[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/vp/ - Pokémon


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


Are they the most neglected Gen1 Pokemon of all time?

>No new forms
>No new variants
>No new evolutions
>Never got the spotlight in a spin-off

For as much as GameFreak goes KANNTTOOOO, you would never think they were a part of it.
>>
>>59010915
They regionally replaced Meowth twice but couldn't give one to poor seel
>>
>>59010915
even its typing wasn't unique after 3–4 gens
they never bothered to give it a compelling mechanical identity
>>
>>59010915
Seel is my favorite Pokèmon he’s so cute :)
>>
>>59010939
It’s typing isn’t even unique in its debut gen
>>
>>59010915
it was born as worse lapras that isn't available for most of the game, doomed from the start
>>
Dewgong is good in Gen I but this is the problem >>59010983

Most often you'll never get a Dewgong before you get the free Lapras because you need to Surf for Dewgong, meaning you already have a Water type to begin with. Lots of Water Pokemon suffer this fate because of how the games were balanced. A friend of mine playing Sapphire wanted a Starmie, but the rod to fish for them was too late game so he was forced to more or less use the Lombre he'd been using as team filler for Surf until he got lucky and got a Milotic. Water is probably the worst choice paralysis type in the franchise because you really might as well use only non-shitmons. Though Dewgong gets STAB Blizzard, so while it's a worse Lapras, it's still better than actual trash like Seaking or Seadra
>>
>>59010937
>replacements
>can't use the gigantamax form
>>
>>59010939
Its typing isn't unique in its debut generation. Everything Dewgong can do Lapras can do better. Its sole gimmick was Hydration-induced 1-turn Rests, but one generation later Lapras also got Hydration so it lost even that.
>>
>>59010915
Gonna use one of these in my next kantoooooo or johto run, but yes. Cloyster at least has shell smash to keep it relevant, these lads get mogged by the Walrein line
>>
>>59011030
The worst offender of all is probably Mantyke. You can argue Munchlax is more out of the way due to its distro method in DPPt but anyone with a Munchlax on their team is doing it deliberately because they want a rare Pokemon that evolves into a strong and beloved one. No one really has any reason to care about Mantyke and no one will add it to their team because its an unevolved Water-type that appears right before the 8th gym
>>
>>59011030
What's even the point of Seaking? By the time you can get one in any game, you can get objectively better watermons like Starmie, Whiscash, Tentacruel, basically any other watermon is better.
What's Goldeen have going for it? Jack shit, yet it keeps accidentally getting booked to have a spot in regional dexes.
>>
>>59010915
They're perfect as they are! Just like Spheal or Clamperl or Maractus!
>>
>>59010961
>>59011276
you guys gotta learn how to read
nobody's going to forget lapras exists, so go with what makes sense
>>
>>59012549
>What's even the point of Seaking?
Going FUCK YEAH
>>
>>59012549
same point as whiscash
it has an ohko move
>>
Sir, we only give meaningful buffs to Ledian.
>>
>>59011030
The only time that even remotely approaches a solution to the oversaturation of water types is B2W2 offering reasons to use a monotype team at all, but not in any way that would make using them in the campaign a good idea and even then you're going to pick the six best of them and water is a stacked type to begin with so there's a ton you're just not going to use, plus B2W2 is approaching modern Pokemon/romhack levels of Pokemon availability so even limiting it to Pokemon in the game doesn't help much.
Seaking peaked with skub memes in Gen 7 which is kind of just depressing.
>>
>>59012589
We only want what's best for him
>>
>>59010915
I mean Fearow, Seaking, Parasect, Hypno, Golduck, Arbok, etc are all in the exact same boat.
>>
>>59010915
Seel was the first shiny I ever found...
>>
>>59010915
they'll get a new evo in WW, calling it now. seals are big right now.
>>
>>59012575
What in the fuck are you talking about?
>>
>>59012623
Golduck not getting shit despite Psyduck being Masuda's favorite mon baffles me
>>
>>59012662
The sealfags already rally around Spheal, they should give it something instead.
>>
>>59012623
They don't have generational gimmicks, but they at least have niches they can fill out, for the most part.

