Johtobros... we won...
>>58830692>XC3 over 1 and 2how
>>58830697sweet sweet dei
who cares faggot
>>58830702You cared enough to reply.
>>58830692I've never played Draogon Quest XI but I wonder how similar it is to that other series with almost the same name
>>58830692What terrible taste
>>58830692being represented in that trash list is a loss more than anything
>>58830692FF7 is better than half of this list>Chrono Kino at #1Valid
Too bad gen 2 is objectively shit and whoever disagrees is a nostalgiafag. Imagine needing a game review site to tell you what games to like and not like. Do you think brawl is somehow better than Smash 4, Ultimate, or any other official Smash bros title too? I specify official because only sub-humans who don't shower think bootlegs like project m count.
>>58830692Why would you ever play Gold/Silver over Crystal or HGSS?
That's pretty high praise given how many better rpgs there are than Pokemon.Certainly Gold/Silver deserve to be top of the heap though.
>>58830692>Chrono Shitrigger #1>X as the FF of choiceAs valid as a pokemon list having Scat and Vomit as the best games.
>>58831067>CrystalMareep>HGSSComfy music and graphics
>>58830692>IGNimagine caring about the worthless opinions of gaming "journalists"
>>58831080Name a more perfect JRPG than CT
>>58830692>No Mother 3 because burgers can't play it legally>Persona 4 > 5 fuckers, stop the cap>Look, I think FF7 is overrated, and that Chrono Trigger is eternally based, but even I think that this is extreme.>But at least Undertale didn't make it.
They had to limit the list to JRPGs so the top wouldn’t be Fallout NV, Skyrim, Oblivion, Fallout 3, Fallout 4, and Morrowind, and Baldurs Gate 3, in that order.
>jrpgall boring shit and pokemon is too high, its a baby rpg
>>58831111Why are you on the pokemon board then?
>>58831098A lot of this is because it looks like IGN is forcing a one game per franchise rule, just to make the article more based. And I think that was a good call.
>>58830692>Too much water list
>Draogon Quest
>>58831111If you haven't opened up to at least one of those games for you to be bound to this board, your kind isn't welcome here, and neither are your opinions.
>No Sea of the SaarsI knew I was being fucking baited. My gut instinct told me not to give into the shill.
>>58831067Gold/Silver had a much bigger impact at its time compared to those 2, even if HG/SS is an objectively better experience
>>58830692We always do
>>58830692>Grandia 2 over 1>Octopath 2 over 1>P5R over 3 or 4At least they picked the correct BoF.
>>58831237You're the first anon I've met that liked Grandia 1 over 2. I figured the only aspect of the game that aged well was the OST.
I'd swap out either Ni No Kuni or Lost Odyssey just to throw FE: Three Houses in there. That title earned its praise fair & square.
Kino.
>>58830692>>58831085I Game Normalfagly
>>58831086She didn’t respond because she couldn’t find anything to beat Chrono Trigger the GOAT
>>58831085Imagine caring about the worthless opinions of retards here.
>>58830697Not everyone from IGN is from /v/, so not everyone has a bizarre deep-seated hatred of the game which probably stems from electionfagging.
>>58831098Based af
>>58831272Let Last Odyssey get this bro. That gem is literally forgotten. I'll agree that Ni No Kuni was mid though.
>Earthbound beating Pokémon Based
how is crystal not above GS? just gonna consider it lumped in with them?
>>58832057Pokemon's grunkle is literally more impactful and interesting than ANY Pokemon game ever released. Same with their grandpa DQNo FF game is fun
>>58832062Only nerds care about tertiary versions of games outside of Yellow.
>>58830692No E33? Did they take the J in JRPG literally?
Man I really really need to just play Chrono Trigger already.Glad to see TTYD at 12. Still best of the franchise by far.As for GS, the step up from Gen 1 was phenomenal. The amount of stuff it fixed, improved, introduced, it was so so much better. The biggest improvement from gen to gen and in some ways the first proper game (Yellow was almost enough patches, but still not enough).
>>58831098I know it's IGN, but I always thought that FF10 was the magnum opus of the franchise, and seeing them agree is a great thing.
>>58832117........why would they not?
>>58832119>Man I really really need to just play Chrono Trigger already.I played through that game with nostalgia goggles completely off, and that game still hits all the right notes. The DS(?) side-quests were a tacked mistake though.
>>58832119>still hasn’t played the best game ever created Why rob yourself of such an experience
>>58832121Because it's just the name of a genre. Just like how STGs don't encompass every shooting game like FPS.
You know who I am by now, but I'm just going to say the obligatory:>Lavos Phase 3 is the theme for the late game bosses>Colress Battle theme is the actual theme for Lavos Phase 3
>>58830768>>58831133Was the OP made in AI?
>>58830692>Bravely Default 2wat
>>58831150Just looked up the final boss because that's a good indicator of SOVL if you don't mind spoilers. Ew, how soulless.
>>58832041I’m not from /v/ either, XC3’s just weaker than both of those games. Also /v/ wouldn’t say XC2 should be up there.
>>58832164If you applied that logic to Pokémon games, which one would be the best?
>>58832222Gold/Silver, just like OP suggestsOrColloseum or Explorers of T/D/S
>>58830692DiaPerbabies... our stolen valor demakes lost...
