What does /v/ say?
>>729518576Where's E33?
>>729518576Terrible ps1 pissbaby boomer picks apart from FFX.
>>729518576Looks fine I don’t ever expect niche picks to win shit like this and it’s not offensively bad
>>729518603E33 sisters... our response?
>dude final fantasy lmfaowhy is that series so dominant in stuff like this? I expect JRPG fans to have more of a niche taste.
All right, but how about JRPGs that actually matter instead?
>>729518603It failed to resonate with actual JRPG enjoyers
>>729518576Cucked echoes should be replaced with MGQ Paradox.
>>729518576Why are FFXVI and Nier Automata here?
>>729518576>ff16>rpg???
>>729518576OST must have been a bloodbath
>>729518576>falcomslop>best anythingkek
>>729518576Overall safe and very mainstream picks, but still fairly reasonable choices, even if I disagree with most if them on a personal basis.Much better than any list /v/ would come up with, since this is a Nintendo hivemind and also filled with porn addicts, so the list would be filled with Nintendo-published stuff (ranging from mildly good like Mario RPG to mediocre like Xenoblade 2, plus the "tactical" one would obviously be a random Fire Emblem entry) and weebshit filled with hentai "humor".
>>729518576>FF9>best characters furry faggots
>>729518576>I started playing JRPGs in 2015.jpg
>>729519139Xenoblade 2 has good game mechanics and is fuckhuge it’d be an entirely reasonable pick
>>729519139>snoy seething again
>>729519139I see people posting this webm constantly as if to prove that the game is cringe. But in reality it's clearly meant to be silly on purpose for the sake of amusementThe fact that you don't realize this proves you're low IQ. The only cringe aspect of XB 2 is the fact that they call out attack names.
>>729519121Nier Automata 580Persona 5 Royal 549Chrono Cross 322Chrono Trigger 284Final Fantasy 8 193Final Fantasy VI 171Xenoblade 2 146Expedition 33 121Xenoblade 3 109Final Fantasy 7 107Nier Replicant 106Final Fantasy X 97Final Fantasy 8 81The World Ends With You 77Final Fantasy 13 65Persona 3 59Octopath Traveler 2 54The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky FC 27Persona 4 25Xenosaga III 19Legend of Mana 18Shin Megami Tensei V: Vengeance 14Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana 10Trails from Zero/Azure 9Neo The World Ends With You 8
>no E33>no Metaphor>no Persona>no Saga RemakeGreat taste
>>729518576>Kiseki>Yakuza>Cuck EchoesLolLmao even, reminder that you forgive your sister's rapist because he's a poor immigrant
>>729518576Never ever beating the Reddit Fantasy allegations.
>>729518576normal nigger taste but it's plebbit so
>>729518576>FFXOkay>FF7RDogshit>FFTVery overrated dogshit, one of the worst "tactical" RPGs there is>FF9Don't really agree but whatever>XenogearsLMAO>Chrono TriggerTrue>FF6Very overrated dogshit, mogged by other FFs, CT and several other JRPGsI don't have an opinion on the rest
>>729519543rebirth is that bad
>>729519543FFT is great>but it’s easyNobody cares it’s fun
>>729519215>sitting in one place while cutscenes and QTEs play out>"good game mechanics"
>>729519887That “criticism” could be applied to any turn based RPG you retard
>>729520029Hence why the whole genre sucks.
>>729518576FFXVI has good boss battles because...woah cutscenes
>>729520117Ok thanks for your input on the good games within a genre you neither like nor play
>>729520117Why are you in a thread, about a genre you don’t like?
WHERE THE FUCK IS PERSONA, SMT, PAPER MARIO, GOLDEN SUN, MOTHER, DRAGON QUEST 9, BRAVELY DEFAULT
>>729518603If it's not Japanese, it's not a Japanese RPG, simple as.
>>729518576Holy fuck I wish this was bait
>>729520252Persona is problematicWesterners don’t care about Dragon Quest or BDPaper Mario is too entry level even for RedditSMT makes American Christians uncomfortable
Too many FFs on this list. Not enough SMT.
