>dude!>the music, dude!>classical music, dude!>it's just like my favorite anime OST, dude!
>>720195268this but for Castlevania SOTN
>>720195268Only it’s good
also gamers>MERRY MERRY MERRY X-MAS>MEMORY FASCIAS>SEPHIROTH!!!11GENIUS I T_T ERRY TIEM
>>720195268the expedition 33 soundtrack seems to REALLY appeal to people with little to no authentic personal music taste. like it just "seems" good in the same way the girl from evanescence "seems" like a good singer, fooling the most impressionable despite being just uninspired and middlebrowthe soundtrack is boring as hell
I look like this and say this
>>720195268Americans only listen to nigger rap and souless pop female singers so I never expected you to appreciate real music.
>>720195268anime hardly features such OST you retard
I dunno, those electric guitar vs violin solo duels are pretty cool.
>>720195268Tbf the music in this game was pretty dope
>>720195268>E33 threads>People Sucking it off like it's second coming of Christ or >People being upset about the most retarded stuff.
>>720195268meds
>>720199369your forgot the 3rd option:>That guy who thinks he's the main character "voice of reason" but is really just a fence-sitting bitch
>>720197231>appeal to people with little to no authentic personal music tasteCan I get a single source for this claim?
>>720195268Pretty generic soundtrack desu. It's like Bloodborne's soundtrack where people blow smoke up its ass but no one can remember a thing about it
>>720196973https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpnrUbnLb68ah yes my favourite piece of classical music
>>720200716Yeah that's the>it's just like my favorite anime OST, dude!one instead
>>720200605>he forgot Ludwig's themeAre you being retarded on purpose? Ludwig's theme is OBJECTIVELY the greatest soundtrack in video game history
>>720200792It sounds like the rest of the soundtrack. It's fine. Good even. It fits the tone of the game
>>720200448It means he doesn't like it, but he has to try and pretend his opinion holds authority over any other
>>720195268https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=61wbti7tIHwThis is my fav just because it turns into a club banga out of fucking nowhere
>>720195268Gonna be honest i found the music really bad. Way too many vocal songs and nothing really catch u can listen to on repeat. Most average Jrpg have better and a more balanced soundtrack.
>>720197231it’s catchy and people like that. dumbass.
>>720200774What are some anime OSTs that sound like that?
>>720195268It's bad, most Japanese games shit on it. Any FF clears it easily
>>720200920honestly you're a philistine and also the reason why videogames music is stagnating
>>720195268Not with those guitars lmao
>>720201825That's because everyone with a guitar is now a game music composer
>>720197231>mumble rap my beloved
>>720195268there was only one track that i enjoyed (that one battle theme with the choir coming in)
>>720197231I like Poppy more, Titanic Sinclair hit gold with her. Who the fuck do I still remember that guys name? The guy who stalked Mars Argo after they stopped working together
>>720195268This but for Parodius
Most reddit game of all time
>>720197231I have worked in the music industry for a decade and I think it's good. You're just a contrarian fag
>>720202393>I have worked in the music industry for a decade and I think it's good.Imagine believing this gives you any kind of authority. shut up you stupid faggot.
>>720202393While it's been going downhill then
>>720202363You """people""" pick a new "Most reddit game of all time" every year.
>>720202560No, it's this.
>>720197231The people who make posts like this are usually metaltards going through their "Just branching out into early 2010s /mu/core" phase.
>>720202560Because its good and anyone here will shit on anything
>>720202510It does, i'm literally better and more informed than you
I like it quite a lot and I'm very much into classical music and travel europe just to go to concerts
>>720202642give me one example of a good artist
>>720200605I can't remember any Souls games soundtrack, it's not as good as any JRPG. I've never even heard of people praising their soundtracks.
>>720203009Souls games are mostly silent except for bosses and main hub anyway
>>720203005Nickelback
post your favorite track from this game because from what little I've heard I cringe at.
>>720197231I don't give a shit about "authentic music", things that sound good sound good.
>>720203431https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Akplrzf5CkEI really liked this one
>>720203431Stop posting on a video game board and play the fucking game.
>>720203431https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gOD5DnkdEmY underrated piano piece that plays v quietly in the background of one of the zones.
>>720195268>nooooooooooooooooooooo game bad because... because people like the soundtrack!
>>720197231Seriously nigger, post your favourite game OST to back up your gay arguement. Exp 33 OST is pretty good and fits to the game's logic
>>720203860it's a long ass rpg game that looks (imo) ugly.I only play games that I'm already familiar with and give immediate action.
>>720195268Do you guys even like videogames?
>>720195268>classicalIt isn't classical.
>>720204815You don't understand, it's recorded with a live orchestra and the instruments are all made of wood, strings and brass. Therefore it has to be classical.
>>720195268shit game
>>720195268just enjoy some good music for a change, you dummyhttps://youtu.be/IunbXWab1_Y
>>720199541Have your tried it?It's a nice fence and view is good.
Why did no one tell me Ben Starr is actually a pretty good singer?
>another E33 thread where 7R schizos desperately try to convince everyone that nobody actually liked the gameI see we're at the "you didn't even like the music, you just think you did because you never heard music before" stage of the crashout
>samples actual classic musichttps://youtu.be/eY7nNo8JgNo
>>720203431They're very different from the rest of the game, but I like the Gestral music like these twohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w0AgYnUpSPEhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcEdif_2PNY
>>720197231Thought "Flying Waters" was excellent. But I'm also a Nash '92 poster on /pw/.https://youtu.be/Ms4Mmb9kY4E?si=d-6FUbned8-JatsL
>>720197231evanescence is fucking awesome faggot
>>720195268Shit game, shit genre, reminds me why all Final Fantasy games are shit and barely games at all, essentially a light puzzle visual novel and I fucking hate them
For me it's Une vie à peindre.This is the one where they FINALLY get the heavy metal guitarist loose and he's not holding back.
