>deserved>deserved>deserved>deserved>deserved>not deserved>deserved>not deserved>deserved>not deserved
>>728899026The fact that Astro Bot got GOTY last year really showed me how dead AAA gaming is
is this in the same order as the image or is it reversed
>>728899132Same order going from up to down
>>728899132it's deserved
Are you going bottom to top, or top to bottom?
You're too young to be here if you think overwatch didn't deserve GoTY. That shit sold 10 million copies immediately and is literally one of the highest selling games of all time. EVERYONE played overwatch and loved it. Shit was a cultural phenomenon that literally spawned a whole host of clones that are still desperately trying to capture its magic. You're an idiot.
Overwatch and Last of Us 2 are the worst games there by far.
>>728899114It just shows that normies can't into JRPGs>b-but E33!!Yes, that game proves the point even further
>>728899360What came out in 2016? I'm trying to even remember.
>>728899236Who the fuck cares how much a live service slop sold? The game has no lasting legacy. You can't even experience the version of the game that earned it GotY anymore. Games of its ilk should be ineligible
tlou is a fraud game
Astrobot shouldn't have won over Metaphor. God of War shouldn't have won over RDR2
>>728899516Dark Souls III and Uncharted 4
>>728899026Last of Us 2 is a better game than E33 unironically
>>728899026Astrobot has the best gameplay
>>728899528The whole world did. Literally the entire world. You retarded zoomers were pissing in diapers still when it came out. Sitting here and pretending like you know what you're talking about is giving me second hand embarrassment. You should be ashamed at how retarded you are.
>>728899236I'm the oldest person ITT. I played it once during a free weekend. It was alright. Didn't hold my attention for long.
>>728899585Even Rebirth would have been more deserving. Astrobot is to platformers what E33 is to JRPGs. For some reason normies latched onto them as if those genres haven't existed until these games "revived" it
>>728899585Metaphor was ugly trash and instantly forgotten. Let it go
>>728899236Kill yourself zoomer retard
>>728899657Nigger, I'm probably older than you. Overwatch is normie garbage for non gamers.
>>728899236>we've reached the point where children whose childhood was defined by fucking overwatch are now posting on this website defending it tooth and nailI'm getting too old for this place.
>>728899236>EVERYONE played overwatch and loved itmorons*
>>728899516Doom 2016
>>72889902617, 18, 20 are undeserved.
>>728899567It has the best 3rd person gunplay in videogame history. Better than RDR2s
>>728899026Sekiro is overrated and mid
Was 2025 the worst year for videogames ever?
>>728899887What deserved to beat it? Its an excellent action game
>>728899026Only 2017 and 2023 deserved their wins
>>728899026The only game I played from this list was overwatch.
>>728899734>>728899753>>728899762>Unironic zoomers try to rewrite historyIf you sit here and pretend that Overwatch didn't have one of the biggest cultural impacts in gaming history then you're a child or a retard. Simple as. I don't care about your personal opinions, objectively speaking it was GOTY and few games have ever had as much impact on gaming as it. No more (YOU)s for you zoomniggers, go watch one of your little yt essays and educate yourself.
>>728899928No
>>728899762Back in like 2011 we used to joke about kids growing up and being nostalgic for crap like Minecraft and MW2
>>728899026Astrobot filters /v/ hard. Even the incel poster boy AsmonGold begrudgingly admitted the game is good.
>>728899026>slop>slop>woke>casualized slop>goyslop>woke>slop>woke>openworld slop>woke
>>728900050Maybe I'll be Tracer>I'm already TracerWhat about Widowmaker?>I'm already WidowmakerI'll be Bastion>NUERF BYASTION
>snoys were so desperate for an actual videogame that they glazed the fuck out of a Super Mario Galaxy clone and rigged it into GOTYlol
Deserved:>elden ring>BOTWNot the top pick but whatever>baldur's gate 3>last of us part 2>sekiro>god of warShouldn't have even been nominated:>expedition 33>astro bot>it takes two>last of us part 2>overwatch
>>728899026>2024literal shovelware sonyslop won>2016wokewatch assfaggots won>2020woke of us 2 with the jew won>2021it takes poo, never even heard of this gameShit like this is why I never get why literally anyone gives a damn about the gay awards its all corpo shilling.