Amarant immediately disqualifies FF9 from having best characters. These people don't know good cast of characters. XB2 unironically is better for that
>>729518576>best indie RPG is about a dude getting cuckedFits Reddit.
>>729519350based rapist
>>729518576Unironically better than any list modern /v/ could come up with
I have never played a FF game before, which "stand alone" games can I play?
>>729518576I don't think it's a bad list but I think best Tactical Game can be replaced with Unicorn Overlord.
>>729518576The most insulting part is the best ongoing series.
>>729521532You cant bro, gotta start with FF 1 on the NES or you wont understand the lore.
>>729521532They’re all stand alonePlay>5 if you want a bunch of jobs to pick from and a traditional story>6 if you want to play the boomer masterpiece >7 if you want to play the millennial masterpiece >9 if you want a more western traditional game that takes the best from all the ps1 games>10 if you want a hallway simulator with great characters story set in frutiger aero>12 if you want to play in ivalice and play Star Wars (this is the best game in the series btw)>15 if you want to go for a road trip with your bros >16 if you want to play game of thrones turn into animeslop
>>729518576Very boring and normalfags picks too many FF>nier>jrpglmao>ff9>best charactersThe main 4 that everyone use (Zidane, Garnet, Steiner and Vivi) are good the other half are nobody and forgotten especially the flaming faggot
>>729521532Just play Crystal Project instead
>>729521532Every FF game is stand alone.7 if you like cyberpunk/dystopian stuff.6 is you like fantasy sci-fi.9 if you lean more into fantasy.10 for tropical and religious tone.8 if you're a faggot hipster contrarian.
>>729518576>i only play normalfag shit the image
>>729518576>Best turn-basedWould have personally gone with DQXI, but that's a decent pick.>Rebirth best actionLiterally all of the Xenoblade games, including trash like Future Connected are better. Even in its own series FFXV is the better action game. Holy recency bias. >Nier Automata best soundtrackNigger are you fucking serious. I can't recall a single track from that game. Should have been another W for Xenoblade. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zUoXO0lU6nQ&list=RDzUoXO0lU6nQ&start_radio=1https://youtu.be/Kh2JI18ByvU?list=RDKh2JI18ByvUhttps://youtu.be/cvTb1VgABw8?list=RDcvTb1VgABw8https://youtu.be/60Ih-D49QJE?list=RD60Ih-D49QJEhttps://youtu.be/GVmBKxjk1DE?list=RDGVmBKxjk1DEhttps://youtu.be/Tx3AbguQZHU?list=RDTx3AbguQZHU>Chrono Trigger most replayableHaven't played it myself, but I can't imagine a game with no option to change jobs/classes belongs here. Agree or don't know/care enough about the rest.
>>729518576too much FF but surprisingly decent, just for being free of coomerbait it's already good
>>729521532X if you want to experience kino of highest order
>>729518576not a terrible list but the best indie rpg is def astlibra.
>>729519289What filter did you use ?
>>729522145Xenoblade is an autobattler.How the fuck could they be considered best action. I don't think you know what action means.
>>729518576Is Radiant Historia good? I've only heard the name in passing, but know nothing about it. Checking out the DS rom now, I do like Atlus RPGs.
>>729518576Holy fuck the shitsona fags are seethingYour shit games have no impact
>>729518576>best story>xenogearslmao
>>729522203>the most shilled indie rpg is def astlibrafixed.
>>729521532Final Fantasy 1 Pixel Remastered isn't a bad game at all. Very barebones obviously since it's an old as fuck game but it's fun enough.
>>729522145Xenoblade is a single player MMO.
>>729521956>>6 if you want to play the boomer masterpiece >>7 if you want to play the millennial masterpieceRetard,
>>729521532Anything between 4 through 10.The first 3 Final Fantasies really aren't that good.After Final Fantasy 10, the series experiments way too much and kind of loses its spirit. The only decent post-10 Final Fantasies are 11 and 14 but both are MMOs and nothing like the previous games. 14 has the best story in the series though.Unfortunately Final Fantasy's been hijacked by "auteur" directors who think they're too good for conventional JRPGs and constantly bend over backwards trying to prove to the world that "See, Final Fantasy isn't cringe like those anime games!"