>>720205525Im glad Im not the only one who loves this song the most out of Exp33's audio list
>>720195268there are maybe two or three tracks on the entire soundtrack that could be considered classical, you absolute fucking moron
>>720202363the one non-pozzed game to come out of the west in years and you call it the most reddit game of all time? nice try, tranny
>>720200920It’s a soundtrack that grows on you, I find. I agree there are too many vocal tracks, but there are still plenty of standouts.
>>720206317It has women in it, therefore it's pozzed.
>>720205768When it kicked in I was like, so it really is a JRPG after all
>>720200920>Way too many vocal songsthat's good thoughvery Nier / FFXIII-2
>>720206941Just admit you are gay
>>720206941Real life has women and blacks in it unfortunately.
>>720208773Real life is pozzed. We should burn it all to the ground.Owari da.
>>720208773yeah but in E33 the women are all attractive and the blacks all die
I would knock Clea up with so many hapa children.
>>720209391Calm down asianon.
>>720197231Post your top 5 compositions now.
>>720197231Bring me to life has 1.5B views on YouTube, lower your tone when speaking of her.
>>720197231Least schizopheric E33 hater
>>720209391...you meant Lune?Clea is very French.
Not gonna lie lads Golra would get it raw til I'm picking splinters out of my cock with tweasers
>>720195268This is an 8 hour long album. How much of the music is actually good and how much of this is filler? Whenever I see people discuss this it's usually the same 3-5 tracks mentioned.
>>720197231You're trying way too hard
>>720199261>anime hardly features such OST you retard>Dancinghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4tEj6gXA_eA>Panoramahttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QA3JD5BL1r4>Vitalis' Songhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yp9sdsHuNAI
>>720202363>un-Wokest game of the year>reddit gamelol
>>720211642Verso was a horny little fucker
>>720204815>>720204917it literally has a real classical music in it, Lorian remixed it lolhttps://youtu.be/ZGya_P6wa1o?list=PLI0_h8FqQIs3pcDzzO8AOdVLN-FqCA4sO&t=66https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHmwEy2Y_jU
>>720211748there are some standouts of course but the songs that are actually in the game are all greatI haven't listened to the entire 8 hour ost on its own though
>>720195268How can westoids even compete?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJpVx32HCSU&list=RDpJpVx32HCSU&start_radio=1
>>720211748to me, there's hardly any bad music in there, they're all really decent, and a few of them absolutely amazing, for a 8 hours album that's really impressive
>>720203431https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=okDFpK2v46o
>>720212083I love Xenoblade Chronicles X, but its ost is really Hans Himmeresque, that's really mid if you ask me, I much prefer the ost of the first Xenoblade (Mitsuda my goat)
>>720211883it's troons false flagging attempting to claim a based game as their own, plus seething tendies and the couple ff/atlus schizos who hate everything but their own favorite seriessame faggots who always say shit like "e33 mogs every jrpg ever, every jrpgs made in Japan is dogshit" when in reality actual jrpgchads love E33
>>720212151I"ll agree that X has probably some of Sawano's weakest work and it's very derivative of like UC Unicorn's OST
>>720203701it's a really good one, but I'm french so I find it cliché as fuck, I've heard this sonority too often in my baguette life lol
>>720203431https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpNVf8sczqUthat one is amazing
>>720200605Bloodborne is the only Fromsoft game I remember the soundtrack of, all souls ost sounds like one song just slightly remixed and Sekiro and AC6 weren't memorable
>>720211642>When she goes Super SaiyanVerso, you little weeb
>>720208773>Real life has women and blacks in it unfortunately.in 1895 there weren't many blacks in France though
>>720195268every song sounds the same.I'm sorry, but I can't bring myself to like it, the execution is perfect, the musicians are clearly talented but the entire game sounds the same with only a few standouts like the monoco's theme.and while I'm at it, every location looks the same too >explore new area, it's a bunch of reused assets sprinkled on natural terrain but now with blue tint instead of brownfor a game that is themed around artistry, it's really bleak and uninspired
>>720212769>and while I'm at it, every location looks the same too >explore new area, it's a bunch of reused assets sprinkled on natural terrain but now with blue tint instead of brownyou didn't play the game
>>720212769true, that's the weakest point of Clair Obscure, you feel like there's no unique zone at all, it's always the same thing, empty space with monsters you have to kill, that's it, and only 2 cities in total? bruh... I felt like playing FF13 all over again except that Clair Obscure has a great story, that helps a lot
>>720212921The game felt like the inverse of FF13. Tells its story well but the environments look bad.
>>720213247>Tells its story wellnah I can't agree with that, FF13 doesn't tell its story well, it's so surface level, if you want to know the deep lore you have to read those fucking wall of text in the menu, like wtf, I'm here to experience a story, not read a book on a menu, that completly missed the point, and they fixed that on FF13-2 fortunately
>>720213406re-read what you replied to
>>720195268>classical music, dude!It's just inspired from early 20th century french music. It's far from classical. And most of it sucks, particularly the Act 3 open world music that features some bitch wailing about seeing and feeling.
>>720195268Silksong has a better OST.
One of the most based OSTs ever https://youtu.be/US5rdot8wmk
>>720213617>It's just inspired from early 20th century french music.not all >>720211950
>>720211950A couple remixed songs don't make the soundtrack classical. Quit being a midwit thinking you have some kind of gotcha when you find 1 or 2 counter examples. It makes you look like a child who thinks they are genius when they point out bonzai trees are tiny so "Check mate people who say trees are large!"
>>720213820Already answered you, pseud. >>720213914
>>720213914>>720213989I don't get that argument though, the composer never stated that his work was about classical music, he uses classical instruments and has modernized chords and structure on top of that
>>720195268>/v/ confirming they're all philistine zoomersLol, go listen to your four on the floor house music, retarded shits. You've proven yet again you're incapable of appreciating the finer things. Pearls before swine.
