Contrarian testWhich looks better
Left.
>>732306141SAAARS NOOOBITCH BASTARD CONTRARIAN!!
>>732306097Left. The sprites are too big on the right.
>>732306097I like right better but I wouldn't want Castlevania to look like Kid Dracula necessarily.
>>732306097>>732306220Fuck off, Cris
>>732306097Left>>732306220Right>>732306280Left>>732306343Bottom for game but for art it's top>>732306396Bottom
>>732306473Right
>>732306097Left>>732306220Right>>732306280Left>>732306343Top>>732306396Bottom>>732306473Right
>>732306097>lefthardware limitations>rightindie game in 2025Right "looks" better but this is an objective question on fidelity and nothing else.
>>732306537Left
>>732306097 Left.>>732306220Neither>>732306280Right>>732306343Neither
>>732306616Right doesn't understand the appeal of Castlevania.
>>732306669If you want me to hate on Hades, as much as it deserves it, find a better example for left first.Right.
>>732306097Right>>732306220Right>>732306280Left>>732306343Bottom>>732306473Right
>>732306097Right looks better on a technical level but it doesn't at all match the artstyle that the original was trying to achieve
>>732306396They took all the soul away
>>732306537>>732306603>>732306720left
>>732306720Left looks awful, right looks boring.
>>732306792bottom
>>732306792Top.
>>732306220OP is the author of the drawing on the left, he's playing mind games so that we call his shitty work "soul"
>>732306097the retarded proportions and the stupid looking ground tiles ruin the right imageshows being talented at pixel art means nothing without a good style
>>732306938All disgusting.
>>732306097I think I would like the right pic more if it just went full chibi like Mighty Final Fight or Mighty Gunvolt.
>>732306097right would honestly be kino for a Kid Dracula game
>>732306938why does the orc look so homosexual in the fanart and the elf looks like a nigger?
>>732307230Me not that kind of orc.
>>732306097Right would look great if you darkened the background pixels by a step.
>>732306792Up>>732306938Up>>732306396Down>>732306343Down>>732306280Left>>732306220Right>>732306537Left>>732306473RightB, A
>>732307253crazy how small indie company Game Freak has never made a title that looks good for its time
>>732307320lel
>>732306097Neither look good with nearest neighbour.>>732306396Wonderboy 3 on master system looks absolutely incredible on an RGB CRT. It's unbelievable how good the sprites are.Outstanding game too. Everything that people claim Symphony of the Night brought to the "metroidvania" genre, was already done by Wonderboy 3 all the way back in 1989.
>>732306097Which one is playable? :^)
Cool an opportunity to post Amiga Castlevania https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pbi1Afg3So8
>>732306097 both are shit
>>732307253God Minish Cap has such good sprite work, they really must have put the whip to those artists
>>732306097>True scale vs heroic scale
>>732306097Right except for the character and enemy sprites, those are horrific
>>732306097Left has better readability and you know it. Right is a mock-up, look great, but for it to be useable in-game it wouldn't even need to be tweaked that much. just needs to differentiate from the foreground and background more.
>>732306097Simon looks weird on the right. Too short. Arms too huge for his height.
>>732306473Left, because we all know all the weebs who said "right" are just fucking AGP gooners.
>>732306823t. tendie
>>732306097This one is somewhat tough, the backgrounds are obviously better on the right, but I don't like the characters. Especially not for Castlevania.>>732306220This time right is easily better.
>>732307318right looks like a sex offender
>>732306097Right looks better overall but the character and monster sprites are fucking atrocious.
>>732306097Right's backgrounds are good, but making everyone super deformed ruins the atmosphere the original intended. I have to go with left. Doesn't matter if you're technically impressive if you missed the mark. >>732306220Right is better. I have no idea what the fuck is wrong with this board. >>732306280Left is superior in everyway. I could see a GBC dev crank that out or close enough. Pokemon has never looked good visually. >>732306343They're both shit honestly >>732306396Both look great>>732306473Both>>732307318Both
>>732306396Top looks like some kind of fucking flash game even if it has "objectively" better background and sprite art. There's something soulless about it that I just cannot put my finger on.
>>732307318>>732306473Both because the cartoony toyetic redesign leans into what they were trying to do in the original Power Modeler. Unlike OP which was a horror game chibified for some reason.
>>732307471Left.
>>732307519Here you go.
>>732306280A gba style pokemon game that looks like the left would be insanely kino.
>>732307634It's crazy how they never made a 2d pokemon game with actual animated battle sprites for attacks.
>>732307471Right is running on an outdated emulator
>>732306097Left is Castlevania, Right is Kid Dracula
>>732306938Top, Bottom, Top, BottomHoly fuck those middle ones look horrendous
>>732307253I think the DS is the only one I might give an edge to Pokemon, PH and ST feel very anemic with their character models especially compared to stuff like SM64DS
>>732313405I can never get over how fucking long they made Marco's face, dude looks like a banana, otherwise though Top all the way, Metal Slug should never leave the sprites it's still one of the greatest examples of spritework ever
>>732306097Left on a CRT.Right with a bullet through your brain.
>>732313405Bottom does look better, the character art on top looks absolutely atrocious, their skin colors are downright disgusting. Fio also actually looks attractive on bottom, she looks like a male on top.
>>732316467Why should people be killed because the art style is 16 bit? Are SNES and genesis now bad systems?
>732306097Right has better art, left has better scale.>732306220Right, no contest but the well on the cliff looks stupid>732306396Top but I think they should have kept the pixel style >732306537Left. The graphics are better on the right, but the left captures the density of the jungle better and is more visually interesting.>732306669Right has more character. Left has an issue with Mar-a-lago face.>>732306792Probably should compare 3d models to 3d models. Tifa’s chunky poly tits are iconic.>>732306938Middle pieces are nice, don’t think I’d go with that style though. The one on the right is an absolute fuck up though.>>732307253Zelda = soul throughout. Pokémon has always been kinda shit in the graphics department.>>732307318I prefer the one on the right but I feel like they fucked up the perspective of the shelves and it bothers me >>732307386Right for sure, but that’s gonna be a pain in the ass to animate >>732311287Right has more character >>732313405Bottom captures the design of the characters well but just isn’t as cool to look at, so top is better
>>732306220Right>>732306378Sneed
>>732308247Shouldn't be any surprise. It was made by old Capcom, back when they were one of THE best 2D artists in the industry, Only beaten by SNK and Vanillaware.
>>732306097>leftright probably has gay voice acting by arin hanson
>>732309501It's traditionally animated in motion at the least. Their take on the music is fantastic also.
>>732306097Right completely misses the tone the original Castlevania is going for, so left
>>732307519B, A, Start
>>732306097everything on the right except the character model