>>729522485>"See, Final Fantasy isn't cringe like those anime games!"i wouldn't be surprised if once square and enix merged, whoever was running the show decided that dq was for the east and final fantasy was for the west and that's how we ended up where we are.
>>729518576>best action>FF7R>not Tales of Graces or any other Tales gameslop list
>>729518576Nier isn't an RPG. Anything other than FFVIII getting best soundtrack invalidates the entire list.
I'll be honest and this might be a controversial take, but I attribute a huge part of Final Fantasy's, and Square in general's decline to the formation of Monolith Soft, who took a lot of the creatives who worked on 2D Final Fantasies, Chrono Trigger/Chrono Cross, Xenogears, and a few other 2D square games, with them.
>>729520667Correct, but it is a JRPG.
>>729522807>not Tales of GracesTales of Graces was the first Tales game I dropped because it was so boring. People would say the story sucks but at least it has the best combat, but it really has probably the worst combat too.
>>729522904And then you realize they made the xenoblade series, a mediocre one
>>729518576better taste than /vpol/
>>729518576From top left to bottom right1. Never played it2. Never played it3. Most overrated tactics game of all time (it's not even actually tactics, it's just bog standard ff turn based with limited movement)4. Never played it5. Never played it6. Never played it7. It's good8. Never played it9. Never played it10. Hate it11. Never played it12. Never played it13. Kamige14. Overrated 15. True
>>729518576Meh, not bad.I love nier but the music wasn't special?Best turn based and more so best characters is out to fucking lunch.Rest I get though.
>>729519289>The only cringe aspect of XB 2 is the fact that they call out attack names.And 100% of the dialogue... and the maid robots. I do agree on the gif though at least.
>>729522145>>729523253what do you gain from outing yourself as ignorant zoomers? is this what you call a humiliation ritual?
>>729520129no it has the best boss battles because it's a spectacle fighter.
>>729519289Also FF9 I disagree with but understand. Chronocross? WTF!
>>729519289>I see people posting this webm constantly as if to prove that the game is cringe. But in reality it's clearly meant to be silly on purpose for the sake of amusementLiterally every cringe/stupid/gay webm or screenshot of a popular game on /v/ is like this.
>>729518576>No persona>No smt>No skies of arcadia>No Shadow HeartsGarbage list.Also FF16 is shit and not a Jrpg.Chronos Trigger is overated.
>>729518576Why doesn't /v/ make their own JRPG chart instead of bitching about someone else's chart?
>>729519543The funniest part is FFX is the only dogshit. You are wrong on multiple multiple levels. Read a book you pleb, thats obviously your problem.
>>729519289>skies of arcadia that highBased as fuck.
>>729518576>jrpg>gameplaylollmao
>>729518576its reddit but radiant historia might indeed be the most underrated one
>>729518576If this isn't bait then I pray for the demise of everyone who contributed to this. Fuck it, even if it's bait. I'm genuinely mad, it got me.
>>729518921>>729518664>>729518576Notice how Persona5/SMT is also absentHow come Reddit has better than taste than /v/?
>>729523697Someone give me a template maker and I'll do it. I refuse to put in effort.
>>729523467Seriosly. Though to be fair never played it is the vpol anthem. He deserves to be here more than we do post gamergate.
>>729522316>FilteredLmao
>>729523689>>No persona>>No smtRadiant Historia is the ATLUS pick
>>729523192And Xenosaga, an underrated masterpiece>Inb4 movie gameI don't care
If Xenogears had good gameplay would it be the best jrpg?