>>720205646Imagine how much better this world would be if you could die in your sleep tonight :3
>>720205646must be a sad life to not enjoy jrpg's though, that's the genre that has the best stories and feels
>>720214374admitting to not liking jrpgs is just announcing that you're a newfag zoomer tourist
>>720197231Hating popular things doesn't make you an interesting person.
>>720214129There are definitely some nods to classical music besides the instrumentation. Lumiere for instance is a straight up baroque chamber quintet, with the straight forward repetitive modal harmony and counterpoint mixed in. Much of the music is of course influenced from French folk music as well. Although like any video game score it does borrow mostly from 20th century film music.
>>720215098I'm 33 and have been on 4chan since February 2007 and I strongly dislike anime, JRPGs and otaku culture in general
>>720195268>dude you gotta play it, it's GOTYIt's mid>dude you gotta listen to the OSTIt's mid.Why does this happen every year? People are now saying HK loli bug is GOTY too and it's just as mid as HK was
>>720215098>newfag who wasn't around for the XIII meltdowns and the jarpig shitpostinglol
>>720216262at some point the ability to have fun relies on (You)
>>720216286that's because FF13 sucks, that doesn't undermine the beautiful story of jrpg's, but for that you need to be old enough to not be considered a zoomer
>>720197231An Opera director who doesn't even like vidya music listened to the Exp33 soundtrack and fell in love with it. Here are his credentials from the video description so he blows your little rant out of the water.>Aaron Grant’s diverse experience in the music industry includes six years with Opus 3 Artists Management in New York working with a roster of acclaimed singers, conductors, and special attractions, as well as four seasons as Assistant Director of Artistic Operations at Music Academy of the West where he oversaw activities of the voice and opera departments alongside Program Director Marilyn Horne, before being promoted to Director of Artistic Administration of the Vocal Institute. >As Founder and Managing Director of Third Bridge Media, he managed the digital profiles for an exclusive roster of internationally renowned artists and emerging stars.>He received the Doctor of Music degree in vocal pedagogy from Florida State University in 2011.https://youtu.be/QxRzhoB7nb8?si=4WzKK-EOJI2b8-te&t=4380
>>720211804thanks for proving my point3 anime of which the youngest is 20 years old and the oldest almost 50
>>720216352There's plenty of decent fun games being made. Still makes no sense why some mid game is GOTY. Ask them to explain why and they can't
>>720217178>There's plenty of decent fun games being madesuch as?
>>720197231you really made the shills seethe with this one
>>720217248Just because I had fun with games doesn't mean I'll go around saying they deserve awards. Especially for the games that need patches + all DLC to be worth playing
>>720216607>a youtuber overreacted for views and since I'm a zoomer faggot with no thought of my own I fell for it (again)Happy for you
>>720216607>pircelI love the face she made towards Verso at that moment, you can feel she is still angry at him from not saving Gustave, deep inside she wants him to suffer, and that's why I choose the Maelle's ending, I don't like Verso he's a snake lol (and Esquie's the goat)
>>720217361come on anon, tell me your personal goty so I can shit on it as well
>>720217449
>>720216607the more expert you are at something, the more you lose the grasp on what the masses enjoy about that something
>>720216607>An Opera director who doesn't even like vidya music listenedYeah no shit, look at that selection of other garbage he had him listen to. Of course this was going to stand out.
>>720217780That sounds like a really cool soundbite, until you start to think about it for five seconds and realise it's fucking retarded.The Top Gear boys were experts at knowing cars inside and out, reviewing, driving e.t.c. and were still very aware and promoted 'hot hatchbacks' which are small affordable cars because. They knew about Supercars they knew about affordable cars and one of their favourite cars of all time was a bog standard Ford Mondeo. The point here is, your soundbite appeals to the retard who likes to delegate thinking to headlines.
>>720218129it doesn't work like that, if he listened to 3/10 musics and then listens to a 6/10 music (according to you), he won't call it a 8/10 music just to please the other guy, that opera director doesn't really care about hurting's feelings, he just tells as it is, so if he finds the music good, then he genuinely believes ithttps://youtu.be/QxRzhoB7nb8?t=4831
>>720218176well it happens with music more than anything. that's why there are so many one hit wonders
>>720216138Imagine being here for 18 years and still not belongingt. 05chad >>720216286XIII is shit and came out at a grim time for jrpg's, of course we were disillusioned then. XIII was supposed to redeem the piece of shit that killed the series (XII)
>>720218415>XIII was supposed to redeem the piece of shit that killed the series (XII)I don't agree with that, 13 is complete ass, but 13-2 and 13-3 are pretty good, they listened to complains and improved their product
>>720218291>then listens to a 6/10 music (according to you)Don't believe I ever made such a claim.
>>720218483I'll be honest I didn't play 13-2 or 13-3 because I couldn't make it through 13I skipped 15 too
>>720218618you did, you made the argument that that music would stand out because he only listened to garbage for an hour straight before, not because it's a genuine good music, and that's a retarded argument, I wanted you to understand that
>>720218629yeah fair, desu I wouldn't have touched at ff 13-2 if I started with 13, but I started with 13-2 and loved it (I stopped at 5 hours into the game because I wanted to know the original lore first), so I forced myself to finish ff13 so I could experience fully ff13-2, maybe you should do the same, get a taste of ff13-2 and if you feel that's a great game that'll give you the motivation to finish ff13
>>720216745>3 anime of which the youngest is 20 years old and the oldest almost 50All of which were incredibly popular and normalfag tier within Japan.If you want classical music in anime, try World Masterpiece Theatre, or Princess Tutu, even implicitly modern works like SAO use plenty of classical or classical styled music.I honestly wouldn't be surprised if Clair de Lune and Moonlight Sonata saw more usage in anime then in most other non-music mediums.
