There is no truly bad 3D Zelda.
>>736441843Dang someone made an image of all the bad 3D zelda games. That'z really convenient.
>>736441843>WW7/10. The Triforce piece section knocks it down a point. >TP6/10>SS5/10>BotW4/10>TotKWhatever Breath of the Wild got.
OOT and MM are vastly superior to the other ones to such a vast degree that they might as well be considered a different franchise.
But Skyward Sword is right there
being boring is worse than being bad
OOT > MM > BOTW > TP = WW > SS > TOTK
Tired of the SS revisionism.
OOT > MM > WW >>>>> TP >> BOTW >> SS >> TOTK
>>736441843Don't care, ALttP mogs every 3D Zelda in every aspect.
OoT > MM > WW > TotK > BotW > TP > SS.
>>736441843tp and ss alone prove you wrong, nigger
>>736447928What's wrong with TP?
>>7364418438.8 blunder of the century
Windwaker is fucking awful. It fails in every regard >braindead combat trivialized by the QTE counter, enemies standing around doing nothing, or the boomerang stun>the “open world” is railroaded by the KoRL until half the game is over, and then you still might as well wait for the triforce hunt because you’ll just be revisiting the islands anyway>the beams of light can only be found by paying tingle, and they disappear when you get close, so you’re just wasting time dropping your grappling hook trying to hit the right spot underwater>dungeons are fucking dogshit>final ganon fight is brainless: you literally can’t do anything to him until the counter prompts you or zelda shoots him with a light arrow>forsaken fortress return is literally just two boss fights and a staircase between them
Wind waker is an 8TP is a 7Ss is a 6 and the only bad 3d ZeldaBotw is right but totk is a 9
>>736441843WW and SS way too highOoT and MM can't both be 10/10sOne can be but the other is so different that also calling it a 10/10 feels more like you're just glazing them for being the earliest+best games instead of legitimately critiquing them
>>736448421>OoT and MM can't both be 10/10snah
>>736448329It looks cute, therefore it’s the best one.
>>736441843Objectively true, Zelda has a pretty good track record of great games. OoT & MM was the peak.
>>736448463I like the cute artstyle personally, but I know everybody in their mother shat their pants in seethe back in 2002 and Nintendo had to quickly get Twilight Princess out to quell the outrage.
>>736441843Isn't Tears of the Kingdom the fucking same as Breath of The Wild?
>>736441843They're all bad compared to the top down games
>>736448581I remember every cel shaded game was maligned back in the day
SS is at least an 8/10. I'd personally rank it a 9/10. People just rank it low compared to other Zelda titles. It's still better than 99% of video games period.
>>736448979your rating goes up or down 3 points depending on whether the controls worked for you or not
>>736448610no, its worse
>>736449068The motion controls in the original version are really good. Some enemies like bokoblins are annoying as fuck but the boss fights are awesome.
>>736448979This is the case for every zelda game, there are games worse than other zeldas but overall they're all in the upper echelon of vidya
>>736441843BOTW and TOTK
I loved SS, including the waggling. I've beaten TP on wii with waggling as well like 5 times. I don't get the hate, it gives it variety
>>736450063SS is not waggle. It's actual motion controls. TP is waggle because the motion controls were a last minute addition and swinging the wiimote is just a less accurate button press. TP has better aiming than SS though because it's infrared and SS was gyro and gyro aiming SUCKS.
>>736450273Sure, but I'm just saying I liked motion controls
>>736450361Other than the bow aiming I can do without it in TP. SS was what I though TP's motion controls would be and it was fun, especially the boss rush mode.
>>736441843Skyward Sword sucked.
>>736441843except SS and TP and BOTW and TOTK. those ones are pretty bad
>>736450273>SS is not waggle.You absolutely cannot swing the Wii Remote like it's a sword. The motion detection will shit itself and Link will do something completely different. The game basically involves figuring out what they're actually looking for and doing exactly that instead of what would make sense given the situation.
>>736448610More or less yes. It has much higher highs but also some lower lows. BotW is kind of a straight line with no real peaks or valleys. It comes out to them being equal.
>>736441843EIGHT POINT EIGHT
>>736441843Fixed your shitty list OP
>>736442780This. They carry this series on their back.
>>736448979I give SS a C plus.
>>736452080Credentials?
There is no truly good 3D Zelda.
>>736448610TotK is one of the most bizarre games in the entire franchise honestly.
>>736441843I did not enjoy the new two. Not even old good new bad because I never played the old ones.
WW is an unfinished mess
