[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


Which way Fremen boi?
>>
>sovlless
>sovlessnessness
>>
>>224410230
I remember back when the first DUNC movie was coming out, there was one anon who used to spam "they should have made the bristles blue", and I kinda agree with him
>>
File: 1599924497836.jpg (285 KB, 1280x536)
285 KB JPG
>>224410230
They should have made the bristles blue so that the the mouth looks like a blue iris, thus highlighting the worms' relationship with the Spice (and also making it look less like a gaping anus). Huge wasted opportunity.
>>
>>224410296
Is it books canon?
>>
>>224410230
How is something from nearly 50 years ago still better-looking?
>>
>>224410230
My dick in the right one
>>
File: IMG_8848.jpg (39 KB, 452x678)
39 KB JPG
>>224410230
How about an actual predator instead of an LSD sand pooper? Alien fucking shits.
>>
>>224410296
No, movies should be grey and beige all over, all architecture should be brutalist, all decor minimalist, all clothes plain black, all lines exposition and great acting means staring into the distance.
>>
>>224410347
Tremor NIGGERS need to leave
>>
>>224410296
>thus highlighting the worms' relationship with the Spice
That's a bit retarded.
>>
>>224410347
It's not a predator tho, it's basically just a sand whale that doesn't want the neighborhood kids on its lawn
>>
Why did the Harvesters even have a ground patrol, and why didn't they have shields? I genuinely do not even understand why the films adapted the shields. They never function appropriately outside of their introduction during Paul's training with Gurney. May as well have just not had them and just not explained why people fight with knives, cause it's the same damn thing either way considering the choreography doesn't even follow the rules.
Fuck these stupid ass movies. Denny is on a generational run of stupid fucking bloated-budget half-baked science-fiction nonsense. Dude needs somebody to smack him upside the head and get him back on $20-$40m thrillers, and for fuck's sake keep him away from writing screenplays.
>>
>>224410296
>thus highlighting the worms' relationship with their shit

?
>>
>>224410418
Shields send the worms into a killing frenzy but I agree, Denis majorly fucked up the sequel and I've no interest in what he does with Messiah
>>
I think somewhere in the books it says if you look straight into a worms mouth, you can see a faint glow from the heat of the chemical reactions in their bellies literally digesting sand and shitting out pure oxygen.
>>
>>224410431
Yeah but the Harvester already attracts worms anyway, and that's the whole point of the Grasshoppers patrolling; to tell everybody to wrap it up. So a worm is coming either way, what's the difference? If anything the whole operation should be gone before it has a chance to go into a frenzy or whatever.
Speaking of which, why don't the Fremen use guns during the Harvester Ambush sequence? The patrol aren't using shields because... reasons, and they have Gurney's resources at that point, so what even was the point of the whole laying underneath the sand? Hell, the whole sequence ends with them just lasering the damn Harvester anyway, because somehow they just know that nobody inside of it or even the Harvester itself has a shield, so it's okay to risk nuking yourself for no real reason at that point because you've already massacred everyone and can just immobilize it and wait for the inevitable worm to eat it.
Fuck it, why am I putting in more thought than that retarded ass Frenchman? Fucking stupid ass movies. Genuinely less thought put into the screenplays than the Transformers films.
>>
>>224410497
It follows the rule of cool. I still don't know how they get under the sand so quickly unless they use the sand compactors but then surely that would lure the worm in the open desert.
>>
>>224410418
1984 DUNE at least had the excuses of budgetary and technical constraints for why they didn't depict much shield use. Dunc has no such justification for simply being retarded with it. They could have had professional choreographers come up with novel combat styles that incorporates shields. They could have written in scenes that depicted shielded fighters vs unshielded ones, maybe wading through small arms fire, etc, to illustrate why hand to hand combat was so important in the Dune setting. Then another scene of shielded troops on Arrakis getting devoured by a worm. But Dunc does none of tthat
>>
File: Annotation 2026-11-22.jpg (300 KB, 1862x678)
300 KB JPG
>>224410418
>Why did the Harvesters even have a ground patrol, and why didn't they have shields?
Read the book. Why are you even in a Dune thread if you haven't read the books lol?
>>
File: hq720 (15).jpg (28 KB, 686x386)
28 KB JPG
>>224410551
The scene of Duncan fighting the Sardaukar in the hallway during the invasion just seems to get rid of the slow blade penetrates the shield idea "Nah, I'm good nigga lmao" always annoys me.