>>720218415>XIII was supposed to redeem the piece of shit that killed the series (XII)Newfag
>>720218383The masses made Bowie, the Beatles, Prince all popular the masses know what is good music if given a platform to listen.The problem with modern popular music are the producers who have decided to manufacture music to such an extent it's become a formula, not in the sense of music theory but pop music itself is a strict formula now that producers work from. The Singer itself is irrelevent in modern pop music, which is why video game music is a breath of fresh air for a lot of music lovers because it doesn't adhere to those strict formulas there are still composers, people who write music, and it is enjoyable exp33's OST for example was top Billboard number 1. This is proof that people do enjoy composed music, but the difference is in the platform.How do a lot of people hear music in the first place, how do they discover it? From the radio or t.v. shows or advertisements right? Which means those shows have strict time schedules and radios have strict time slots they need to adhere to for advertisement placements, or the music itself needs to fit the theme of the show upbeat music for example fitting a morning breakfast programme you're not going to have Alicia from Exp33 play in the morning on the radio commute to work.
>>720217348People are going to be confused when you point at a bar of solid gold and aggressively insist that it's actually a compact bar of shitTake your meds
>>720218792maybe I'll try that because I do actually want to get through them and 15 sometime only because they're the only mainline games I haven't played
kinohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1-DSn_6eRQ&list=RD3kMbTzomh94&index=2
>>720218704It is good music, I never claimed otherwise, but you're using this guy's opinion to legitimize that it's so good "even someone who hates vidya music" can like it. But if his frame of reference to vidya music is total dogshit then that doesn't mean much.
>>720219257the lyrics spoil the story a lot, but the language is a mix between french, latin and something he invented, so even as a french I didn't understand shit (as it should, would be terrible to be spoiled by the fucking OST of all things lol)
>>720218946>The masses made Bowie, the Beatles, Prince all popularYou realize that people who considered themselves music afficianados of the time thought The Beatles and Prince were hacky, and that Bowie himself was a borderline one hit wonder until he started drugging himself 24/7, right?
>>720218946>The masses made Bowie, the Beatles, Princeindustry plants, the music industry is 99% fake since the jews took over.I agree with the rest
>>720219710>industry plants, the music industry is 99% fake since the jews took over.it was always the case, hip hop was invented in the 70's because they were tired of the slop in the radio, so they made their own genre to prove a point
>>720218886so anime invented classical music? its just silly to say because a game has orchestra its "anime" because most anime and I mean the ovewhelming majority doesnt use it and we both know it but I give you an exception from this decade as a sign of goodwill, pic related uses moonlight sonatawestern media also constantly uses classical pieces especially the ones you mentioned, hell clair du lune is the main theme of oceans eleven
>>720197231I don't really like Evanescence, but Amy Lee is objectively a good singer, she can perform live up to standard and has become a millionaire in doing so, it seems you have a case of being a teen contrarian faggot.
>>720220714>so anime invented classical music?Nobody said that.What was said was that anime utilizes a lot of classical music.>its just silly to say because a game has orchestra its "anime" because most anime and I mean the ovewhelming majority doesnt use itThe majority do use classical and operatic style music at various points. It's so prevalent that Dragon Ball's Japanese music is often called "Godzilla music" by English speakers due to its heavy usage of orchestral arrangements.
IIIIIIIII FEEEEEEELLLLLLL YOOOOUUUU
>>720218176eh it do be like that sometimessee tf2 where most people dont give a shit about comp or nocritsor current day eminem making rap tech demos instead of cool rap songsor bodybuilding which started with aesthetic physiques and degenerated into shapeless meatball fetishor powerlifting with its 2 inch rom benchpressat least bb and pl are walking their bullshit back a little
>>720216607>>720218291>guile's theme is boring and generic but necrodancer trailer's beat is fun and adventurous in comparisonbig yikes from me, senpai
HE GAVE HIS LIFE FOR MINEBLAH BLAH DE BLAH HOOPLAH DEMY BROOOTHER HIS LOVE WILL LIVE ONthat loop was WAY too short for that one endless tower stage
>>720219603There's a few in English and one track with German words, a lot in French and in old Occitan. A lot is mangled speech messing the grammar. He used the last one because no one would spontaneously understand the spoken lyrics that spoil the story (it's half understandable if you read them) aside from some guys that reads the original troubadours.
>>720221804Genuinely, one of if not my favourite song out of the entire soundtrack. The love of a sibling giving their life selflessly for another, well I say selflessly but it's through love is a deeply powerful thing. The survivors guilt the Alicia feels is so haunting. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Duwx1L3JYI&list=RD1Duwx1L3JYI&start_radio=1
The music is fucking terrible , guess you have to be a brainwashed tranny cultist to enjoy such generic slop
>>720222321>The love of a sibling giving their life selflessly for anothertrue, and what Clea said was powerful aswell>he sacrificed his life for you, and I don't know if I should be proud or angry at himmeaning that she knows there was no good choice in that situation, both were valid, your life or your sibling's life
>subhumans dislike classical musicNot really surprised
>>720222672no one said that shilltranny
>>720222602Yeah, it's clear Clea is still hurting from Verso's death but ultimately as you say deep down there was no right or wrong answer, if he didn't sacrifice himself then Alicia would have died which is why Clea says she loves him for that, but also sacrificed himself and died which is why she hates him because she misses him so much.
>>720222835no one cares gay nigger
>>720223023shut the fuck up troon, you are brown you don't know subtlety, it went all over your small head
>>720223127you post like a bitch ass nigger kek
It's a good soundtrack. The only reason to listen to it after playing the game is to reminisce about playing the game. (Which isn't a knock against it by the way).
>>720223023Cringe>>720223127Based
Why do you guys have to be so rude to each other? Can't we all just be brothers and sisters?
