what does /v/ think of the official persona romance options?
>>730735732Only one you got right is Rise. It's Yukari and Sumire for their respective games.
>>730735732replace rise and makoto with marie and sumire
>>730735732Makoto sucks, real men go for Ohya or Kawakami.
>>730735860>>730735817P3 made an entire DLC where you control makoto's robot gf
>>730735732Why is the actual robot more fun and soulful than the bot in the middle?
>>730736136Because Makoto does nothing throughout P5's story but nag and ruin the fun flow of the game by making everyone else have to be written like utter retards in order to make her look smart. There's a reason the game majorly dips in quality around the time she joins, and doesn't recover until around the casino palace.
Romances in P5 that can't be canon like the teacher or the doctor are the best, but they'd never be canon because half the fanbase deems them problematic and fatlus would never dare to go against western fans. So we're left with mostly trash but out of all of them Makoto makes the most sense.>sumirecharacter is just a female joker that didn't make the cut before the vanilla game, so they reporpused her as another generic character>the five headbarely relevant at all, used goods, joins too late>journalist, hippy, shogi playerFluff romance options just to pad the roster of females joker can fuck>annshe's just a friend, acts like "one of the bros">futabathis one might work but i don't think sojiro would just ignore his surrogate daughter's moans coming from the atic, logistically impossible to romance
>>730735732I love Aigis and Rise
>>730737090Ann is for Ryuji anyway.
>>730737496>ryujifunny way to spell mona
I think they're good but there is minor room for improvements. See attached, I have perfected Rise by combining her with Belle Delphine
>>730737618The cat deserves to suffer.
>>730735732In my heart Kawakami is canon.
>>730737858Based
>>730735732You're completely right but it's just indicative of Atlus' dogshit taste and yoursWhenever people say "[modern] Atlus should just do games with a single love interest" I hope those people to go hell
>>730737997Nice.
>>730735732>Previous heroes daughters romanceable in Persona 6 Thouthgs?
>>730735732Adult women only
>>730737758Can you please no associate that STDs filled fatherless whore with Rise ever again. Thank you.
>>730738559
>>730738402This
>>730735732Rise was the only one I liked
>>730735732For me, it's>P3: Aigis>P4: Naoto>P5: Makoto
Rise is my waifu I want to marry her in real life not just the game. My dream is for God to create a cute wife based off rise for me. Naoto is cute too.
>>730735986Ohya always gave me the alcoholic aunt vibes who tries to bang her nephew.
>>730735732why would a i want a sex doll when i can get actual girls in P3?As for P5, all the characters in that game are dogshit, i'd rather romance that Rise's poster
>>730738150I think only the Persona 1 and 2 protagonists are old enough for their kids to be high school age for 6. Naoya could probably have a kid with Maki or Elly. Tatsuya would have a kid with some literal who given the ending of IS and EP. Maya is past her expiration date and lives alone imagining getting dicked by IS Tatsuya.
>>730741746Oooh that naoto drawing is so cute! Do you want God to make a cute naoto wife for you?
>>730735732EllyMayaAigisYukikoMakoto
>>730742309Persona started at 3
>>730738402Based
>>730735732for me it's elizabeth, naoto and haru
>>730735732I despise Makoto and Aigis
>>730742446>matching rings>bedt dates in the game>sweet and sarcastic personality that matches Joker wellYup, she's the one
>>730737090>fans are heavily anti-Ann and pro-Makoto, insisting Makoto is the only valuable person because she's smart and mature and so on>then Dispatch comes along, these same people all flock to the character who is stupid and unhinged
>>730735732I think that for me it's Naoto+Makoto and the rest of you Can take the rest.
>>730737758Wow, this is awful!
>>730735732Takemi clears shitkoto, since her social link is about her and not a rando npcAigis starts at the end of the game so it’s doa and i’m pretty sure Yukari is the canon choiceYukiko >>>>
>>730743531I prefer Makoto and BB thohaps.
>>730737090Joker is not a person and has no character therefore what the argument is actually about is objective worth. The discussion is really about who they like and want to succeed and who they hate and want to suffer.
i wish girls were real bros
Mitsuru Chie Makoto
>>730737090In addition, on the note of deeming characters problematic, they're so manipulative they find ways to deem ALL CHARACTERS WHO ARE NOT MAKOTO problematic. Do you understand that?