>>
File: 1496954895159.png (29 KB, 252x264)
29 KB PNG
>>224410254
>>224410296
>>
>>224410296
Newfags dont know this is pasta
>>
>"On approaching his adaptation with care rather than complacency, Villeneuve told Empire, "Maybe it's a good idea to go back to this project, not out of nostalgia, not because I miss it, but the opposite—I'm tired of it. I want to make sure that I will be severe with the material. That I will not be complacent,"
>Completely trashes the second half of the story of book one

What did he mean by this?
>>
>>224410724
Newfags created that pasta.
>>
>>224410230
Left.
Thanks to Westwood kino.
>>
>>224410581
>The scene of Duncan fighting the Sardaukar in the hallway during the invasion just seems to get rid of the slow blade penetrates the shield idea "Nah, I'm good nigga lmao" always annoys me.
not a single fight scene actually follows the "slow blade penetrates the shield" idea they all seem to swing it pretty quickly and it goes through anyway, which makes me wonder what the point of the shield is when everybody follows close quarter combat rules anyway
>>
>>224410581
This shit made me laugh to no end, and not just because of the shields, but because he could've just locked the door and escaped out the back still been alive.
His sacrifice as it's portrayed didn't cause any noticeable delay lol.
Oh and my favorite cameo, laserbeams lmao, cause these stupid assholes just use it to open the door even though they now have reason to suspect that the people behind the door are not just the Fremen they were looking for, but Atreides survivors who could very well have shields on that would react with the laser and cause a nuclear explosion.
Ah, fuck it.
>>
File: dune_awakening_001_1920px.jpg (203 KB, 1920x1080)
203 KB JPG
>>224410803
Based. Dune Awakening also used them too.
>>
>>224410568
see>>224410497
>>
>>224410803
Kino game.
>>
File: paulhorsie.gif (3.38 MB, 820x470)
3.38 MB GIF
>>224410783
Lynch already set that precedent in the 80s. Villenueve made a fine adaptation outside the castings of Zendaya & a geriatric Christopher Walken
>>
File: Annotation 2026-11-22 2.jpg (141 KB, 1856x446)
141 KB JPG
>>224410497
>>224410841
>So a worm is coming either way, what's the difference?
Read the book anon.
>>
>>224410809
There is no point in the Dunc movies. But if they wanted to show how it would work, the choreography would be kind of weird and novel for film fighting. Probably lots of grappling and weird changes in tempo as fighters did stuff like leaning/body-checking into incoming strikes, while making light probing attacks that turn into powerful thrusts, once the shield is penetrated. At least that's how its described in the book.
>>
>>224410878
I can hear this in Max Von Sydows voice when I read it.
>>
>>224410809
>Dart traveling super fast and getting stuck in the shield somehow continues through
>Baron survives the cyanide even though the gas traveled through the shield and everybody else in the room collapsed immediately
>Grasshopper hadn't been firing for several seconds and the shield was reactivated, but somehow Chani's RPG passed through because the plot needed it to
It's actually amazing how pointless this plot device is, and how miserably it's portrayed.
>>
Are the shields portrayed convincingly in any of the adaptions?
>>
>>224410939
>>Baron survives the cyanide even though the gas traveled through the shield and everybody else in the room collapsed immediately
This is the worst. Anything caught inside a shield stays there, it should have been death by Dutch oven for him.
>>
>>224410878
So Harvesters don't attract worms?
>>
>>224410581
>slow blade penetrates the shield
Literally doesn't mean anything in the film
Brolin even says it in the first training fight, while they're fucking swinging and slicing at max speed anyway
Completely nonsense
Really the fights should be them grabbing and wrestling each other to the floor, then one getting on top and slowly driving the blade through while pinning the other guy. Maybe if both fighters are wearing shields they don't have friction against each other, so you're purely pushing and redirecting like aikido or tai chi or something
Then that explains why the harkonnen and sardaukar get deleted by the fremen, who just attack like crazy because nobody uses shields on dune
>>
>>224410977
not in a killing-frenzy manner the way shields do
>>
>>224410497
I don't remember if they mentioned it in the book, but worms are very territorial, so a harvester on it's own will only attract a single worm, but when they go into a killing frenzy, they get extremely aggressive and will go into other worms territories.
>>
>>224410992
Shields are more for bullets etc.
A fighter isn't going to be swinging a knife at the speed of a bullet.
