SH2 > SH3 > SH1 > SH4 > SH2r > SH F > Shattered Memories > Homecoming > Downpour > Origins
penis
>>722650219Low effort baitF is the best one by far, but 3 has the best soundtrack and atmosphere
why do people hate sh4? its on par with 3
>>722650715It's too different from the other games, you dont even visit the town per se, it should have been an independent game instead of stapling the Silent Hill name on it
>>722650771>It's too different from the other gamesAnd?Who gives a fuck, same on the faggots hating F because muh town muh fog
>>722650715Breakable weaponsAnnoying backtracking Main character is boring as afk and the plot is pretty bland.Amazing environment, atmosphere and enemies tho.
>>722650219SH2>SH1>SH0>SH2R>Downpour>SHSM>Homecoming>Rushed half-baked slop>SH3>Not even a SH>SH4
>>722650771but you do visit the town
>>722650841You can really tell the F team took a lot of inspo from 4
>>722650841>Breakable weaponsWhy is it a bad thing?It's a good feature that resembles real life, it's even improved in Origins which allow us to use many random things as weapons.
>>722650219SH1 >>> the rest
>>722650440
>>722650219>SH2 > SH3 > SH1Posercore take
>>722650219Plot - SHF>SH2>SM>SH3>SH1>SH4Music - SH3>SH2>SH1>SHF>SH4>SMProtagonist - Hinako>James>Heather>Harry>Cheryl>RestCast - SHF > SH2 > SH1 > SM > SH3 > SH4Atmosphere - SH3>SHF>SH2>SH1>SH4>SMGameplay - SHF > SH2R > SH3 > Dogshit > RestLevel Design - SHF>SH2R>SH3>SH1>SH4Controls - SHF>SH2R>SH3>Dogshit>RestPuzzles - SH3>SHF>SH2>SH1>RestBosses - SHF>SH3>SH2R>Rest
Story:: sh2 > sh3 > sh1 > sh4 > sh fGameplay/puzzles/design: sh3 > sh4 > sh2 > sh1 > sh fMusic: sh2 > sh3 > sh1 > sh4 > sh fAtmosphere/horror: sh3 > sh4 > sh2 > sh1 > sh f
>>722650986i didn't hate the breakable weapons but having to return to your apartment to store the broken weapon was dumb, it should've just been discarded when it brokesh4's major issue is just how repetitive it becomes though, it felt like i had played the game twice during my first playthrough and i never really replayed it like i did with 1-3
>>722650554>>722651063Posts made by chronic dilators.
>>722651132Not a argument contrarian retard, stop pretending to like games you didn't play
>>722651189What do konamitrannies achieve by shilling an objectively mediocre gayme?
>>722651063F has great music, and thematically the strongest it should be second behind 3.
>>722651189It's a statement retard. You are a tranny.
>>722651245>Most acclaimed>Best seller>Most popular>Objectively plays, looks and written the best since every other game had garbage gameplay and controls that people gave up on playing and watched on Youtube instead>bbbut it's badCope
>>722651265Not even one track is memorable from it.
>>722651332DSOTM has no hits and is one of the best albums of all time because the entire album is strong
>>722651326First point and it's already wrong. Acclaimed by who?
>>722650219Switch 1 and 3 and move Origins in front of Homecoming, that's basically my ranking. I can tell you're not a baiting schizo, at the very least.
>>722651326>fake endorsement>fake sales>garbage gameplay that tries too hard to be souls-like but fails miserably>garbage story written by a pretentious trannyfucker>looks just like yet another soulless plastic UE5slopDilate.
>>722650219I tried to play a Silent Hill game and I got bored immediately.
>>722650219no no origins is great, easily after sh4, and downpour is better than shattered memories, and shattered memories has a great story but mehh gameplay, so its homecoming then f. And reminder homecoming was shit thanks to the gameplay but the story was nice the enemy design was probably the scariest of all nu sh.
when will konami stop shilling on this board? silent hill f isnt even a silent hill game
>>722651189>contrarianliterally all youtube didn't like this game, even fuckin reddit has hard time defending it lmao but nice bait
>>722651518they are doing the same thing, to a T, they did during the whole Assassin Creed Shadows.It's crazy how similiar it is, during the game hype, every thread praised the game saying oh its selling really good guys, next they are gonna do this for ghost of yourass
>>722651434CRY
>>722651371???
>>722651651>muh criticsNow show the player score would ya?
>>722651651and the audience score 0/1
>>722651610You are crying about your goyslop getting shit on though?
