[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


VILF edition

Previously: >>224351802
>>
star trek sex with shran
>>
One of my best friends reminds me of Commander Riker.
>>
>>224383676
You lost tranny.
>>
memory alpha challenge: find an actor who appeared on star trek and also has at least one other legitimate acting credit but has no other shared appearances with anyone who was ever in any star trek production. Joanna Cassidy in OP worked with like 40 people from trek from shatner to jeri ryan to Marc Alaimo to christopher plummer
>>
>>224383762
Best friend here. You remind me of Lieutenant Broccoli.
>>
>>224383875
that's more like an imdb filtered search than memory alpha challenge
>>
>>224383656
Tell me about her home Protein resequencer. Probably the only thing interesting in that episode. Showing that homes have such technology.
>>
>>224383997
except memory alpha already has it on every actors page and imdb is cancer
>>
The Borg going to fluidic space means they can create new technologies and not just assimilate existing tech, of some species already went to fluidic space and the Borg assimilated them.
>>
>>224383918
>You remind me of Lieutenant Broccoli.
T... thats... Thats not my name... c...c...commander...
>>
>>224383918
Friendly reminder Barclay is the only person to canonically survive the transporter
>>
star trek jambalaya orgies with t'pol, who would much prefer plomeek monogamy
>>
>when normies who don't understand Star Trek try to make a bunch of assumptions about it
>>
>>224385033
it is truly a painful and terrible feel but it's not as bad as when people who actually have watched Trek start talking about it and you realize they're retarded
>>
>>224385423
Had a guy tell me yesterday that Starfleet isn't actually a military and that they only follow rank in crisis mode, that's why they occasionally accuse each other of "pulling rank," and that there is no need for military command or autocracy in Star Trek because they just do everything by committee.
>>
>>224385785
they literally use the phrase "chain of command" MANY times in the series
>>
>>224385812
THE CHAIN OF COMMAND NEEDS TO BE BROKEN. ANARCHY MUST REIGN YAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
>>
>>224385812
Sometimes, I wonder what these people are even doing when they're "watching Star Trek." Are they just scrolling their phones and occasionally looking at their TVs and going "haha TNG is so comfy, love my heckin' second family" and then they just go back to scrolling.
>>
>>224385812
One of the most well-regarded episodes (it's a two-parter but I count it as one, fuck it) is literally named Chain of Command, too
>>
File: AdmiralNechayev.jpg (82 KB, 694x530)
82 KB JPG
>I'm here to relieve you of command of your penis
>>
Beva Lee !
>>
alright. Watching the last episode of Picard. Then onto SNW. Then ENT.
>>
Geordi is Data's Friend. And it is so cute when Data mentions that Geordi is his friend.
>>
>>224385033
Thats me!
>>
>>224385866
Pretty much yeah
The Pstew sticky revealed so, so many casuals who only watched top 10 TNG because of certain internet reviewers
>>
>>224385033
>Implying trekkies understanding of Star Trek is any better
>>
>>224386081
don't worry Nechayev, my penis is AWOL because you hit THE wall
>>
alright this Picard Finale is pretty emotional.
>>
File: ro 19.jpg (52 KB, 1016x768)
52 KB JPG
kiss
>>
>>224386656
she does not compare to my Goddess Wife.
>>
Alright. Picard Show watched.

Now onto SNW.
>>
>>224386694
Are you sure, Elmer? She has a pwominent cowwalbone and anguwar cheeky-weekies or whatever infantile shit you like to say.
>>
>>224386936
I talk like that with her because she's so cute.

She is Tall with Red Hair, Pale skin, fweckles, prominent front teeth, and prominent clavicle.
>>
It's clear at the end of Picard they were setting up for a new Series with Seven as Captain and Jack Crusher in the show as well.
>>
File: nakednow_hd_345.jpg (362 KB, 1440x1080)
362 KB JPG
This is how you can always spot a filthy casual, from these opinions
TOS
>Kirk is a womanizer
>the sets are cardboard
>the effects are cheap
>Roddenberry's ideas were bad
>my favorite episode? Balance of Terror
TOS movies
>the even numbers are good, the odd numbers are bad
>TMP almost killed the franchise because it was boring
>my favorite movie? Wrath of Khan
TNG
>Picard is a hypocrite
>Seasons 1 and 2 reuse TOS scripts, that's why they're bad
>Roddenberry's ideas were bad
>what is this, gay space socialism??
>my favorite episode? The Inner Light
TNG movies
>they're all bad except First Contact
>my favorite movie? First Contact
DS9
>Sisko is a schizo
>I love how it's sooo dark and edgy, it's a more realistic version of Starfleet
>it's 100% serialized
>everything that isn't Dominion war related is boring
>my favorite episode? In the Pale Moonlight
VOY
>Janeway is bipolar
>the show is too light-hearted, it should've been Year of Hell the whole way
>it should've been 100% serialized
>my favorite episode? Tuvix
ENT
>Archer is stupid
>Temporal Cold War is a waste of time
>did you know that season 5 was going to be completely about the Romulan War, change the whole way the ship would look, AND add Shran to the main cast??
>my favorite episode? In a Mirror, Darkly
nutrek
>it's bad because it's woke OR Star Trek has always been woke
>STD was only good for Jason Isaacs
>Lower Decks is a love letter to the franchise, you can tell they did their research
>SNW is good
>Picard was a good sendoff to the TNG cast
>>
pwominent fwont teefs
>>
>>
>>224387012
Okay buddy, what's YOUR favorite episode of DS9?
>>
>>224386863
why?
>>
File: trekdamar.gif (446 KB, 370x277)
446 KB GIF
Test
>>
>>224387012
i cant argue with any of this and I'm the crotchety asshole who loves to argue
>>224387069
The Visitor is the best episode
>>
File: sttngladder.jpg (40 KB, 600x458)
40 KB JPG
>>224387012
filthy casuals will always rule
>>
File: 1755005039855917.gif (3.31 MB, 538x360)
3.31 MB GIF
>>224387085
>>
>>224387069
The Visitor or Civil Defense or Body Parts or The Way of the Warrior, it can be hard to choose
>>
>>224387019
She is so hot and cute.
>>
>>224387074
To watch all Trek except Discovery and the JJ Abrams Movies. I also am not watching Prodigy because it's simply not on Paramount+.
>>
>>224387069
Duet
>>
File: feezal trip.png (749 KB, 1192x714)
749 KB PNG
>>224383656
Trip absolutely should have fucked T'Pol's mom out of spite after all the games she played on him. Phlox's wife too, desu
>>
>>224387012
filthy casual here. Watching tos, ntg, and ds9. So many of the season 1 episodes, which i am currently on, are great. I just watched 1001001. probably my favorite so far. It was just so much fun, and a great concept of the ship being abandoned without the captain knowing while hes still on it.
>>
File: Sakonna.jpg (32 KB, 499x384)
32 KB JPG
>>224383656
Let me add to the VILF collection
>>
>>224387266
Now see that's the right way to think. Like yeah season 1 especially is a little strange and the characters act weird compared to the rest of the series, but there's a lot of heart to it.
>>
Imagine how efficient a vulcan handjob would be
>>
File: dr selar 3.png (292 KB, 500x370)
292 KB PNG
>>224387399
need
>>
>>224387158
Damarvis the best character ti you realize it was originally written to be Dukats hero arc and they couldnt have that cuz racism n shit.
>>
>>224387411
thats a great shot. i wonder who is responsible
>>
>>224387441
you go on the list too >>224387012
>>
File: dr selar 4.jpg (112 KB, 540x960)
112 KB JPG
>>224387443
???
>>
>>224387441
absolutely wrong. see >>224387455
>>
File: 7436184731891.jpg (21 KB, 593x517)
21 KB JPG
>watch babylon 5
>can't enjoy DS9 anymore knowing it's the temu version
what do I do bros, how do I put the genie back in the bottle
>>
Dukat was never going to have a heroic arc and I don't know why people keep repeating this lie
The plan always was to "soften" him (during S4) and then have him turn around and do something villainous again (during S5)
>>
File: trekodo.png (346 KB, 1092x540)
346 KB PNG
>>224387455
>>224387471
Ooooohhhhhhhhh youre the spammer lmao
>>
File: stsws.png (2.1 MB, 1603x1017)
2.1 MB PNG
I'm not your boogeyman and you're also posting my OC
>>
>>224387318
And I can tell, as an experienced tv watcher, that they are exploring the show. Some episodes are silly. Some soap boxy. But they are always using good storyline principles.

