>tries to atone for his sins>cares for his community>a true gentleman and nice likeable guy all aroundwhy do y'all hate him again?
Why dis yt boy ain't rascis like me doe???
How dare you Jeremiah Compson? How dare you participate as an overseer in the legal trade of slavery.
>>729287625He's woke and gay so no, he's actually a pretty bad sinner currently and doesn't even feel guilty about it.
>>729287625blud masked up every time it didnt matter and the one time it matters he catches bovid and dies. when he started looking and acting like a sick dying cuck i rushed the ending.
>you keep misgenderin' folk, Dutch
>>729287625well the jewish history books all say the whites were racist and liked to use the nigger word, but for some reason arthurt doesnt. not period accurate.
>>729287625He insists
Why this criminal from 200 years ago has political views of 2025 democrat?
>>729287625He won’t call blacks and hispanics with racial slurs :(
>>729288214>those POC are not evil, brother, I’m telling you. Those damn red lining zones and hecking over policing are responsible for their high crime rate. I’d say we abolish the police and TRANSRIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS
>>729287625I insist, Dutch, we give women the right to vote.
>>729287625>y'allGo back.
well iunno there, dutch. if a man wants to cut his pecker off who'm i to stop him?
>>729287625
>>729287625He's not racist so naturally /v/ thinks he's a wuss. I'd say it takes a strong man to take a stand against that shit in the 19th century.
>>729289072>I'd say it takes a strong man to take a stand against that shit in the 19th century.Has nothing to do with his character. He's just portrayed as having sense, he's not portrayed as going against the grain and learning about himself or the world around him.
>>729287625WEEEELLLL I DUNNO MUCH BOUT ALL THAT I JUST KNOW IF WE HAD A BIPOC TRANS PRESIDENT MAYBE WE'D ALL BE HAPPIER FER IT DUTCH! IMAGINE ALL THE FOOD
>>729287849Its 126 years, retard.
>>729287625It's a meme that plays off the fact that Arthur is pretty morally and politically progressive, similar to Dutch, compared to the rest of the characters. The audience generally grants this creative license due to the fact they're outlaws and rebels of society but not /v/, because poking fun of it is funnier. It of course ignores the fact the first few missions of RDR2 have you debt collecting and you beat a sick man (he gives you tuberculosis) for not being able to repay his debts.>>729289391>kills a man because he legally owned slaves this one timeNo, you find out he was a slave catcher, you call him out on it, he blames a changing society (and you) for making his life harder and tries to shoot you with his old pistol you give back to him, but it jams. Also, you don't have to kill him, you can just walk away.
>>729289072>He's not racist so naturally /v/ thinks he's a wuss.These retards think that because they refuse to acknowledge that Arthur was raised in a multicultural gang and naturally he grew not to be racist. The in game world could have been a bit more racist though, and that women's vote mission is too on the nose
>>729289065>Wanting to go back to Tony 'Vito being gay is OK with me' Soprano.
>>729287625He's genuinely one of the most likeable protagonists we had in the past 2 decades.
>>729288154You do realize that slavery wasn't abolished yesterday?
>almost current year + 1>still salty about the depiction of the KKKI mean, HOW SENSITIVE are you guys?
>>729287849I say this in his voice sometimes and chuckle to myself
>>729287625>Spend twenty years being a vile human>Should be forgiven because for the last year you felt bad and did some minor acts of charity
>Yeah I murdered people, robbed them and terrorized them but you won't catch me being a god damned racist bigot, chud!
Simply put, John is betterBetter look, better storyline, better voice actor, better theme.
>>729292995>pro-feminst>pro-abortion>anti-sexual assault>pro-cuckoldry>anti-racist>pro-trans>anti-slavery>pro-illegal migration >would vote for black woman president Hmmm
>>729289563> multicultural gang and naturally he grew not to be racistMost racist people grew in multicultural areas, most anti-racist grew in gated communities
>>729293428Trvke
Because RDR didn't need a prequel
>>729289514>Also, you don't have to kill him, you can just walk away.You're right, but the game raising your honor level for killing this destitute old man who has nothing to live for was a bit much
>>729293526You shouldn't take everything you read on /v/ as fact. Try playing the game.
>>729293579That's why large cities are so overwhelmingly republican but rural towns are dem holdouts
>milkin' stallions?
>>729293662>racism is dictated by the political viewpoint you possesInsane to even type this absolute dipshit take out like it's a gotcha lmao pathetic
>>729293662Large cities are mostly segregated areas, most white folks live in white majority areas and so do blacks in black majority . Most anti-racist never go into black majority areas because it’s physically dangerous for them to go there
>>729287625How does he "atone for his sins" without accepting Christ?The game tries so hard to make that a point or whatever but never once does it bother to go any further into religion or actually having Arthur come to faith an say anything about Jesus / God in general to point to the fact he is saved through faith in Him alone. All because the studio behind the game is actually a progressive, atheist driven hellhole who does not actually wish to delve into proper, positive portrays of Christianity since on top of hating it, they are also scared of the backlash they would get from their degenerate fans for daring to portray Christianity there as a good and positive thing.By the way they wrote the story, Arthur is still going straight to Hell, regardless of how much he attempted to "atone" for what he did since God alone is the only one who could save him an wash away his sins through Christ's sacrifice on the cross. All that Arthur did in the end accounts for nothing when it comes to the ultimate, eternal wellbeing and safety of his soul since he died without having accepted Christ in his heart.
>>729293662>I like my black friends>as long as they live in their own neighbourhood as far from me as possible
The Honor system is a bit wonky since you can slaughter entire towns but you aren't locked out of the High Honor ending if you say Hello enough times. Also fuck the infinite spawn of police.
>>729293428John married a whore, he's worse by default.
>>729293751Racism is a political stance in itself and both mainstream American parties have clear stances on the topic. >>729293792>majority So not exclusively? I think if you check actual demographics, those "majority" white areas are still a smaller majority than that of a rural backwater.
he killed hundreds but it's ok because he makes a few jokes, has a journal, is a sad boy, and is ok with women voting
>>729293998John turned an illiterate whore into an honest woman
>>729294025What a pathetic faggot your dad raised damn
>>729287625I'm so tired of all these post-secular prophet protagonists
>>729287625>learns his lesson too late>doesn't really commit to the idea, still robs and murdersA bit tongue in cheek, innit?
>>729294104At least my dad raised me
>>729293579>Most racist people grew in multicultural areasThe difference is that multicultural areas people are forced to coexist with each other, but in Dutch's gang, there are but few people who share the same ideology and try to survive as scoundrels. Usually multiculturalism works in small numbers, but in large numbers it doesnt work, and this is why racism happens
>>729294142Arthur is a prophet?
>>729287849Arthur would never say this. Dutch would criticize others for accidentally using the wrong pronoun but then turn around and murder a tranny in cold blood
I don't like women, minorities or jews
>>729296732So brave
>>729296732>you need some betterin' kiddo
>>729287625>why do y'all hate him again?He's not racist (jewish coded)I don't hate the game though, the most expansive and detailed open world of them all after all, this is all I want from a game
>>729293101Niggers are uppity for what happened, like, 500 years ago and you're okay with that, so...
>>729287625I don't dislike him but there's no redeeming mass murder
Arthur is a better man
>>729287625>Slaughters towns by the hundreds >Can still be """honorable""" because you helped some NPCs ride to town on your horse The honor system was completely fucking retarded
>>729298678you just know it was some assholes self insert movd