>>722651676>PLAYER RATING - 90%
Eileen shaving
>>722651713>Metacritic - 7>Steam - 77%
>>722651721claudia unshaving
>>722651713Opencritic is not a reliable source for that info since only like 15 or so people reviewed it there.
>>72265174270%, solely due to SH Troons review bombing it for not being set in the US
>>722650219SH1 is a perfect survival horror game except that it doesn't have difficulty modes above "Hard" and doesn't have unlockable costumes for Harry.SH2 has the best narrative but as a game it is very basic.SH3 has the best gameplay feeling, ng+ unlockables, most likeable characters, and most intense enemy encounters but level design, pacing, and atmosphere don't match up to 1 (though it comes close)SH4 is the most unique, weird, experimental, kino
>>722651984Konamibucks are not worth this much embarrassment anon.
>>722652094Continue coping troon
>>722652135>cucknamitranny talking about copingIt's sad that no amount of shilling is enough to make an ugly turd look good.
>>722651497>but the story was nice...you're joking right? The story was contrived to all hell and was pretty goddamn stupid. Imagine taking the premise of "what if an army dude went to silent hill" and instead of doing anything interesting or insightful with that concept went, "BUT ACTUALLY, he's just crazy". And what really gets me is how limp wristed that premise even is. If you're going to go for the "he's just crazy" you need to commit to it, but Alex claiming to be in the "war" only comes up like once or twice in the whole game.
>>722650715I love pretty much everything about the game except that the levels are not fun to play through. Hitting a dead end where nothing is happening, and the solution being "just go back to Room 302 and something new will be there even though there is no indication of that happening :)" is shit. Going to Forest World for the second time just to light a torch and pull mannequin limbs out of water wells in four different corners of the level is shit.
>>722652135Even though it's one of the best games ever made, F has broken the pedos here because of backlash over r07 for Higurashi Sotsu and contrarianism towards the awful gameplay and writing of the originals which they like for it's "soul"
>>7226502191 > 3 > 4 > 2
>>722652358this is my ranking too
F>3>2>1>4 is the correct answer, 3 is probably the best pure horror but the story sucks and it's level design is nothing but generic hallways with dogshit tank controls
>konamicuck replying to ximself for reassurementThis is some of the most pathetic shilling attempt I've seen this year.
>>722650219Based.
>>722651132I've never seen more pathetic contrarianism on /v/ than this game outside of Bloodborne when PC fags rage baited about it being terrible for not being on PC
>>722652531I refuse to play the weebcringe game. Sorry!
Can't you nufags use the Catalog??Also, SH PC Guide's Pastebin:https://pastebin.com/uf5XhyXz
>>722652531>contrarianism is when you dislike objectively shitty gamesYeah shf is indeed garbage, and it's not just about muh peeminism btw.
>>722652617>ObjectivelyYou don't know what that word means, gameplay makes a game good and no other title before F had functioning gameplay with minimalistic writing entirely told in lore text for autistic youtubers to spoonfeed a playerbase that never played any of those games
>>722650219Silent Hill 1 is objectively a great game. The visuals are just too old.
>>722652746the visuals work perfectly for the kind of feelings the game is trying to elicit, I feel like it captured the feeling of a nightmare perfectly and I don't think it would have if it looked like SH2 or 3
>>722652717Gameplay in shf is objectively bad, yes. Slightly more polished shit is still shit.
>>722652717SHF is not even a horror game and the combat is just as shitty as the old games, just in a different way.
>>722652802silent hill 3 did a pretty good job too. remember the blurry vibrant red textures with those moving blobs?
>>722653053the mirror room was the highlight for me in terms of special effects in SH3. To be honest I didn't really find the moving gunk/blood on the walls effect that impactful. I guess it did enhance the feeling of panic and sensory overload in areas like the hospital where the game would just spam the crawling pigs at you over and over. For me the best part of SH3 is the sound design with the ultra realistic banging sounds or the deep breathing of the monster in the office building or the hyperventilating of the nurses
>>722652746>passposter is also a graphix whorereally makes me thing....
