how would you handle the next visit to your favorite region?
>>58783054By making it at least mainline, not some shit rushed filler that didn't even have an official meta or natdex like BDSP that was dead on arrival since PLA was released around same time. It didn't even have some trainer design updates or changes to be impactful or improve its trainer popularity which is mostly niche beside shitrona and Dawn.Less handhandling or random soulless legendary and mythical events you get delivered at the pokecenter. The old style overworld nostalgia can be a good bet for a videogame but if it introduced new characters or redesigns and new pokemon it would be an issue, everything needs 3D models now for other games and media.Actual decent battles, not level up movepool trainers and retarded moveset rematches with the leaders and league.And something that will never come back, battle frontiers.Then again, Hisui was the real Sinnoh revisiting and new approach experience.
I wouldn't. HGSS is already perfect
So even after Joe's, NumbNexus's, SacredAlmighty's, and Pokémon Challenge's combined efforts over six years, they failed to sway the public opinion of HGSS? Lmao
>>58783054No matter our expectations, they will find a way to make it worse. They already ruined my favorite generation, so my only hope is that they never touch my second favorite, ever.
Honestly would just rather have a remastered collection of BW1 and 2 than an actual remake. (It would likely just be the first game and no BW2. And lore seems set in stone rather than up for reboots like ORAS) Just add some modern qol, online and Dream World access to themGame Freak are clearly incapable of doing a proper fully 3D remake without compromises with their time and low budgets. And even they seem to know they cannot to it justice based on the Teraleak and they would rather revisit regions in the Legends format of smaller scope take on the region with experimental gameplay with new lore
>>58783203why do retards want big empty fields
>>58783054BW3
>>58783213BoTW has fried many brains
>>58783054Lesson learned: Never listen to fans. For a decade all you saw was "Faithful, faithful, faithful" when people talked about what they wanted from the next remakes and then they do exactly that and it's universally despised.
>>58783054Like GSC or BW2
>>58783236people wanted a faithful remake of platinum, not some chibi dogshit dp
>>58783203>open world meme
I really liked the gameplay in ZA. It was easy to control which Pokémon was being used and the lack of PP made grinding for long period easier. You could customise your trainer a fair amount and your Pokémon would follow you. I know spoke people are divided on this but I also liked being able to use TMs multiple times.So, in the next game remake, if they manage to do all of this, I’ll be pleased. (Plus, add in interaction with your Pokémon)
>>58783054Where is Let's Go PE?
>>58783203>ruined my favorite genIf your favorite gen was ruined by simply having a near 1-to-1 remake on newer hardware, you never liked that gen to begin with.
>>58783054I understand the criticisms with BDSP and I agree with most of them but I’m fine with it. Most of the changes don’t take away from Sinnoh as a region. I wasn’t a fan of a lot of ORAS & LGPE’s changes to their originals
>>58783054Honestly would be fine if BW got the BDSP treatment.BDSP is literally just fucking DP, but not as ass-dickingly slow, better Pokemon variety, and a fix to the shitty overabundance of HMs, and direct compatibility with modern games. Literally the only thing worthwhile Platinum has over it is an expanded Battle Frontier.I like BW. A remake that lets me transfer my modern mons to it on the Switch is fine by me. Just need some ribbons to be actually added to the region and I'd be pleased. IDEALLY, they'd also add compatibility with more Pokemon than just Gen 5 and prior, but I wont shit my pants when a remake functions like a normal remake like 99% of other game remakes. >>58783242>not some chibi dogshit dp>Implying the originals werent also chibi
>>58784035Not that anon, but I can see why people were upset:>enjoy game on old hardware>play it regularly>remake on new hardware gets announced>made by a no-name company that makes shovelware>it's just the same game with some QoL stuff and a dodgy artstyle, but priced as though it was an AAA game>even the chibi sprites are kept, but turned into 3D in an unappealing way>whole thing feels like a rush job meant to make a quick buck, which it wasFor me, the art is the silly part, it's not like Link's Awakening where they went for a tilt-shift thing, they just went with the 3D chibi designs in the overworld just because, and didn't really do anything special with it, then used some pretty cool models for trainer battles just because.