>>729523893Here I guess and just use a free polling site for votes
>>729523689>no fatlus shitAlready better than /v/
>>729521532VI, VII, VIII, IX, X are pretty good picksFor VII and IX you want to mod the Steam versions (you just need Moguri for IX and VII has a mod browser)>>729522485>After Final Fantasy 10, the series experiments way too much and kind of loses its spirit.It's because X is the last Squaresoft Final Fantasy gameSquare Enix a shit
>>729524174Radiant historia
>>729522248>>729522359I was told Xenoblade 2 connected to Xenosaga so I played it. Worste horniest 90 hours of my life for a shitty 5 min cutscene at the end. Just an awful awful fucking game with noth bad gameplay and plot.11/10 voice acting though.
>>729524063It already is.>Amazing artstyle (Kunihiko Tanaka)>Amazing graphics and cutscenes that aged a lot better than FF7>Story is self-explanatory>Mitsuda scoreThe only real flaw is the gameplay really, and even then, the problems are the encounter rate (something that was common at the time), the combat lacks depth and the platforming
>>729524097Radiant HistoriaGrandia 2
>>729518576>ffx>best turned basedfucking whatliterally linear until the end and when it opens up it's fast traveling through a menuthe gameplay is literally attack or different attack with the same shitty magic and summon system like any other FF gameextremely mediocre game to downright bad
>>729520667Chained Echoes is not Japanese
>>729522904Its an intresting theory. Its wild to me how influential that flop was. You'd see echos of it in almost all RPGs for the next decade. Ton of studios spun out of Monolith.Timeline adds up too as I think FFX was the beginning of the end.
>>729518576>no Star Ocean>no Sagagay niggerfaggot list
>>729524097>Japanese Role Playing Game Games
>>729524274Im at the end of chapter 7, and the beginning of Xenosaga 1 is much more interesting that the entirity of that
>>729524530Unlimited Saga is best slop.
>>729518576I don't trust anyone thst uses the term "JRPG" to know anything about RPGs or actually give a shit about them beyond lip service.
>>729524626>Unlimitedoh u
>>729524660JPRG and WRPG are different things
>>729522015>Crystal ProjectThis actually would've been my vote for best turn-based gameplay or gameplay in general. I've never played a JRPG where the gameplay was interesting enough to outweigh the fact the story is almost non-existent. And the music was amazing despite it being license-free.
>>729522807>Tales of Slop
>>729521532Tactics>7>6>9>3>5>Rebirth>16>Remake>15>12>X-2>1>2>10>Tactics GBA>8>4>Origins>Tactics DS>13They are all standalones if they have different numbersDont @ me without your own list. I dont care about your petty grievance autist. This list is objectively correct.
>>729524660FINALLY SOMEONE GETS IT! KINGDOM HEARTS, FINAL FANTASY V, TACTICS OGRE, DIABLO, AND FALLOUT 3 ARE ALL THE SAME GENRE!you're retarded
>>729518603it's too new, it'll be there next time they do t
>>729525049Rollslop is a JRPG and I like tomatoes in my fruit salad.
>>729524660if you don't like the genre why are you stinking up the thread, faggot?
>>729518576>No Dragon QuestInvalidated.
>>729525295Ive been wondering what I'd put for best turn-based. DQ11 probably is the winner?
>>729523697JRPGfags have been mindbroken because a few games released that aren't shit
>>729525482What makes DQ11 so much different than the other DQ games?
I would post my list but v would make fun of me
>>729525482if you think DQ11 has the best turn-based combat you really need to play more jrpg'sX-2 is better than X and DQXI
>>729524324Man imagine if Xenogears had at least 1 more year of development time , hell FFIX literally came out in 2000 I don't know why game developers were so allergic to delaying games back then , the combat system had so much potential only for them to not use the one unique quirk it had over it's competition and basically had it play out like any standard jrpg game except that it's even more simplified for a game that's over 70 hours long , in that aspect it honestly felt like disc 2 was more of a blessing in disguise since you didn't really have to deal with the half-assed combat system and awful encounter rate half the time , it's even more of a shame since the PSP was probably the best chance to actually remake the game and complete the second disc but the main developer left Square before the PSP hit the shelves to create a spiritual successor and cannot regain his original IP to this dayPretty sad
>>729523192The Xenoblade series is unironically the only mainstream modern JRPG series that picks up the torch where games like Chrono Trigger/Cross and the Grandia series left off.For some reason modern JRPG developers are allergic to adventure, everything now is a fucking military campaign, a high school/academy simulator, or contained entirely to a small area like a city.
