GU

>>725962740
They're all good in different ways. I genuinely think you could boot up any of them right now and have a good time, but if I had to pick one it'd be 3U

>>725962740
P3rd, 3U, and GU.

>>725962740
Freedom Unite by far, don't listen to nintentoddlers that needed their games to be more casual friendly.

>>725962740
FU, GU, P3rd
P3rd would be the best by far if it had G-rank.

>>725965042
4U is better than GU in terms of design and pacing

>>725965330
P3rd is classic gameplay and doesn't have apex shit.

>>725965493
yea I'm quite fond of 3rd gen and p3rd is the best of it basically outside of no g-rank

>>725965330
4U is worse than GU because
>the maps are mostly bad without the good maps from previous gens that GU has
>there are monsters locked behind event quests or GQs which means fighting them is complete RNG
>brought back all the garbage from gen 1-2 and even gave some of them subs which makes GU having those dromes look tame in comparison
>has worse camera control because the max speed is slower
>has worse menuing because features like removing all decos from all armor was introduced in Gens

>>725962740
>no charm RNG horseshit
>especially no relic RNG turbo ultra mega horseshit
>no "you have to talk to that npc to unlock a quest and clear it, then talk to that other npc to unlock a quest and clear it, and [repeat 6 times] and that's how you unlock high rank zinogre"
>no apex horseshit
>no hyper horseshit
>no 4th gen maps (the worst in the franchise by a fucking landslide)
that's why FU is my pick, it does have its own horseshit moments but i'll take those over 4th gen horse shit any day
p3rd was ok but no g-rank and again, charms can suck my dick

>>725962740
Tri

>>725962740
Hello, Anon I have come here with the true answer
FRONTIER > Tri = 3U > FU = Dos > 4U = P3rd > Freedom 1 / 1 G
Not clasic: Gens and is also garbare

>>725966086
there's so much to love but it does fall short
and 3U doesn't properly replace it at all

Dos and it's not even close

>>725966141
"classic" is anything that doesn't look like world/rise/milds and pretending not to understand that doesn't give your post any more weight
gen is classic mh

>>725964763
I have actually beaten all of Master Rank solo in FU, it's a piss easy game for babies compared to GU or 4U, simply because most monsters are pants on head retarded and only know 4 moves who are very easy to bait out on purpose

>>725966365
Dos is kino indeed, but Frontier is Dos on steroids
Dos and Tri for actual classic MonHun
Frontier and 3U / FU for good slightly more casual MonHun

File: 20250130_133736.jpg (380 KB, 1762x2000)

380 KB JPG

>>725966439
>Gen is classic MH

>>725966467
>FU
>Master Rank
Good bait

>>725966565
Everything that still runs on the MH2 engine is, if you like it or not

>>725966467
>4U
Now try acting like mounting isnt boring and cancer that no one likes that literally needs to be reworked every single game its in
And that the maps arent complete dogshit ledge infested and wall climbing nonsense
And that gacha palicos and weapons are good
And that the RNG maps are good
And that the endgame isnt boring as shit
And that the artstyle doesnt suck
And that the farma are worse
And that crutch blade and IG are blatantly op
And...

3U > 4U > GU > FU IMO

all 4 are significantly better than world/rise/wilds

>>725962740
I'll answer a different question for you
>Whats the best MODERN MonHun
Unironically world
T. Gen 2 elder

File: 1762361478010740.jpg (37 KB, 800x450)

37 KB JPG

>>725963027

>>725962740
XX=3U=FU>4U

P3rd despite it's lesser amount of content is probably top 3 best MH titles.
Most faggots never got to play it cause you gotta emulate and get an english patch to fuck with it.
P3rd blows Worlds, Wilds, and Rise out of the fucking water.
GU shitters are drinking their own piss when they say it's better than FU or 3U.
Unironically, GU is when the whole franchise started going to shit.

>>725962740
Dont listen to anyone saying GU is any good
Its literally poor mans frontier

>>725967002
P3rd is the worst of the three gen 3 titles. It's a casualized to hell version of tri and doesn't have a G rank like 3U to compensate (p3rd's casualization on its own is already worse than 3U's added 50 defense, no G rank balanced around it just seals the deal)

>>725966704
G-Rank then fine, metal raths for example are still easy as shit in that game

nooo not the 4U maps nooo well let me tell you something
you have to climb walls in every fucking game
2nd gen snowy mountain can go to hell

by the way I JUST got done finishing p3rd and it is easily one of the weakest entries, literally a quick cheap slice of 3U and nothing else. easy skip yet some of you guys just can't help but talk it up like it has something special going for it such as... being completely void of content

>>725967087
I liked deviants and Valstrax is one of the coolest designs in MH

>>725967174
Post screenshot pal I want to see your set
That double diablos nekoht quest is almost impossible
Too tanky

File: lol.webm (2.73 MB, 640x360)

2.73 MB WEBM

>>725966141
>>725966483
>frontier

>>725967241
>Snowy mountains has 3 climbable walls that are so optional that you probably only know 1 exists
>Meanwhile 4U has them on EVERY MAP ALMOST ON EVERY ZONE AND SOMETIMES SEVERAL PER ZONE in high traffic areas where you need to go to chase monsters btw

>>725967348
Damn that's KINO
What game is this? Surely looks better than the dogshit visual in Gens and the horders of shitmons it has

>>725967348
>Capcom brought MVC2 Air juggles to MH
kino

>>725967348
>Magnamalo is a worse version of this
Goddamn Frontier, I didnt know you were that good

>>725967296
>Nekoth
Anon that's village hr what are you doing? Just get a pellet hbg and rape them to death

>>725967667
>Bowgun
Oh sorry miss

>>725962740
FU

>>725967784
>Not using every weapon
Fake hunter spotted

File: lol2.webm (2.86 MB, 640x360)

2.86 MB WEBM

>>725967550
I have a couple more

File: 1762955268105930.jpg (44 KB, 571x576)

44 KB JPG

>>725967136
>P3rd was casualized

You think you're not obvious when you say that shit? Dumbass.
You didn't play it. Do you honestly think you're fooling anyone?

