remarkable enough for inclusion in an encyclopedia entry? Could it perhaps be that Grice's maxims are at play?
>>224364078>Not at all trueImagine actually trying to argue "truth does not matter" in this day and age.>misguided when speaking of artYou think art is about believing in lies?>no concern for stress testing the definitionBecause that's not what we're here for. We are having a discussion about films and what they are about. That means we should use words as they are defined to facilitate mutual understanding. Not bend them until they break and we cannot communicate anymore at all because everyone just uses words randomly according to his private definitions.>I've not applied a single definition! Of course you have. The thing is that the definition you applied is way too narrow, made up on the spot and not commonly accepted.>(there is no real dwelling on or interrogation of bullying as a concept)True, but that's only how you evaluate abstract themes, not plot points. What happens in the plot is also what a film is about, trivially, and there plot points rarely ever get questioned that way. Accepting this argument of yours would mean that you cannot say that Schindler's List was about the holocaust, because the holocaust never was examined critically from different viewpoints or interrogated. It just happened, while the thematic focus was on doing the right thing while being caught in a corrupt system. Again, you choose too narrow a definiton of what "being about" means by only focusing on one aspect (themes) and neglecting another (plot).>is it not the case that every film is ultimately about communicationYes. That is an argument you can make. Just like every film is about conflict. Which in a plot driven by characters usually involves a party pressuring anyother party by means of force or coercion, i.e. bullying. That was my whole point from the beginning: If you want to avoid bullying/conflict, you have to avoid traditional storytelling altogether.>restricting the authority of languageThere is no such thing as "authority of language".
>>224364078>And why would it be that they'd not consider war to be remarkable enough for inclusion in an encyclopedia entry?Because war has its own elaborate article already, mostly. Better to list things that do not.War is also not the most prevalent example of bullying in most people's lives, as it is bullying between states and armies, not between individuals. There is a point to be made that small things that happen thousands of times every single day in the lived experience of people are more noteworthy than large things going on on in international politics, which certainly affect people, but not with their insight.But why don't you go to the "bullying" discussion and ask them why they don't include war as an example, when the definiton does very much apply to it? Granted, I don't think they'll give you much of an answer other than "if we included everything that the definiton applies to, the article would explode in size".
bot vs. bot
>>224364303Indubitably
>>224356449cringe
>>224362299please kill yourself already so we don't have to read your blog anymore.
>>224364241>Imagine actually trying to argue "truth does not matter" in this day and age.Never said or implied such a thing. If anything, I did the opposite in challenging your not explicitly justified insistence on definitions.>You think art is about believing in lies?I don't think that art is fundamentally about belief at all.>Not bend them until they break and we cannot communicate anymore at allThat's what you're doing! You're saying "common usage and context be damned! All hail the lexicographers!" about one word to argue your point. Does the special artistic use(s) of "about" not trouble you here? Does that not have even more bearing on settling this question?>Of course you haveWhere?>Accepting this argument of yours would mean that you cannot say that Schindler's List was about the holocaustI'm not stipulating that only one use of about is the correct one here. Both senses are fine, but the propriety of saying "X is about bullying" can differ depending on which sense you're talking about.>Yes. That is an argument you can make.But should one make it? Why?>There is no such thing as "authority of language"The on what basis do you object to my supposedly narrow and arbitrary secret definition(s)?>>224364287So, truth is indeed not the only norm governing communication just like I said.>There is a point to be made that small things that happen thousands of times every single day in the lived experience of people are more noteworthy than large things going on on in international politicsThe point that war is more noteworthy than other kinds of bullying due to its far greater destructiveness could also be made. Whether one should do that is of course another question.
>>224364303Very based
Does Virginie Ledoyen have a kino filmography?She is so pleasing to look at
>>224364536she was in MILF (2018).
>>224364610She was in that?!So she's still hot
>>224364303But how did they pass the captchas?
>>224364718Frankly that might be the easiest thing to do nowadays
>>224364724Then what purpose do they serve?
What does /film/ drink? Cheers from the johnny walker blue label
>>224364740humiliation ritual!
>>224364751Kirin Ichiban most of the time and Maisel's Weisse on special occasions.