Its like what the Pickwick Papers is to the rest of Dickens oeuvre
>>
>>224387684
Yeah it takes them a while to figure out the show. The characters have their fair share of cringey lines early on, so they stop doing that. Picard comes off as too much of a hardass, so they let him chill.
>>
>>224387012
"Early TNG was always reusing TOS scripts" is always something that baffles me.
I think somehow "Early TNG feels like TOS" turned into "Early TNG /was/ TOS"
The only TOS episode they shamelessly ripped off was The Naked Time, which became The Naked Now.
The only reused scripts were from the planned, and abandoned 70s TOS continuation, Phase II. These were The Child (S2) and Devil's Due (S4). Which were retooled enough where you wouldn't even know they were meant for Kirk, Decker, Ilia.
>>
alright, starting SNW S1 E1: "Strange New Worlds"
>>
>>224387716
I was surprised with how tough he is. I had the "collective cultural" understanding that he was a moral leader, not a hardass leader. To be honest, I kinda like it, although I can see why they softened him up. And he is awkward being a hardass. Kirk, its more natural.
>>
>>224387909
There's some clunky Picard dialogues in the first ten episodes like this
>I should at least give my son a tranquilizer.
>The Boy should face death with open eyes.
>Is that your opinion as a man?
>...rubbish.
where he comes off as kind of a prick
I think they weren't exactly sure how to write Jean-Luc until they finally nailed him down.
>>
File: a kink.webm (1.73 MB, 960x720)
1.73 MB
1.73 MB WEBM
Krik is definitely not a "hardass." I'd say he is the most whimsical and chill of all captains
>>
>>224388031
Kirk is chill but he's also not afraid to use a firm hand.
I don't know where him being a womanizing loose cannon came from.
>>
>>224388075
Kirk has the perfect personality to do the mission he's on. You simply can't beat it
>>
>>224388031
He knew how to set a standard. That is, in these days, hard ass. But it cant be the only standard, if that makes sense.
>>
curious that we never see the Gorn again beyond TOS...
>>
>>224388322
you see them in ENT but it's stupid and not worth mentioning even though i just did
>>
Alright. SNW Episode 1 was good.
>>
>>224388372
I've watched ENT twice and do not remember this. Well, I'll see it on my 3rd Rewatch.
>>
another offensively boring character on B5 is Franklin. I mean you're the doctor can't you have SOME kind of interesting character trait? You're barely in episodes and you're just some lame goody two shoes guy. MUH PATIENT yeah yeah yeah
>>
File: annie.png (364 KB, 532x534)
364 KB PNG
Damn, Worf is a gigantic homo
>>
>>224388454
You just have to keep watching. It's not like Bashir was like "muh Dax" on DS9 the entire time, right? Not that both are too remarkable when compared to other characters, but still.
>>
File: HLRdSHLXwAQnYRl.jpg (61 KB, 783x783)
61 KB JPG
>>224388736
don't worry im watchin. I just gotta complain you know how it is
>>
>>224388372
The best episode(s) of ENT is very much worth mentioning.
>>
>>224388868
don't make me tap the sign >>224387012
>>
>>224388887
Youre the spammer hahhahaha
>>
Imagine Star Trek but like Parks and Rec!!!1 So much funsies!!!
>>
Do you think Barclay was actually a good fencer because of all the practice he had on the holodeck? Rewatching Hollow Pursuits and was just thinking it would have been a fun callback to have an episode where he fights off some hostile aliens on some away mission.
>>
>>224389000
I think if it was a real situation and he was under pressure he could pull it off. if it was a friendly match he'd probably choke.
>>
>>224388974
This, but unironically
>>
>>224389025
That's how I picture it too. A life or death situation where he doesn't have an opportunity to get caught up in his own head and surprises everyone, including himself before Geordi makes a comment about his time on the holodeck not being a waste.
>>
File: 1755623941804309.gif (786 KB, 357x256)
786 KB GIF
>>224387012
I defend VOY more than anyone in this thread and the Year of Hell thing and the serialization things are at least 100% true. Not total serialization but more serialization would've definitely helped VOY, something along the lines of DS9 where you'd occasionally get 3-4 parters. And Year of Hell is closer to the original concept of the show which is honestly a better concept than what we got.
However, the casual thing isn't holding these opinions, it's holding them and thinking that VOY as we got it sucked BECAUSE of these two things, which is not true. VOY is still good despite those two things being true.