>>725967867
Based, good to see newfags learning

>>725967906
I like the zinoger knockoff that impales you with a spike that becomes a lighting rod and kills you

>>725967867
Of course I use every weapon
Every Melee weapon that is
According to old lore, ranged weapons are for disabled hunters, anon.
Are you disabled?

>>725967906
Thanks bro
Do you have any webms of the heart attack condition?

>>725967942
P3rd reduced monster damage across the board to the point where the damage difference was more egregious than the added 50 def in 3U for low/high rank. I know you have fond memories of playing it on your psp as a kid but you played a casualized version of tri.

>>725968135
>Claims that a village HR quest is almost impossible
I don't know what to tell you anon that sounds pretty mentally disabled to me

>>725968245
>playing p3rd on the psp as a kid
You really have no idea what you're even talking about huh?

>>725967550
Frontier
its FU extended to absurdity
there are private servers for Frontier now too so you can just play solo or with others and I believe tweak out all the bullshit (being an MMO it does go overboard on grinding but I think private servers have resolved this)

File: __monster_hunter_felyne_a(...).jpg (758 KB, 2560x1440)

758 KB JPG

>>725962740
I like all of these games for different reasons and you should play all of them, including 1 and Dos and Tri for all different reasons as well.

>>725968452
This was a knowlesge check, Anon.
That Hr Nekoht quest is infamous for actually being a late G rank quest, the Diablos have too much HP for the regular player trying to do the quest at that point.
You are most likely to just time out before killing both
If you didnt know about, I sincerely doubt that you actually played FU
Abd if you did, you're still a bowgunner tranny lmao

File: 1754862062036974.webm (2.95 MB, 640x360)

2.95 MB WEBM

>>725968210
sorry these three were all I had saved

>>725968491
You're in no position to say anyone else doesn't know shit when you yourself are unaware of the damage value changes in p3rd

File: 1585332342893.webm (2.93 MB, 1024x577)

2.93 MB WEBM

Frontiers you say?

>>725968491
Of course he doesn't. He's so fucking obvious it makes me cringe.

>>725968731
lmao you are thinking of the one horned diablos retard the double diablos don't have that
>you're still a bowgunner
A retard with 0 reading comprehension

>>725968824
That's very cool but why don't you explain how a kid would play p3rd on his psp first?

File: 1761508638681256.jpg (57 KB, 377x423)

57 KB JPG

How the fuck did we get to the point where Worldsperms and Wildcucks lie out of their fucking ass about having played any of the older titles?
Why the fuck do they lie about having played older titles? What the actual fuck is their problem? It's beyond shameless holy shit.

>>725969048
>one horned diablos
that's a monoblos
>double diablos
and a tetrablos

>>725969104
>Zoomer doesnt know piracy
Specially on the fucking psp

>>725969384
No one played it on the actual psp when you could just emulate it with HD patch you retard.

>>725969634
Lmao what a retard you are
Specially when it came out on spanish before english and everyone was scrambling to get it going in half taco half moonrunes
Fuck off my shit zoomer

File: 1751258134498945.jpg (194 KB, 1423x1988)

194 KB JPG

So, when are we gonna play a Classic MonHun trogether, /v/?

Apjrvp>>725968575
Would you happen to be able to recommend a private server? I'd really like to try it

>>725962740
The answer is always going to be 3U.

>>725969634
>Thinking psp player cared about HD
Say syke rn

>>725969803
mitebcool to play a no armor run of 3U, 4U, or GU

>>725962740
Except for FU, none of these are classic MH.

Also the answer is FU. Fuck bingtrannies. They want to LARP as oldfag vets so much it's unreal.

>>725970419
This.
It's so fucking gross.

>>725970419
No game that allows you to charge your Greatsword is classic. Kill yourself nigger.

>>725962740
3U > 4U > GU > FU (I really don't like the 2nd gen movesets for weapons)

Ichinose, and whoever is tasked with making a G rank for his releases, really are the only ones putting out good MH games.
Since the alternative is this overly ambitious, and ultimately half thought out mess of unfinished ideas that only sound good on paper.
A mess that tends to drone on about story/ecology so much it just becomes heavy handed. Desperately wanting to be taken seriously and harming the actual gameplay in the progress.

>>725970536
Ah yes the classic
>3dsbab tries to act like a gen 1 hunter
Tale as old as time

>>725968927
>looks like FU
>but there is a fucking Uragaan
My brain can't comprehend this

>>725969634
I had a friend who played it with translation patch on PSP
not sure why you think this isn't a thing given all PSPs are known for is its CFW potential
I did in fact play it with the PS3 HD patch though, that definitely was probably most popular.

