Choose
>>743264437black. it has the shittiest designs, least amount of content, worst exploration, and shittiest replay value
bdsp
>>743264516most pokemon fans are foids lol
soul silver
>>743264437Go forever like, Never ending? or the other way around?
>>743264437Soul Silver. Literally easiest choice of my life
HG/SS can go, overrated remake of trash games and just not fun to play with the trash dex, ass level curve, boring ass Rocket slog hideout. The BF is already in Emerald and Patinum so I won't even miss the Factory.
>>743264437Black because white would still exist and the sequels are better anyway.
>it's another thread where we retcon reality into thinking gen 5 wasn't complete and utter shitPokémon died after the setting left Japan
>>743264437Black, not even a competition.
pokemon black easilygen 5 pokedex remains the biggest stain on the franchise
>>743264437SS since Crystal is fine.
Black.I am 35 and cried like a bitch when I couldn't catch a Pidgey in it and was forced to use new Pokemon by the way if that matters.
>>>/vp/
>yeah these are good replacements for the legendary birds greenlight those>oh fuck everyone hates them make alternate forms quickly!!!
>>743264437Gun to my head, gen 5 is my least played of the 2D gens, and while I prefer BW over BW2 it's gonna have to go
>>743264437I know your shit containment board is dead, but pokepedos aren't wanted here either.
>>743265193>I couldn't catch a Pidgey in it and was forced to use new PokemonThis. Pidgey > Pidove
>>743264437black and its not even closepokemon gets worse each generation
>>743264437the remake obviouslythere is already a Pokemon gold and silver
Black only cuz B2W2 is better
>>743264943Every time i read someone saying how great B/W was i legit can never tell if i'm getting trolled or people actually liked these chucklefucks
>>743265776Yes everyone likes N
>>743264437soul silver diddy blud how is this even a question? the gsc era sucks nigger cock
>>743264437Fucking Platinum, how is that even a question?
>>743265776N is a good rival antagonist
>>743264543Love BW but you're 100% correct. In those aspects it's absolutely worse than the other games listed.
thinly veiled bait thread so OP can screencap people saying>get rid of blackon 4chan and repost it on other sites for replies and clouti'm onto you faggot
if Black is gone then so is Route 10 music, i would never do that ...goodbye Emerald
>>743264437Platinum because fuck Sinnoh or Black because the sequel is a million times better.
>>743264437it really does not matter. every pokemon game is basically the same.
>>743264437All of them so we can all agree that Pokemon was never good.
Not even black 2? Is this a joke?
>>743264437Pokemon Black for being a contrarian, Platinum if you are honest
>>743268032black is easily the worst fucking game there lol
platinum and it's not even close
>>743268032platinum does its best to salvage the dp dumpster fire so i wouldn't delete it. gen 3 can survive without emerald
>>743264437I barely remember Platinum so it can get fucked.
Anyone not saying SoulSilver is a nostalgia faggot manchild. Those have the most bafflingly retarded design choices in the entire franchise
>>743268321>Looks over to gen 7, 8, 9Literally every 2D game is better than the 3D games
>>743264437Black but it wasn't an easy choice. I just think some of the tropes that make modern pokemon games shit started there. Mainly trying to focus more on story and being interrupted every time you enter a new town
>>743264437SoulSilver easily because we'd still have HeartGold and Ho-Oh is the superior legendary anyway.
>>743264437black 1 so long as somehow BW2 still get to exist, otherwise platinum easy. fucking hate the dex, region, retarded villains, plot, etc
SoulSilver > Emerald > Platinum > Black
>>743265401-Wow seriously? These were legendaries?I assumed it was just one late-game pokemon that operated like Castform or something.
kill gen v
>>743264437Emerald, this isn't a dilemma at all when you're not in the spectrum.
>>743269397these are highly unique pokemon i'll have you know
>>743269693>these are highly unique pokemon i'll have you know*digimon
>>743269730Digital monstersDigimon are the champions!
>>743269693I like their other forms, at least
>>743269730I'm not hearing this shit from 'people' who were okay with Lucario and Blaziken.
>>743264516if that were the case we wouldn't get endless kanto pandering
>>743270132>lucario and BlazikenThey don't have 7 leather belts around them and 3 different variations of the same sprite. Also; Blaziken has its roots in gen 2
>>743264516Explain to me how that picture doesn't apply to videogames in general.
>>743264437every single one. the original silver is the best pokemon game by far. experiencing that on release was amazing. the duplicate glitch was based.
>>743264437Black
>>743264437Does deleting Black get rid of Black 2?This is an important detail.