>Fearow
Gets Drill Run. A good alternative to Pidgeot, who is pathetically weak.
>Seaking
Mostly useless. Known for memes and gets Horn Drill.
>Parasect
Gets Spore and False Swipe.
>Hypno
Memes and gets Hypnosis.
>Golduck
Useless.
>Arbok
Memes and gets Glare and Coil.

Dewgong gets no coverage, is at the ass end of the game that requires you to already have a Surf-user to reach, and doesn't do anything that Lapras doesn't already do. And Lapras also gets Sing.
>>
>>59012623
Dodrio too. That fucker got nerfed in gen 9 for some stupid fucking reason.
>>
>>59012893
so much for KAAAAAANNNTTTOOOOO. I've seen Genwunners or people who haven't played since Gen 1 or 2 look at Spheal for the first time and genuinely like it.
>>
>>59012859
That might very well be the reason, the Teraeak2 showed that game freak is bitter towards Masuda for cracking the whip ever since Gen 2. Masuda might have been in charge but he doesn't have absolute power to Game Freak almost certainly ignores the psyduck line to passive aggressive get back at Masuda.
>>
File: images (5).jpg (36 KB, 554x554)
36 KB
36 KB JPG
>>59010915
Yup, market corrected by the spheal line
Also you forgot Dewgong having 25 SpA deducted in the gen 1-2 transition for no reason at all
>>
>>59012896
Beyond use in game, Dewgong is the only Water/Ice type to get Water Jet/Ice Shard and Fake Out. It has tools that none of its contemporaries have, but it just needs a bit more to distinguish itself.
>>
>>59012979
Damn, how bad must it have been for everyone at GameFreak to want to spite him like that?
>>
>>59012905
Huh? Lost moves or something?
>>
>>59012623
Arbok is considered a Team Rocket staple, Golduck is part of the Psyduck line and Psyduck gets a fuck ton of play, and Dodrio got a decent spotlight in Unite.
>>
>>59010915
Even by gen 1 standards they're both pretty plain. In basically every dex they exist in you can just run Lapras or Cloyster instead
>>
>>59012623
All the replies are coping heavily, especially 59012896 using memes as an argument.
>>
>>59013952
Not really. Even memes give attention to a Pokemon. Imagine being a Pokemon so unbeloved that it doesn't even have a funny joke associated with it.
>>
>>59013986
In a serious discussion, no one's bringing up jokes or memes to prop up a Pokemon. Some of those Pokemon either need a stat boost, an evo (preferably for me) or unfortunately, a mega or regional form. GameFreak/Pokemon rarely acknowledges memes or in-jokes from fans.
>>
>>59014016
You have no soul.
>>
>>59010915
The poliwrath line is even more forgettable
>>
>>59012575
>you guys gotta learn how to read
>"even its typing wasn't unique after 3–4 gens"
>Dewgong
>Lapras
>Cloyster
Sounds to me like you're some ESL nignog with a double digit IQ.
>>
>>59011276
In gen 3 Dewgong was like one of the only two Pokemon that could use Signal Beam.
That's it, that's his entire niche that was made irrelevant immediately when Signal Beam became widespread distributed move and then literally just removed altogether because Gamefreak is fucking gay.
>>
>>59010915
The week Pokemon Go came out, a Dewgong shadow appeared on the radar and I remember running around my neighborhood trying to find it. I didn't.
As a fan since 1998, that's my best memory of the line. A mobile game.
>>
>>59012549
Seaking has actually been the MVP in some of my runs.

Rain dance waterfall and horn drill come in clutch.