>>725966735
>Mounting
Only a problem if you're playing IG against specific enemies or SnS. Otherwise you shouldn't be fishing for more than one mount per hunt anyways.
>gacha palicos
Why would you care about them being random when they've been so weak in every game up to and including 4u? Why complain about a gacha when the end result barely matters whether you get lucky or not?
>gacha weapons
Post game grind. You don't need them because you've literally beaten the whole game already. These are just bragging rights.
>rng maps
Ok you're right here the guild quest maps suck
>boring end game
Unless you mean farming the same 140 GQ a thousand times for a weapon you don't need, it's great.
>arstyle doesn't suck
what nigga it's the same as every other game, unless you really hate the paper cut out loading screens
>farms
It's... fine? I guess there's less flavor since you're just talking to an NPC rather than having a comfy farm map? I guess it's a valid complaint but this is a pretty small point.
>CB and IG
As if every monster hunter doesn't have questionable weapon balance. The thing is that CB and IG aren't even that good. GS and HBG are still ridiculous as they've always been. LGB is super strong because of hame and slicing shot.
Plus CB's strength in 4u has ALWAYS been over exaggerated. In terms of speedruns/clears, DB is basically on par with it, and you don't hear anyone complaining about dual blades. Even shit like SnS has impressive times now. The real problem with 4U's balance is more about certain weapons getting fucked at end game like switch axe, gunlance and hunting horn. CB is just a super easy weapon to play (while pretending to be complicated) while being new so it's an easy target.

>>725970625
>noooooooo I get to arbitrarily decide what is classic wah wah
That's you

>>725970419
>immediately rustles the bingtrannie's jimmies

Yep, that's the one

>>725962740
Probably 3U overall. The only MH game I played and didn't click with me was Generations(not counting Wilds of course). Although I gave GU a chance later on and came to enjoy it.

File: igualito.png (1.19 MB, 1118x481)

1.19 MB PNG

>>725970710
>NOOO IF 4U ISN'T CLASSIC THEN NOTHING IS CLASSIC
This is you
>>725970673
>>arstyle doesn't suck
>what nigga it's the same as every other game, unless you really hate the paper cut out loading screens
Yes brother, 4U looks like every other MonHun

FU is just a worse Dos that stripped out all the good ideas.

>>725970825
4U is so ugly

>>725969104
By downloading it online? I was playing it in my early teens

>>725970673
>Unless you mean farming the same 140 GQ a thousand times for a weapon you don't need, it's great.
not that anon but I disagree, the endgame outside of GQ grinding sucks ass because of the usage of wystones. needing to sharpen your weapon twice to hit a monster even at full sharpness is stinky, god help you if you use weapon that eats sharpness quickly

>>725970851
Don't pretend you played Dos lol

Also both are 2nd gen and thus classic MH

>>725970825
>NOOO I CAN'T ACCEPT THAT FU IS SIMILAR TO 3DS GAMES AND JUST AS SHIT SO I MUST ARBITRARILY MAKE A LINE IN THE SAND
That's you

>>725970942
>game has a farm
sorry anon there's only one classic MH game

>>725970901
>>725970964
Not pictured:
The disgusting wind effects on all of the Hunter's attacks that make it look like the weapons have no weight to them

>>725970942
Dos is the good one.
FU is arcade Ichinose slop only larping newfags pretending to be oldfags for street cred like.

>>725970419
I miss when armors had a more medieval feel to them. I really hate the direction they went with future games with their armor designs.

>>725971061
FU was where Ichinose wasn't already full of himself and gimmickyfied mainline MH with his garbage ideas.

>>725970673
>Bro goes on a rant about the CB not being OP as fuck as the best IMPACT, SLICE, ELEMENTAL, DEFENSIVE, and COUNTERATTACK weapon in the game AT THE SAME TIME
yep, that's a 4U bab alright

>>725971060
Wind effects imply weight however. Are you slow?
Express your opinions better and say it looks like shit.

>>725970419
>They want to LARP as oldfag vets so much it's unreal.
every single time

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UujNF_BuupY
Anyone tried the Forward Fivers server?
It's a "classic" Frontier server from before things got way out of hand. Looks interesting.

>>725962740
Everyone who typed GU, you just admitted your first game is World btw.
>WHAT IS THIS
>USING POSITIONNING AND ROLL TO DODGE MONSTER ATTACKS?!
>LET ME USE INVINCIBLE PARRY AND INFINITE AMMO BOWGUN OTHERWISE I CANT WIN
Lmao, go play DMC newfags.

>>725971241
>go play DMC newfags.
Would be a better way to spend my time than with GU

>>725971182
>He needs wind effects since the artstyle and weapons feels so shit to use this time around
Gotcha pal

>>725971157
FU stripped the identity of MH and could not follow up on what the devs wanted MH to be. It is a bastardized release that people only pretend to like because it makes them feel superior when the reality is any browno pirate could play that game for free.

>>725971327
That's not what was said. I'm just commenting on your retardation since that's not how physics work. Make sure you get it right next time, tardo.

>>725969834
rain or renewal are the most popular/userfriendly and commonly recommended
mezelounge is exclusively for the most autistic players because it adds custom endgame content (unlimited zeniths and z4 road/achievements)

>>725966735
>Now try acting like mounting isnt boring and cancer that no one likes
so just ignore it faggot. sure the je suis monte might get upset that you interrupted his mount, but who gives a shit about him? he's french anyway.

>>725962740
I like GU the most because its easier to get it going and play online, also uses the assets of most previous games so there is a lot of content, also even with the "ez" styles like adept or brave, the endgame is quite hard (deviants/ex). also best rendition of the HBG zamn

>>725971334
And that's why your favorite (first) MH is actually 3rd or 4th gen, right?
You bingtrannies are so funny

>>725969834
the launcher itself has a smorgasbord to pick from, but you can always make your own
here's a guide from /mhg/ https://pastebin.com/QqAwZSTC

>>725967942
p3rd gutted Barroth AND Barioth. those boys haven't recovered TO THIS DAY from the nerfs p3rd gave them.