Also the ENT ones are funny and just reveal personal butthurt on your part.
>Archer is stupid
He is a completely incompetent moron in some episodes.
>the thing about Shran being added to the cast just because you got BTFO about it ITT a few days ago
kek this one actually made me laugh out loud
>>
>>224389000
Fencing is a sport but it's not as good in a general purpose fight as you might think.
>inb4 grapplefags over strikingfags
Watch a buhurt match and you'll see that fencing limits a lot of the attack space, especially when using foil
>inb4 slashing is acceptable with saber
a fencer would get his shit pushed in by an actual HEMA or other cultural weapons martial arts fighter
>>
>>224383676
star trek sex with wesley
>>
File: the neutral zone.jpg (59 KB, 900x506)
59 KB JPG
Name my band
>>
>>224389291
It's as good in a fight anything Kirk does, that's all that matters.
>>
File: 72 - Nice Shot.png (1.48 MB, 1440x1080)
1.48 MB PNG
I still wonder what that guy meant last thread by calling me cottage core.
Anyway, tonight's episode is "The Lights of Zetar", another one I'm going into completely blind. See you in an hour or so.
>>
>>224389465
>I still wonder what that guy meant last thread by calling me cottage core.
Woops I never responded. What I meant by that is that you're performing the same general unifying purpose as the watch along on H&I from last year, but limited to one series at a time in something akin to a small batch, artistinal approach. It wasn't an insult. It's good fodder to keep the general lively, though it's no jambalaya orgy with shran
>>
>>224389279
>VOY is still good
Great show, just needed to work on the dialogue, characters, acting, plots, lighting, blocking, set design, makeup, world building, framing, pacing, and script supervision
>>
>>224387012
>>TMP almost killed the franchise
People love saying this despite the fact it made 1 gazillion dollars and guaranteed sequels, just ones with lowered budgets because Paramount flipped out when they got the bill.
>>
>>224389279
>he still believes that after-the-fact fanfic where Shran was gonna be on the bridge for all 26 episodes
lol okay man
>>
>>224389765
Well, no, they'd probably have him join in a specific episode. Early in the season I'd say, so maybe he'd be in the last 15 episodes on the bridge. Why would that be absurd? T'Pol is there. Sussman said it, Coto said it. It is what it is.
>>
File: 1794179122289879.png (1.12 MB, 1440x1080)
1.12 MB PNG
>>224389742
>dialogue
As good as TNG or DS9, largely same writers
>characters
I made a post about this the other day showing that VOY's characters compare quite favorable to other Berman Trek rosters, particularly TNG's crew.
>acting
Ethan Phillips, Jeri Ryan, Robert Picardo are all S-tier Trek actors, up there with the best of the best.
>plots
Some of the best Trek episodes of all time, some of the worst. VOY's strength is in its consistency. It has a ton of average to good episodes.
>lighting, blocking, set design, makeup
The visual effects guys, Westmore, the line producers, guys like David Livingston were doing the best work of their careers on VOY because it was Berman Trek at its most refined, production wise.
>script supervision
Here, you actually hit on something that was worse on VOY, no doubt about it, tying back to my earlier point about its consistency of average episodes. It's the reason why VOY is a rung lower than TNG and DS9.

To you, I guess, you can't be a rung lower than TNG and DS9 and still be a great Trek show. But you're wrong about that part.
>>
>>224389510
Ah, why thank you! I don't think of myself so highly as the watchalong, but I'm glad people continue to find what I have to say entertaining or interesting.
>>224389465
And indeed, this was quite the entertaining and interesting episode. Finally, we get to the origins of the term Memory-Alpha, a library of all the collected works of the Federation housed on a small planetoid (I'm unsure if the library spans the entire celestial body or just a small portion of it, since the records are all computerized), and much like the Library of Alexandria, disaster befalls it. Spock's words on the matter seem to imply that humanity failed to learn from our history and much information kept there was the only copy in the galaxy.
In a similar vein, Mira's strange visions reminded me of the Greek myth of Cassandra. Thankfully, after a couple things match up they do take her seriously, especially with the overlap between her brainwave patterns and those of the titular Lights of Zetar. I found Jan Shutan's performance to be really incredible, especially since the staff made her a freshly promoted Lieutenant (whose father was chief engineer of Starfleet, explaining how her first deep-space trip was something that should've been a cakewalk instead of doing pickup work as a Yeoman to earn her way to the Lieutenancy), because it makes her workplace difficulty understandable in a way that isn't for someone like the archeologist from "Adonais" or the historian from "Space Seed". Probably also helps that she fell in love with Scotty instead of a threat (nearly said alien there but Khan is still an Earthling). It's nice that both Bones & Scotty have a love interest now, I wonder if either one will be mentioned again. If the newest couple stick together, that's gonna make him getting stuck in the buffer even worse for them both.

continued
>>
>>224390773
The visual effects continue to be really creative. I don't quite know how they accomplished the Lights, maybe they took some strands of tinsel and boosted the contrast really high? The extreme closeup into Mira's eye was also really great, as was the frog gurgling she did after her first exposure.
How many times in the show has taking evasive maneuvers actually managed to evade something? And every time they fail to do it, they do the same thing on the viewscreen where it slides off to one side and then slides back in to the center of the frame. Trust me it never gets old, but you'd think they could shake it up more than the once (when the entire planet of Gothos teleported in front of them instead of chasing them down), this trick dates back to the Corbomite Maneuver.
Another amusing production detail: when they beam back up from Memory-Alpha, the trio walk out briskly, while Scotty & Mira trail behind holding eachother after he just saved her from a transporter malfunction (man, it'd REALLY suck if they're still together when he has his accident), and the gap between them is large enough that the automatic doors start to close before detecting them and sliding back open, which I think is the first time that's happened. I wonder if it was something they planned to do, or if the guys operating the doors didn't realize the scene was still going and had to be prompted to do it.
>>
>>224385033
>ThErE ArE FoUr LiGhTs
>>
>>224385033
Babylon 5 did it better than Chain of Command
>>
star trek sex with david corwin
>>
>>224387069
Little Green Men
>>
>>224387069
The one where Sisko murders the whole planet.
>>
>>224391781
Starfleet evacuated both colonies off-screen (-:
>>
>>224383656
I am very attracted to this old lady, I do not know why.
>>
File: 1779913526346862.jpg (19 KB, 741x414)
19 KB JPG
>>224389765
Tread softly anon. You're treading on my dreams.
>>
>>224389765
It wouldn't feel right.