>>720223127cringe >>720223023based>>720223191based and hetero aryan>>720223230cringe and brown faggot
>>720223263e33 is inherently a faggy estrogen fueled game for homosexuals, trannies, and morbidly obese cat ladies with toxoplasmosis so the cultists are extremely emotional
>>720223263Some people think to fit in here you need to be as edgy as possible. It makes talking about a game, threads tiresome.
>>720223470Makes sense.
>>720223512meant for>>720223445
>>720223445it's the least woke game of the year, even the devs are all white lol
>>720223546>posted within 22 secondsYou're bad at this anon
>posted it again awarde33s strongest shill tranny is always on duty
>>720223654why are they all jewish and ugly women?
.
>dumping xer entire brown folderI won
>>720223830who looks jewish according to that picture?
>>720195268>european classical music is anime musicstick to sharting up those walmarts, incel, this isn't your area of expertise. and lose some of that weight,you're an eyesore
>>720223985obviously everyone but nice try moshe
>>720223883They don't think it be like it is, but it do.
>>720201489A lot of the Utena insert songs, as well as Outlaw Star/Gundam Wing era Kohei Otani stuff.
>>720223654>fr*nch>white
>>720224075>everyone I don't like is jewishI'm sure you have plenty of proof of that, not providing evidence is a jewish tactic btw
>>720224140>kike is already seethinglmao
>>720197231Agreed it's a bland OST. It has some good boss and cutscene themes, but man is the zone music BORING. 90% of the games music is bland and nothing melodic or interesting.
>>720224201>doesn't provide evidence of his baseless claimpost your node moshe
>>720224101Yes, yes, only the purest of anglo-saxons (ironically a mix by it's very name) count as real white people muttoid.
>enemy you only encounter at most 7 times>has the most kino non boss theme in the gamehttps://youtu.be/u2VKoynKctw?si=RCr_-auYVsbyoaCe
>>720224632>defending the tribe this hardkike moment
>>720224684frogtranny seethe, France is literally a nigger muslim country
>>720195268it's winning GOTY and there's nothing you can do but cope and seethe.
>>720197231>desperate weeb clings onto whatever he can
>>720197231post your favorite music you contrarian faggot.
>>720195268I wanted to go to the concert but it sold out in 5 minutes
>>720225164yup, it sold incredibly fastI fucked up my only chance in the span of like 10 minutes when there was still a decent amount of seats available and I wanted to check in with my brother whether I should buy a ticket for him as well, and when I got the go-ahead it was sold out
>>720225164You can buy a scalped ticket, inflated prices I know but check ebay or whatever French equivalent there is for scalped tickets. Plus if it sold out so fast that means demand is incredibly high which means they'll absolutely put on more concerts in future.
>>720225164I hope the world tour wont just be in the biggest cities but it probably will
Why did this game get 0 fanart compared to Stellar Blade, a game that came out within a similar timeframe?
>>720228010because people who played that game aren't gooners (unlike stellar blade), they respect their characters
>>720228010look at the xitter retard. Sorry western fan art doesn’t get uploaded to anime boorus.
>>720228145>>720228191It literally has less then 800 post on rule34 (western) for a game that has been praised this much that is much beyond pathetic.
>>720228428>rule34lol
I genuinely love Alines theme and motif https://youtu.be/vGVeDm4118Q?si=w8wUmiBlbOTsTzc_https://youtu.be/XVIVOoeocMY?si=fbdmaaez60u040YF
>>720228010>>720228428>WHY IS THERE NO PORN! THERE'S NO WAY IT CAN BE POPULAR WITHOUT PORN
>>720228145French people are just ugly as sin.
>>720228716poor Aline :'(
>>720197231Hi /mu/
>>720228863>Lune is ugly, that's why we don't see her on rule34are you joking?
>>720195268>>it's just like my favorite anime OST, dude!I'd personally say that it's better.
>>720203431https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oeFkb3LsmlQFlying Waters was when things clicked for me. That whole area was pretty comfy
>>720229016Lune isn't french
You can tell there are no valid criticisms to this game based on the posts ITT.
>>720224097>Utena insert songsUtena's insert songs are just zeuhl/avant-prog and are an outlier in anime soundtracks. Plus they don't really sound like Exp33's soundtrack at all.
>>720229393I think you need to read the discussion again, it's about "Why are the main characters from Clair Obscur not often featured on coom sites like rule34?", and the answer isn't that because they're all ugly, it's because we respect those characters and this transcend coom
>>720229481You should've have seen the attempts at shitposting for the first months of this game.It was quite literally people throwing shit at wall ,making up shit and spamming as much as possible and it all failed.
>>720229612>they're all ugly
>>720229707Your reading comprehension skills are unmatched.
>>720195268hello Saar
>>720229707that's what I said? Lune is beautiful, so she should theorically be spammed on rule34, it's not the case, because the Clair Obscure fans aren't coomers and respect their characters
>>720195268>people enjoy something>seething thread pops up on /v/Lol its just music it ain't that deep fella
>>720229802I have cumbrain fatigue
>>720195268It's a video game SOUNDTRACK you fucking impressionable children, you are supposed to listen to it while PLAYING THE GAME. It sounds amazing when you hear it for the first time because it amplifies the experience that you are PLAYING at that moment, such as wandering in Lumiere and taking in that magical lore and world design, or the dramatic battle agaisnt Renoir, or the theme of any of the areas, which also step into the battle themes. You listen to it again and it feels great again because you relive the joy of playing that part of the game that the track came from. It is the game that makes the soundtrack work. There isn't any video game soundtrack that would work in a vacuum except for a few vocal tracks. E33 just happens to have a few good ones but they are not even that special to warrant the cum-in-your-pants excitement that all you immature uncultured children get from it.