>>729525664Why do you care about the opinion of trolls? If your list is serious people will reply normally
>>729525482I think DQ8 or DQ5 deserve a spotBut best turn based should be to something like SMT VV I think
>chained echoes on any "best" list of anythingNo. Fuck off with this actual cuck fetish german trash. I wasted fucking hours of my life for reincarnation cuck porn and the main character turning into a fucking bird.
>>729525675See my list, I liked X-2 >>729524892
>>729518576>Best turn basedIf we're going purely by gameplay it's a fair choice, there's better options though.>Best actionNo issues since we're strictly in JRPG genre.>Best TacticalAs much as I love FFT there's better choices in FE4 and Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together which is just FFT but even better.>Best Sidequests and minigameNo debate, you could just slot any Yakuza game in there and it'd be objectively correct if it wasn't for having to be a JRPG.>Experienceeh, OG FF7 has the better atmosphere.>Best StoryCorrect>Best Boss BatlesFor spectacle? yes. For challenge there's better options.>Best soundtrackI'd hesitate to call Nier a JRPG but if it qualifies then it's a no brainer.>Most ReplayableGood choice, but I'd personally go with Star Ocean 3.>Best indie jrpg>reddit>picking this over le ebin deltarune/undertaleI've never even heard of this game, is it any good?>Most underratedtrvth>Best remake/remasterbretty gud choice>Best retro jrpgobjectively correct. It's Ultima 7 if we're outside of the jrpg restriction.>Best ongoing seriesFalcom has been absolutely on fire in the past decade, correct choice.all in all better taste than expected.
>>729525675X-2 is not turn based.
>>729525896don't ever reply to me again faggot you have the worst subhuman trash ranking i've ever seen in my life
>>729525910>>Best soundtrack>I'd hesitate to call Nier a JRPG but if it qualifies then it's a no brainer.this is such an insane opinion. Automata OST isn't bad but it's mogged into the fucking dirt by everything Uematsu ever touched, most Atlus games, and many many many other OST's. fucking Stellar Blade OST is better than Automatas
>>729518576>a bunch of Final Fantasy fellatingI see why a bunch of tourists and normies think E33 is "best jrpg ever"
>>729521532V. All other replies are dumb and gay and probably have AIDS
>>729522904monolith made a career out of making ffxi clones.
>>729525645Only one Ive played besides 1. Im told I need to try 8 so I will.>>729525769That good huh? I liked but didn't love Persona so Ive always stayed away.
>>729526001Kek, X-2 faggot saying that is hilarious. At least I can take great comfort in knowing your shitty taste will never breed, or even be cared about, lol.
>>729526316>X-2 faggotfucking retard, i said the combat is good, it's low on my FF rankings. what makes you a dumbfuck nigger is having 15 or 12 above literally anything, and having 10 and 4 so low.
>>729526215The beginning of 8 and 5 are the peak of the series but they both fall off hard in the back half. Though nothing falls like 8.
>>729526091As much as I love Uematsu's whole body of work and the Atlus library that I've played so far, I genuinely do not believe there is a more consistently excellent single soundtrack for a single game than Automata's or even the OG nier's soundtrack which the remake bastardized in varying levels of severity per song.Okabe's entire library gets mogged by Uematsu's if they go head to head though.
>>729526475I know you have 10 high becuase you sound like a seething genetic deadend autust. Its probably why you are so "triggered". I just insulted your only friend. Even though this post shows you have reddit taste, and fans know it was a bad game and the beginning of the end.4 was just garbage and tells me you are a retard who was too dumb to get into college. Plot was not good.