>>58784028Twitter only lets you put 4 options in polls. They'd have to use an off-site poll for more, and a lot of normalfags don't like being redirected to another site just to do a poll.
>>58783236>out source an ugly as fuck chibishit unity port with forced affection and removed content at the last minute in case people don’t like plass>retards like you try to gaslight others into thinking it’s what they asked for because they used the word “faithful” in the marketing
>>58783054HGSS with Gen9 QoLsjust that
>>58783155Most people aren't as obsessed as you are with random e-celebs.
>>58783213why do you want empty corridors?
>>58783118this, don't ever touch Johto again, you'll ruin it
When they inevitably make gen 5 remakes... they will very likely be obtusely bad. Extremely flawed but in a completely deceptive and unexpected manner.I expect them to have slightly more "quality" at the outset, so for trailers and such you'll think it might look good, but there will be strange inconsistencies and odd choices that compile such that when the game finally releases it'll be effectively unplayable.That's my expectation.
>>58783054Legends was so fucking wretched for fucking over the DP remakes.
>>58783236>For a decade all you saw was "Faithful, faithful, faithful"That's just an outright lie. People shat on ORAS for being too faithful to RS instead of Emerald. Even HGSS and FRLG were criticized for not changing enough things, like Johto's distribution and level curve or FRLG preventing gen 2 evos before the natdex.Nobody was asking for a remake in the vein of BDSP, or at least, nobody was asking for that of DP instead of Platinum.
>>58783075>regurgitating the board meme because Legends games didn't use the baby tier formula of the paired release gamesGame Freak don't release spin offs kid. That's what TPC and Ishihara's for. That's also why Raifort gave lectures in front of a board with details about the professor who wrote the world's first pokédex.
>>58784307They're just going to be the OG game ported to unity. So if they're "very likely obtusely bad", it's likely because the OG editions were that from the start, but 7 year olds ignored THAT aspect of them to stan them heavens hard since getting online.
>>58784577>>58784572>must…suck…goyrfreak….cockreminder boomerfag is a 46 year old Scottish furfag incel that spams this board with shitfreak defense all day
>>58783205Crazy idea, but I think the most sensible thing to do would be to remake BW2 instead and include the main campaign of BW1 as a prequel side mode with some extra challenge to make the two treks through Unova distinct. Kind of like how Pikmin 4 had a simplified remake of Pikmin 1 as a side game.They could even give the option of playing the prequel first so you can carry over the Memory Link stuff to BW2.
>>58784577Yeah it’s gonna be the originals with a gaudy art style and retarded chibi Ghetsis, mandatory exp share, forced affection, buggy overworld movement, Battle Subway with removed multis, even shittier Musicals, and the OST and East Unova will only be available in a day one patch. Who the fuck would want that
>>58784599All wrong, but it's your delusional headcanon to cope with being unable to refute my claims with hard evidence, nor admit I had a better handle on how Game Freak played their cards than (You).>>58784613>even shittier MusicalsThey don't remake the rehashes kid, why do you think they'll start now? Even taking 2030 as the next new Gen game, that's Gen 10 26, DLC 27, Legends Galar 28 leaving only One year to burn, before moving onto Gen 11 and further away from your childhood than this year's been. Never know, maybe ILCA will be able to shit it out in three this time, instead of dying trying to shit it out on Game Freak's schedule.
>>58784604I could get behind this. BW1's map and mon distribution kinda sucks shit. There's a reason why people like BW2 a lot more
>>58784577What a roundabout way of trying to start a genwar
>>58784962I'm sorry you feel like that's a slight on your childhood. If I wanted to start a genwar, I'd go after the sacred cow of Gen 3, because you babby bastards sure as fuck can't handle it getting criticised however. I enjoyed BW, BW2 was the pinnacle of "just rehashe it ladz" however.
