gonna get the obvious ones out of the way first
>>719523672Resident Evil
>>719523672bait
>>719523672That wiiware gameboy castlevania remake. The original game is terrible
>>719524951The only real answer
>MM3D>"surpassed the original"I remember when bait used to be believable.
>>719523672Neither of these are remakes, they are remasters.Hell, OOT literally has no gameplay changes other than bug fixes and gyro aim
>>719523672People will fight over the switch remaster but the gameboy color remaster was amazing.
>>719525440DX is the best version of LA. Even Nintendo realized this since they put it on NSO years after the remake came out.
>>719523672The only one that comes even close is FF Origins. 99.9% of remakes are shit.
>>719523672RE4 HD projectResident evil 1Wind waker HDPokemon soul silver/HeartGold
MM3D is an abomination, it literally would've been better if it was a rushed turn-and-burn like OoT3D.
>>719525341Yes, it absolutely did. The original is a ridiculously flawed game and the remake at least tries to make up for the faults of that. OoT's remake, OTOH has more minimal changes, but the actual improvements it makes just don't offset the flaws it introduces and on the whole it's not worth playing over the original.
>>719525341the benefits that outclass the original is a mile long avalanche of a list
OoT maybe because the QoL is great along with gyro aim, though the style mind of sucks.MM, no. They made great QoL and went overboard with improvements. They circled back and made some shit a lot worse as a result. Tons of unnecessary changes
>>719529135wassup aonuma?
>>719525236ReBirth isn't a remake, honestly. It has almost nothing in common with the original.
>>719525236It's unreal just what an upgrade Belmont's Revenge was. They fixed all the big issues with Adventure.
>>719523672ALTTP is a better game than NES Legend of Zelda.
>>719523672RE4R i dont give a fuck if any nerds think otherwise. original absolutely GAPED by the remake
>>719531684ALttP isn't remotely a remake of the first game unlike Oracle of Seasons, or ALBW for ALTTP, or is it as good.
>>719523672>MM3D vanilla>Surpassing the originalIf it were with Project Restoration, I'd agree. Otherwise, PICK ONE AND ONLY ONE.
>>719523672>MM3D>taking Koizumi's baby and Aonumaifying it>good
I liked OoT3D a lot. I never played MM3D because it seemed casualized to oblivion.
off the top of my head the positives that make it objectively superior are-the clock now displays the full cycle and even minutes-the clock now doesn't fade when performing an action-the clock runs 33% faster making for a slightly more tense game-3 save file slots instead of just 2-save files retain time & date of last played-save points added to the beginning of dungeons-song of double time allows selecting specific hour-gyroscopic aiming-red dot added to aiming-target retical signals if something is hookshotable-stereoscopic glassesless 3D-high detail map displayed on bottom screen-dungeon fairies and chests shown on the map-an additional item button-in addition to ocarina having a permanent button-in addition to the pictobox having a permanent button-songs are displayed on bottom screen while playing ocarina-fishing locations have been added-an entire suite of fish to catch including a fish boss-location of important NPCs in more convenient locations-stuff like only being able to get upgraded wallet on day one fixed-stone mask is obtained in the location it's most useful now-analog camera when using New 3DS or Circle Pad Pro-goron rolling is now a toggle instead of a hold-spikes added to deku link's spin-deku link now requires a build up to speed-the R trigger can be pressed while flying to display where you will land-zora link's default swim offers far more control for navigating tight corridors-the boomerangs can be recalled instantly by pressing B again-can play the instrument underwater now-pulling back on epona will perform a 180 in that direction along with a speed boost-Link has additional expressions of animation
-bomber notebook is now highly detailed and tracks useful information-now includes more entries, a schedule, and a new events section, which includes ongoing, rumored, and completed events-can even set an alarm to a specific time to be reminded of any event-a new optional hint system has been added to the clocktower-game runs at 30fps instead of 20fps, the menus run at 60fps-touchscreen item management means less menu navigation-fire, ice, and light arrows are their own item and can all be assigned-boss battles have added phases to the fight-new animations are added to the giant mask-new shortcuts to the southern swamp and pirate fortress-an additional bottle added to the game in a new sidequest-mask of truth reveals hidden grottos-cutscenes are shortened after the first time they're watched-song of soaring cutscene is skippable-B button makes Link climb faster-redeads even have additional dance moves
Big fan of the recent Star Ocean 2 remake.
>>719534219>-the clock runs 33% faster making for a slightly more tense gameNot a good thing and seems like a genuine error because the balancing always made more sense for how it used to be>-zora link's default swim offers far more control for navigating tight corridorslol fucking bullshit, it was perfectly controllable before>-boss battles have added phases to the fightMM bosses suck either way but the only one improved is Twinmold and that's because Twinmold in the first place was the worst boss in the game, they still managed to fuck it up with the giant phase feeling like absolute dogshitMost of the other "changes" are minor enough that worse transformations are nearly entirely dragging the game down and the only genuine improvement are the visuals and the UI. Who the fuck cares about redeads dancing or fishing that doesn't tie into anything in the game and rewards nothing of value when they made Deku Palace and GBT easier for absolutely no reason? Luckily Project Restoration exists and if Nintendo knows what's good they'll pick up a few clues from it once they decide to make new ports. With PR fixing major missteps it does become one of the best versions of the game though of course it's still easier in some places.
>listing the nerfed Deku Link/Zora Link abilities and the pace-breaking Bomber's Notebook as "objective positives"Yeah he's just farming for (You)s lol
>>719523672
>>719534721It's not a bad thing either, and it really helps cut through some of the arguments about it being easier when the main mechanic is pressing down on the players that much more. Zora link controls in the fast speed mode exactly like Superman 64 does flying. That's not great when you just want a little bit of precision for a location right next to the player. Having a default swim be more precise as an option is a general good. Magic usage isn't really a huge deal considering how little magic was used in the original, and the new location of obtaining the double meter being "easier", and alongside a new bottle (bringing the total to SEVEN) a player can even encouraged to spend rupees that largely went unused originally, in a game that generally gives the player the items they need when needed anyway including magic power. I didn't mind the boss battles in the original, but one thing I always wanted was being able to fight Morpha in the water in Ocarina of Time, and MM3D essentially gives me that fulfillment during the second phase.
>>719534883How ADHD are you that you label a more practical utility for completion a "pace breaker".
>>719535119No, ADHD is no longer making it optional, needing the game to interrupt you way more often, and having slow animations instead of making notifications instant like the original.
The animations in the 3D remakes are so fucking dogshit that any objective improvement one could possibly list will never be enough to make up it.
3DS Twinmold is better3DS Gyorg is better3DS Goht is worseOdolwa is a huge nothingburger in both versions
>>719535337I dont mind it, but then again I'm no speedrunning tranny.
>>719535936>I like having shit shoveled down my throat because it heckin owns someone else
>>719523672>Remakes that genuinely surpassed the original releases>gonna get the obvious ones out of the way first>posts two remastershuh?
>>719536885He's just trying to stir shit by defending MM3D.