>>729525664it's okay anon, whatever you have in mind, I have worse because I would make up rules on how to define a JRPG, like I would potentially include Elden Ring and a Korean roguelike anime builder because it is Japanese inspired and plays like a RPG
>>729526795i'm not even a huge 10fag, 9 and 7 are my top 2. your taste is just fucking dogshit to the point it feels like ragebait.
>>729525664I mean yea, but normal people are understanding and who cares what autistic fags think. They are just really mad that their family lines are done anyways.
>>729526849>you sound like a seething genetic deadend autust.>i'm not even a huge 10fag, 9 and 7 are my top 2Retard pottery, lol.
>>729522254i wasnt impressed, the combat is undercooked, the core mechanic of timelines isn't designed critically and will raise eyebrows each time, art is fine though
>>729526230>Only one Ive played besides 1. Im told I need to try 8 so I will.I mean I didn't meant to shit on XI but I just don't see it.It's pretty generic and plays the same as the other in the series, except maybe IV with its AI controlled party members
>>729525664We'll make fun of you anyway. Do it.
>>729521956All the westoid shit is what drags down XVI the most. Not the core principal anime and manga components
>>729518576>What does /v/ say?Redditors continue to have absolute dogshit opinions.
>>729523467>didn't play a bunch of recent shit like nier>that means you're a zoomerWow you're fucking retarded, zoomer
>jrpgfour of them aren't jrpgs>include westoid troonslop >don't have crystal project, probably the best western "jrpg" in existence from a pure gameplay perspectivewhy?
>>729527172Vvindswept had better have had a vvindfall from that game
>>729525664I mean, you have to accept that someone will call out the flaws of the games on your list but that's just part of discussing things.If the person you're responding to, isn't a fucking retard, it should be fine to say what you like about the game.Also, why give a fuck what someone on /v/ thinks anyways?If you say you like Persona or Pokemon or E33, retards will say that you don't actually play JRPGs.But name Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest (true normalfag picks) and nobody will say anything/v/ is too focused to being contrarian
>>729527084There is a bunch of ways to rate a game. I fucking loved FF9 but its 15 second battle load times make it unplayable today. So are we rating on how good it was at the time we played it, or how good it is now?Babe Ruth is amazing but lets not kid ourselves. Jr High players are better baseball players now.With that in mind, how would you rank top 3?
>>729518576>best turn based gameplay>not grandia
>>729518576FF16 isn't a JRPG. Even it's own producer Naoki Yoshida said it's not a JRPG.
FFT is such ass
>>729527391Well, it's about turn based gameplay and I just wanted to know his opinion why he picked DQ XI
>>729518576>automatanot an rpg
>>729527495In reality its a single player MMO add for an MMO. You are always going to have hazy blurry lines no matter what though.
>>729524274>he fell for the Enelcord shillingMany such cases
>>729527418The only place Grandia deserves on a list is "most dogshit port" with Grandia 2 and that retarded fight against Millenia
>>729527657This is more accurate of a description, it's a single player version of FF14 with better graphics.
>>729518576>actually surprised there is no "jrpg"->chained echoesInto the trash it goes.>>729518603Not a JRPG.
What's a good modern jrpg to play for someone who hasn't played any?
>>72952766190 fucking hours... staring frustratingly at those perfect tits you'll never get to suck on well autobattleing and listening to furry things talk about robot maids.
>>729527826>Not a jrpg Yes it is.Elden Ring is an RPG it's not a JRPG because it's made in the western style but it's still a Japanese made game, yet it's not made in the style of the genre that is JRPG. As Exp33 is a JRPG because it's made in the style of JRPG's and not a western rpg like Witcher 3 or Kingdom Come Deliverance.
>>729524274>someone recommends you the second Xenoblade game because you like Xenosaga>play Xenoblade Chronicles 2 instead of Xenoblade Chronicles X
Oink oink nigga lemme ow cuh
>>729525910Respectable and based.