>>725971481
Where did I mention 3rd or 4th gen?

>>725970825
>Comparing the map with the highest saturation vs the one with the lowest
Dishonest comparison. It doesn't even look like that on the 3DS screen.

>>725970912
>Wystones
But you basically don't need them. There's only 1 single mandatory apex monster quest and then you beat the game. I don't remember how many optional ones there are, but Apex monsters and needing wystones is overstated because of end game players grinding guild quests. You could argue it's "mandatory" in that using them on frenzied monsters (of which there are a ton of) gets you a knockdown, but then you're just spending a moment to use an item to get a knock down later, which is basically no different than spending time using any other item to get a window to attack a monster. It'd be like complaining about traps.

>>725971160
>Best at all of those at the same time
You don't genuinely think that do you?
If you want to say it's OP because it can do all that at once, then sure, but it's definitely not the best at ALL of them at the same time. IG is genuinely better as an example of a bullshit weapon that can do everything at the same time, even though it lacks a guard. It does more damage, can do crazy status, you can even build it to do stupid ranged blunt damage if you want, etc.

Anyone who says GU is bad hates fun. Sorry, that's just how it is.

>>725971547
Your irrational hatred of FU reveals your true intentions, bingtranny.

>>725971472
I quite like Brave GS and Adept DBs even though I fully understand while they're very easy to use, they're also very fun to use. this board has collectively convinced themselves that difficulty is the singular measurement of enjoyability, which simply is not true.

>>725971624
Your obsession with boogeymen out to get you is real tranny behavior lmao

>>725971595
to be fair, GU's start is pretty bad. It's a massive list of boring as fuck gathering quests that you have to do before the real monster hunter starts, thankfully its only like 5 hours out of a 500 hour game though. although i'm still mad about the time i decided to play a palico since it was just a gathering quest, only to find out its impossible to clear without using goldfish bait so i had wasted the last like 20 minutes trying to find the right pool of water.

>>725971717
>no u
Sure sure, bintranny.
One of these days you will play a real MH

>>725969803
Never these threads just exist to passive aggressively cry about Wilds

>>725971472
oh yeah and also has lots of mods compared to the previous games
fuck there's even a mod to restore CB to what it was in 4U, transmog armor using an hex editor, a few quite decent balance mods, etc.
also the game runs at 120fps 1440p on ryujinx 4x internal res ez zamn

>>725969803
Dos got a new translation. Any of you fucking baby hunters could try playing that for once and then maybe try LARPing as a vet again.
We could even do multiplayer.

>>725971835
Your garbage only deserves a no-u.
FU is still dogshit just like the 3ds games and you're still a tranny.

>>725971826
To be fair, start is the most boring part of any MH. The real game starts in G-rank anyway.

>>725972001
So we're shitting on FU now? New contrarian meta just dropped?

File: 1656669125787.jpg (98 KB, 929x928)

98 KB JPG

>>725971930
>Mods
GU is so dogshit it actually needs to be modded LMAO

>>725972218
Bingtrannies always hated everything before 3U released. MH literally didn't exist for them before that.

>>725972218
FU is not classic and anyone who claims it is because they don't want to admit it's similar to the 4th gen games is a retarded faggot. That's what's going on atm.

Quality of FU aside I agree with that.

>>725962740
Personally I like MHFU, but it was my first. Tri was extremely cozy. 4 had a lot of pop and new monsters. MHGU is fantastic as a send-off for all prior games. 1 is fucking weird but someone into the series should definitely give it a few hours to see the vision. All of them are worth playing.

File: 1634782215274.webm (2.9 MB, 960x540)

2.9 MB WEBM

>>725972218
That's the 3dsbabs for you
they shit on anything that's not 4U / GU
no matter what, if someone is trashtalking their little gems they'll invent any narrative down to acting like Console Warring started with World
All the way to Monster Hunter not having a real endgame before 4U

File: 1739650664359601.webm (3.73 MB, 1280x720)

3.73 MB WEBM

>>725972283
all games need and will be modded as I see it fit
GU is perfectly playable without mods, but there are some styles that are mostly just dogshit, like alchemy.

>>725972385
>it's similar to the 4th gen game
Now that is some new level of shitposting.
You neither played FU or 4U kek

I don't even know what you're shilling here

>>725972218
FU is just Ichinose slop that is "acceptable" to like for oldfag credit. It's the safe horny version of MH lmao. Has more fans than people that have played it.

>>725972385
>FU is similar to 4th gen
I'll admit to this when you admit World is literally 4U-2.
>4U is the story focused one
>With a bunch of intrusive cutscenes (characters talking to you)
>Introduces a bunch of fags that will keep on appearing in its direct sequel (WORLD)
>Gets rid of side content to focus on fighting
>Casualized to hell and back

>>725972218
people have been shitting on FU for the wonky hitboxes since the dawn of MH threads on /v/. for me it's the wonky hitboxes and going back to the 2nd gen movesets that make me realize I like 3U the most, which even with swimming it has the best maps in the franchise and it's the first game where weapon movesets feel complete. imagine going back to lance with no counter, or GS with a charge slash that you just need to hold without timing it

File: 1757813151544811.jpg (21 KB, 280x296)

21 KB JPG

>>725962740
3U > 4U > GU > FU

>>725972527
It is similar. You being a schizo that loves axewounds doesn't change that.

>>725972576
>Wonky hitboxes
Ah yes, iframe dodging, the bane of all 3dsbabs existence
Bet you can't even dodge roars LMAO

File: 176324697080139.jpg (226 KB, 1423x881)

226 KB JPG

>>725972560
>I'll admit to this when you admit World is literally 4U-2.
Make the devs admit that first when they said the exact opposite in reality.