>>224364476>>224364241Please continue, I enjoy the sport
>>224364751Coke and water. No alcohol, too expensive and bad for my stomach
>>224363087You and the guy both give a certain reputation to the general that's certain
>>224364476>Never said or implied such a thing.Me: "Truth is what ultimately matters" - You: "Not true at all".Really, anon?>That's what you're doing! Listen, fucktard. You're getting seriously on my nerves here with your "no u" spouting.When I insist on using words how they are commonly understood in accordance with common definitions, and you insist on "muh context" and "doesn't apply" and "muh examples" to limit those words to whatever restrictive meaning you need to maintain your nonsensical disagreement ... it's certainly NOT me who's bending words. If you want to continue this embarrassing display of bullshittery, I will henceforth ignore you.>Where?What the fuck do you think your "bullying is pressuring someone, but ONLY with a disbalance in social power" was? You're applying very narraow definitions all the time here. Again, you're being a dishonest arsehole.>Both senses are fineYet you insist on dismissing one of them.>depending on which sense you're talking about.Then why did you attack me for including one of them in my argument?>But should one make it? Why?Why not? Should you get to decide which arguments people are allowed to make?>The on what basis do you objectCommon use and speaker's consensus, which the lexical definitons are based on.>truth is indeed not the only norm governing communicationNo, but as I've already said: It is what ultimately matters. Just because it's not the "only norm", that doesn't mean you can dismiss it like you did.>war is more noteworthyThen go to the wikipedia discussion page and tell them that.
New thread!>>224364767>>224364767>>224364767
>>224364792And are your hands clean?
>>224364800>Really, anon?Yes, really. The vast majority of communication is not truth-apt. Facial expressions, gestures, greetings, commands, questions, etc. I have never said that truth doesn't matter, only that it is not the sole norm governing communication.>When I insist on using words how they are commonly understood in accordance with common definitionsBut the whole point is that you're using them in ways that won't be commonly understood or accepted. Your claim that mugging includes an act of bullying would at the very least raise an eyebrow if not laughter even in a low-voltage conversational context and your response is just to insist that the (undefended!) definition is sovereign. You're trying to have your cake and eat it: when I say "you're being obtuse and pedantic, ordinary people don't use language that way" you say tough shit and then when I challenge your approach on the grounds of truth you accuse me of being pedantic and dishonest. When you originally responded to the person saying "I don't like watching films about bullying" I don't think you were seriously puzzled about what he meant. You can admit that "There are certainly films that are more about bullying than others, revolve around it more, have more focus on it..." and it's not a leap from that to "he doesn't like watching films focused on bullying as is commonly understood, as in Toxic".>What the fuck do you think your "bullying is pressuring someone, but ONLY with a disbalance in social power" was?It was stress testing your own definition using your own source!. It was a request to not think that one sentence from a Wikipedia article was enough to settle the issue.>Then why did you attack me for including one of them in my argument?I told you: because the sense in which it's understood impacts how the question is answered.>Why not?I've told you. No good reasons for it and good reasons against (triviality, uninformativeness, etc.) >It is what ultimately mattersWhy? How?
>>224365096>The vast majority of communication is not truth-aptNot when you do it, yeah.>I have never said that truth doesn't matterYou literally have. See your "Not true at all" comment.>you're using them in ways that won't be commonly understood or accepted.I used the common definition, which can be found in all mainstream dictionaries.Other than you, no one here had a problem understanding me. Someone else who replied to my initial post actually got my very point that all films can be argued to be about bullying and elaborated on it.You took offense because you did not (and still don't) undestand what "bullying" means. And you doubled down and tried to shift the goalposts (and still are) after the definition was given to you.>It was stress testing your own definition using your own sourceYou're not here to "stress test" anything. That's not how language works.Besides, you didn't use the source. You tried to strawman the source into saying something it did not actually say, as you yourself admitted when I pointed that out.>because the sense in which it's understood impacts how the question is answered.So what was I supposed to do? Not answer the question with both possible interpretations in mind, and instead just assuming that anon must have meant just the single "thematic" and not the equally justified "narrative" one, nor both in combination? Making assumptions is generally not advised. It's what you did when you replied to me, what you are still doing all the time. And everyone can see what a mess this leads to.>No good reasons for itUntrue. It's a rather interesting question to ask what kind of things film is about as a medium, or what all storytelling has in common. In fact, it's a much more interesting question than "what's exclusive to film X or story Y". But of course, you seem to have no academic curiosity at all. You've already shown that when you argued against truth being what ultimately mattered. You just care about "winning" arguments
>>224365199>Not when you do it, yeahLmao. Fucking pissweak, mate.> "Not true at all" commentIt's not true at all that truth is what "ultimately matters" concerning communication because much communication is not about truth or truth-evaluable you fucking moron. Of course it makes perfect sense a mummified pedant like you would take a statement of a definition as a more paradigmatic and fundamental instance of communication than a smile or kiss, but for most people the world's bigger than dictionaries.>You tried to strawman the source into saying something it did not actually sayI did no such thing. I misquoted it, and as I said it was unimportant to my broader argument anyway.>That's not how language worksIt's how it works for people with the academic curiosity you claim to value. You can't both claim to care about truth and then just hide behind dictionaries. There's nothing to stop someone with greater concern for linguistic precision and economy than you from just saying "I don't mean X by bullying, I mean Y which renders your point about all films being about bullying untrue in any given sense".>So what was I supposed to do? Maybe just ask him to clarify instead of just assuming that he was wrong from the outset like a fucking blowhard spouting variations on "Die Hard is a Christmas movie"?>ultimatelyYour silence on how and why this is case is even more telling than your completely ignoring my point about speech acts and non-linguistic communication. Maybe you should concern yourself less with my apparent concern with "winning" arguments and start concerning yourself with actually arguing.