>the JRPG thread from a bit ago>filed with people who love games discussing them>redditbait thread>full of screechers wailing and moaning about which games they hate the mostlol
>>729518739It's best jrpg. All others jrpg are far inferior
>>729527984The whole WRPG/JRPG system is retarded anyways.It should be split into cringeRPG, basedRPG and autisticRPGFor example Xenoblade Chronicles 2 is cringeRPG, Xenosaga would be a basedRPG and something like Etrian Odyssey an autisticRPG
>>7295281514chan has had Reddit Derangement Syndrome for quite some time. /v/'s case is pretty much terminal.
>>729528229I was about to call you a fucking retard after I read the first line, but then read the rest of your post and you won me 'round and I completely agree.
>>729519139Ninpedies aren't gamers.
>>729518792I knew SaGa schizo was the one shilling Enchant Farm.
>>729526581>>729526091Nobody played this game and its a single guy on a Piano but its my choice fir best Soundtrack. Though I respect FF7 and 9 as close 2nd and 3rd.https://youtu.be/rc1MMP9Jz7g?si=SszIFnaLpRG6nQaS
>>729527984It's not made in Japan by Japanese creatives so it fails the J in JRPG.
>>729518576>best turn-based>FFXStopped reading. At least got a good laugh out of it though.
>>729518576Best turnbasedPersona 3Best storyPersona 3Best charactersPersona 3Best boss battlesPersona 3Best sound trackPersona 3Best remakePersona 3Most replayableStar ocean 2 Most underratedResonance of fate Best retro rpgSkies of arcadia Best indie rpg Yiik a post modern rpg
>>729518576Should’ve been FFVII instead of X but not a bad list
>>729528265Kek, though to be fair tv/ is the worst. Ill never understand why its the most poltarded board by far, way ahead of even pol. I only go for Halloween recommendations and its ridiculously toxic.
>>729521532II
>>729518576>Chained echos >Best indie Good to know reddit is still retarded
how can xenosaga have the best story when its storytelling was disjointed and incomplete due to an obvious rush job to get the game out
>>729528649This. Though Im confused for Nier having best music and FF9 having the best characters. Both great games, id even respect 9 for best turn-based, but characters?
>>729528680/pol/ is far more level-headed when it comes to Reddit. They either laugh at redittors, or tell the reddit screencappers to fuck off./v/ goes into autistic shit fits over anything reddit./tv/ has always been a shithole, though, for varying reasons.
>>729518576>Most relatable isn't pokemonLove it it hate it pokemon has the most repayable JRPG by a massive margin
>>729528875vivi and steiner are basically the most universally loved characters in the PSX final fantasy games, like there are no differing opinions on that.
let's see you fags make a better one then
>>729528496Too bad, it's still a JRPG and more than that it's a better JRPG than most JRPGs that have been released for a very long time. Also,>Japanese creativesAlmost none left in Japanese vidya industry, they're all salarymen business execs trend chasing. That tells me right there you haven't got a fucking clue.
>>729528368I mean it is basically a SaGa game, so.
>>729528995I want a website that let's me put in the game titles automatically if I have to edit it myself for 1 reply that's too much effort.
>>729528823It isn’t, hence why Xenogears was better.
>>729525910Good post.
>>729524097top left to bottom rightOctopath 2Stranger of ParadiseDisgaea 4Xenoblade 3Final Fantasy XVSuikodenSoul SacrificeFFXIISecret of ManaTales of (insert your favorite here)Project CrystalPhantasy Star 4Odin Sphere LeifthrasirDragon Quest 3Xeno
>>729529235>cuckhold projectlist automatically invalidated because of your western garbage.
>>729528987I felt that way but haven't really heard others say it. Good answer though, makes sence. Sure as fuck isn't tailboy.Funniest I found is Square found Lightning to be their most recognized character edging out cloud. The best known character is their worste game, probably due to porn.
I'm just here for the autistic jrpg recommendations, carry onBout to continue my atelier journey, played ryza and marie remake so far, both has exceeded my expectations dramatically
>>729529275If chained echoes can be on the list, project crystal can.It's also a great game and you're a faggot.
>>729529235You and I have the EXACT opposite tastes. In every way, its uncanny. I kept trying to figure out why I loved Octopath 1 but dropped 2. I think you solved it with your list.Only one that makes me really mad becuase we are close is why Disgaea 4 over 5?