>>725972634
Trannies weren't even invented yet when I played FU

>>725963027
fpbp

>>725971930
>there's even a mod to restore CB to what it was in 4U
yeah I've been playing with 4U CB moveset after starting with adept for a while
having now played every iteration of CB, I have to say that the original moveset is the best and most balanced (even though the MVs themselves are really unbalanced)

4U even reintroduced all those generation 1 and 2 monsters along with their subspecies to make it more in line with Gen 2 games.
FU and 4U are more alike than they are different. But autists hate their worldview being challenged.

>>725972685
I shouldn't have to iframe through attacks I'm positioned to avoid in a game about positioning properly and punishing opens anon. if you love I-frames so much why don't you go play GU eh?

>>725972708
>They literally said they based World from 4U
>They never said the opposite
?
If it wasn't 4U-2 Mounting wouldn't be in it
Nor it would be story focused
Neither the tranny Aiden

>>725972951
punishing openings*

File: 1643452060018.jpg (57 KB, 640x474)

57 KB JPG

>>725972951
Because real iframe dodging takes skill
Pressing button for supermove in GU does not
See the difference?
Your next reply will allow me to measure your IQ depending on which route you take:
a) Accept it
b) Cope and deflect

>>725973012
>they didn't like 4u
>so we had to change the game to be different from 4u to make it more global
Yeah that's the opposite.

Can we stop throwing shit at each other when ALL of the MH games are on PC now?

Just play the one you like most.

>>725969634
>no one played p3rd on an actual psp
of all the retarded things said in this thread full of retarded things this might just be the most retarded

>>725973221
>No one liked 4U
>So instead of trying something new we just expanded on the shit no one liked about 4U until they had no choice but to act like they like it
Yep, if everyone hated Underwater and it was removed
Why do we still have mounting?

>>725973305
Because some games are just terrible. Such as 4U, 3U, FU, GU, 5th-6th gen.

>>725973118
>avoids the positioning argument entirely to shitfling like a chimp over iframes some more
my fault for trying to make fun of you using GU I suppose

>>725973371
>4U
correct
>GU
Correct
>5th and 6th gen
halfway correct.
World is actually decent

>>725973371
Please stop falseflagging. What are you even trying to accomplish?

>>725973358
Everyone hates Raths. Why aren't they removed?

>>725973371
>no mention of Monster Hunter Puzzles
we're safe match 3 bros

>>725973510
I love them. Especially donking on their silly heads with my hammer.

>>725973465
>World is actually decent
Lol.
A 6/10 game at best

File: 1657409722333.gif (2.54 MB, 498x498)

2.54 MB GIF

>>725973417
So cope and deflect, I see.
Answer with a yes or no the following question, anon
Do you actually think Pokemon and Kirby games are good?
>>725973510
>Deflecting
Answer the question anon
If no one liked 4U why did they expand on all of 4U's main features? Even bringing some more back IN RISE AND SUNBREAK

>>725973626
Damn they are falling right into your game
Are 3dsbabs this retarded?

>>725973305
The thing is GUfags are Worldbabs who cannot cope with the fact they are the biggest tourists of this franchise they discovered when the highest selling capcom game of all time dropped and now they have to larp as oldfags by picking the easiest MH game pre World.
They will tell you "im totally fine with old monhun jank" but truly they'd rather play newMH than any games released pre world for the exact reason they didn't played these games before 2017, because they were too hard for them.

GU should be made open source and ported natively to PC to create an infinite and endless platform for old school monster hunting.

>>725973626
>noooo only I can deflect

GU's weapon moveset changes from 4U suck balls. Guild style is NOT 4U movesets. Game's still good though.

>>725973810
So you can't answer either the yes or no question
or your narrative where everyone hated 4U but they doubled down?
I see

File: 1762346458345.jpg (248 KB, 627x1080)

248 KB JPG

>>725973371
My favorite MH is MH Diary: Poka Poka Felyne Village as well bro

>>725973626
Where are wystones and apex in World?

>>725974047
Finally a classic MH game. Unlike some garbage Unite.

>>725973871
a bunch of the movesets are really bizarre, like the lance combo ender that's like the little hop move or whatever. Only guild style I used in GU was Hunting Horn

>>725974047
Was this ever translated?

>>725974085
>Apex
Arch tempered
Coming in the wilds expansion

>>725974330
Doesn't work the same way. Try again.

man how do people play a second monster hunter game, they're all the fucking same shit

>>725975416
clearly they must like the formula of the series

>>725975416
Different monsters I guess

>>725975416
it's fun

>>725975416
killing monsters with giant weapons is fun

>>725975416
>man why would people who like a thing want to be able to play more of that thing
if you cannot wrap your head around this you are brain damaged

File: jared 2.png (234 KB, 399x363)

234 KB PNG

>>725971525
p3rd was lucky it never got a western release, it would be shat on near world levels for its casualization. Instead we have nostalgiafags sucking it off because it was their first MH

File: F2S3WO5bUAEV4EV.jpg (424 KB, 1920x1080)

424 KB JPG

God...take me back.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m0W1rr1BoJw

>>725977118
it was very easy but I'll always give credit to the game for being the first MH to make hunting horn an actual weapon

>>725962740
Dos-FU-Tri

>>725977118
Was it really that easy or is it just exaggeration?

