[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 20260401_185718.jpg (3.24 MB, 4000x3000)
3.24 MB
3.24 MB JPG
Why are they giving this movie 30-45~ scores?

Its really well animated, Peach isn't as much of a girlboss, The cameos were not intrusive, has a normal child/family adventure movie plot.

Is rotten tomatoes filled with furfags or something?
>>
dis nigga really went to a movie theater for bing bing lmaoooooo
>>
>>736202445
cause it sucks dick
>>
It's an advertisement you pay to see
>>
>>736202445
It just fails at being a film.
In a proper adventure film, the characters have flaws that are challenged over the course of the adventure, which results in character development that is necessary to solve the plot.
In this movie, the only character that changes is Bowser, but his development is dropped and has no effect on the plot whatsoever.
The characters constantly split up only to meet at the same locations and only serve as a means of delivering more 'memberberries to the audience.
Rosalina is barely in the film despite being the emotional backbone of the game they are supposedly adapting.

The lack of character development means the film only exists to be a showcase for mario stuff O N T H E B I G S C R E E N which I don't really care about.
>>
File: 1771462538616317.png (131 KB, 741x231)
131 KB
131 KB PNG
>>736202445
>Is rotten tomatoes filled with furfags or something?
kek, are you still seething about this?
>>
>>736202445
The critics score is for once accurate
>>
disney is afraid of nintendo, it's a collective hitpiece by paid journos but it won't work because kids don't give a shit about review scores
>>
File: Keys-jingle.gif (740 KB, 165x161)
740 KB
740 KB GIF
>>736202445
>Its really well animated
The faces look really bad. so it's really not well animated.
the plot is some of the worst garbage ever made. a family plot is something like the incredibles or ratatouille that adults can actually enjoy.
not this absolutely slop that only a child with brain damage would think was good.
>>
File: export202604012306358340.png (121 KB, 1600x1600)
121 KB
121 KB PNG
>>736204660
I havent even seen the shit yet, but seriously dude go make a fucking movie. its abundantly clear you have what it takes vs several multi billion dollar companies.
>>
>>736204031
There's another way of putting it.
It attacks the problem in the womb, this way:
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1775099899181681.mp4
>>
>>736202445
grow up tendie
>>
>>736206548
The movie sucks
>>
I thought it was fun if you're a Mario fan. It's not like it's an amazing film. Power-ups appear as needed like deus ex machinas, it's a lot of references, and not enough is really established to make it work as a self-contained film. But it's totally enjoyable if you like Mario and are familiar with his games.

Sonic 3 was the better movie, because even though that's also not really self-contained, it at least has more going with the narrative it introduces. Lower lows, but higher highs.
>>
>>736208950
>But it's totally enjoyable if you like Mario and are familiar with his games.
No it's not.
because even then none of the characters even remotely resemble their counterparts from the games.
they are the characters in name only.
>>
>>736202445
it barely has a plot, just like the first movie, it's just a bunch o references thrown together so tendies can soiface
>>
>>736209179
You have brain damage.
>>
>>736209179
>Mario
>Character
I can't believe the grand narrative of Super Mario has been sullied by this movie
What's next, Mickey Mouse? The Sunday funnies? I am literally crying and shaking, mamma mia...
>>
>>736202445
>Is rotten tomatoes filled with furfags or something?
If they are then the score is actually inflated thanks to Fox.
>>
Watch it for yourself

aHR0cHM6Ly9tZWdhLm56L2ZpbGUvRFVvU3hJQkkjNzg3ZzBodzJhdjJsMS1MajBaUFhSd3pMeV9QS1AybVZ5VFJ1TUhjX2RsSQ==
>>
>>736202445
>Is rotten tomatoes filled with furfags or something?
This movie stars a furry and two lizards that gay men love.
>>
File: IMG_3354.jpg (115 KB, 1077x1184)
115 KB
115 KB JPG
>>736202445
It was too many fucking characters shoved into one movie. Just a bunch of TikTok shorts in sequence.
>>
>>736202445
Because it's not a movie.
>muh girlboss or not!
no one cares.

It's useful, when watching a scene in a movie you're analyzing, to think in terms of what it accomplished in the overall structure of the movie.
That isn't to say that every scene must move the plot forward (though that is part of writing a -tight- script), but that every scene should serve a purpose. Maybe it provides characterization that will be needed later, or provides a break in the action so the audience isn't overwhelmed, or plays into specific themes or character arcs. If a scene can be cut from your movie without any impact on the rest of the edit then that scene should be scrapped or entirely reworked.

