If this is a 10/10, what does that make the original, a 14/10?
It's not a 10/10
It's not a 10/10 and neither is the original
>>738020681>what does that make the originala solid 5/10
It's 9.5/10, the original being 9/10.
>>738020776Nah, the original gets bonus points for being innovative
>>738020681The DEmake is irredeemable cancer, that nobody asked for. It's an all around massive downgrade from the OG RE4, that indeed is one of the few truly timeless, groundbreaking, endlessly engaging masterpieces.
>>738021312And the remake gets less for being a remake? That makes no sense. The remake improved on the original by trimming the fat
A 6/10 because it doesn't account for modern audience's sensibilities
>>738021438>And the remake gets less for being a remake?Yes? Innovation is objectively superior to deriviation.
>>738021598But the innovation is still present in the remake. It wasn't removed. There's plenty of shitty games dragging the industry down, yet RE4R remains winning. They get praise for not shitting the bed, too
>>738021418>It's an all around massive UPGRADE from the OG RE4FTFY
>>738021916>But the innovation is still present in the remakeWhat new ideas did the remake bring to the gaming industry?
>>738021312>>738022025>b-but its innovative!!!So is the original ford car and yet no one drives it cause it sucks now
>>738022025The realization that QTEs were retarded, for once
>>738020681I got to the castle in the remake and got tired of it and moved on to something else.
Could Leon defeat the Skulls?
OG is 8/10 because of the retarded storyline and characters
>>738020760ftfy
>>738022175So you can't name one?>>738022184Removing QTE is not innovation.
>>738022508>removing dogshit QTEs everybody despisedNTA but damn it was a great innovation
>>738020681the original just felt more responsive and less reliant in RNG, in the original i could shoot the head or kneecap and get my stun making the gameplay faster and precise, with the remake i need to wait the feedback(can take from 1 to 3 shots in the head to stun) killing the momentum at times.
>>738022291>Could Leon defeat the Skulls?This man can do ANYTHING
>>738022720This is why the original is so easy and boring, this is why nobody plays it anymore besides speedrun troons.
The entire catalog is just bait.
>>738022737My bad, forgot the sauce: https://gofile.io/d/obWrSM
>>738022462this is pretty well made bait
>>738022767both are easy but the rng and waiting for the reticule to close isnt fun.
RE4 has always been such a weird game for me. I grew up playing the OG RE and RE2 on my Playstation in high school and I loved them, and then in college RE4 came out and i remember everyone hyping the fuck out of it and then i played it and was just like, "This is what everyone is freaking out about?" Don't get me wrong, I don't think it's a bad game by any means, but I really don't get why it has this legendary, one of the greatest games ever, status. What did it really do that changed the gaming industry for the better? Its shift to action pretty much ruined the RE franchise for the next 2 main entries and the story is one long ass escort quest and it didn't do anything revolutionary compared to other action games at the time. I guess I just don't get it.
>>738021438it didn't trim the fat though, it added fat, lots of fat, and yellow paint, its a lazy remake
>>738023136it added better story, better characters and last but not least much better gameplay
>>738020681DEmake is 7/10, RE4 is a 9.5/10
>>738023120>one long ass escort questactually the escort sessions are quite short>compared to other action games at the timenot even trolling, name 3, i can only think of Cold Fear.those campaign based TPS became extremely popular on gen 7 for a reason.
>>738023352REupgrade is 10/10, RE4 is a 6/10
>>738022508Innovation doesn't make you a better game
>>738023195it added unnecessary bloat, added time wasting puzzles that require zero thought that force you to run back and forth between areas, added sidequests to kill rats, sidequests to backtrack to collect some trinket like some shitty fucking mmo that wastes more of the players time, added some of the worst weapons in series history, added stealth segments that have objectively terrible gameplay, removed enemy variety, removed key locations from the original, removed features like being able to upgrade ashleys health, it made the script worse, made the characters worse, made the voice acting worse, and no, the gameplay isn't better just because you say it is retardo
>>738022291They ARE a bioweapon, anon.