>>
>>224410230
>no scifi miniseries version
>>
>>224411028
>>224411044
Does that affect anybody to any discernible extent? I mean like I said, the Grasshoppers patrol for miles during a harvest to watch for the first sign of any worm.
So what's the difference if a worm or multiple worms is ambiguous angrier than it would have been? The operation's already gone. Are the worms going to kill each other? Does it affect spice production? I'm begging for an answer here, because I don't remember there being one in the novels, and I hate these films, which brings me to my overarching point;
People mocked Dune (1984) for distrubing a legend. If this adaptation, made on 100x the budget, with 4x the runtime requires pre-reading of the entire source, then Denny can go fuck his hobbit hole bloody.
>>
File: plate armor.jpg (2.12 MB, 1134x1799)
2.12 MB JPG
>shield stops projectiles
>armor stops blades
unstoppable in the world of Dune
>>
>>224410977
Imagine harvester is a noisy cricket that somehow managed to get in your kitchen, while activated shield is a fucking mosquito hovering next to your ear.
>>
>>224411074
Yeah... but they do, or at least to the extent that the shields register them.
Shields are for bullets, which is why over thousands of years people have adapted to fight at slow frequency with blade and knives. Yet somehow, they're still consistently swinging at full speed.
>>
>>224410296
>and also making it look less like a gaping anus
Never seen a delicious blue anus, I take it?
>>
>>224411125
What does it taste like?
>>
real talk
the implication that the orifice on the right isn't really a mouth - because it doesn't close, there are no jaws because it doesn't chew, it's a hoover and a filter - underlines its existence as a semi-elemental force.
The existence of the trifold-jaw on the left makes it seem more animal, ascribes implicit actions and instincts to it. Gives it a more semi-sentient vibe.
no cap
>>
>>224411120
I think you explained it yourself there anon.
They've adapted to shields in combat for thousands of years to the point they know exactly what speed they need to fight with to get through shields.
The earlier scene is most likely exaggerated for the audience so they understand how the shields work.
>>
>>224411118
You're missing the point three-times over. I'm not arguing that in the incredibly vague, ambiguous explanation that a shield's reverberation is not more annoying than a footstep or a massive, mechanical piece of farming equipment.
I'm arguing what relevance it has, how angry a worm is, in context.
>>
File: IMG_8990.png (629 KB, 1655x617)
629 KB PNG
Which way bros?
>>
>>224411101
>So what's the difference if a worm or multiple worms is ambiguous angrier than it would have been?
The difference is your likelihood of survival, anon
>I'm begging for an answer here
So read the books
>>
>>224411044 (me)
>I don't remember if they mentioned it in the book
I meant to say in the films.
>>
>>224411170
Oh of course, it's a training scene. Paul is learning as much as the audience (or reader) is. And it's a great scene, with a great, poignant line by Gurney.
The issue derives from it being meaningless. The scene loses its meaning when the logic and lessons established fail to be upheld, to absolutely no detriment. The scene effectively becomes filler, with minor exception, that being the interpretation that the "slow knife" translates to Paul's patience for revenge, rather than exclusively to knife combat.
But that's a bit of a stretch. Because while a bit clever, it makes no real sense for Gurney to mean it like that.
>>
>>224411115
The world building of Dune is really dumb when you think about it for more than 5 seconds.
10 seconds if you are an American.
Shield reflects all objects moving at high velocity, fighters have to do tricks to get the blade through the shield slowly and then stab.
The survival depends then only on the armor or stopping the enemy from reaching you.
Somehow, for hundreds of years, humanity is unable to manufacture proper armors AND alternative weaponry that could effectively bypass both shield and armor.
This is why I'm going to defend the Lynch Dune and this is the hill I'm willing to die on: Atreides getting sentenced to death for the development of sonic weapons WAS THE SMARTEST THING I HAVE EVER SEEN IN THIS SHITTY SETTING
>>
>>224411265
I think we're just overthinking it, the whole thing boils down to a reason for not using firearms thousands of years into the future by Frank (outside of a handful of examples like Maula pistols), mainly because many other sci-fi books of the time resorted to using laser guns.
>>
>>224411219
>The difference is your likelihood of survival
Why would that be affected?
To reiterate for something like the fourth time, the whole setup for this longrunning operation is that they're gone before any worm(s) arrives. So what the actual fuck is the difference?
If I'm in a box wearing a bulletproof vest, and I have the option for you to throw one mildly-perturbed snake into it or a dozen virulent ones, why would I give a shit if I've already left the box?