I like the dualliste ost, it fits the fight so well and is part of why it's so fun. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HF11KimKdFo
>>720197231they didn’t like this one chief
>>720212083That's nothing, now watch this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bMfvZmhqW0A
All time great soundtrack achieved and hall of fame spot secured. Your turn is next e33, dont blow it and let donkey kong steal your spot.
Ah yes, classical musichttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_r2iKZ1NWTUhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcEdif_2PNY
>>720197231What, so it's fake good?
>>720230235Retard, back in the day people actively bought and listened to movie soundtracks, there's millions on vinyl
>>720197231>*tips fedora*
>>720229802>>720229707>>720229016>>720228807>>720228631name a genuinely popular female character whith this little fanart oh right you cant becuase fanrt and popularity go hand and hand,hell even FUCKING ALOY HAS MORE FANART FUCKING NICK AVOCADO
>>720230896e33sisters our response
>>720200716https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_JtTscKXXFAthis is the best song in SotNdon't at me
>>720203431Alicia’s birthday party; hell I listen to it on YT even after finishing the game months ago.
>>720230896>fanrt and popularity go hand and handnot coom fanart though
>>720230896>>720231057Porn is Jewish and using it as a metric makes you a turbo goy
>>720200774Prog rock isn't "anime music".
>the smoothbrain encounters music that isn't R&B, and short circuits
>>720231160it LITTERALLY does 2b Laura Croft Bayonetta zelda eve
>variety of genres like orchestral, electro, ballads...>songs in french>opera singer>DMC5 vocalist>200+ tracks>niggers contrarians be like "heh, this is SO generic. this shitty JRPG copypasted chiptune ost is much better"
>>720197231I vouch for this poster: the soundtrack's are not bad, but they are bland, where every soundtrack sounds the same to me, and none of them really stood up.Same feeling for SkSong atm, even though the first game had more than several "on the spotlight" ost's
>>720197231Explain how the girl from Evanescence isn't a good singer.
>>720231619Music isn't iterative, this isn't a graphics cardMusic doesn't have to be better or worse
>>720197231>it's not good>it only pretends to be good>people like it but they've been tricked>you might like the way it sounds, but actually, it's all a ruseyou absolute fucking schizophrenic nigger lmao
>>720231739Ok, doesn't help that as a whole package it's an 6.5/10, for me at least
>>720230559To someone with low "musical discernment", past a certain point of music quality, they can't tell any difference. It's all equally amazing to them. But to people with a high level of discernment they can continue sorting things out in terms of quality even past the red line. Basically, the music in this game is just at the level of the red line. For midwits, music doesn't get any better than this. But in reality, it actually does, midwits are simply incapable of recognizing it. There is a whole spectrum of subtle touches and flourishes in better music that goes right over their heads.
>>720231792Never listen to people who have memed themselves into having "advanced" tastes in music. They just end up listening to increasingly dumb shit (like everything /mu/ tells you to listen to)Being "into music" is like the biggest personality substitute that there is. It's not like being into video games, where you're actually expected to take part in something, and you can objectively fail.
>>720200716Bach would do metal if he was alive.
>>720231574>niggers contrarians be like "heh, this is SO generic. this shitty JRPG copypasted chiptune ost is much better"it isE 33 is literally 2k electro swing meme but in videogame ost formatlook at this guy, posted by a different anon earlier https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxRzhoB7nb8&t=4380sthe boomer opera expert glazes e33 after shitting on sonic's greenhill and ff6 ingame opera, this is the average e33 ost shill, it sounds good because it is technically good, it is music for audiophiles that are so focused in quality they have no inner monologue for critical thought and no ear for the actual soul of the composition
>>720229629>day of release>anon spamming the negro NPCs in town in the first ten minutes and saying the whole game was a Blacked episode>>720230235A third of classical music is soundtrack for masses and other Church offices. Another third is soundtrack for upper class dancing. Then there's music for ballet, opera, etc, and the countless exercices that were not meant to be played outside musical learning. Pieces designed purely for concert was the minority of "high" music until like 1960. Soundtracks of films and games have no reason to be below because they're designed for a specific context.
>what pseuds think good music sounds likehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r9lpLm7jwQY>what good music sounds likehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w068PdDw0hs
>>720232165>sure it’s good and everything is correct and all>but the SOUL, the game is just SOULLESSJust say “I have no actual reason I dislike it but I feel compelled to by contrarianism”.
>>720195268the ost is good and varied. the best songs arent even the classical ones unless post game bosses have really good tunes havent done that yet
>>720195268oh cool a collection of interpolations
>>720232165>"we got a steinway!"Kek. Shows what he really cares about. Complete silence while listening otherwise, but the brand of the piano was worth speaking up about.
>>720232587being "correct" is what kills the soul, this is why you like AI music on a first listen, but no one ever listens to AI music artistically, it's done by the numbers, it's done to please your ear, but because it is so, it lacks a certain something to make you stay, the soul is not something you can put in words.
>>720200605nah. bloodbornes ost is just random noise while e33 has some good shit.when renoir 2 starts playing its immediately apparent how good it is. gestral party is also great and is completely different
>>720232976>I liked it, and that’s why I hated it
>>720203431 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dffRUOBNGB8
>>720232165>Professional musician has questionable to mid taste, trust meActually that is more common than you'd think
>>720233063do you throw away one time use items?
>>720233063exactly, the coexistence of competing contradictions approximates to the essence of the human experience
>>720232165Thing is ff6 was cool when I was 12, it was good for its time, it can't compete with e33, neither can any other jrpg, they're all left in the dust, will Japan wake up?
>>720233196I agree, arguments are less fun without horrifying retards to argue against sometimes.>>720233143Do you refuse to utilize useful game mechanics?