>>730743531Why does this redditslop keep getting shilled here?
>>730744947Anything that's contentious, anything that can be framed as a war or attacking some enemy will always be popular
>>730744947Girl on the left fits the two major types of girls /v/ loves: "tomboy" (meaning short hair and brown skin) and "I like the girl with actual personality" (in this case personality always refers to being a huge bitch).
>>730735732P3: ChihiroP4: AiP5: Hifumi
>>730745102Meh, brown girls are ugly and smelly except persians, and the cow ring is always cringe. Shit taste as always, /v/
>>730745102You act as if /v/ is any different from the rest of the internet
EllyUlalaFuukaAikaHaru
>>730735817Sumire gets kneecapped by never being a part of the team in spin-offs. And when she does appear it's always as Kasumi.
>>730735732Where's Ken?
I hope we can play as a girl in the next game.
>>730746036Why? So you can go on dates with guys and take dick?
>>730745764That's the Makotofag's excuse for her. They just try their best to pretend she doesn't exist.
>>730746131yeah
The goth doctor who peddles drugs got me acting unwise.
>>730742218Joker likes older women. Ren x Rise is canon (to me (I decide what's canon for everyone)).
>>730746228If you look at Royal in a vacuum then Sumire is the most pushed girl with Joker by far. But unlike Aigis and Rise they barely push Sumire anymore outside of the main game. Makotofags pretend she doesn't exist as much as Atlus does.>>730746589>anon's canon is that Rise is a whore that ditches her senpai who changed her life for some high school delinquent
I thought Ai was the canon romance for Yu. I swear I recall seeing that before, and people were mad because they only chose it for the stupid pun.
>>730735732>P3Aigis share custody with Yukari, the answer and the arena games don't make sense if Yukari and Door werent fucking, by how the games portray everything and the dates on P3 Yukari was the main bitch and Aigis the misstress, wich make sense as to why Yukari was coping and fuming when Aigis got the wild card.>P4here sadly is Marie, Marie and Yu are meant to be a couple at a conceptual level, just look at their roles in the game and their personas, Marie got an anime and everything, meanwhile while Rise crush is played straight it ends up as a gag of Her being blatant about it and Yu kinda dodging it, they even had Rise getting keked in the Golden anime.>P5unlike P4 here is actually Makoto lol, Makoto was Soejima and the staff pet character, she got basically two palaces of development, a plus 20 in all stats weapon, arguably the best desing of the pt outfits, never lose protagonism in the base game unlike Ann for example, get shumako moments in the base game like the griping joker by the leg gag (present in all spin offs as well btw) or getting saved by Joker or sitting together in the car, her SL is pretending to be a couple from almost the start, Katherine outfit, small stuff that keeps adding on, both of them get shilled in collabs outside of the game, they get shilled in Strikers and Tactica, got matching outfits in dancing, they act as "dads" of the group, its as blatant as it gets.Meanwhile Sumire>confined into royal hell, no arena, no tactica>the collabs she has in games don't shill her and joker together>her goodbye scene sucks ass and doesn't acknowledge the relationship>her sl is gimped by the story>you can barely use her>has like two romantic events (makoto is available for all)>her romantic events suck ass>Has 0 relationship with the rest of the cast (not even Marie was this keked)>b-but she confesses to you (so does haru)>b-but the matching outfits (so does Makoto in dancing)
>>730746953>arguably the best desing of the pt outfits,Kek her PT outfit sucks outside of showing off her ass. Only Futaba's is worse.
>>730746951It's Marie
>>730747278Joker>Makoto>Haru>Ann>Zenkichi>Yusuke>Akechi>Sumire>Ryuji>Morgana>Futaba
>>730746953I hate Makoto so much it's unreal but you're wrong in a number of parts like her being Soejima's favorite when she's really Hashino's favorite
>>730746872Because Atlus tries its hardest to force Makoto on people
This hurts me more than it should.
>>730735732>romance in videogames>lures people in with the idea that it's about preferences but it's actually all about propaganda and psychological engineering
>>730735732>Yukari - P3>Naoto - P4>Kawakami - P5Thats my taste, thank you
>>730748096I can't stand even looking at this fucking cunt.