>>725975416
In someway they are but if you really dig each gens you really don't get the same feel from playing the first game, FU, Tri and 4U. If you started with 4U and immediatly fell in love with Charged blade and its gameplay, you'll be extra dissapointed and disadvantaged when you go back into the older games where the weapon does not exist.
Modern MH has this problem accentuated to absurd degree where absolutely everything is streamlined and casualized, you move faster, can use items while moving, have mounts, special moves, instant dodges, fairer hitboxes for monsters and weaker monsters overall.
Pokemon Red and Blue and Pokemon Scarlet Violet are the same game intrinsically, Monster Hunter and Monster Hunter Wilds are not in no universe.

Out of these I only played 4U and really liked it. Which one do I go to next?

File: dovahkiin.png (113 KB, 385x238)

113 KB PNG

>>725977373
FU WORLD DOS

>>725973878
>>725973626
Still waiting:
>>725973810
>d natively to PC to create an infinite and endless platform for old school monster hunting.
>>
>Anonymous 11/15/25(Sat)15:04:26 No.72597

>>725977540
World or GU

>>725977540
3(U) or GU

>>725962740
MANDATORY LORE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sb6B01f0zv4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXqmFL_oyZg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PWbjfqWietQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5I5n2dP_FRA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tKLAMTGtx4E
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVOBNl_28PU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e9NYYewCSxo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oa2wMvBvpBc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-VPVvKrqcM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WhZiT8WTUvM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mtpkuf3g3GM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94_QgfVdQDA

>>725977757
Already played World and also liked it
>>725977757
>>725977828
I'll look into GU, thanks anons

>>725977756
>PAY ATTENTION TO ME
you're so desperate it's embarrassing

>>725977838
worldsperm, risembryos and wildzygotes crumple to ash upon seeing this level of sovl

P3rd = GU > FU (just barely) > Tri = Dos > everything else

I would put FU at the top but there's too many missions that feel like filler or are out of place for their ranks (too easy/too hard). P3rd hits everything just right but is a bit too easy overall, though you can handicap yourself by just using weaker armor & weapons. GU has tons of filler but you can skip way more of it compared to FU, and the extra gameplay conveniences make filler less taxing when you're forced to engage with it.

Shoutout to Tri for *still* being the prettiest game in the series to this day, shoutout to Dos for still having the cool Right Analog attack controls.

>>725967348
How are you suposed to survive that?

File: IMG_3560.jpg (39 KB, 257x296)

39 KB JPG

>>725962740
4U because the Evade Lance is the best iteration of lance in any MH game + the new monster additions kicked ass + the endgame was insane when the servers were live.

It also has a lot of cozy areas that are severely underrated, like Cathar and the updated Dundorma. And the free hunt mode actually goes into G rank which was the one disappointing thing about 3U’s moga woods. I have 400 hours in it and will gladly sink another 400 in if we ever get a port. But I realize 4U enjoyers are a niche within a niche and we’ll probably never be catered to

>>725978562
don't get hit

>>725978128
>3dsbab's made up narrative crumbles when faced with any opposition
lmao

>>725978640
I asked for an actual real answer, most of frontier webms show an unavoidable instakill attack, how can you have fun if its imposible to survive anything.

>>725978835
they aren't unavoidable

>>725971986
>Any of you fucking baby hunters could try playing that for once and then maybe try LARPing as a vet again.
i played dos beforehand. and i wouldn't play it with you because your attitude is horrendous

File: 1753854751304353.jpg (26 KB, 680x447)

26 KB JPG

>>725963027
>GU

File: IMG_1036.png (651 KB, 843x866)

651 KB PNG

Genuinely insane how a single schizoposter made oldschool MH discussion on /v/ fully unusable

Like, it genuinely seems like we will never have a normal oldschool MH discussion again unless an IP permaban becomes a thing

>>725972545
Lodesabuzzwords

>>725979574
>Old school Mh discussion
When was this ever a thing it was always just mon hun discussion. It’s only recently some autist is trying to wedgepost because he can’t run Wilds or whatever

>>725978562
Survive?

>>725977483
>Pokemon Red and Blue and Pokemon Scarlet Violet are the same game intrinsically, Monster Hunter and Monster Hunter Wilds are not in no universe.

It’s the same fucking game you guys are just acting like “ohhhhh Sword and Shield is modern Pokemon because speed calculates mid turn”

File: 1717440841125470.png (19 KB, 580x1866)

19 KB PNG

>>725962740
4U>3U>GU>FU.

>>725973626
Kirby games are good. I play both Kirby and oldschool monhun. You should play Kirby Robobot's True Arena mode.
>>725971986
NEW TRANSLATION FOR DOS!!! FUCK YES THIS IS THE BEST YEAR EVER

>>725978575
4U was my first time hunting with other players. Holy fuck the amount of people I hard carried in that game. Tendies are dogshit players

>>725980642
>You should play Kirby Robobot's True Arena mode.
>You should slog thru 99.9999% of the game just for it to start having any semblance of difficulty
miss me

File: official mhg list.png (441 KB, 1140x369)

441 KB PNG

>>725962740

Dos = FU = P3rd = 3U = 4U = GU = World

They're all fantastic. Rise and Wilds are shit tho

>>725982016
this is such strange bait
it doesn't even anger its just baffling

>>725982016
>Rise that high
obvious bait

>>725962740
MH4U or GU by a wide margin

>>725980405
>Nintendo/snoy shitflinging
>Game tribalism especially Worldfags
>unironic monster fuckers, furries, and scalies invading
FU/p3rd was the last era of consistently good MH threads

>>725970419
This right here. The amount of tribabs in this thread is making gag.