>>224365426>>224365199Let's get you two chads into the next thread!
>>224365426>It's not true at all that truth is what "ultimately matters" concerning communication Case in point. You simply talk for the sake of talking and "winning" arguments. You do not care about the truth of the points you make.Thank you for admitting this.>as I said it was unimportant to my broader argument anyway.No, it wasn't. It was meant to support your broader argument, hence why you made that point in the first place - whether the misquote was intentional or not.>It's how it works for people with the academic curiosity you claim to value.Nope. Academic curiosity is not the same as trying to change a word's definiton to "win" an argument. Academic curiosity is about the subjet matter. Any serious academic will stick to what words mean, because that's how you guarantee a mutual understanding between parties.>greater concern for linguistic precisionKek. Someone with a concern for precision will use more word to narrow down what he wants to say, not just use a very general term and then pretend that it wasn't supposed to mean what it usually does, but only this or that specific part of it.>just saying "I don't mean X by bullying, I mean YHey, sure, if you say that right at the start, before using the word wrong, we can say you did enough to establish a different meaning. But if you attack someone making a point about X, and then after a handful of posts back and forth start saying "but I want it to mean Y instead", that's just bullshit.>which renders your point about all films being about bullying untrue in any given sense".By the common definition of the word, what I wrote is absolutely true. That it might not be if we use your narrower private definiton does not prove my initial statement wrong, because your definition has nothing to do with the statement I made.
>>224362942>TWO HOURS of Jack Nicholson just going from place to place, waling around, doindg...things, and then leaving. Rinse and repeat, until (spoilers) he dies in the end. Yeah, it's kino.
>>224365426>Maybe just ask him to clarifyWhen someone says "I don't like films about bullying", why would you need to ask for clarification? All of those words have a commonly accepted definition. It's not as if he said "I don't like quibbles about potchies". That's when you'd need to ask for clarfication.>Your silence on how and why this is caseAre you fucking retarded? You really need me to explain to you why truth matters when communicating something?Why don't you try to think for yourself for a moment? What even is the point in arguing ANYTHING at all when truth does NOT ultimately matter? Then anything that is said becomes utterly pointless and meaningless drivel that is just said for no reason whatsoever.But of course, that would explain why you talk the way you do.Listen, let's bring this bullshit to an end.It's going nowhere. You're arguing just for the sake of arguing, as you do not uiltimately care for the truth. You have repeatedly admitted that.And I do not want to drag this bullshit of yours into the next thread.So, if you want to have the last word, fine. Just be aware that I won't reply to you anymore. Both because the thread is running out of time to do so, and because there's obviously no point in doing so anyway.>>224365570Please no.
>>224365632>You really need me to explain to you why truth matters when communicating something?No, I need you to explain why it's what ULTIMATELY matters with regard to communication when there are, as I have shown, many forms of communication that aren't truth-evaluable, you fucking philistine.>Academic curiosity is about the subjet matterWhich you lack. Which is why in a conversation about language and communication you hammer your thick fucking skull deep into the sand the minute that Grice's maxims, essentially contested concepts and speech acts are brought up and use the end that's not buried to shit out a torrent of ad hominems to preserve your ego when it's shown that you're out of your depth and the one who doth protest too much with regard to being obsessed with winning.>Any serious academic will stick to what words meanAny serious academic will consider the notion of meaning itself something to be interrogated.
>>224365765>>224365632Could've saved on a lot words by just saying "the film was too italian for me".
>>224364767 >>224364767
bump of /film/
HOWEVER