>First yoshi game is one of the best platformers ever made, holds up flawlessly to this day >all subsequent Yoshi games are exceptionally mid in the 5-7 out of 10 range>Yoshi and the Mysterious Book looks like it’s just more midslopWhy did Nintendo do this?
Better than Island Those who argue otherwise haven't played it
>>737498076That game is the definition of 7/10 forced soulYoshi’s Island feels like an epic adventure. Everything that’s come after has been an inferior retread that doesn’t capture the adventure epic feeling of the original
It was supposed to be their last 2D game as they were ready to move forever into 3D with Super Mario 64 releasing next year so they aimed to create the best 2D game possible. The internal 2D Dream Team was disbanded after that and separated to different projects and the Yoshi IP was tossed for third parties to do something with.
>>737498076Truer words were never spoken
>>737498076Nintendo should port it to switch. I don’t want to dust off my Wii U.
>>737497916poor man's mario world kek
>>737497916Yoshi's story all melons > Yoshi's island
I know you guys hate remakes but Nintendo should remake yoshi’s island using hand drawn animation.
>>737497916Nintendo misunderstood the appeal of Yoshi's Island. Yoshi's Island was loved for it's thrilling gameplay, fantastic level design and charming aesthetic mimcking storybooks. It seems Nintendo only read that people enjoyed the general storybook vbe of Yoshi's Island and nothing else. Since then Yoshi has been regulated to platformers focued on "wacky and novel aesthetics" for possible gameplay gimmicks, while gearing towards a younger and younger auidence with each entry. It's sad, Yoshi's Island on SNES is easily one of Nintendos best games, far exceeding any Wario, DKC or even Sonic game during that era.
>>737497916Indie platformers are so much better than the big budget ones. It’s a lost art to large studios.
Yoshi's Story is good
>>737497916Blame this fat faggot.
this gets overhated for no reason>hurr durr ItZ a KiDz GaMe!nigger, all video games are for kids
>>737497916>go for 100%>red coin disappears in you are pathheh... nothin personnel kid
>>737503294>Oh man I love playing the same game over and over again just to maybe experience one new levelSaid no one ever
>>737503170BALD
>>737497916>holds up flawlessly to this dayI recall the vehicle transformation sections being pretty boring and lame
>>737503294>nigger, all video games are for kidsBashing your own hobby is some insecure behavior.
>>737498076I tried this game twice both on Wii U and 3DS, never finished either version. I don't think it's bad or anything but it really doesn't engross me at all either. I don't see how this could be seen as better than Island, second to it I could easily agree with better is baffling.
>>737503695I remember there being a particularly annoying auto scrolling level with multiple junctions that required several replays to memorize the correct route for those coins.
>>737497916They keep giving the series to third party studios that don't understand or care what made Yoshi's Island great. Each attempt to follow Yoshi's Island has been a poor imitation and each time they try something more unique it's just mediocre slop and some of them even feel akin to a licensed game.>>737503294This game is why the Yoshi series is the way it is in the present day, in both mediocre games and presentation.
I don't care where games take him. I'll be there. I've loved Yoshi since I was a kid and that weird little 'saddle noise' he had in SMW will be burned into my brain forever.
>>737503704You know you can go through the game 4 times without playing the same level a single time right?
>>737498515>cover of the box/cart literally says Super Mario World 2Illiterate faggot.
>>737507037>Just know where everything is and collect the required items to unlock the levels before you grab enough fruit to automatically end the levelSaid no one ever
>>737507637>it's a baby game>but I can't find the collectiblesThe hearts make noise if you're near them, it's absolutely trivial to find them. This is a baby game anon, it is not hard to unlock all the levels.
>>737498325They have the right idea making their potential last 2D platformer something like Mario Maker so the fans can continue making new content for themselves. Maybe make the real last 2D game something that can emulate the mechanics of the majority of 2D Mario/Yoshi/Wario games and everything in between?
>>737497916$10 off physical at Walmart. Looks fun to be honest. It’s a SM64/Wario Land 3 kind of puzzle game. Not a point A to B platformer.https://www.walmart.com/ip/19926072010?sid=6151E3B7-D62E-458F-A75C-304751348B7C
>>737503294>overhated for no reason>ruined Yoshi's design for years>source of the recycled voice clips we've heard for nearly 3 decades despite Kazumi Totaka recording new ones>vast majority of levels are literal straight lines, barely any change in terrain or platforms>ridiculously short game, even if you replay to access the other levels>eating 30 fruit is stupidly easy>eating 30 melons is just tedious and you get nothing for it>absolute joke bosses, final boss has a fucking invincibility fruit you can eat>White and Black Yoshi can't be used in Trial Mode>saying all games are for kids as if that excuses this particular game from being more brain dead than others
>>737506556For you anon, I hope this new game is good.
>>737505396I look at Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze, then at Yoshi Crafted World and sigh
>>737503294This game was crap and I thought this at the time when ANY new game I got was good.
>>737498076how is the 3DS version anyway? i don't want to dust off my Wii U, but grabbing it off H shop is easy enough.
>>737497916Takashi Tezuka stopped making Nintendo's games.Yoshi's Island was his last game, and their last truly great game.
>>737503170You mean thank him for making such brilliant games in the first place.He designed/directed all of nintendos greatest games.Zelda 1Zelda 3Zelda LAMario 3Mario 4Yoshis Island.
>>737503294Even Murder Sex Gore Kill Bloodsport Penis Flaying Hitler 2: More Gore More Fury?
>>737497916Yoshi's Island was born because Miyamoto felt mogged by Plok.
>>737497916this. tendies say we can't criticize nintendo because they make products for babies but nintendo games were never this piss easy before so who the fuck are these $80 retard games being made for?
>>737503294not all video games are for kids, autist.
>>737513513really its just the next evolution of modern games where "death" means rolling back to 5 seconds ago.
It's insane that we still don't have a 3D Yoshi game and instead they keep trying gimmicky shit. They already had perfected 3D Yoshi controls as far back as SM64 DS.
>>737513513Just like Warioland 3