>>729518576
What Jrpgs would you in best characters Jrpg bros?For me I would probably put caligula effect because the writer actually put in way more effort that just generic anime girl maid and anime guy who likes to save people or whatever.I also liked Resonance of fate because it's just 3 friends shooting the shit about philothy etc.I'll also include things Persona since I like the social link stuff that let's you get to know em outside the main plot.
>>729529025Concessions accepted.
>>729529067Yeah, and no one is going to play it. Buy a fucking ad retard.
>>729529647>buy an ad>for a free gameNo, thanks.
>>729518576FFXVI is not a JRPG and even if it was it does not have good boss fights, despite the impressive spectacle. Radiant Historia is good though.
>>729524209XI is squaresoft
>>729529206Best turnbasedTrailsBest storyTrailsBest charactersTrailsBest boss battlesTrailsBest sound trackTrailsBest remakeTrailsMost replayableTrailsMost underratedTrailsBest retro rpgTrailsBest indie rpgTrails
>>729529624is caligula effect actually good? I keep seeing it at a discount but I never know what it's even about
>>729529119the same reason I haven't made my own
>>729528525I never got far into Resonance of Fate, but I remember finding it boring. Maybe I should go back to it someday, I did like the clockwork aesthetic of the city.
So what's the endgame of this thread shitting on reddit taste or shitting on especific fanbases?
Where's the entry for hottest character?
>>729529781I didn't like the gameplay but I liked the story and characters which is what kept me playing.The plot is like reverse persona where a bunch of losers are trapped in a simulation reliving their high school days but I don't want to spoil it.
>>729529624Fire Emblem 3 Houses. Just a bizare lightning in a bottle FE never repeated before or after.Than I'd probably go Xenogears than rebirth. Nu-Aeries Yuffie and Barret make up for Tifa and Cid.
>>729521532Can't go wrong with X
>>729529941Well Im not impressed going class over the dog slut shows character. Though the druid hag is obvious winner.
>>729518731mama mia, i cooka da pasta and other french words
>>729529981I love how she's the best character despite the lines and voice acting being straight out of engage.
>>729518576Most FFs oats are better than nier
>>729530237I-is Italy the same as France to you?
>>729518576Correct. Except for Trails that shit is so ass
>>729530257I just dont remember nier music, good or bad. I guess the metal remake of the ending song was fire but otherwise?https://youtu.be/v72zoaQVTg0?si=LW_TYomU98K0pdmc
>>729529980thanks! I'll keep an eye out, sounds interesting enough, mediocre gameplay is not unusual in jrpgs at the cost of a story/characters after all
>>729530353Absolutely.
>>729518576Terrible list but that is to be expected of leddit. I don't even consider nier jrpg and even if it was it it definitely doesn't deserve the best soundtrack spot. Personally I'd put Ar Tonelico into that one.
>>729530353American education, please don't be mean.
>>729521956>Recommending any after ffx
>>729529729I always forget that exists
>>729530579>Recommending any after ffix
>>729519139They voted the Trails series for "best ongoing", don't think they're better than us
>>729525295>>729525482There is not a single western tier list for JRPGs where a DQ game is making the Top 10, let alone Top 20, including the ones on this site.The series has no fans or real presence outside Japan.
>>729518576>trails>best ongoing seriesYikes
>>729530803>ongoingdoesn't have much competition
>>729528995Tried to limit it to one per series otherwise there'd be a lot of overlap. Also no 3D ARPGs included
any of you weebs can tell me what or who Tsuchibashi is?
>>729518576Normalfags really don't venture outside of Square RPGs much, huh? (Not even Enix since not a single DQ on there)
>>729530842I was thinking that. Still DQ11 made inroads. Blew me the fuck away and now Im wondering what I have been missing.Also we have to be able to top ff10. 7 is a much better answer but I sympathize it is unc slop. So what's the best turn based ever?
>>729531121For best ongoing id say DQ