Shran just taking orders from Archer?

Shran should have his own ship and they should be moreso in an alliance.

Not Shran on the Bridge.
>>
>>224392155
>Andoria joins the Federation
>Shran gets into hot water, loses his commission and his position
>Archer does him a favor
>Shran ends up on the bridge, taking orders from Archer and working side by side with T'Pol
Is it good writing? Is it a good idea? Not really but it's Enterprise and a lot of bad ideas got through.
>>
>>224391807
Still M-Class planet became uninhabitable.
>>
>>224392452
>>Shran gets into hot water
>>Archer does him a favor
Star Trek sex with Shran indeed
>>
>>224392452
Does not sound like a favor.
Shran doesn't fit the look of being another officer on Archer's bridge.
>>
File: Spoiler Image (3 KB, 125x76)
3 KB
3 KB JPG
>>
>have the only actually good character on your show that sucks become second banana to the main character who sucks in a desperate attempt to keep people's interest in your show (which sucks)
it's such a fucking retarded idea
>>
>>224393208
ENT doesn't suck, but yeah it is a bad idea to make Shran a lackey of Archer. That just isn't Shran.
>>
obviously shran would be an advisor outside the chain of command to help archer meet aliens on the andorian side of the galaxy. a lot of it would be shran letting archer make a dumb mistake and then bailing him out and gloating.
>>
>>224387012
>Temporal Cold War is a waste of time
This is 100% true thoughever
>>
>>224393320
thank god Enteprise got cancelled
>>
File: vosk.jpg (53 KB, 400x183)
53 KB JPG
>>224393342
it was a neccessary plot device to protect the original timeline but calling it a cold war was stupid. it was hot as hell.
>>
>>224393418
>it was a neccessary plot device to protect the original timeline
How?
>>
>>224393342
Groups of people using time travel as a weapon is a pretty kino idea, it's just that ENT may not have been the best show for it
>>
>>224390530
>Why would that be absurd?
because that's not the type of character shran is, he wouldn't be anyone's lackey
>T'Pol is there
as the token vulcan, eventually she considers pursuing a career in starfleet
>Sussman said it, Coto said it. It is what it is.
they were making shit up like 5 years after the show was canceled
>>
>>224393679
The big problem with prequels is maintaining continuity, time travel lets you sidestep any problems by pressing the reset button at the end. See STD and star wars for how NOT to do it.
>>
File: cardassia prime.jpg (169 KB, 1008x474)
169 KB JPG
ATTENTION CARDASSIAN CITIZENS
>>
File: Trans-Wes.png (479 KB, 720x604)
479 KB PNG
>>224389320
Nada!
>>
>>224395499
I still dont get trans wesley. This woman looks nothing like him.
>>
>>224387253
H-hot denobulan mommies!!
>>
>>224383676
Based and bluepilled!
>>224389320
Gay and cringe!
>>
File: IMG_2424.png (216 KB, 500x360)
216 KB PNG
>>
>>224395777
that's nice, let's see if you change your tune after I blow up your preschool
>>
star trek sex with tom and harry
>>
why did none of you B5 bros tell me I need to watch The Gathering first? I'm like 11 episodes in and they're talking about shit that never happened turns out it's from the "pilot movie"
>>
>>224395904
I did the same thing
>>
>>224395777
>When you look at her face for 10 minutes trying to figure out what alien species she is, just to realize it's not a rubber make up
>>
>>224395777
Facts and logic destroy the Bajewran
>>
File: Living Witness pt.2.png (557 KB, 500x1060)
557 KB PNG
>>224396628
Indeed
>>
>>224394125
>they were making shit up like 5 years after the show was canceled
anon I don't know if you know this but writers and showrunners "just making shit up" is how shows are created
>>
>>224396762
Don't sound like a dishonest (((Ferengi)))
Several years after it was canceled they said "oh yeah, we could've done this, maybe, possibly"
That doesn't mean they were thinking YES WE ARE ABSOLUTELY DOING THIS before news came down from the network that the show would not move beyond season 4.
They were definitely humoring fans by just saying shit they thought they'd like to hear.
>>
>>224396762
>>224396999
exactly the same as Andy Robinson and Behr letting everyone know GARAK WAS DEFINITELY GAY WE DID IT LIKE THAT ON PURPOSE 20 years later only after fans came up with it first. loathsome attention seeking pathological liar behavior
>>
File: 1554266074740.jpg (151 KB, 1070x851)
151 KB JPG
>>224396740
>>
File: ent11-2.jpg (188 KB, 1510x850)
188 KB JPG
>>224397093
Exactly but Trekkies are retarded, I mean look at how they tried to keep nutrek alive.
Doug Drexler shared his design of what he FELT an NX-01 refit WOULD look, which somehow became "the ship was totally going to look like this in Season 5 if it wasn't cancelled!!!"
But there's no fucking way; Season 4 already had a slashed budget (less than TOS in the 1960s AND THIS WAS 2004) they would NOT have changed the ship's design, built an all new engineering set, and rendered a dozen new CGI establishing shots, it just wasn't possible.
>>
File: shran.png (326 KB, 1346x1014)
326 KB PNG
>>224396999
Dude, you are fucking hilarious. You are still refusing to admit you were wrong about an argument from DAYS AGO. Get a fucking grip dude.
>uhhh they just said we could've done this, possibly
WRONG. They said, specifically, that it had "always been the plan." They inferred that it was the plan before the show was cancelled and was part of their mapped out intentions of S5. Now, you can choose not to believe that all you want but to do so is just arbitrary and self-serving for the purpose of your argument. Your position is backed by absolutely nothing else but an inability to own up to your own ignorance.