>>
>>224411265
Faggots really using AI to make posts here.
>>
>>224411330
worms get there faster due to the frenzy
multiple worms from different directions
spice harvest has to be abandoned much earlier meaning a much lower yield
>>
>>224411330
>why would I give a shit if I've already left the box?
If you have nothing of value to lose there's no reason to activate a shield is there?
>>
>>224411335
get used to it
tons of datamining and bot garbage
the internet is such a fucking pile of shit nowadays
it's like the crumbling husk of an abandoned mall
>>
>>224411372
>worms get there faster due to the frenzy
That's headcanon.
>multiple worms from different directions
Easier to spot
>spice harvest has to be abandoned much earlier meaning a much lower yield
That's only if they actually arrive significantly earlier, which you made up.
The funniest part? There's no established use of using shields (or any method) as bait to distract from harvesting. As in, you're planning to harvest X, so use bait far away at Y to attract the worms in the immediate area. Now you not only have a pinpoint on the majority of the worms and can track them, you can actively lure them away from your harvester for an extended, calculable amount of time.
Whoa...
>>
>>224411335
You know you can reverse-check if a paragraph was AI-generated, right? I encourage you to do so.
Might amaze you to learn not everybody's as illiterate as you. Where do you think AI learned it from? Not from fuckin' retards like yourself, I guarantee you.
>>
File: 1502147242459.jpg (21 KB, 325x325)
21 KB JPG
>watching Dunc 2
>Feyd Rautha is portrayed as a cunning genius strategist who can turn the tide of the war against the Fremen
>his plan?
>bomb the Fremen base with artillery from a safe distance instead of trying to fight them in hand-to-hand combat where the Fremen thrive
>nobody else ever thought of this until he got there
does this same thing happen in the books?
>>
>>224411373
No offense, and I know a lot of people are going through rough times so I genuinely hope you're doing okay, but believe it or not I do value my life.
I imagine most of the in-universe people in question do too, but I suppose that's projection, since they're largely just faceless goons.
>>
>>224410418
The ground patrol and aerial surveillance should be the last resort. There should be some infrastructure to alert everybody of the incoming sandworm hours before it's too late.
You know, something you could expect in the most important place in the galaxy, where a critical resource that keeps things running is being manufactured.
I know it's based on airplanes patrolling the sea around naval vessels to spot any hint of submarine getting close, but fuck, Herbert is really a hack.
Speaking of which, I can't stand how the urban centers on Dune are always depicted as underdeveloped shitholes, ignoring the real life development of oil countries in the Middle East. Obnoxiously rich, gaudy city - dirty medieval village a dozen kilometers outside of the suburbs - desert with some violent retards. Dubai was already a developed place when Herbert started to write his stuff.
>>
>>224411486
Oh so you're just a thesaurus redditor, same shit.
>>
>>224411530
What's a thesaurus?
>>
File: Annotation 2026-11-22 3.jpg (51 KB, 1828x140)
51 KB JPG
>>224411512
>I do value my life.
Then why turn a shield on?
>>
>>224411505
>he can turn the tide of the war
>his plan? It's X
Find AI posters, behead AI posters, mutilate the corpses of AI posters
Fuck thinking machines
Ted Kaczynski was too soft
Butlerian jihad NOW
>>
is Part Three going to retcon the ending of Part Two? I'm trying to figure out how an adaptation of Messiah makes any sense with the way they changed the ending, unless the opening is just a "lol just jking" rug pull.
>>
If a giant worm attacks you the shield is useless anyway, but there are Fremen who are constantly attacking your harvesting operation so you're better off having the shield on
>>
>>224411559
To protect from the more immediate, known threats, in this context the Fremen.
>>
>>224411476
You should read the Dune Encyclopedia (approved by FH), a lot of the things you're talking about were already mentioned in there:
>PSEUDO-SHIELD. A sabotage device designed for use only on Arrakis. It. produced an unusable field that emitted radiation like a true defensive shield, driving sandworms berserk.
>Nothing could stop a worm that had been aroused by this maddeningly painful device.
>The huge creature would attack and destroy the pseudo-shield and all nearby objects.
>>
>>224411580
Messiah is fucking garbage to begin with so it's best to be ignored entirely. I'm fine with Dunc 3 being fanfic
>>
>Spends the second half of his career resurrecting dead franchises
Is Villenueve too much of a fanboy for his own good?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.