>>720231964
>>720203431https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zs05Geio770
>>720232165>>720232976>>720233196This is trying way too hard to hate something. I don't know how you people don't get embarrassed acting like this even if it's online. It can't be healthy
>>720232165skipped through the videowhat a bunch of shit music he used in itlike most these games have better songs than those put in thereand who the fuck decided to remaster ff6 song, thank god I never played that remastered shitthis is the absolute definitive version of the song https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqZiSqIaBagthat faggot has no context and doesn't know why this apparently simple chiptune song is so amazing
>>720233329comparing functional mechanics to objective art is quite the stretch. songs that use textbook-safe progressions, rhythms, melodies, arrangements, and vocals that are pitch-tuned and quantized are soulless and generic. it's possible to be too sterile and sanitized with art. now, do you have any logical reasoning otherwise?
>>720232165Just skipped to the Monster Hunter Wilds timestamp. He makes a completely baffling comment on this one too. "We gotta modulate." When the song hasn't modulated at all. He's just throwing out musical terms at random. This guy is a fraud.
Video game music will never be art.
>>720233616Yes, that these songs aren’t paricularly safe and sterile. Not everything has to be Passenger of Shit and actively unpleasant to listen to.
>>720233736>art will never be artYou will never be sapient.
>>720233736But it already is.
>>720197231Trvth Nvke Same deal with Nier Automata. The game just blasts you with sappy orchestra music constantly which is enough to make brainlets think it's deep and emotional
>>720233752cool thanks for agreeing. still not playing e33 or listening to the sound track and now closing this thread
>>720195268Classical is just a small part of it, go on being a contrarian hipster
>>720233867Okay nigger, enjoy your contrary life.
slopcult33 trannyslopped and got plopped in my toilet
>>720234035The true essence of /v/.
>>720233135This singing is horribly out of tune holy shit. Every track I've listened to from this game aside from the main title theme is so amateur.
>>720234268and the only post that matters
>>720233616So you agree this song is absolute kino and blows out the majority of most video game music. https://youtu.be/LINB9BJN8Wc?si=kIYr1VxiKIHsQ_8wAfter all it's unique ,unsafe, and full of "soul"orhttps://youtu.be/OzsGmdmhDTI?si=yg-tIb7ekGqOJEVdMaybe these feminists were just too ahead of their time and their dissonant music can now be regarded as soulful /v/ core
>>720234268/thread
>>720233484this isn't that good. At least post some sick chiptunehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gz0fAz9n_Oshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4EcgruWlXnQ
anyone figure out who he's quoting?
>AI makes a better theme than the originalgrimhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mHX_7lb7Dw8
>>720238909You cannot possibly score below 15.
>all tracks posted ITT are the most normie onesabsolute pleb threadhere is the (official) list of kin0 song from the gamehttps://youtu.be/1np3BcYgP2o?list=RD1np3BcYgP2o&t=168https://youtu.be/KbDjPsQJ0TU?list=RDKbDjPsQJ0TU&t=35https://youtu.be/p3WHa1gDNQM?list=RDp3WHa1gDNQM&t=109https://youtu.be/pDxQEj23XoM?list=RDpDxQEj23XoM&t=88https://youtu.be/WbK7iYQ79ng?list=RDWbK7iYQ79ng&t=113https://youtu.be/CA70_cnlKAw?list=RDCA70_cnlKAw&t=111https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KD-xe9pj2Kk
>>720197231When a game makes me stop mid-gameplay to listen to the music then it's good.
>>720195268Classical music is better than that though.
>>720232132Metal is lacking in complexity in comparison to Bach's simplest counterpoint. Playing fast in odd time signatures isn't complexity.
>>720232165>it sound good>it's technically good>it's music for audiophiles>(all your actual quotes)>but it's bad because I said so
>>720241758In terms /v/ would understand, it's the good art style vs. good graphics (realism) argument. E33 has "good audio quality" because the music was recorded in a studio by real clasically trained musicians (in reality, only some of the tracks are. There are a shitload of tracks and tons of them sound very amateur from what I've seen. But the main title theme at least is very well produced). But the compositions are simplistic and repetitive and nothing particularly special. It's like a game that focuses on bland realism and photogrammetry compared to a game which is unrealistic but crafted with love and care by actual artists. A midwit with no aesthetic sense will prefer the former, patricians prefer the latter.
>>720241150>our painted deathKino
>>720242492couldn't disagree more.if you think this musical atomosphere was not crafted with love, then you are literally brown sorry.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rp9fY_5DsRYhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zs05Geio770https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7tFYu3xC8g
>>720242953>the compositions are simplistic and repetitiveEvery single one of these songs you just linked is the same thing. A woman moaning a simple, slow, sad melody with simple chord accompaniment or no accompaniment.Compare:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mYdf0yqK_FcAre there any songs that even get close to this level of density/complexity in E33? I'm not listening through the whole thing because it was boring the shit out of me.
>>720197231>>720200920imagine being so retarded you cant appreciate the music of E33 which is far superior to anything the japs have done. Bloodborne has a few memorable ones but most just feel like poor non white copies of white people music.
>>720243827is your monk choir shit supposed to be impressive?problem is that you brown people think complexity is what makes something interesting.I feel 10 times more things in this very simple piano arrangement than in the trash you posted.https://youtu.be/bctA_nQjjOs?t=53
>>720205254its crazy isnt it
>>720244024So true, white men understand the beauty of simplicity. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8UFIYGkROII If you can't appreciate this you are brown, end of.
>>720242953>50shttps://youtu.be/Rp9fY_5DsRY?t=50How did they get this perfect submarine rendition?
>>720244310>So true, white men understand the beauty of simplicityI don't know if your post was supposed to be sarcastic, but yes unironically.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0xL3WAJEfI
>>720243827What fucking complexity? One Winged Anges is conceptually extremely simple. They add one fucking vocal track saying SEPHIROTH and the underserved gaming audience loses their fucking shit.