Incredibly embarrassing that you are still going on about this.
>>
>>224397093
Or Roddenberry and co. spinning different stories about why Majel Barrett as Number One in the pilot didn't continue into the show proper, from "it's because she was a woman in power!!" to "it's because she was his mistress!!" The real reason? Women test audiences didn't like her. They liked Spock more.
>>
File: pretrans wes.jpg (539 KB, 1040x1024)
539 KB JPG
>>224395639
>>
File: Latestbobgunton.jpg (111 KB, 600x800)
111 KB JPG
>>224397271
>They said, specifically, that it had "always been the plan."
And I'M calling them LIARS.
But sure, keep believing all of these fairytales about what Star Trek producers could've/would've/should've done but couldn't because of [false reasons].
>>
File: 155254521232_0_jpg.jpg (725 KB, 1440x1080)
725 KB JPG
Manny Coto is not like Gene Roddenberry or Ira Steven Behr. He is not some weirdo who considers himself a cult leader and a forerunning champion of wokedom, he is quite literally just a guy talking about how the blue guy was going to be added to the crew in the next season.

He has no history of sensationalism or distorting the truth. There is genuinely not a single reason to doubt his word, particularly when it's backed up by Sussman. There was genuinely nothing at all for him to gain personally by talking about this.
>>
>>224396740
Please stop with the prosemitism
>>
File: 1763072224009879m.jpg (39 KB, 1024x768)
39 KB JPG
>B5 pilot is a Changeling plot
DS9 bros...what the hell...it really is a ripoff
>>
>>224397363
>He has no history of sensationalism or distorting the truth.
Oh I'm sure of that, except in this instance.
>ENT is cancelled
>years after the fact, fans are able to reevaluate it from the DVDs and syndication
>Shran becomes a fan favorite
>Coto/Sussman: "Oh yeah? Well what if we told you that he was going to join Archer's crew in season 5 if you'd actually supported the show while it was on!"
It's dishonesty mixed with guilt tripping as well.
>>
>>224397478
You literally just made all of that shit up and you're choosing to believe your spaghetti headcanon over something the people who were in charge of the show are telling you, AGAIN, with absolutely nothing to gain by saying it.
You are autistic beyond comprehension.
>>
>>224397502
Actually autism is when you have no theory of mind and therefore can't discern when or why someone might be lying to you and take anything said by anyone as true at face value
>>
File: archer-shran-babel-one.png (140 KB, 750x422)
140 KB PNG
>>224389765
Do I need to say this again?
Like I've said numerous times before, something like that would absolutely ruin Shran's character. Shran would never in his right mind agree to be made a subordinate to Archer. He was best utilized as an equal of sorts, facilitating the alliance between Earth and Andoria through a position of strength and mutual respect. Shran deserves his own ship, and his own command, even if he makes regular appearances to help out. It's a dumb idea to make him an Enterprise crew member. The position is an inferior one.
May as well have had Soval join the crew as well.
>>
>>224397550
Right, so listening to the people in charge of the show creatively and taking what they say at face value is autism but crafting elaborate fan theories in your own personal headcanon which are directly contradicted by multiple credible sources? Nah, that's not autistic.
Do you consider it autistic to listen to your doctor as well?
>>
>>224397502
Yeah okay sure now I totally believe that Garak was meant to be a complete homosexual fruit because ISB and the actor go on twitter and say so in 2026
>>
>>224397317
> The real reason? Women test audiences didn't like her
I find this believable
>>
>>224397605
Already refuted, see >>224397363
>>
I visited my elderly father recently and he was watching Picard despite not really having seen any star trek before. I haven't seen any either, but I was surprised at what absolute garbage it was. Are all the new shows like that?
>>
>>224389279
Does that make Ronald D. Moore a casual?
>>
>>224397625
>Are all the new shows like that?
Worse even.
Picard is just the least stinky turd in the giant pile of shit that is nu-Trek.
>>
>>224397625
>>224397697
it's the same level of garbage, don't let people convince you otherwise.
>>
>>224397605
andrew robinson has a profit motive to say that, he directly benefits from playing into the garak bashir shit at cons
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KOCDO42NsfA
>>
>>224397609
Even the wiki accepts that fact, also Bob Justman's book is definitely a required read, our TOS watcher should pick it up when he's done.
"We fought for a female XO but sexism prevented us, we were totally trying to be more progressive than we could!" makes them sound good, but it wasn't the truth.
>>
>>224397317
>>224397765
Isn't the story from the NBC side that they told Gene "You can't make your mistress the first officer"?
>>
File: IMG_1033.jpg (381 KB, 1206x1995)
381 KB JPG
>>
File: 1749138255116346.jpg (88 KB, 694x530)
88 KB JPG
/trek/ is fighting again
>>
>>224397911
>"Actually, sex in the future is exactly like my own ideal fetishes." -- Weird Swinger Freak Pervert
I think the shift towards meritocracy and intellectualism would make people more selective about their romantic lives, not less, and more respectful of their partner's wishes. Sure, they wouldn't be ashamed of sex but intelligence is often accompanied by a certain personal modesty.
>>
>>224387312
Imagine the grip
>>
>>224397180
>I mean look at how they tried to keep nutrek alive.
It existed for 8 years. Not a bad run.
>>
>>224397725
>>224397363
And Doug Drexler had a profit motive when he started telling people that his Enterprise refit concept was absolutely what it was going to look like in S5, because they started selling it as model kits and Eaglemoss replicas, and they even "canonized" it in Shitcard, that is if you consider nutrek to be canon (I don't)
>>
>>224398144
It should've died sooner.
>>
>>224397957
>>224397911