>>743269693>when landorus was on EVERY FUCKING TEAMLandorus, Heatran, Blissey and Skarmory should be deleted from the dex
I dont care about gen 3Bye-bye Emerald. Really like the anime version of the elite 4 theme thoughhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y1hBm4LRZRw
>>743265776N and the rivals are good, Ghetsis is fucking garbage and written like a saturday morning cartoon.
>>743265958Route 10 is also in BW2, inside a specific house
>>743264437Platinum I hated the DPP generationBW at least finally gave us full body sprites with animations, it removed the uppercase Pokemon games "PIKACHU used", and good graphics
>>743264437BW, easy. BW2 as well, fuck it.
>>743264516Why isn't the little girl barefoot?
>>743264437Black easy. Black2 is much better
>playing pokemon post gen 4Also gen 4 was the last gen I enjoy comp post garchomp OU ban
>>743265776N is for foids. Gen 5 was the beginning of the foidification of Pokémon
>>743265798I
Platinum and it's not really closeWhat does it offer that the other games don't? Assuming you mean just get rid of Platinum and not Sinnoh entirely.
>>743273929Being the most playable version of Sinnoh
>>743264437Eh, I guess SoulSilver. The overworld map is a relic from the gameboy. You go from that to RSE and it's a big difference.Though BW does have that problem with the region being a circle.
>>743264437>No games past Gen 5 on hereFuck this is difficult I guess the Gen 2 Remakes can go
It's between Platinum and Emerald. Platinum added the least new things of the two I think so that would be the best answer.
>>743264437HGSS has to go because it didn't fix anything about the major issues of Gen 2. All the stuff that hurt Gen 2 is here as well.
Grew out of Pokeymans in 2003.Do people over the age of 15 really play that shit?
>>743274154>Being the most playable version of Sinnohthis is hilarious since i guarantee you dick suck hgss while crying about dp's lack of fire types or some shit while bdsp has more than both lol
>>743265776i hate them because they wont stop talkingi hate gen5 for introducing endless dialog to the series
>>743264437Emerald
>>743274865i only started playing it when i was 15
>>743268249Gen 4 mogs gen 3 seethe harder loser.
>>743264437That's easy, Platinum.
>>743274865bonbi fell off so fucking hard
>>743269693Designs so bad they gave em alternative forms in the sequels
>>743264437Platinumgen 2>5>3>1>>7>4>6>9>8
>>743270725Hgss is an improvement in every way nostalgia faggot.
>>743264437Black 1, EASIEST choice of my damn life.
i just want a pokemon game with>new graphics>151 original pokemon (maybe second gen too so it has more variety?)>all current maps>a way to use TM without having to carry a TM mulewhy is it that hard? why is there nothing like this?
>>743269397They're weather gods with alternate forms. These are incarnates
>>743264437Soulsilver has a dogshit level curve. BW fixed the levelling and properly balanced the game. So SoulSilver it is
>>743264437black, back2 and white2 are better
>>743274868Bdsp looks like shit though
>>743264437Gen 5, its the zoomer Pokemon game
>>743264437Emerald if you hate water.Black if you hate how fucking linear Pokemon became after it.Easy two on the 50/50.
>>743274868>HGSSGood remake but gen 2 is a weaker of the classic games regardless>Gen 4Has improvements to trainer teams, tilesets, and the engine, while also including the coolest box legendary sequence of any of the games. I don't use fire types often so I don't care about that much beyond it being an oddity in the pokemon distribution. BDSP obviously uses DP content instead and is horribly fucking ugly so I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
>>743275446yeah but it it doesn't have 8 hms, slow hp bars, a retarded minigame grind for tms, and some actual dex options in the undergrund unlike hgss, my underage johtofaggot nigger
>>743264437Black easily
>>743265776N actually is sort of fleshed out by Pokemon standards. It's a goddamn shame they ripped the story in half however.
damn I feel like playing pokemon again. are you performing hebrew magic on me? so be it. I wish they would put the rest of gen 3 on switch and make it work with home already
>>743264437Emerald, so tired of water pokemon and surf.
>>743264437this isn't even a questiongen 5 fucking sucks and I am tired of underages never shutting the fuck up about it when it is utterly mogged by everything before it
>>743275341Why would they? Gamefreak makes a shitty mobile game and sold 30 million units.
BW is objectively the weakest link. If it were BW2, then it would actually be a hard choice. That being said, the original BW aged like good wine and the only people who dislike it are genwunners that piss and moan that they have to use new Pokemon instead of the ones they have nostalgia for. Nostalgia niggers deserve the rope. BW was still rough, but it was a clear progression of the mainline Pokemon formula and the poor sales only proved that Poketards truly have horrible taste.
