Only 3 of the games pictured deserve to be there. Can you guess which ones?
THPS3Perfect DarkSoul Calibur
>>735089686*2SC2 and OoT
>>735089686SC2Prime OoT
OoTMetroid PrimeGTA IV
Ocarina, Mario Galaxy and BOTW
Ocarina, perfect dark and soul calibur would be my favorites, but the only entries that actively annoy me being there are gta5 and Mario Galaxy.
>>735089686all unironically shit
>>735089686Ocarina, Galaxy 2 and Prime
>not a single game made before gen 5 on metacritic>Sega Saturn missing entirely out of the gen 5 systems
>>735089686SMG 1 + 2 are still very fun to play, timeless classics.Most of the boomer games aged like shit (terrible graphics, dreadful controls, 10-20 fps) and don't deserve to be there in the context of it currently being 2026.>RDR2Too slow>BotWOverrated>GTA VHow is it that high>OoTShit controls (specifically the camera + z-targetting), poor performance, obtuse dungeon designs, secrets are shit ("lmao go to this obscure corner of the map and play every Ocarina song until one of them happens to be the correct one and you'll get a Skulltula")I can't really pick a third game. They're all bad.
>>735090768>Shit controls (specifically the camera + z-targetting),Shit camera and "z-targetting" are staples upheld by From Software to this very day and I have been led to believe they're some of the best games ever made.
>>735089686
>>735090059>SC2>Hawks3>BotwOoT doesn't hold up anymore
OoT, Galaxy 2 and Prime.The GTA games and SC are there to appeal to blacks and browns so they can be safely discarded.
>>735091094>boomer choices>mind is so mush he can't even count to 3Checks out.
>>735090693>not a singlethe real distinction is that all of those titles are 3D action games.Reviewers have been 3D cucks for the longest time
>>735091503That's just a byproduct of not having any home console before PS1 (or the 2D powerhouse Saturn). Handhelds always get lower scores than home console releases which is why you have a Link to the Past at 43. when it absolutely rapes most of the games in OP.
>>735089686Gta 3 gta 4 gta 5
Bump
>>735089686>All that western trashDisgusting
>>735089686OcarinaGalaxyPrime
>>735089686gta 4, gta 5 and rdr2
>>735089686I mean that's just objectively false. These are in the top 12 on Metacritic after all.
>>735089686prime, botw, thps3galaxy is the worst 3D mario game ever
Gta VRed dead 2Perfect dark
>>735091731>having any home consoles before PS1what?It's a byproduct because they only started rating games since around '95. You'd expect to see ALTTP, SF2, DK country 2, Catlevania SotN, Chrono Trigger here but they are too old.You'd expect to see a Diablo 2, RCT, Civilization, Half Life, Deus Ex but they are PC games.there isn't even a racing game like Underground 2, no rts like RedAlert 2, no rpg like DQ8, no Ghost Trick, Noita, because all of those are genre games not made for the most common denominator reviewfag. It's always surprising that SC often makes it on toplists, but you have to remind yourself that SC had incredibly smooth animations at release basically no other fighting game could keep up with for a while. Darkstalkers had this in 2D but reviewers didn't care about 2D anymore.
>>735089686where the fuck is cory in the house
>>735093431>It's a byproduct because they only started rating games since around '95.They? Who the fuck is "they"? I can dig up review scores for games released in the 1980s and Famitsu has been doing reviews since the mid 1980s for every major title. It's a purely random line in the sand that metacritic decided to draw because they couldn't be bothered to dig for old reviews.
>>735089686galaxyrdr2soul calibur
>>735093431>You'd expect to see a Diablo 2, RCT, Civilization, Half Life, Deus Ex but they are PC games.https://www.metacritic.com/game/diablo-ii/https://www.metacritic.com/game/half-life/https://www.metacritic.com/game/deus-ex/They're all listed but they aren't rated high enough. having played all three I do kinda agree that the usual OoT, Galaxy 2 and MP1 are better games, even if I enjoy all three PC games immensely. Milage may vary.
>>735089686Perfect Hawk's Redemption 2
>>735089686Perfect DarkPro Skater 3Metroid PrimeIf San Andreas was on here instead of every GTA game not called San Andreas I’d put it ahead of Pro Skater 3
