Killing your wife is pretty bad but I don't think it quite warrants being trapped in a looping hell for eternity
>>724440953Is that why theres James bodies? Bad Ends?
>>724440953James asked for this hell though.
If Konami really wanted to try something risky they would have a protagonist who was a pedo and he is in silent hill to suffer.
>>724441159Yes, they're from other loops
>>724441356I still want to see Fat Albert in Silent Hill>...What the fuck did I do?
>>724440953there's no fucking loop in silent hill 2 you twat
>>724441356You can read Made in Abyss or Saya no Uta if you want that.
>>724442597what? So why doesnt he just get out? I thought it was like Groundhog Day
>>724441356So like, are the nurses in cunnyhill mskgs or something?
>>724441356Just imagine all those loli monsters born from his guilt...
>>724440953>>724441159>>724442385>loop theoryheadcanon>but da demake has-no
>>724442786Because then you wouldn't have a game.
>>724442786He gets out at the end of the game.
>>724442786Loop is only in shitty remake, anon...
>>724442860maybe>>724442842ACTUALLY!!!!! there's evidence in SH4 that he was never found
>>724442943yeah because he either kills himself or starts a new life with laura/maria or revives mary and weird shit happensit's a multiple choice ending left vaguely acknowledged in sequels
>>724443023That doesn't negate loop theory. All the gameovers could be past James and him breaking the loop could be the one you play. Or you could say he kills himself and loops again as punishment. At the end of the day it doesn't really matter because theres multiple endings and no canon conclusion.
>>724442713I'm not saying I want it. I'm saying if Konami wants to do something controversial and risky thats what they should do.
I mean as a designer you have very specifically got to place a very specific asset down possibly staring it for hours at a time, it's james and he's looping, nothing else makes sense.
>>724443445In the remake definitely
>>724440953Tell that to Jinnkid.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NFxS1gitGFUhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BTCkTt392KAhttps://www.nbcsandiego.com/news/local/san-diego-tik-tok-ali-abulaban-sentenced-murder/3552934/
>>724443183The loops bullshit didn't exist until the remake. The original had no such thing.
Silent Hill 2 is just a spinoff
>>724443445Yes, Angela is in the mall in Silent Hill 3 and Claudia is in the hospital in Silent Hill 4. Nothing else makes sense.
James Sunderland here. I do feel kinda shitty about killing my wife. At the time it felt like the right call, but in retrospect maybe I got a bit impulsive. It was my bad. Anyway, I learned my lesson, and if you let me out of Silent Hill I promise I'll never go near a pillow again. You have my word. Come on guys.
The James looping through SH thing was a fun theory. But that's exactly where it belonged, as just a dumb theory.
>>724441356That’s actually literally the plot of Sad Satan
>>724443706Has James become a BETTER MAN?
>>724443706You got 150000 more tries to go
I'm pretty sure I will be sent to a Silent Hill type suffering dimension after I die due to certain bad things I've done in my life and I deserve it.
>>724444731That's just hell.
>>724441356Yeah Silent Hill is an American city so it fits the overall theme.
>>724442713>Saya no UtaI'm pretty sure the meat monster was adult in human years.
Eileen shaving
>>724440953Theres worse things than killing your wife. Like killing your children, or voting for Trump
he's trapping himself there because he can't forgive himself
>>724446232Gr8 b8
>>724446180pervert
>>724446180>MFW
>>724442842Remake outsold the OGCope.
>>724440953Killing your wife is bad, but ever heard about MARRAGE!?!?!?!!?You will go INSANEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!
He's there by subconscious choice. Mercy killing his wife who he still very much loved despite their relationship deteriorating alongside her health really fucked with his head.
>>724444731I wish. It will just be nothing, like a dreamless sleep or before you were bornBoring
>>724440953The game unequivocally communicates to the player that killing Mary was the right thing to do. The bad part was how he felt about it. If it was only to put her out of her misery, he would have a clear conscience and not go to Silent Hill. Part of him doing it for selfish reasons is the sole cause of his purgatory, not the killing itself.
>loop theory
>>724441159>Devs reusing assetsMuh loop theory!!!!
>kinos in your path
Still mad they vindicated the retarded theory of Mary's body being in the car. There was no reason to do this except to appeal to turboautists
>>724440953>looping hell for eternityIt's really not though. He's there until he faces what he did and makes a decision.
>>724441356>>724445567You would just be a hispanic or black guy then considering this is America and they are most likely to be pedo more than any other race on the planet
>>724452436Why is it retarded? I'm not a SH autist. I played 2 on ps2 at launch and the remake on pc. Never got into any of the other games or even really deep into all the fan stuff surrounding it. Why is the backseat body dumb?
>>724440953It's not looping, Silent Hill makes you become a better and stronger person by making you defeat your traumas
>>724448360all remakes sell more than OGs by default due to video games being more popular than ever before
>>724440953Why do chuds in particular love this game so much?
>>724454803you're making shit up for no reason
>>724454803Dude, everyone loves this game.