>>728900140Remember the average v user doesn't even play games.
>>728899026anyone in this thread that gives a shit should immediately neck
>>728900385It Takes Two is a great game.
What is it about her that makes trannies like OP seethe? Is it her effortless femininity?
>>728900224Its not even half as good as Galaxy
>>728899026>Astroturf Bot>DeservedNo one thinks this.
>>728900528>ugly woke slop abomination
Has anyone actually played Astrobot? I sure haven't (so I have no idea if it deserved GOTY)
2017 is the only one that didn't deserve the win.
>>728899026No award is deserved. Not until the labour-power of human beings is still exploited, their existence precarious, their hard work and sleepless nights reduced to a single man who happened to be the director of their project. Every worker a member of the board!
>>728899516
>>728899516Persona 5
Actual list:2016: Stephen's Sausage Roll2017: BOTW2018: RDR22019: Sekiro2020: HL:A2021: Not a single good game released this year2022: Elden Ring2023: Thief: The Black Parade2024: Not a single good game released this year2025: Not a single good game released this year
>>728899516Deus Ex Mankind Divided
>>728900613found one
>>728899516Overwatch's competition for GOTY was Inside, DOOM, Titanfall 2, and Uncharted 4Aside from that, 2016 hadDishonored 2FirewatchMafia IIIOxenfreeAbzuStardew ValleyOwlboyHyper Light DrifterHitmanBattlefield 1Gears 4Ratchet & Clank PS4XCOM 2Civ VIXenoblade Chronicles XDark Souls IIIDeus Ex: Mankind DividedBut Overwatch was GOTY that year
>>728899026None of those deserved it in hindsight. Not a single one.
Elden Ring > BOTW > BG3 > God of War > Expedition 33 > Sekiro > Astro Bot > It Takes 2 > Last of Us 2 > Overwatch
For me its:2025: Expedition 332024: FF7 Rebirth2023: RE4 Remake2022: Elden Ring2021: Guardians of the Galaxy2020: FF7 Remake2019: RE2 Remake2018: God of War2017: BOTW2016: AM2R: Return of Samus
>>728901658Was gotg really that good? After avengers I checked out of superhero games entirely.
>>728901782The story and characters are good. The gameplay is pretty basic 3rd persom shooter type stuff. Its nothing like the avengers gate at all desu.
>>728900703Its a good game, but I also played Metaphor and Rebirth last year and both of them are better
>>728899026TLoU2 absolutely deserved it, GoW 2018 did not, though, so I agree there.
>>728899585Astro Bot and BG3 are the best games on that list, it's not even close.
>>728901128Overwatch deserved it. That's a weak lineup. I even liked xenoblade x and firewatch but come on
Breath of the Wild is so overrated.
>>728900979>rdr2>botw>goodlol
>>728903603Overwatch is online slop
>>728899789>le same game for the 100th time, but it deserves GOTY now Do DOOMfags really?
>>728899114Wukong sold 20m in a month that year you fucking retard. Shit like battlefield isn't winning an award for goty at tga either. Your metric is utterly retarded.
>>728903678So what? better than botw gow tlou and it takes two. At least it actually had gameplay and shit
>>728901241then what did?
>>728903882>better than botw gow tlou and it takes twoimagine thinking this
>>728901423BG3 > ER >BoTWdidn't play the rest
>>728899236>t.zoom zoom
>>728900050Sorry, your bait failed
>>728899114Don't care, it was worth it to see nincels get cucked in their own wheelhouse.
>>728899026I agree.
>>728904339If a 3D Mario had come out that year it would have dwarfed Astro
>>728899236I didnt play it. I only play single player games.
>>728899236Never play cuckwatch and never will.
>>728899236>game gets GOTY>can’t even play it anymore>>728901128>Get nominated for GOTY>*fucking (multiplayer) dies*
>>728904403>If a 3D Mario had come outMario's retired. He's a movie character now.
>>728899026Literally all of these are slop
>>728899236Titanfall 2 was a way better game both as a campaign and a multiplayer shooter. Overwatch only won it because it was more popular with normies.