He has such cuck chair phenotype
>>
>>224398249
It will live one year longer.
>>
>>224398512
And fade away into nothingness. No one will miss it. No one will even remember it happened.
Who will have won, in the end?
>>
>>224398555
>No one will even remember it happened.
Millions will.
>>
>>224397358
You are face blind.
>>
>>224398555
It will make a comeback, like Prequels. See you in 10 years.
>>
File: Vibe_Tubes.jpg (79 KB, 830x872)
79 KB JPG
>>224398262
>cuck chair phenotype
the name of my klingon acid punk band
>>
>>224398629
>>224398704
Delusional. No wonder you think you can just change genders all willy-nilly.
>>
>10 years... just give it 10 years... people will be missing STD... just give it 10 years... kids will be nostalgic for it...
>>
This film is fine and over hated.
>>
>>224398796
>No wonder you think you can just change genders all willy-nilly.
Nilling your willy is exactly how you change genders.
>>
>>224399274
This and Insurrection have Picard acting the most like his TNG self
>>
>>224399274
all the parts without kirk are pretty dull
>>
>>224399274
Killing off Picard's brother and nephew was unnecessary
>>
>>224399382
yeah their random offscreen deaths were almost nutrekkian in nature
>>
Babylon 5 vs DS9

Actor's performance ranked 70% + character itself 30%.
>>
>>224399382
agreed, was pretty retarded and overly bleak. I dislike the discrepancies between the use of TNG vs DS9 uniforms as well, they should have just stuck to one uniform for the whole cast. Otherwise it feels more TNG than First Contact, even though that film's not bad.
>>
>>224399296
>Insurrection is the most like a TNG episode
>The Final Frontier is the most like a TOS episode
So basically, the more like a Star Trek episode a movie is, the worse it is.
>>
>>224399548
"Worse" is subjective.
>>
File: 1773171754270280.gif (2.73 MB, 400x309)
2.73 MB GIF
>>224399518
>>
>>224398718
I got yer vibe tube right here.
>>
File: 1757089780027756.jpg (238 KB, 1125x375)
238 KB JPG
>>224399518
Weyoun 6 was literally in one episode why single him out?
>>
>>224399282
You just know.
>>
>>224399524
Everybody outside of DS9 seemed determined to fuck up the logic of the uniforms. In DS9 (pre-FC) it was perfectly consistent, station personnel had colored shoulders and shipboard and planetside personnel had colored chests - you see this when Dax comes onboard in the pilot, when Bashir's doctor lady friend visits, when Sisko is at Starfleet Command, etc.
For Generations they tried making new uniforms but rejected them at the last minute, so they just gave them a mishmash of TNG uniforms and ill-fitting borrowed DS9 ones (and the TNG ones ertr themselves a mishmash of real S3 ones for the leads and modified S1 ones for the extras, which we were always supposed to ignore but nonetheless adds to the visual chaos when you see all three together in the same shot), and then Voyager further committed to it by having the whole crew wear what should be space station uniforms.
>>
>>224399611
That was just the best picture of (all of) him they had.
I wish they had a single, number free Weyoun.
>>
>>224399518
>Mark Alaimo behind Sheridan
Jesus Christ, immediately tossed into the trash. Horrible list. Maybe I'll do this properly one day just to embarrass you specifically.
>>
>>224399518
D isn't "bad" on my list, it just means "expected" or average performance for a TV show for a drama TV show in the 80s/90s.
E is below average sliding into average soap opera/porn acting
F is community or high school theater level
F
>>
>>224398642
Shut up Wesley
>>
File: 1761689506315190m.jpg (50 KB, 1024x773)
50 KB JPG
>>
>>224395904
There are a lot of bad season 1 episodes.
Season 3 and 4 are probably the best 2 seasons of sci-fi ever.
Season 2 is solid. Season 5 sucks for most of the episodes, but the last 6 or so are amongst the best.
>>
File: bait_.png (1.05 MB, 1140x827)
1.05 MB PNG
>>224399518
inspired me to make my own TOS-VOY list, never seen b5
>>
File: kevin.jpg (39 KB, 1024x780)
39 KB JPG
Vic Fontaine dislikers are weak as fuck
>>
>>224400192
He's fine for the most part, just shows up too much in s6-7, would've been better spaced out through the whole series
>>
File: generationspicard5.jpg (142 KB, 1106x980)
142 KB JPG
>>224399711
The original Generations uniforms were intended to be used on Voyager immediately after, but I guess someone higher up decided they were ugly (t b h they kinda were)
The "official" reason "we decided we shouldn't have too may new things at once" sounds like b.s. to me. I think they didn't screen test well at all.
>>
>>224400192
I liked It's Only a Paper Moon and the casino heist episode, but that's about it
>>
File: fd34234.jpg (31 KB, 904x535)
31 KB JPG
>captain stops acting like an incel
>entire bridge crew decide to mutiny
>>
>>224393342
>thoughever
>>
File: 1784635546163660m.jpg (38 KB, 1024x576)
38 KB JPG
Stay litty /trek/!
>>
>>224401127
you can't tell me what to do. You're not my real dad.
>>
File: theconscienceoftheking.png (1.06 MB, 1442x1079)
1.06 MB PNG
Watching TOS for the first time.
The Menagerie was weird since I already watched The Cage, so I had to skip some parts.
>>
File: theconscienceoftheking2.png (896 KB, 1436x1079)
896 KB PNG
>>224401285
Didn't like this episode much.
Kirk was acting completely retarded the whole episode, which killed 2 people and almost killed a crew member.
Even Doc looked less dumb this episode even though he did some stupid shit too.
>>
File: 1787276925878930.jpg (43 KB, 637x489)
43 KB JPG
arise
>>
>>224387069
The Magnificent Ferengi
>>
>>224403723
Based
>>
>>224387069
In The Cards
The Nog wheel-n-deal plots are some of my favorite parts of the series.
>>
I never liked DS9 because I can't stand Ferengis or Cardassians.
>>
I never liked DS9 because I can't stand niggers.
>>
>>224403810
Self-sealing stem bolts.
>>
I never liked DS9 because I can't stand Bajorans.
>>
There’s still time for nuTrek to bring back and ruin Species 8472.
>>
>>224404494
Even the Federation starts naming their enemies like the borg. lol
>>
>>224404527

According to Star Trek Online, their real name is the Undine..
>>
>>224404545
they're name after a mythical Earth creature? how gay and retarded.
>>
>By Barclay
>>
>>224404545
There has got to be a better star trek type game than star trek online
>>
>>224404574
Not any official ones I can think of.
>>
>>224404601
Mass Effect 1 is pretty star trek. Anything else like that?
>>
>>224404574
A real Star Trek game would be more something like Planescape Torment, a game with a lot of talking, a lot of RP, and less of a focus on combat.