>>722651332I wouldn't say unmemorable, looking at the OST there's quite a few tracks that are pretty good, a lot of it is atmospheric https://youtu.be/3QhOMzudj-4?si=9Q8Kw0acYyiQDrCwhttps://youtu.be/27hmscznOP4?si=elYECA46ar3CpBKihttps://youtu.be/mNK2zx00zV8?si=13NFifwXgGAjYymnhttps://youtu.be/K-vQaipprxE?si=pEYGZrOQxXBjFEbihttps://youtu.be/2eux7DScV_A?si=Q8C5Lg8PjE8dgtz8https://youtu.be/LHJeJSsazC8?si=yiG_xNTjoEHk3dXohttps://youtu.be/NLfdR3K7Rqk?si=ZLNviFPHhn2uFlb-https://youtu.be/jR6uCLObpFc?si=U2s48sezJLAu_Qkxhttps://youtu.be/r1uajbbJnkc?si=wBUR76J30vK9TAgHhttps://youtu.be/M9YjFuAhs-w?si=pghvny8j0DUsthKRhttps://youtu.be/L2ZMT9GHzP0?si=J31FbMaitZZNODodhttps://youtu.be/-So44-pmOEw?si=YG0nUAiih7U2H_bYhttps://youtu.be/nR57l_g36lw?si=juq3SDHsyugL-1i4https://youtu.be/y-N0p4iLmGE?si=Askdpp6qUsVwl4pchttps://youtu.be/A45d-EYAXEM?si=ZKiuxyvZLzHujtaS
>>722653142yeah the sound design is brutal, especially in the very first level where the soundtrack ganks up on you with the sound effects>the mirror room was the highlight for me iirc i exited the room before heather got infected with the gunk so i missed the impact of that scenethe experimental visuals of sh2 3 and 4 do a great job of recreating the low res spooky kino aura of the OG ps1 game. the latest games are embarrassingly generic
anyone here replay sh3 with the over the shoulder camera mod?looks kinda neat as a gimmick
>>722651360>Money >not a hitk
anyone who ranks 2 below 3rd in this series is a contrarian faggot. i can see the argument for 1 and maybe 3 but thats pushing it, anything beyond that is pure hipster faggotry
>>722655680the gameplay is too simple and not challenging enough, except on hard combat mode where the gameplay remains simple and not challenging enough until you hit the final bosses who are bullet sponges that will take you literally 15 mins of running corner to corner in the arena to kill
Playing Origins right now and the atmosphere and sound design are fantastic. I don't mind the combat since all SH combat is jank af.I really don't understand what people look for in SH games if not for atmosphere kino.The best games in the series don't have particularly good combat or very deep fleshed out stories.
>>722655779the combat is the worst part of all these games tbf
>>722652272Alex being crazy was to be expected, but he didn't go crazy over being a villain or doing something horrible, it was an accident and the way he thinks of himself as a soldier is because he always wanted to prove to his father how he was a good man because his father treated him like garbage.
>>722656358origins ost of the menu is terrifying, never heard a more unsettling song in my life
>>722655779>i play SH games for the awkward tank control fights...here we go again
>>722651438The gameplay is pretty shit for all of them desu. They're just glorified puzzle games. You play them for the atmosphere and story.
>>722651189>game is controversial among fans>contrarian You must be a dumbass newfag
>>722656757god forbid i play a game for the game
>>722651326>Objectively plays, looks and written the best since every other game had garbage gameplay and controlsShill detected
>>722655779It can still be kind of fun to manage your supplies during the course of the game and make sure you have enough for the final bosses. It's not like SH1 didn't leave you with a shit ton of items by the end on Hard mode either, but for some reason SH2 is always gets called out on it.
>>722656757tank control games in the meantime are getting love and indie releases like every month, so no matter what you think of them people clearly love them
>>722650715There is something very special about 4.The atmosphere alone makes it really feel like it's cursed
>>722659512I love how the story keeps escalating in tension and stakes keep getting higher & higher, and the responsibility of looking after Eileen is put upon you. Henry the nobody spends the first half of the game watching everybody around him die brutally & then he has to buckle up and save Eileen. It's like the perfect premise for an action-horror game... There are disturbing moments in SH4 for sure but I really feel like it does the action extremely well
>>722650219SH2R shouldn't even be there, at least Downpour and Homecoming are new games.
>>722651721WHY IS SHE SHAVING WHERE IS SHE GOING OPEN THE GODDAMN DOOR LET ME OUT
>>722650219SH1 > SH2 > SH4 > Western SHs > > SH3 > > > > SHf > > > > > > > > > > > > SH Ascension
>>722651518>>722651603And sh2 demake, which also got shilled to hell and back and most likely flopped.
>>722660039>This hole in the wall is getting really big and my landlord won't fix it>I'm running out of chocolate milk>I just want to get my car magazines :(
>>7226502192 > 4 > 3 > 1 > 2R > SM > 0 > DP > HCHavent played F.
>>722660872That one sold even worse than the original