>>738023708>it added unnecessary bloatno idea what are you talking about> added time wasting puzzles damn, a puzzle in a resident evil game wow> force you to run back and forth between areasyeah backtracking like in classic RE games>added sidequests to kill rats, sidequests to backtrack to collect some trinketas opposed to shooting blue trinkets in the original? >added some of the worst weapons in series historyno idea what are you talking about, the bolt thrower is great> added stealth segments that have objectively terrible gameplay?you mean the ashley section? it's present in both games>removed enemy varietyat this point you are just making shit up>removed key locations from the originalremoved dogshit QTE sections from the original *ftfy>removed features like being able to upgrade ashleys healthand? who the fuck wants to waste g+r+y on ashley?>it made the script worse, made the characters worsefalse, luis and ashley are objective improvements>made the voice acting worseyeah maybe for ada, the rest is not any worse>he gameplay isn't better just because you say it is retardoit's not just because i said so, it's objectively superior in every single way
>>738020681A sidegrade. The original does some things better and some things worse. Neither are "10/10" because they both have flaws. They're both very good though.
>>738020681The remake is a 7/10, the original is a 2/10.
these new vs old RE threads are cringe as fuck
>>738021418now strafe left and right
I remember there was a blogpost some jap made about Oshi no Ko, and the anime adaption. He was like "dont get me wrong the anime is about a 90/100.... but the manga is 9000/100"And that kind of made me rethink how i rate things in my head.
>>738024454kek you bodied that freak with 5 words
>>738023364Huh, I guess you're right. All the ones that immediately comes to mind like Mass Effect, Dead Space, Gears of War, etc. all came after RE4. So I guess that explains it. Definitely thought over the shoulder action was already an established thing before it released.
>>738024941>Dead SpaceDamn that game shits all over RE4, just the like RE4R.
>>738021418Kek. You're probably just salty that you can't cheese your way through the game like you did the original
For me it's the treasure combination system. I liked how in the original you got certain colored treasures in an area to eventually put together into one over encompassing treasure item. The remake did away with that in favor of just two different shapes of colored gems that can be used for all of them. Better than 5 just doing it away with it altogether I guess, but there was no point in changing it
>>738025209>you're just salty that you have to ice skate up hillyeah, it's objectively a downgrade
>>738025437RE4Rs movement system is an objective upgrade, you can seethe and cope all you want about it.
How do I dodge Nemesis in 3? I can dodge some of his attacks but he just slaps my ass so quick. Do I just grab Brad's card from his corpse and nope out?
this nigga has been remaking this thread on the daily ever since that guys youtube video came out for the sole purpose of getting replies on a chinese basket weaving forum btw
>>738025554Holy shit
>>738025472been awhile since i played but can't you stun him? probably a better option than trying to dodge, no idea if you mean OG 3 or r3make
>>738025606and it's obvious from his replies that this nigga hasn't even played either game lol
>>738025727OG, I want to grab the weapon parts from him but I can't even survive into RPD lmao
>>738025606that is seriously messed up
>>738020681The remake is a solid 9.5/10 with awesome graphics and fast-paced, challenging gameplay with infinite replayability, especially on Professional and if you're going after S+ rank or using mods. Definitely a masterpiece, an improvement over the original and one of the best games from this generation. The difficulty rightfully angers aging dad gamers who lack the skill to adapt to new challenges, but the gamers have spoken and it's by far the most beloved and popular entry in the whole series. Controller in hand, it's endless fun.The original is a little outdated and too slow, gameplay didn't age well, not because of primitive tank control limitations but because enemies are easily trivialized non-threats even on higher difficulties and things like QTEs being a sad normie fad that thankfully got cut and improved by actual gameplay in the Remake. It's a good 6/10, maybe even 6.5/10 with nostalgia and if you like to play games for atmosphere instead of gameplay. It was OK when I was a kid, it's still above average but outside of nostalgia or if you are a loser who wants to complain about inane shit like low audio levels there's no reason to replay it today basically.