>>58830692Where are Kotor and Kotor II?
>>58832236Read nigga
>>58831098Undertale isn’t Japanese
>>58830692>no Tales of Symphonia>FFX over Vii>Xenoblade 3 over the others
>>58832302>>FFX over ViiBased
>>58831067Millennials who left after Gen 2.
>>58831086FFVI wipes the floor with it so badly it's not even worth laughing.
>>58832302Can't speak for XB, but Symphonia got surpassed really quickly. It was the best JRPG on the GameCube, but that only takes you so far.About 10 > 7, the nu metal edgelords are finally quieting down, and so the truth is slowly but surely coming to life.
>>58830692Sinnoh shitters seething
>>58832417>buggy/broken battle system>weaker ending than both 4 & 5>Kefka was only compelling because of the English localizationYa lost. Only by 1 point (FF6=9, CT=10), but you still lost.
>>58832295Yea it is>B-But Toby Fox is w-Man shook hands with Itoi, Sakurai, is literally part of Game Freak, and the game is weeb af. Undertale (and by extension Deltarune) are JRPGs.
>>58832302Based Mallow poster for calling out shit taste
>>58830692Ngl, any Pokemon game shouldn't even be in the top 20 best JRPGS of all time.
>>58832581You should go to the 4chan board of those games and- oh wait HAHAHAHHAHAHA
>>58832581>it sold>it had an impact at the time>aged well/still fun to playStoryline was shit compared to the others but it still qualifies
>>58832595Gen 2's storyline is majorly a reflection of Japans changing times from traditional to modern. And it reflects that era well enough.
>>58832625I just meant simply as besides the other Nintendo RPGs on the list (EB & Paper Mario) the MC doesn't have any personality or room to grow. It's their criteria to make (You) the player, but at the cost of the actual character having most of his story left up to interpretation.
>>58830692There's a reason Infinite Fusion uses it as a baseThough of course HGSS is the superior version
>>58830954>>58831080>>58832302>she's mad
>>58830954>overrated crap game is better than overrated crap gameSigh
>>58832438Lol no. Kefka is compelling because of his actions, not the meme translations. And it has the most powerful ending with the world actually left ruined for good despite the heroes winning. CT has a super fun battle system, but the plot and the characters are worse that your run of the mill isekai.
>start another FF8 playthrough because I never beat it>expect it to be janky and snail paced>actually pretty snappy and 3 hours went by like nothing>even enjoying the draw and ATB systemI think people just got more ADHD brained
>>58830692>Gold and Silver>no HGSS which were quite literally improvements in every way
>>58832745better game but less soul
>>58832746It literally oozes with soul from every pore. Pokeathlon is absolute kino, all the remade musics were super well done, you also have the new safari zone which has a stupid amount of depth. It's the same game but with updated visuals and more content
>>58832742>And it has the most powerful ending with the world actually left ruined for good despite the heroes winning.All that proves is that 6 was more worthy of expanded lore than 4, 10, and arguably 7. 6 outdone themselves in the characterization department, but very few of them actually got rounded out by the time the game ended.Also, how are you going to compare CT to a genre that barely existed back then? CT is one of the only known media that incorporated time travel without the cringe. And the silent protag meta humor (that was quickly followed up by Mario RPG) was yet another cultural trendsetter that stuck.But the main thing is that CT has the advantage of being a standalone project 6 has its divisiveness for being the first to drop the crystal plot entirely, which is why a lot of people appreciate 9 so much.
>>58832745In the youtube video they put HGSS, idk why
>>58830697Wokies and Christcucks like XC3 over XC2 because the females are less sexualized
>>58832947Same for Persona 4, with the addition of wokies getting cucked at every turn.
>>58830692>Xenoblade 3 beating 1 or 2>Persona 5 over 2, 3, or 4
>>58830692Is that... an actually based list? From IGN? Man, what a time to be alive.
>>58830692>SMT Nocturne as the rep for mainline SMT>At fucking 25th placeFucking retarded. Shin Megami Tensei V Vengeance is the best game ever made, let alone the best rpg (I don't like using the term jrpg as I consider it kind of racist).
>>58833192>>Persona 5 over 2, 3, or 4What's wrong with this? The mere fact Persona 5 doesn't have procedurally generated dungeons puts it above its predecessors.
>>58830692>DraogonDoes no one spellcheck this shit?
>>58832117If it's not made in Japan it's not a goddamn JRPG no matter how hard it emulates them.
>>58832744You mean you didn't spend 20 hours abusing your starting girlfriends by turning cards into items and then into spells?
>>58833513JRPG = Japanese-like RPG
>>58833468Because it's a worse game than even P1.
>>58833519The Japanese didn't even invent turn based combat, it was a staple of old, western made rpg's for ages. Also not all Japanese made RPG are turn based, there are a lot of action based games that are considered jrpg like tales of.
>>58832947>westoids are afraid of /ss/
>>58832746It has more soul which is evident the second you see your pokemon following you
>>58830692>HA HA HA HA HAAgreed, though. FFX is my favorite JRPG, almost 25 years later.
>>58830692>P5RIt's not even the best Persona game, but it's laughable it beat so much else anyway.