>>743265401its wild how people complain about the genies and are fine with Uxie/Azelf and Mespirit
>>743270920Now it's Tornadus since Tailwind changes the speed order mid turn
>>743275341>>151 original pokemonwhy are people so autistic about thisyou don't even like all 151when's the last time you took Muk all the way to the Elite 4? What about Parasect? Seaking? Tangela? You niggers don't want 151, you want 15
>>743275341Not the same but try Pokemon Mystery Dungeon
>>743264437Black easily.Gen 5 had no reason to exist. Shameless cash grab generation that added nothing of substance and ruined more things than the ones it improved.
silver was better than soul silver
I genuinely don't understand why people are saying Soul Silver
>>743264437I throw them all out except Emerald.
>>743278278>Cashgrab>Only gen with a sequel instead of a full priced DLC???
>>743264437Platinum
you can nuke all but emerald out of those
>>743264437Black or SoulSilver since White and HeartGold still exist
>>743265776Nigger why do you even care about the story and why would you prefer the nu-pokemon blues clues handholding shit over this anyways? The great thing about pre-3ds pokemon is that the story is barely there and you're just adventuring.
>>743264437The only one that deleting would potentially impact anything is B/W, but the writing was already on the wall before that. I don't think Gen 5 suddenly disappearing would change the direction they went in. Maybe there'd be less pandering at first.
>>743279728>Nigger why do you even care about the story and why would you prefer the nu-pokemon blues clues handholding shit over this anyways?Probably because gen 5 pushed it and shoved that shit right into your face constantly.
>>743264437i never played black or whiteso it can go, but i'd rather violet leaveyou know what? everything after fire red.
>>743264437I only ever played GEN I and II so all 4 games in your pic can go if you ask me.
>>743264567Foids were included in the left picture. Kids and foids are always in the same category.
>>743276226Not really. The latter are uninspired, sure, but they aren't fuckugly abominations.
>>743274865>le I grew outBy this logic you should have grown out of video games completely by 18, yet you're still there, so you're 100% retarded. People stop playing Pokemon because they're insultingly bad full priced games.
>>743264437Black. Pokemon stopped being good with platinum.
>>743264437bye bye soulsilver, crystal's better anyway
>>743264516How do I cope with the fact that I am literally on the right? I am literally like that. I cringe and make fun of people like that on the internet but it’s just projection of my own self hatred because that is literally me. Maybe less openly enthusiastic about it, but I am a fully grown adult man who still plays with the same childhood toys I did 20 years ago. Why can’t I change? Why can’t I grow up? Why can’t I move on?
>>743284980? it literally has all the content from crystal
>>743264437I've literally not played any of these games. I stopped playing with Pearl and I never finished it. The only two I have finished are Ruby and FireRed.
>>743285045literally doesn't
>>743264437soul silver since it is just a remake while others are originals
>>743285097what it doesn't have? it has all the eusine shit and a battle frontier(original had a battle tower).
>All this Gold/Silver hateGenocide zoomers. Wipe them from the face of the earth. Single most useless generation of humans ever conceived.
>>743264745nice youtuber opinion
>>743264437Black no contest.
HGSS is only good if you're playing a difficulty romhack. Otherwise it's a remake of a dogshit game with a copypasted frontier from Platinum.Emerald is shit by the fact of being gen 3 and its frontier being garbage outside tower and factory.BW is ass and rendered moot by BW2.
>>743285629>copypasted frontier from Platinum.damn oras is probably the worst of all because it has a battle maison copy and pasted from xy
>>743264543/threadI would have been okay with HGSS as well (since it is a remake instead of being new) but Pokemon could have ended after Gen 4 and would have been better off
>>743264543don't forget being gen 5 means all the berry farming is exclusive to dream world shit a dead web browser minigame. i don't know why nobody talks about this
>>743264437hhss easy
>>743264437Remove every game from the canon that doesn't enable you to collect 'em all in one playthrough without trading.
Jesus CHRIST why do you zoomoid bitch monkeys hate Gold and Silver so much?
>>743285990That's all of them.
>>743286000Sorry to break it to you unc, but Johto sucks.
>>743285990legends arceus chads don't have this problem
>>743286076Your entire male generation suck penises for entertainment and wears a perm, why would I EVER care about your opinions at ALL?
>>743286327you don't care so much that you keep crying about it
>>743286380Concession accepted, dick sucker.
>>743286436but enough about your homoerotic fantasies
>>743276226I am mentally ill and want to fuck moe blobs, not genie men with Wario faces.
