The great debate
>>58935931Scarlet and Violet
>liquid shit vs puke>"debate"
>>58935931Top: Sharty region Bottom: Sharty magnet
>>58935931I'll take SwSh over SV
>>58935931how it feels to say>Scarlet and Violet are better games, Sword and Shield are better POKEMON games
>>58935931both were launched blatantly unfinished, are objectively ugly, are full of mechnical jank, full of absurd power creep mons, and mixed bags on new mon designsSV is more ambitious, has a better story and characters, tera is easily the least dogshit mechanic so far for multiplayer, and has better DLCall SwSh offers is traditional routes but even then they are probably the most barebones and forgettable in the entire franchiseSV > SwSh but both are objectively bad. only real high point for the last few generations has been basic QoL improvements for getting into multiplayer.
>>58935947probably true
>>58935931SV easily. They're amongst the best games in the series with an abundance of content. They're easily the most replayable too considering you can go in any order you want and the dex is massive.
>>58935931SV 100%
>>58935931The only thing SWSH has going for it is that it looks way less ugly SV claps in every other category
>>58935931latinxes shouldnt even be compared to GODlar
>>58936061Youtuber opinion
>>58935931Artstyle, character designs, and stability: SwShLiterally everything else: SV
I played Sword and Arceus Legends and never touched Scarlet/Violet and that ZA game and I'm glad I didn't. I might bite next games though.
>>58935931Gen 9, no question. SwSh was garbage. SV wasn’t much better, but I don’t look at Paldea with disdain like I do Galar.
>>58935931all shit
Is there a reason for the complete drop-off in quality when it came to the Switch era in Pokemon? Genuinely, what happened? Is it the Switch's fault?
>>58936392Game Freak could mask their technical incompetence by system limitations. When they were forced to move to consoles, it became clear they couldn't handle being on par with current gen technology. Trying to do so just results in overtaxing the system for trying to run Gamecube level games
>>58935931Pokemon Trash vs Pokemon Garbage
>>58935931Remove Area Zero and no one gives a fuck about SV.
>>58935931>storySV>gameplaySS
>>58935931I refuse to pit two bad bitches against each other
>>58935931Both are shit
>>58935931SV was the worse game I've played on the Switch, I at least liked SwSh's dlc
>>58936639its honestly hard to give a fuck about even with it
>>58935931
>>58935931SV has a better campaignSS has a better everything else
>>58937254Anything below the score of 90 is garbage or mediocre
As much as I enjoy both,dawg this is comparing like dominoes to little ceaseser's to see what's the less mediocre/dissapointing pizza at best.
>>58935931Switch 2 version of SV
if SV had proper open world game design (level scaling bosses) it would be the clear winner but since it doesn't it is only a narrow winner
>>58935931Sword for Bea feet on my faceViolet for futuremons. The pastmons should have went with an "ancient lost technology" angle and not just made them look like extinct animals.
>>58937443if there was a wrong opinion to have on the paradoxmons this would be the most wrong one
>>58937507Fuck no, pastmons look like overdesigned tryhard dogshit.
>>58935931It really isn't a debate, SV shits all over SwSh and whoever says otherwise is trying too hard to be a contrarian.
SV is the worst Pokemon game ever made so far. 2nd worst is a toss up between ZA SwSh. SwSh has more potential as a fan game using an asset rip and flip in unity/Godot/unreal, that's really about it.
>>58935931SwSh
>>58935931SV is superior
>>58935931Swsh. Somehow sv ruined breeding and ruined raids
>>58935931I've played more Pokémon sword since buying my switch 2 than scarlet even though I have the pay to win shiny encounters on scarlet
>>58935931both are shit, but I much rater play through SwSh again than playing through SV, that Open World is by far the worse Open World game I've ever played, it's so fucking boring to explore.
>>58937782rather*
SV is better in every way
All the posts saying SS are so forced they can't even put the correct abbreviation
>>58935931???There is literally no debateSV >>>> SwShEveryone who disagrees didn't play them and/or is a troll
>>58935931The female npcs of Scarlet and Violet are clearly modeled off Eddie Hall
>>58937896i played both and SwSh is genuinely just a more fun pokemon game, the only thing SV did better was the story and the characters, which i'll admit is atrocious in SwSh
>>58937813I liked SWSH more than SV :)
>>58935931Even if you don't like SV at least it does new/different things, SwSh at BEST is the worst version of the traditional formula and there's no real reason to play it over any of the others