>>725968135
>according to old lore
Quit making shit up

>>725982016
I don't even know where to begin with this shit

port GU to steam already crapcom faggots

>>725982752
>FU/p3rd was the last era of consistently good MH threads
Because tendies weren't yet in it.
As soon as you give them SOMETHING it's the best thing ever. Everything else just doesn't compare.

File: Extreme Thunderblight.webm (2.89 MB, 766x522)

2.89 MB WEBM

>>725968210
Gotchu senpai

>>725978835
Frontier musous are unironically for the best of the best, a whole few orders of magnitude beyond what mainline's endgame usually delivers. That particular monster is infamous for not getting a solo true slay for the first eight months it was available. They require very precise strategy to fight. In other words, you have to have that touhou elitism autism to have fun with these.

Zeniths will probably be more your speed if you want real challenge without it being absolute bullshit.

>>725962740
DOS

File: mh.png (380 KB, 1140x610)

380 KB PNG

>>725982016
fixed retard

File: Bu.png (82 KB, 408x453)

82 KB PNG

>>725983798
>had to farm a shitload of these back in the day
Dark times.

>>725984576
Dogshit tier list, Tripedo.

>>725983798
>>725984595
Actually scratch this, I skimmed the webm and thought it was Zenith Khezu.

Zenith Khezu is fucking aids by the way.

>>725984668
and a happy 15 years of envious seething to you, FUxister!

>>725984576
your ninteniggerism is showing

File: 20251115_202741.jpg (394 KB, 1536x2048)

394 KB JPG

Reminder that we live in a bizarre timeline where a MH game NEW COPIES ended up in the bargain bin for 5 dollars less than a year after its release.

File: 1.jpg (525 KB, 1920x1080)

525 KB JPG

JP version of MH1 online using the private server.

>>725984576
>rise
>fun

>>725962740
Dos or 4U. Dos is the better game but 4U has Dalamadur so it is entirely even as to which is better.

>>725977430
Anyone saying it was casualized obivously never touched it.
They're larping as oldfags, but most likely Worldsperms of Wildcucks.

Frontier looks like a fever dream

>>725984926
Wilds is fucking dogshit, nothing bizarre about that.

>>725977430
P3rd was easy compared to FU but mostly because the ridiculously broken hitboxes were fixed.

>>725984668
>>725984836
I miss this

>>725984925
not my fault snoys get all the bad monhuns :)
>>725985050
yeh sometimes. at least with frens

>>725984926
Because they probably printed 20 million of these

>>725984963
Tell me how to set this up without discordfaggotry, you sexy mofo

I bought the wilds deluxe edition on release
I'm such a fucking idiot

>>725977430
it wasn't world/rise/wilds levels, but it was notably easier than the games before and after, including tri and 3U

>>725985506
Hello fellow idiot.
Me too!

File: 1699177961426122.jpg (169 KB, 1024x702)

169 KB JPG

>>725962740
I've pondered this question for a long time since those past monster hunter games were iterative in a lot of ways. And yet, I think that FU, 3U and 4U are all worth playing. FU for when the combat had a stoic simplicity and beauty to it, not bogged down by much meter management. 3U honestly is mostly an atmosphere and nostalgia pick for me. even if the underwater combat is not as good as the land combat and the game is kind of unfocused in that way, I can't help but like it. 3U flooded forest is my favourite MH map I think. 4U is just the best game of the old monster hunter formula that combines everything into a great package with impeccable pacing. people complain about the rng relic weapon endgame grind, but it didn't bother me as I was never the type to stick around for 1000 hours trying to min max every single bit of gear until there's truly nothing more left to improve.
I haven't played XX, only X. I enjoyed it, but it's more like an all you can eat buffet featuring everything from trash to quality food and is a fairly diluted experience as a result.

>>725985453
https://mholdschool.com/viewtopic.php?t=120

>>725983079
lmao newfag

>>725962740
MHFU. Early peak of the franchise.

I also have a soft spot for P3rd aesthetics. Not enough content tho.

>>725967906
H-he's fast!

>>725985772
>a forum post
You're so based it's unreal

>>725982016
>generations that high but GU in the bottom
funny list

>>725985384
yeah they probably thought they'd see another world sized release again

>>725988423
Should have release another world quality release again

>>725985382
anything is fun with friends this is not a valid excuse

>>725984963
>Sex
>Male
>MH today
>Body Type A/B
A...

File: 1424746493020.gif (2.75 MB, 245x263)

2.75 MB GIF

>tfw no mh4u on vita

File: 1691253649033729.jpg (165 KB, 498x480)

165 KB JPG

>>725988209
Thanks don't forget to join the Discord though https://discord.com/invite/Ebs8gkCdBY

also the wiki: https://wiki.mholdschool.com/

>>725989293
God bless you for keeping this alive

>>725988906
that's the funniest part, they thought they did. they really thought world sold gangbusters because of the narrative focus and open level format, so they doubled down on it lmao

>>725989293
>you either die a villain or grow old enough to be the hero
god bless

>>725989575
I can't wait for MH: Origins where we: Go back to the game's roots
Screenshot this post.

anyone played the board game? is it fun solo? i dont know how to play but willing to learn if its ok solo as i doubt ill find randoms to play with on tts

>>725989924
the what
also who plays a board game solo

>>725984926
How is it surprising? As much as japs love Monhun, they aren't going to buy a ps5 just for it, not when they have become more and more tethered to phones or switch. If your game isn't on those, might as well not exist in japan.