Black since Black 2 was better
>>743265776It's honestly insane how little porn there is of Bianca. She's a reoccurring female character in most zoomer's first ever Pokemon game and has hips 3x wider than her shoulders and is a clumsy ditz obsessed with muscles. There's a lot going on there.
>>743276226the lake trio might be weak shitmons but the genies are ugly as fuck
>>743271317>and written like a saturday morning cartoon.Like any other Pokémon villain?At least he has the guts to try and kill you after losing a Pokémon battle, unlike the others, who simply accept that you defeated them...
>>743287687>A criminal organization like Team Rocket lets you merrily strut around their HQ after getting defeated instead of tying you up to a chair, putting a sack over your head and chopping off you ballsShit will never not be amusing.
>>743264437I'd trade them all away for even more Palworld
>>743289346no one cares about your soros-backed troon slop
>>743264437Emerald. Any other answer exposes fake fans especially the Black haters. The real answer is actually everything made after X/Y, and even then X/Y only gets the pass because I think megas were a nice addition and I have nutted truckloads to Hex Maniac
>>743270710Because it's another "I hate Nintendo and every game that isn't Nintendo is for mature gamers like me" retard. They do this shit every fucking time.
>retards saying get rid of Black and White because BW2 is better don't realize that getting rid of BW would mean no BW2Are you retarded?
There is no difference. They all have the same fucking brain dead gameplay where you press the same attack and it kills the brain dead AI
>>743289346everybody cares about your soul-backed chad gem
>>743287506BW girls in general hardly get any love because hardly many played BW back in the day unfortunately. Also her BW2 design is sex and remains my top 5 favorite girls
>>743264437Gen V was so bad it ruined the whole franchise so easily kill that one.Although if by “go forever” you mean some esl way of saying “last forever” then the answer is Soul Silver, which is the apex of the whole franchise
>>743291368I think many hate BW because "OH NOO, I CAN'T USE MY GEN 1 POKÉMON ONCE AGAIN FOR THE 5TH TIME IN A ROW!!!!!"Nostalgia is a fucking cancer in this franchise. It's why we get so much Kanto pandering.
>>743264437Soulsilver.>>743264516Those adults were the intended audience at one point they just grew up and kept playing the games.
>>743264437Platinum. I hate Gen 4 to its absolute core.
>>743293791This. But Emerald is also an acceptable choice. People who hate Gen 5 are midwits.
Emerald is a rerelease and most people didn't even celebrate Gen 3 back in the day. You could remove this game and nothing would be lost except maybe Battle Frontier V1.
>>743294503Okay, I'm just going to say it: I don't believe any of you actually give a shit about Battle Frontier or Battle Factory or most of the post-game content. It's just something you think you SHOULD care about.
>>743295701I do, because games like Ruby and Sapphire become useless the moment you finish the league
>>743295701I cared about the idea of it, but making competitive Pokemon prior to gen 6 sucked and I never wanted to do it. But as soon as they make breeding not shit, they cut all of the side modes.
>>743289346>Lovander (1900)>Salazzle (5000)Hmmm...
>>743289346Man, i wish Lovander had that design, i can't stand her every-gay-furry face phenotype that looks it was stung by bees.
>>743264437>One Pokemon game has to go on forever It has
>>743289346Based
>>743264437soul silver because og gen 2 exists already anyways lolif it deletes gen 2...i thunk i'd do it anyways, gen 2 fucking sucks, but gen 5 is pretty bad too
>>743264437>ChooseI can't. Does SoulSilver include HeartGold? Does Black include White? Even Black&White 2?So if we assume what I said above is true, it comes down to SS or even Platinum, the question is just: Do I want to play Crystal or DP? No... Crystal is too old, I much prefer SS, but when I kick Platinum, I have to play the OG Diamond and Peal versions...>FireRed / LeafGreen>HG/SS>Emerald>Diamond&Pearl>BW/BW2Yep.. have to go with this setup then.
>>743264437I still find gen 4 one of the worst gems ever riddled with questionable evolutions of old Pokémon, like 20 legendaries and Lucario being overshilled pile of shit. The worst is that a lot of faggots that grew up with it pretend it's somehow the bestest thing ever
>>743264437Black. How is that even a question?
>>743264543BUT GEN 5 IS GEN 1 YOU *HAVE* TO LIKE IT!!!GEN 3 AND 4 ARE ALSO GEN 1!!!!!
>>743264516>intended audience>
>>743296487>Plap! Plap! SPLURT!Haha, literally me.
>>743264437bro all 4 of those could go and I wouldn't give a single fuckin fact, just nuke all of PokemonIt had its time in the sun, and it has spoiled
>>743265776I used to cum buckets to Bianca eons ago.Now I almost had to google her name.What happened to me man? I've betrayed who I am.