People talked up the Stellaris mod for years to me but it just doesn't feel like Star Trek, it feels way more like you're just playing Total War with Trek factions. What the hell are you even supposed to do as the Federation? It only makes sense to play as the Borg, an aggressive power that actually wants to take over the map.
The old Bridge Commander game or whatever is still by far the best.
>>
File: 1538675680130.jpg (232 KB, 1914x1440)
232 KB JPG
>>224391781
>S-Sisko what are you doing you wouldn't actually do th=
>FUCK YOU EDDINGTON AND FUCK YOUR MAQUIS PLANET TOO FUCKING TRAITOR

yeah that episode is fun
is that when they hamfistedly compare sisko and eddington to les miserables over and over or is that later
>>
>>224404700
>is that when they hamfistedly compare sisko and eddington to les miserables over and over or is that later
Yeah it's that one, where ED DING TON thinks he's Valjean when he's just a LARPing phony
>>
>>224404699
> What the hell are you even supposed to do as the Federation?
Spend all your time buttering up other factions so they’ll join a coalition with you, then ask them to join the Federation. For factions who are just too different like the Gorn, start an Impose Ideology war, then do the previous thing after you win. Conquer the map diplomatically, while dealing with story events.
>>
>>224404700
>is that when they hamfistedly compare sisko and eddington to les miserables over and over or is that later
it's eddington himself who keeps doing that, and nobody says anything about it, probably because it's way too cringe and they have second hand embarrassment
>>
>>224404804
Doesn't exactly sound like a compelling time to me
>>
>>224404816
You have to be into Paradox autism to enjoy it.
>>
>>224404804
I have Stellaris downloaded but have never played. I only have experience in ck2. How is it for new players?
>>
File: image (90).png (1.19 MB, 1048x735)
1.19 MB PNG
>>
>at the end of the episode where Eddington dies
>Sisko: "wow I guess he really did believe in his cause"
that's fucking bullshit, he did not, he just liked the thrill from being an outlaw and having a bunch of devotees
>>
>>224404947
Says you.
>>
>>224404947
Why did DS9 have more maquis lore than Voyager?
>>
>>224404960
Just like in real life anyone who does that "starting my own insular community far from civilization" crap is only in it to start a cult and fuck kids.
>>
>>224404963
>the one Voyager episode where they get the phone call that all the other maquis are fucking dead and they just have to sit there and seethe about it
>>
>>224404929
It’s much less complicated than CK or EU, it’s a typical 4X strategy game in space. If you can play ck2 then Stellaris won’t be a problem.
>>
>>224404998
I seethe when chakotay tells belanna "the cardassians have a new ally it seems, a new species from the gamma quadrant" voyager got swept up by the caretaker like 5 months after dominion first contact, don't pretend you don't know who they are you retard
>>
>>224405004
Sounds good thank you!
>>
>>224404994
You’ve had zero experience with that kind of thing and have only heard about them from sensationalist news stories from your favorite sources of smarmy infotainment. You yourself a nihilistic vacuum and as such that cannot fathom that others may actually stand for things.
>>
>>224405075
NP. Just be warned that the Star Trek mod can be jank at times due to modder error or version mismatch or something else.
>>
File: IMG_6893.jpg (65 KB, 475x567)
65 KB JPG
>>224404945
Neelix is voyager’s O’Brien
>>
>>224405085
>t. Eddington
>I'M GONNA SET UP MY OWN INDEPENDENT FREE STATE IN THE DMZ btw lemme keep attacking an already beaten and defeated Cardassian Empire (which just drove them into the arms of the Dominion)
>>
>>224405118
I was just gonna do it vanilla but with all the dlcs
>>
>>224405221
Good choice.
>>
>>224392500
Did you actually watch the episode?
Oh wait, this is /trek/, of course not.
>>
File: 1775715253502466.webm (127 KB, 612x720)
127 KB
127 KB WEBM
>>224387468
God, she's perfect
>>
>>224387012
>it should've been Year of Hell the whole way
It should’ve been a season arc
Most of your opinions are pretty reddit tho.
>>
Also season 1/2 of TNG are the best seasons. Everything after 1-2 is a direct trajectory ending with nutrek.
>>
File: images (21).jpg (34 KB, 517x386)
34 KB JPG
We can't go on together
With suspicious minds
And we can't build our dreams
On suspicious minds
>>
one thing cringe about B5 is the religious dogshit. It's fine for aliens but why is there a fucking rabbi in this episode? you literally fought a war with aliens god is obviously not fucking real.
>>
What happens at Deep Space 8?
>>
>>224405674
>god is obviously not fucking real.
that’s never stopped anyone before
>>
File: IMG_20251215_203616.jpg (785 KB, 1290x1092)
785 KB JPG
Zeta Gundam > DS9 > 0079 > B5
>>
File: ar55841.jpg (33 KB, 475x355)
33 KB JPG
>>224387069
Siege of AR-558
>>
>>224405697
Ships stop there thinking it’s the one with the wormhole and need to be told “no that’s deep space 9” all day long
>>
File: 20261116_190853.jpg (3.68 MB, 4000x3000)
3.68 MB JPG
I went to Vegas last week. Didn't they want to build a Star Trek experience there?
>>
>>224405715
kek
>>
File: vulcan booty.webm (1.04 MB, 720x576)
1.04 MB
1.04 MB WEBM
>>224383656
>VILF edition
>>
>>224387100
>>224387167
Why do people like The Visitor? The narrative device of some random young white chick showing up at old Jake’s house so he can tell her the story through flashbacks while he poops his adult diapers is so weak.
Hell the episode would actually be good if it was told through timeskips instead of starting at the end so you know everything gonna just be reset from the start.
>>
>>224387012
>Picard was a good sendoff to the TNG cast
You take that the fuck back
>>
>>224405770
>Why do people like The Visitor?
don't worry about it
>>
>>224405755
I like the retarded Maquis Vulcan Quark almost date rapes
>>
>>224405525
she does nothing for me.
>>
>>224405697
Space Station 13 tier shenanigans
>>
star trek sex with malcolm and hayes
>>
File: br022zhorashoot.jpg (72 KB, 550x307)
72 KB JPG
>>224383656
>>224383875
Reminder that Joanna Cassidy came back 25 years later (2007) to do reshoots for the final cut of Blade Runner, which meant her tits were just as perky then as they were in 1982
>>
File: IMG_6897.png (182 KB, 500x357)
182 KB PNG
I hate this chatbot more and more every rewatch
>>
File: baddabing_535 (1).jpg (45 KB, 692x530)
45 KB JPG
>>224405847
She's a bit too tall, lanky, and bossy. I prefer my women petite and submissive.
>>
>>224405119
Except he deserves his suffering
>>
>>224406353
Tall Woman mogs short woman by the way.
>>
>>224406420
A tall woman with fweckles.
>>
>>224406353
I love Ezri she’s so retarded.
>>
>>224406429
Correct.