>>730748202Sorry you aren't ALLOWED to have personal tastes you have to go along with what the manipulative fucking Jap writers preach at you for and browbeat you into
Beep boop
dogshit thread
>>730747968It's either forcing Makoto or pandering more to the Akechi/Joker fujos. No other options. Pick your poison.
>>730735732For me, it's>P3Elizabeth>P4 Ayane but marrying Nanako when she grows up>P5Lavenza
>>730748609I choose Akechi and Joker fujos, easily. I hate Makoto and I hate the Makoto wank with every fiber of my being I'm not even kidding.
>>730735732>posts all the shit choices
>>730735732I prefer Mitsuru over Aegis, but this is a good list
>>730748990You're a fucking subhuman
>>730735732But P5 canon romance is everyone.
There is no such thing as canon.
>>730749621makoto dies.
>>730749621Counterpoint:
>>730748680Why settle for 1 loli when you can have 2?
>>730737090>character is just a female joker that didn't make the cut before the vanilla gameonly thing in common is the red hair
>>730746872Sorry, Yu and Rise aren't canon.
>>730749960hey wait a sec
>>730749135no u
>>730749960hot
>>730743465
>>730735732seeeexseeeexseeeexhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6dCxrx4sNw
>>730745156>>730748202
>>730735732>AegisnothingI can understand the appeal (an innocent, blonde, blue-eyed doll seeking the meaning of life, and desires to fulfill your post-partum wishes) but she always felt like a plot device rather than a person.>MakotoI feel ATLUS regretted making Naoto have little impact in P4, so they overcompensated by making Makoto the most important character ever (still contributes nothing). Her appeal is a competent woman who is a little too strong-headed and has self-esteem issues (i.e. great girl who needs You), but again she puts me off because she's P5's plot device.>RiseI have to say, I actually liked Rise. My biggest problem with P4 was how shallow the girls were and how dependent they were on You. Meanwhile, the guys had actual problems that they learned to resolve. Rise was the best of both worlds: a pretty girl AND she resolves her arc of being uncertain who she should be. It ties her appeal and theme of the game nicely: a nice girl-next-door inside, but an ultra whatever-she-needs-to-be outside. The only suspicion of her being ATLUS' pick is that she can easily deduce cheating on Valentine's Day and her Christmas visit discusses Your stay in Inaba rather than gift-giving.Overall, these three aren't terrible picks, and I respect both anons who pick them or depart the mainsteam for whoever appealed to them the most.
>>730755138>not posting the right versionhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fobG6jZwtkg
>>730742446
>>730735732
>>730756894aigis is a weird one because her whole backstory is interesting (last of a line of killbots that were discontinued for some reason, is arguably the reason for half the plot happening due to shoving death inside of door)but p3 has little to no interest in actually going in to iti think it could've easily tied aigis', strega's, and mitsuru/ akihiko/ shinjiro's backstory into a clear through line of what kirijo was doing but it just doesn't hell, they could've even explained that the orphanage that akihiko and shinjiro were at was connected to the kirijo group and they torched it to cover their tracks with the orphans they were forcing personas on, like strega
>>730735817>Sumire Sumire isn’t in P5. How can she be the canon romance option in a game where she doesn’t exist?
>>730758552More Makoto fag bullshit from you
>>730757987>(last of a line of killbots that were discontinued for some reason, is arguably the reason for half the plot happening due to shoving death inside of door)It's strange that they elaborated on the killbots in The Answer and P4 Arena, but rarely spoke of Aegis being the first cast member to meet Door-kun. It would have been touching.>the orphanage that akihiko and shinjiro were at was connected to the kirijo group and they torched it to cover their tracksIt would have been metal, but overkill. Letting the fire be a stand-alone event better fits into the theme of death coming for us all. Though now that I think about it, everyone else's suffering is directly because of Kirijo Group. Perhaps Makoto will be freed once Mitsuru successfully turns it around.
>>730735732P3: All girls with Yukari being the main one, because womanizer.P3P: ShinjiroP4: Friendzoned everyone or Yukiko (He asks for her number.).P4G: MarieP4D: RiseP5: MakotoP5R: SumireFor the record, I personally chose Yukari, Akihiko, Chie first playthrough and Margaret the rest, Ann and after Royal Sumire.
>>730735732>what does /v/ think of my headcanon persona romance options?FTFY