>>743264543It has Hilda
>>743276226The genies are ugly as fuck and don't fit the theme of Unova at all>USA inspired region>genies It's fucking retarded and so are the starters. Who the fuck looks at America and thinks a grass snake (the only one that fits at all), a Chinese pig, and a samurai otter? It just shows how little Japanese understand anywhere outside of Japan to not include a skunk, opposum, or raccoon in THE USA THEMED REGION.
>>743264437oh Gen 5 for sure, easily
Emerald is the only game where I can consistently finish playthroughs. I always lose interest in HGSS after Ecruteak. Therefore Emerald is the best
>>743296892>Black. How is that even a question?It doesn't make sense to pick black, except if you really hate it. But it would be much smarter to kill Platinum, SoulSilver or Emerald, that way you can at least play the base versions (Diamond/Peal, Gold/Silver/Crystal and Ruby/Sapphire)
>>743264437Black. I fucking hate blacks.
>>743264567This. My friends wife has a dozen pokemon plushies and when i visited them in 2016 she dragged me and him around the city while she played Pokemon Go to the polls
Emerald, because it's my favorite pokemon game but I played it so much that I won't play again in a lifetime. Fuck the other plebs, I'm gatekeeping my favorite game
>>743269448Kill yourself
>>743271052>>743274951>>743275456>>743275643>>743294490>>743294503>>743300812Go fuck yourself
>>743264437Black or soul silver.Just play white or heart gold instead.What a retarded question.if we are talking about the whole block of games. Probably platinum. I didn't care for sinnoh. Alternatively if we get to keep black2, then black.
>>743264437Just delete gen 4 and 5. And the gen 2 demake while you're at it. Emerald is the peak of the entire series.
>>743264437Probabky soul silver. I can just play gen 2 in that case.
>>743301185Don't make the Hoenn kids upset...!
>>743289346Truth nuke!
>>743264437Why BDSP isnt on the list
>>743264543>>743265776the music is nice and as a tech-demo it's pretty cool. as a complete product it doesn't stand up to the other 3, but it was underrated/overhated and now people want to compensate. (hell, i typed this even though "it doesn't stand up to the other 3" is in my post.)
>>743275643you got it backwards
>>743264437This is stupid. Outside of platinum and emerald. You can just play the other version.
>>743264543Gen V has the best story, and difficulty selectors though (only after you beat the game for some fucking reason). It also has N, which is basedNo seriously though, why didn't they make difficulty selectors a permanent addition to the series?
>>743265776you tellin me were supposed to hate on a pawg'd out snowbunny?
>>743276226>Geniesugly as fuck and meta so you're forced to see them online. Doesn't help that Gen V had very little variety in mons for a lot of the game too, so you're forced to look at shit like patrat for 20 hours>PixiesCute but lazy designs its really not that surprising
>>743305995Rosabro...
>>743305941>expecting gamefreak to follow through on anything.
>>743264437Gen 3 was the start of the soul drain from the series.>no day/night cycle>time was only for the annoying dogshit berry mechanics with built-in FOMO>too much water>worst soundtrack in the entire franchise>wally was a little bitch faggot>some of the worst roadblocks in the franchise>the true beginning of HM bloatFuck anyone who likes Gen 3.
>>743264437emerald or black
>>743305941they probably somehow know that no one used it though i dunno how, probably survey
>>743264437platinum because I hate Gen 4 the most.
>>743276226The lakes were cool, going around the region to fight them chasing after Team Galactic was cool and they didn't suck donkey dick like the fugly genies.Also their music was coolerhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tK1PWoWdUXY&t=59s
>>743285424Not that anon and that was my opinion as a 12 year old kid when I finished it back then. Kill yourself.
>>743270071I used this Thundurus form for the postgame of Reborn, he was cool.
>>743264437Blackeasiest choice ever
>>743264437Everything after they gave up on handhelds. Pokemon are literally supposed to be POCKET MONSTERS
>>743276164BW is bad because it was a leaps and bounds downgrade from HG/SS for gameplay and how it was made for the DS.Imagine actually getting rid of the bottom screen menu to replace with a permanent useless c-gear black screen that does literally nothing? how RETARDED do you have to be actually do that?
>>743274154Sinnoh is trash though and not worth having a playable version
>>743305941>Gen V has the best storyoh you're one of those retards
>>743264437I like unova but i have to pick Black. it's not even a third version with extra content like the other two
>>743264437Scarlet and Violet.>But anon you can't only pick one and those aren't even choicesDid I fucking stutter?
>>743309370Sun and Moon were for a handheld system. They fucking sucked.
>>743312867This.