I say all this because nearly every scene in the Mario Galaxy movie could be scrapped and it would be the exact same movie. You could literally just have the start with Rosalina's capture, everyone goes to rescue her, final scenes, it would be the same fucking movie but 20 minutes long.

Reviewers aren't being hyperbolic when they call this an anti-movie. The previous Mario film at least pretended to have story beats and a character arc; it fucked up the paint by numbers but you could still recognize the form of the picture. This movie has none of that to the point that people might rightly compare it to clip shows.

The closest it gets to any kind of actual writing is Peach wanting to find her Sister and discover her origins, which takes up approximately 35 seconds of runtime and has no impact on her character whatsoever.

Have some gock
>>
>>736206548
>you can't criticize a thing if you can't make a better one
thats not how it works
>>
Since when were Peach and Rosalina fucking sisters. Lame as FUCK reveal
>>
>>736202445
the movie is great, don't listen to retards telling you otherwise
>>
>>736204517
This is delusional. I'm a Nintendo fanboy and the movie sucked. It felt like they completely phoned in the script.
>uh i got heckin teleported here because my engine malfunctioned, that's why i'm here. Buy my new game when it comes out.
Just one action scene after another and the justification for anything happening was so flimsy.
They should've come up with a better plot and character development. Fewer characters with more development and time to shine is more enjoyable. Instead they threw a ton of watered down shit into a blender. Mario felt like a side character in his own movie.
>>
>>736209972
It's the NCU retcon
>>
>>736202445
post top 10 movies OP
>>
I'm not seeing this one because the first one fucking sucked and subverted everything foundational to what made the Mario story work.
>>
>>736204031
>a movie has to have le epic character developer because thats what they told me at artsy fartsy school!!1!
Dont care
>>
>>736210019
> Mario felt like a side character in his own movie.
I got so annoyed when they immediately cut to Peach doing her Mary Sue gymnastics after Mario closed off the gate instead of showing the main character fight the antagonists. Make a Super Girlboss Sisters movie and FUCK OFF whoever wrote the script.
>>
if this fails will nintendo stop making movies?
>>
>>736202445
Critics don't like the movie because they don't understand video games. They still think all video games are "Nintendo" Just look at the Chris Pratt interview where he talks about "stomping on turtles n sheeet" like he knows absolutely nothing about Mario or video games.
It's a niche movie marketed for millennials and their children. Movie critics are like vidya journalists where they look for dumb wokeslop to worship like that white slavery movie that dominated the oscars.

There are problems with the Mario movie that are legit. There's no direction. It feels like a bunch of youtube shorts spliced together that doesn't make sense even with context. This is acceptable for children. I don't even know what Mario and Luigi themselves do in the movie besides fight Bowser/Jr. together. It's weird that half way through the movie Fox steals the spotlight and so jarring that a non-Mario character is the most memorable character in a Mario movie.
>>
>>736202445
China has heavily invaded hollywood. And we all know how the chinks feel about the nips.
>>
>>736210240
>a movie needs a le story
Yes, faggot.
>>
>>736206548
This is the biggest cuck argument of all time.
>>
>>736210258
It's already the best selling movie released on a Wednesday in history. It will shatter the box office come the weekend.

The bowser death scene was fucking brutal I can't believe they showed that in a kids movie.
>>
>>736202445
It's barely a movie. It's just references and setpieces on ADHD speed. I can imagine someone who hasn't played the games being completely lost by all the random shit happening.
>>
>>736202445
>buster_at_the_computer.jpg
>>
File: illumination.jpg (627 KB, 945x2486)
627 KB
627 KB JPG
>>736204660
>The faces look really bad
They use this expression too often, I don't care for it
>>
>>736210346
Why? Also you seem to be confusing story with plot but in eithee case, why?
>>
File: 1741396544851949.jpg (41 KB, 680x494)
41 KB
41 KB JPG
>>736209943
No, he's right, youre a faggot if your argument isnt any more elaborate than "Its objectively bad because I say its bad and Im an authority because I said I am"
Niggers like you and hacks like the poketranny and nerrel need to stop pretending you have a triple digit IQ.
>>
>>736206548
Sure, give me several billion dollars. Right now.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.