>>720238909this is fucking awful
>>720233308Any song can sound good when it’s arranged for orchestral instruments and recorded and played by world class musicians. Give any old jrpg score the E33 treatment, not changing the actual composition, just the recording, and they would all be hailed as the greatest scores of all time
>>720197231You can't say this without posting what you believe is Authentic
>>720245326They've been doing exactly that for literal years with orchestral renditions. Very few of them hold up. It's time to accept that simple limited chiptune arrangements were never that special.
>>720245326Only 8 tracks out of 160 tracks were recorded by an orchestra in Expedition 33.This song for example is not orchestral and it shames every jarpig track from the last decade.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwLbxKPOixk
>>720245418I understand you have some personal investment in E33 and you want to push it’s narrative by downplaying every other game in existence made by our friends in the east, but come on man
>>720197231>throwing shade at evanescenceGigabased
>>720245542>shames every jarpig track from the last decade.Heres why you're wrong.https://files.catbox.moe/f70hx3.mp4
>>720197231I don't want to shit on it, it's pretty alright, but for me there were only 6 or 7 standout tracks. Which would be quite good for a regular game score, but considering there are 10 hours of music in this one, that's kinda disappointing.
>>720245246By conceptually simple you mean lyrics? I don't give a shit about lyrics, I'm talking about the music you dingus. I assume you are focusing on lyrics because you don't know anything about the actual music side of things. One Winged Angel is densely polyphonic (by videogame standards). It's still not on the level of a Bach fugue or something but there is a lot going on musically.
>>720245667Come on what? Am I incorrect in saying that even after orchestral arrangements, most classic jarpig songs just don't hold up?
>>720245734The music is also simple. The lyrics are simple. There are only a very few musical tracks ongoing simultaneously. IT is simple in every regard you could apply the word.>by videogame standardsIt has the density of fucking soap suds.
>>720245542You are being disingenuous, yes not everything is orchestrated, some tracks are just piano and vocals and some have electric guitar, but compared to old 8 bit tracks it’s still going to sound better by virtue of modern recording techniques and instrumentation.
>>720245747yes you are incorrect lmao
>>720245817>There are only a very few musical tracks ongoing simultaneouslyIt's an entire symphony orchestra + choir. Retard. That's about as dense as music gets. You know absolutely nothing about music. The average IQ of this place gets lower every day.
Game with good production values and actual art direction, attractive female characters, good if melodramatic (it is a JRPG after all) story made by western dev without breaking the budget.Chuds mad, french are jew-arabs even if they look white, there's even a.. gasp woman there, game is shit because reasons and turns out western music canon is actually bad, fucking defenders of western civilisation.
>>720246071>dude, like, the instruments are numerousAnd the composition is simplistic. The chorus all are hitting the same notes. It's boring to the ear, ultimately.
>>720245951Quite the opposite. 8bit tracks are way more memorable than "orchestral" tracks.Something like this would be considered a cult classic:https://youtu.be/Jd699LXy2Oc?t=35
>>720246339>turning a harmonic vocal track into a fucking one track waveform
>>720246175>The chorus all are hitting the same notesThey are not, actually. I know because I actually learned how to play this shit on piano. The choir part alone is at LEAST a 3-part harmony because that's what it reduces to on piano, but in reality it might be even more voices than that. What gives someone the urge to talk so confidently about things they know nothing about, anyway?
>>720246630The same urge that lets you pretend a twenty year old PS1 game holds up compositionally despite constant orchestral renditions proving that not to be the case.
>>720246812There were literally 0 limits holding back audio on PS1 games. The audio could be as simple or as complex as you wanted it to be, they had access to FULL QUALITY CD AUDIO by that point. Once you again, your retardation is on full display.
>>720246945And it still sounds like that. They had quite severe limits to the amount of storage the game had allotted for audio, in fact. And of course they did, because LISTEN to that shit.
>>720231619>Same feeling for-Yes, of course you people are never able to present a positive example because that would expose how shallow your critique actually is.
>>720246812but it does hold up, why are you trying to pretend this isn’t one of the most critically acclaimed tracks of all time in video game history? It’s THE boss theme. Even other Uematsu tracks like Rosa’s theme have been studied as part of the Japanese curriculum
>>720248185And it's primitive. Tetris is one of the most acclaimed games of all time, Pong is in museums. Both primitive. The artform has progressed and what used to be groundbreaking and genre-defining has become rote. The cinematography used in Citizen Kane is no longer special, but it was special at the time. You are handing me something that was great nearly thirty years ago and trying to hold it over something that is great NOW. Well I'm sorry, Windows 98 is outdated and so is 64 MB RAM.
>>720246339Like most of the effect of the track is the two vocal lines, It just doesn't work if you squash it. It loses all expression of the original.
>>720195268Better that Shitsong's "le brooding ambiance" with no memorable tunes or lietmotifsNo seriously, I'm challenge you to hum a song from Silksong in your head right now.
>>720195268I genuinely liked it
From the information in this thread im guessing fromzoomers hate any vocals in videogame music that is not monk chants
>>720251505Having vocal tracks with like intelligible (well in french in this case, but still) lyrics is somewhat unusual for soundtracks I guess though I can come up with some other prominent examples.I've always liked it though. I wish more games did it.
>>720250373It's good soundtrack. I don't get why it makes some people so mad.
>>720195268Bump
>>720254229bing bing wahoo and dark souls boss monk chant enjoyers are seething a real soundtrack is getting all the attention
>>720203236Hoe ass artist tf u talking bout unc 8WH0A
>>720252529Keylocker has voiced music in english. Also timed hits on turn based combat oddly enough.
>>720197231trooth nook
>>720203236This is actually a good answer unironically
>>720200605the only track from Troonborne that I actually remember is the Cleric Beast one and thats just because its the first major one in the game
>>720202363>Most reddit game of all timethat's Red Dead Redemption 2
>>720205521Monaco's theme is straight out of KOF 98.
