Do you think Ending C for GTA 5 should have been more depressing so that it balanced out with the other endings instead of being the blatantly obvious best/good ending?
zoomers want either a good ending or a bad ending, no in between and no grey area
>>724324003It's GTA, nobody actually cares about story
>>724324003it was supposed to end with franklin dying (lamar takes his place as PC post-game). they should have went with it. with each ending you lose a character and player have to decide which two they like the best/which one they like least.
>>724324273People are pretending (or maybe they actually are interested) to for GTA VI though… I suppose that’s the new Rockstar of David audience who cried at Arthur’s death though.
No it's all hollywood make me laugh make no sad story where everyone is a happy reddit chungus who talk about FUCKING and KILLING but can't say a no-no word.
>>724324304I really wish there was more information on this original version of the ending, because as of now there is basically literally nothing
>>724324304I hate all those characters, GTA V doesn’t have a single likeable character, yes they’re piece of shit criminals but Vice City, SA, and IV had likeable characters, III’s characters weren’t really characters, they felt more like ghosts as everyone does in that game (it’s why it’s the only kino gta)
>>724324304yeah lamar actor got arrested so they scrapt the idea
Who cares? 5 was dogshit anyway.
You're a faggot who doesn't really go outside if you pick any other option other than killing trevor
>>724324713t. Seething Klebitzfag
>>724324003Honestly yes. Because option c pretty much completely negates the purpose of multiple endings because it's objectively the happy ending. If it were more gray and ambiguous, there could have been more of a purpose, and more discussion around the endings and which is best.
>>724324003Hmmm who to save, the literal cuck, the LE CRAZY redditor who isn’t even that crazy, or the boring token nigger who’s there to be a nigger and complain… I wish there was an ending D in which they all die and I can play as Red Harlow in modern day LA gunslinging and blowing heads off all the CA niggers and troons.
>>724324159Yeah and millennials only want morally grey ending where everyone is depressed, and nothing is resolved. Why do you hate classic good vs evil so much?
>>724324003I like the concept of ending A and B better, where the protagonist succumbs to the greed and selfishness that plagues everyone in Los Santos and ends up betraying his friends. But in terms of execution so they were so mediocre and Ending C is objectively better as it stands.
>>724324003No because it’s not trying to be as tryhard as GTA4. Every GTA ends with you killing the villain and winning. GTAV should be no different. No one picks A or B because it’s so angsty and does not fit at all with the rest of the story. If anything C should be the only ending as if anyone even picked the others.
>>724324003I think it could have communicated a better crime doesn't pay message because all the endings just lead to misery. But GTA has always just been about fun and escapism so maybe it's better not to go that direction
>>724324003Yes, Michael's family should have been killed, as well as Lamar and Franklins love interest and aunt, all stemming from the the cartels being pissed off at having all their connections screwed up all at once. Michael and Franklin will descend into being like Trevor. Michael becomes a legit serial killer, and Franklin starts using crack with that towing crack-whole from mission 2. Meanwhile, Trevor actually gets clean and becomes stable, and is almost an entirely new character.>All their abilities break>Michael bullet-time doesn't actually work and has erratic shaking>Franklins ability enables drunk-mode with it>Trevor's is just gone completely, but he gets double base health.
Impressive how hard Lamar mogged Franklin
>>724325896Franklin keeps mogging Lamar throughout the entire story, that's literally their relationship
>>724325986maybe in brain but when it comes to entertainment and interactions
>>724324159Zoomer balls didnt even drop yet, this is milenial slop
>>724325242GTA 4's endings were misery porn
>>724326261GTA 4's endings also felt kinda rushed
>>724326261I always picked to save Roman, because Kate goes full bitch mode for no reason and just ghosts you. She also has zero fucking chemistry with Niko.
>>724326447I can deal with GTA4. The biggest rushed ending and pos overall is TLATD. That shit could have been sick, but the gay spic story got all the features.
>>724326739Rockstar really thought we would care whatsoever about a character whose relationship with Niko is mostly optional, what were they thinking
>>724326880all of /v/ was filtered kate. niko has the most chemistry with her despite them not actually dating.
>>724327053*filtered by
>>724324003No but they should have just not included the other endings in the first place
>>724326261I didn't like the forced romance.
>>724326880probably what said >>724325242, just like gtaV you get one proper ending, though if you are seeing it from the perspective of a first time play thorough it does makes more sense, you have to deal with 2 scumbags and you don't know the ramifications of your actions, do you deal with the guy that has been tricking you since the beginning of the game? or the fat italian maniac idiot? logically you would deal with the biggest threat, unaware that is the decision that will kill roman
>>724324003Ending A is canon in my heart
>>724326261bros before hoes, GTA IV was easy. Also Roman dying was the "reward" for cucking out and not killing Dimitri.Deal ending works better as a tragic movie ending though, Jimmy as an endboss is worse than Dimitri.