>>728899026>didn't play>didn't play>played, didn't like>didn't play>didn't play>didn't play>didn't play>didn't play>played, didn't like>played, didn't like
>>728899026>yes>no>no>yes>no>no>yes>no>yes>no>mfw there's a rhythm to my tastesthat's how you know it's good
>>728901128overwatch genuine phenomenon when it came out
>>728904703post not slop>>728904828>Overwatch only won it because it was more popular with normies.Isn't that the point>>728904894based
>>728899026>ad>ad>ad>add>ad>ad>ad>add
if marvel rivals , valorant or apex are a thing now is because of overwatch people legit don't get how big as an impact that game was and i am tired of pretending it didn't deserved it
>>728905247>it didn't deserved itsaar, live service games should not be allowed to be nominated. The version of Overslop that won GotY no longer exists, so what is the point when it has no lasting legacy?
>>728905351>it has no lasting legacy?It spawned an entire industry dudeYour sour grapes about never being able to play it are irrelevant
>>728905351overwatch created an entire new genre , his impact can be feel to this day. Not their fault years later blizzard went retarded.And before TF2sisssies cry no one gave a shit about that game other than the hat economy.
>>728905454Doesn't change the fact that live service slop should be ineligible. Just because it spawned a bunch of addictive garbage for goycattle doesn't make it good
>>728905047>post not slopDeltaurneIt's literally a better game than all of these combined. But this event is for AAA slop only.
>>728899528overwatch wasn't live service. Overwatch 2 was the live service patch
>>728905664>deltatroonlmao
>>728905598>live service slop should be ineligible.Why? You're being arbitrary. At the time no one could see the future. Microsoft, Sony, Activision, EA etc lost billions betting that live service was the future.>>728905664havent played but i can believe it
>>728905664Deltarune has the GOTY for whatever year the full game launches on lock already
>>728905893Depends on the event. I mean, it can't be helped, if an event is for AAA it's not one worth considering in my view.
>>728899026>OverwatchEasily deserved, people who never even played a shooter before were mass installing it and it basically controlled the entire multiplayer landscape until BR got popular. People forget because of how hard blizzard hard threw but this IP easily could've surpassed something like Halo>BotwI think Mario Odyssey was better but yeah it deserves it arguably the first good open world game>god of warlmao>sekiroI don't know a single thing abo ut this game>tlo2LMAO>it takes twogot lucky with the year it came out in>elden ring>baldurs gatefair>astrobotfuck no Balatro basically invented a new genre of indie games and this just looks like another 3d platformer>expedition 33fuck no. The 2d platformer is the quintessence of gaming, a formula that has been mastered over 35 years ago, and Silksong stands above any other published this millenium, yet somehow the AI generated slop game takes the award instead
>>728905848>At the time no one could see the futureAre we pretending that they never intended to change the game over time? It should have never been nominated.
>>728903858Wukong is AA
>>728899026From those games I only played:Expedition 33Baldurs Gate 3Elden RingLast of Us 2 (dropped after 2 or 3 hours)Sekiro (dropped at water gorilla boss)God of WarZelda BOTW
>>728906673>Sekiro (dropped at water gorilla boss)many such cases
the bias against e33 is beyond pathetic because it gave me the same feeling i had with lost odyssey. A game that invites you to try other rpgs and celebrate the genre. Instead people use it as a weapon to attack a gene that is totally fine and weebs are seething because their panttsy animu slop are not getting awards.Hundred line is the biggest example , great idea in concept but the game ends being quantity slop over quality.Also i think Geoff defition of indie needs to change or at least separate indies A with AA
>>728899026the only deserved one was E33E33 SWEEP
>>728906242silksong isnt a platformer>>728906512We thought it was the new normal at the time
>>728899026I think it's ironic that the only snoy game deserving of a GOTY win (Returnal) lost to Josef Fares co-op slop. Grim
>>728907306GOODMORNINGSAAR
>>728903603>live service game that doesn't even exist nowThey will never deserve GOTYThey are fundamentally inferior by virtue of their design
>>728899208It was deserved to us 3000 years ago
>>728899026>somehow mhw didnt get 2018 gotyniggerism
>>728901128>gears 4nigggggaaaaaa how is that game so old....
>>728899026>GoW>not deservedYou MUST be better.
>>728900250>>728900000