Tall with Red Hair, Pale Skin, Fweckles, prominent front teeth, and prominent clavicle.

Mogs all other women.
>>
>>224405674
One of the best episodes involves gospel music
>>
Tonight's episode is "Requiem for Methuselah"
Tonight's dinner is potato chips (going grocery shopping tomorrow)
See you in an hour or so.
>>
>>224406268
strange take. EMH is one of my favorite characters in all of Trek.
>>
I'm going to actually opt to do my 3rd Rewatch of ENT

before I watch SNW.

For 3 reasons;

1. After seeing the first episode of SNW, it seems that the show may actually be good. So a palette cleanser may not be needed.

2. SNW is not finished. So watching ENT would give some more time for Season 5 to come out.

3. Ending the Watchthrough at SNW leaves a neat chronological segway into starting the watchthrough again at TOS when I rewatch Trek again.
>>
>>224407644
He was good until LLMs came around and now I can’t see it as anything other than a crew of retards slowly giving human rights to chatgpt (to their own detriment)
>>
So far, out of the NuTrek that I've watched,

The only NuTrek that I would put on a standard Trek rewatch Watchthrough cycle, is Lower Decks.

I have not seen SNW yet, but I have a feeling SNW will also be in the rewatch watchthrough.
>>
>>224383656
Dr. Selar owes me sex. She has impressive, Vulcan tits.
>>
Lower Decks is for /co/posters (trannoid retards), SNW is for run-of-the-mill idiots who don't know anything about Star Trek.

If you enjoy either, you are gay and unwelcome here.
>>
>>224406718
Great episode up until the moment Kirk kisses Rayna. What could've been a great new take on Bluebeard turns into a twisted version of Pinnochio where he turns into a real boy and immediately dies from the shock of it. Gotta be the absolute worst romance they've ever written for Kirk, because he starts out chaste and restrained, and it's only once he learns that Flint loves his "adopted daughter" that he decides to take her from him. Maybe if they had focused more on Kirk wanting her to actualize her agency instead of him saying "YOU DON'T LOVE HIM, YOU LOVE ME" like a schoolyard crush. Hell, they could've done something even more cerebral with Flint performing a test of Envy upon mankind through the three of them: Bones' desire for medicine, Spock's desire for art, and Kirk's desire for love. It would've been a really powerful story for them to go through the door and have him reveal they failed his test and that mankind would suffer the absence of his advances for another thousand years, and they each get their consolation prizes (the cure, the new Brahms, and a single kiss) before they're forcibly beamed back up and the planet vanishes. Then the coda could be a meditation on how even as far forward as we've come, we still have a ways to go to overcome our imperfections, and then Bones could rib Spock about him failing the test too.
I wish Spock could whisper "Forget" in my ear for this episode.
>>
>>224399862
something is very wrong with you. seek help.
>>
>>224395499
she looks nothing like wesley. something is wrong with you.
>>
>>224407947
can you keep your name on all the time so I can effectively ignore literally anything you have to say?
>>
>>224407947
Your suggestions would have improved that episode exponentially.
>>
>>224395499
Anon. Wesley has a very soft and boyish face. He doesn't have those high cheek bones. I'm sorry but your picture doesn't really work.
>>
>>224405401
Are you a retard?
Oh wait, this is /trek/, of course you are.
>>
>>224406268
>Thanks for not resetting my memories. By the way, I wrote a book about how dumb and gay you all are.
>>
>>224388031
they were different times
>>
>>224407686
SNW sucks butts
>>
>>224407686
SNW deserves an Emmy.
>>
>>224409398
I just imagined her in plaid pajama pants sitting criss cross on a bed with popcorn bowl in her lap.

She is so perfect.
>>
>>224409420
talking to yourself is a sign of mental illness, anon. please dont seek help.
>>
>>224399518
you should post this in the popular and beloved B5 general
oh, wait, lmao
>>
>>224399518
O'Brian was in Babylon 5? Holly molly!
>>
STAR TREK
>>
>>224410359
Has never been better, than NuTrek.
>>
>>224410399
That sounds like a controversial opinion.
>>
>>224410529
Only to boomers.
>>
>>224408897
You misspelled, "better".
They were better times.
Zoomer's who deny this are only screaming sour grapes.
>>
>>224406420
Stop lying Sheryl
>>
>>224410853
>My times were always better than your times
>>
>>
>>224408088
>>224408104
>>224408469
Wesley is having a meltdown.
>>
>>224410976
Impossible. I've been laid 1,000 times more than you.
>>
SHUT UP, WESLEY
>>
>>224411041
1000×0=0
>>
>>224406437
All women are retarded.
Just ask Leonarda Jonie.
>>
New:
>>224411146
>>224411146
>>224411146
>>
>>224411041
I'm sorry you've been laid off so many times, maybe try harder at you next job.
>>
File: file.png (440 KB, 881x604)
440 KB PNG
"11 Recorded attacks"
>>
>>224408180
Should've spoken up a few weeks ago when it was decided the only time I'd have this on is during episodes and when I reply to people who reply to me. The feedback window has shut, sorry.
>>224408197
Yeah, and that's only the simplest of ways to remedy the script. I read on Memory-Alpha that the Bixby's teleplay was revised by this Arthur Singer guy, whose article shares this story from Nichelle Nichols:
>Singer "wandered onto the set and asked our set decorator, "By the way, what does that transporter thing do again?", at which point most of the crew gave up caring."
I would've blamed Freiberger, but apparently he was trying to right a sinking ship, according to the cast.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.