>>724324304>>724324562Never fucking happened, why do you retards accept "source: dude trust me" shit you read on the internet before checking for yourselves whether it's actually a thing or not? Worse than YouTube comments, I swear to God.
>>724326739>>724326880You don't know who you're choosing to "save" when you make the choice, brainlets. The choice isn't "Save Roman/Save Kate", it's "Money/Revenge". In a first playthrough you don't know the consequences until they happen.
>>724327916No I looked it up before making the decision so I knew
>>724328428
>>724327652>Deal ending works better as a tragic movie endingI always thought this. The deal ending is so much more emotional and impactful. Meanwhile I could not care less about Kate dying
>>724327916Who cares, R* didn’t even go all the way with it so the choice is pointless becauseA) money is only good for buying clothes and guns and worthless outside of thatB) even if you pick revenge the game still rewards you with the money anyways.C) both of the main villains die in either endingIts such a pointless choice that only thing that matters is which of your own dies
>>724324003I think it could have been ok if they hadn't canonized ending C in GTA online
>>724328787Most people picked C for obvious reasons but also A and B don’t really make sense. Killing only one just calms down one of the like 6 groups that want Franklin gone
>>724324003It is depressing>Trevor is still alive and is a fucking psycho he can decide no actually I do want to murder Michael and maybe Franklin too at any moment>Michael is still a scumbag and learned nothing>Franklin is now a hitman and has two insane evil boomers keeping tabs on him
>>724329026I guess in those endings Franklin felt that killing all of his enemies was impossible and it was better and more realistic to just appease one group/enemy
>>724329250According to the post GTA 5 from online, Trevor has become some lifestyle coach, Michael is a film producer, and Franklin is a businessman who is still kinda criminal
>>724325242>No one picks A or B because it’s so angsty and does not fit at all with the rest of the story.I agree, I just don't understand why A and B are even in the game. Did R* feel obligated to have multiple endings but couldn't be bothered coming up with more than one?
>>724324003Honestly they should just cut A and B, they don't really fit the story
>>724329250There is actually a pretty important hangout interaction after the game ends that shows Michael and Trevor truly making amends for their past, where Michael apologizes to Trevor for everything wrong he did to him and Trevor says he accepts his apology
>>724324003Didn’t both Michael and Franklin’s VAs say they went with killing Trevor? And Steven Ogg fucking hates Trevor for getting him typecast and has said he’s on board with Trevor getting killed off in 6 like Johnny
>>724331165Yeah Michael's VA said multiple times in interviews that his favorite ending is ending A
>>724327053kate was a bitch who never put out. only naturally beta simps would get attached to that.
>>724324003nigger, I played this game 12 years ago. I barely remember the character's names. You better tell us more.
The end should have been Franklin leading Michael and Trevor into the hood and then betraying them into being gangbanged by all his homies.At the end a cum-covered Trevor and Michael are kneeling after the bukkake, cracking jokes and fistbumping the black homies.
>>724324003I picked C because I assumed it was the black that died.
>>724326261Obviously kill the female. (She doesn't even put out...)
>>724328428Yup. I don't know why devs even bother putting choices in games, everybody will just chose the optimal choice. It's better to just to stick with one path (saves on dev time too $$)
>>724324806C is the slightly harder ending of the three, since the other two just has you chasing the NPC.
>>724331165Johnny dies?
>>724327558Almost everyone used guides for games back in the day.
>>724324003Death Wish is a retarded ending that shows that the stakes never really existed and almost feels like a troll by Rockstar as if to mock you for ever caring about the story in the first place.Imagine if Micheal had just killed Madrozo instead of doing a robbery to pay him back. Why not, after all there would be no consequences as the Death Wish ending shows. If you kill your enemies you win, no questions asked.
>>724324003Ending A is unironically the best ending if GTA 5 was a movie and not a video game it would be the ending I pick.
>>724326447leslie benzies is a retarded hack
>>724326169Go fuck yourself
>>724334884They’re all retarded and poorly thought out. If you kill Michael they don’t resolve the Chinese Triad wanting Trevor dead or Franklin dead as well for saving Michael from the meat plant. If you kill Trevor, they just hand wave away that Devin won’t be problem but never explain why, they say Merryweather is gone but that shouldn’t stop someone as rich as Devin from hiring a hitman to kill Michael and his family. C is however the most GTA ending in which you just kill the bad guys and win
>>724336662I'm so glad /THEBENZ/fags were astronomically BTFO by the shitshow that was Mindseye
>>724324003Option 3 should have been a secret or required more thought than a button press. GTA IV had binary choices but you choose by driving to one objective or the other.
>>724326261I've completed the game more times than I can rememeber and have never chosen the Roman death ending.
>>724327916Moreover, Roman tells you to take the deal, believing it will make everyone safer so if you want to do right by him because you like him it ends with him dead.
>>724325782why though