>>725989986
>the what
? what the fuck do you mean 'the what' you clearly understood what it is by your second comment
>who plays a board game solo
no friend losers like me, Issac is pretty fun solo

>>725967241
It's because p3rd has the nippon aesthetic
It's the sole reason people shill it so hard

>>725990212
oh you're autistic my bad

>>725990256
>my bad
apology accepted, im not mad just do better next time

>>725990384
ok baby *kisses you on the cheek* see you next thread

>>725990432
*blushes and turns away shyly* n-not in front of the other anon's, anon

>>725991082
An attempt was made

>>725989343
>Thanks don't forget to join the Discord though
NO.

File: 17648235457.jpg (48 KB, 672x390)

48 KB JPG

>>725989873
>Screenshot this post.
Like gen 1 and 2?

>>725985285
P3rd was easy compared to fucking TRI

>>725989924
It's probably outsourced and based on some other shitty board game.
I could care less.

>>725991775
Tri was way easier, even with the underwater combat. You obviously never touched P3rd's high rank.
Even Devil Jho was easier in Tri than in P3rd.
If you haven't played it shut the fuck up. You're just making a fool of yourself.

I've been playing MH2 Dos with the MH2 Plus Patch and English translation. I am only playing single player mode.

It's fun. I am playing emulated on psxc2 and I save state every 30 seconds because I would lose my mind if I had to fight these bosses with 50 adds attacking me at the same time and when I kill a boss I have A TIME LIMIT TO SKIN ITA BODY WHILE BEING ATTACKED BY 200 FUCKING ADDS ARE YOU SHITTING ME

don't care if this means I am not "truly" experiencing MH2 Dos, this shit would be insane single player only with no save states

I have played these games in that order:
MH3U (Wii U) -> MHGU (Switch) -> MH3 (Dolphin) [still in standby because I still can't get a rathalos plate] -> MHR (PC) -> MHRS (PC).

I say 3U for the vibe (Moga Village), the monsters and for the G rank even it has some flaws: Tri is short but it has superior graphics comparing to 3U and has the night mode.

I have never played 4U because it was on 3DS, I prefer playing MH games on big screens.

I agree that GU is the best in term of content. But it was bloated as fuck. I disliked the game a little on a personal level: as a completionist, there were too many gathering quests.
Also, fighting some 1st, 2nd and 4th gen monsters were painful sometimes and when you had to take down 3 of the same time, it was hell

To finish, I hope Capcom release 3U, 4U and GU on PC but I know it will not happen

>>725991715
They'll scale the story back to 4U levels with small cutscenes but not the Snoy tier Last of Hunts bullshit Wilds and World were
Back to one singular village as a Guild Hunter again complete with a farm.
Gunner Armor added again
They'll go back to smaller maps instead of open world
No gimmick claw or tether
Separate Village and Guild hunts
UI clutter reduced
MH language as an option again, possibly. Aflies can't really read so regular language isn't going away

>>725991082
>>725991427
Soul, thanks anon

>>725968491
you didn't play the japanese version on your hacked psp when it came out?

>>725995042
Not a lot of people did.
Especially if they were still in the fucking womb like some of the faggots in this thread obviously were.

>>725962740
Frontier is special

>>725989293
rest in chocolate orange

>>725995302
You are special like a retard

>>725995302
I really need to get around to setting up Frontier on my PC, everything I have seen about it makes it look like an incredibly fun if very frustrating and absurd experience.

>>725962740
I played FU, P3rd, 3U, 4U, my sister played GU.

I think 4U is the best. It takes the best from FU and 3U.
3U does not have as much content.
FU is not as polished.
4U only has one peeve for me and it's weapons that are not balanced. I've used all weapons that aren't Gunners though extensively, but IG seems much more imbalanced, especially if you run cheese builds.

I ran a lot of cheese builds in online lobbies. Paralyzing+Rodeo IG makes hunts a breeze, even shitters don't die if they get free hits all the time.

>>725962740
>old
3 ULTIMATE is "old???" I wouldn't even consider its original release on the Wii "old!"

Criminy. I don't even know what gaming is like, anymore...

dos and gu worth running through before sacrificing myself to the frontier gods? 3u worth running through if I played tri up to seadussy back in the day? world worth playing? wilds worth playing?

File: 1763183473628453.gif (2.67 MB, 640x640)

2.67 MB GIF

>>725967348
>that health bar fighting for its life

4U>FU>3U>>Power gap>>GU>>literal dog shit>>Anything post 4th gen

I hate Gen Ultimate for a multitude of reasons, but I'd play it a thousand times over rather than touch World once. it still depresses me that classic MH is dead and buried

>>725962740'
If Crapcom wasn't retarded they'd port all these games to PC

>>725999089
>dead and buried
give it a couple years and copyright will expire and we can all make our own kino monster hunters full of soul

File: Sharq-Attaq.png (111 KB, 400x400)

111 KB PNG

I'll vote Tri and 3U everytime.

>>725982219
>Dos
You never played this game.

>>725999406
I've always wondered why no one has ever tried to mod one of the classic games to add new maps and monsters. Granted I know nothing about those games' engine, that might be an unrealistically tall order.

>>725996221
very fun game hopefully you have a few friends to play with its truly the ultimate mh coop game

RECOMMEND ME A MH2 DOS WEAPON / ARMOR SET WORTH GRINDING FOR I AM GETTING MY ASS HANDED TO
ME BY A PLESIOTH

File: 0fwh0wIhzuk-HD.jpg (131 KB, 1280x720)

131 KB JPG

>>725962740
>what's the best old monster hunter game?
it's 2

but none of them have my wife chichae in them so they're automatically worse

and the one that does have her doesn't have a mod that allows you to plap her as a reward for completing missions so they're all bad