Whiscash is just very cute, I love the earthquake fish.
>>
>>59012979
>ignores the psyduck line
but psyduck and golduck were the only pokemon to be in EVERY SINGLE GAME until plza
>>
>>59010915
It's so easy to fix it though.
>Ability: Icy character: If hit by ice type move it speed raises drasticly.
>+20 att -10 sp attack
Moveset change: Instead of aurora beam it learns Ice spinner
Instead of Take down it learns Liquidation
Learns FREEZE DRY naturally after evolving.

>
>>
>>59014414
I'm serious about Pokemon getting organic pushes, not in-jokes by a sect of a few hundred people. Never work for a company trying to push a product, you'll tank their reputation overnight.
>>
>>59015052
Calling you a "bugman" would not be harsh enough.
>>
>>59015052
>organic pushes
Oxymoron.
>>
>>59012575
You seem to have forgotten cloyster though
>>
>>59014016
I mean, I dunno, it depends on the meme. Can we really say that Mudkip has never gotten its time in the spotlight?
>>
>>59010961
>>59014426
>>59015237
Its probably the only Gen 1 Water/Ice type whose Ice type makes immediate sense.
>>
>>59010915
It's funny that Primarina is the reason why it hasn't gotten anything
>>
>>59015551
Lapras didn't get a Pokedex entry justifying its Ice-typing until gen 8
>Crossing icy seas is no issue for this cold-resistant Pokémon. Its smooth skin is a little cool to the touch.
>>
>>59015858
Why would a Gen 7 pokemon prevent anything
>>
>>59015988
The Teraleak had an original map for Sun and Moon with Pokémon listed to appear in every area. Revealed stuff like Bug/Fairy Scyther and Rock/Electric Rhydon with no sign of Lurantis or Alolan Geodude elsewhere. The starters weren't finalized yet, just listed as water 1 water 2 water 3, but there was a Water/Fairy Seel and Dewgong listed as well.
>>
>>59010915
>literally just a seal
>literally just a dugong
>couldn't even come up with more creative names, just change a couple letters
And people said Gen I designs were peak.
>>
>>59015858
>>59016067
I believe it. Because I believe Crindisgrace is the reason Lopunny were dexcut at first in Gen8 and then through all of Gen9 (except for ZA).
>>
>>59016159
>And people said Gen I designs were peak.
Imagine believing shitposters
>>
>>59015551
We dithering about cloyster?
>>
>>59016564
>dithering
I will never understand how auto correct thinks I want to type shit like "dithering" instead of "forgetting"
>>
>>59016564
>>59016569
NTA but how is Ice on Cloyster immediately obvious
>>
File: DewgongInfernoX84[1].jpg (872 KB, 734x1024)
872 KB
872 KB JPG
If a Pokemon has a full art with a background then they've done it justice. Seel has none. Dewgong has 1.
>>
>>59010915
the only gen 1 mons that are strictly worse and more ignored than the seel line is the paras line. it fucking astounds me that pokemon like them are allowed to exist even though they've shown theyre okay with moderate buffs/nerfs in the past. gen 1 has a ton of anomalies that are never addressed
>rapidash strictly worse than arcanine in 9/10 scenarios
>oh yeah sure it got a regional form, the base still evolves at level fucking FOURTY and doesn't get any better stab than fucking flame charge
>despite that PONYTA has a higher bst than PARASECT
>parasect evolves 14 levels later than the other kanto bugs and gets blessed with a 4x weakness to flying and fire, gets no moves to set it apart from beedrill
>hypnos stats aren't the absolute worst for an early game tank but its movepool is dogshit and stalling in solo content (especially early gens) is pointless. completely outclassed by kadabra in everything but spdef
>people clown on fearow but it's strictly better than pidgeot in every game that mega pidgeot isn't available, also available 10 levels earlier
>you can get nidoking and nidoqueen at like level 16 because of how retarded stone evos are, 2 gyms before arbok which is a strict downgrade in every way
>farfetchd before swsh
>jynx is okay but only available via a trade at end game
>dewgong may very well be the last wild pokemon you find outside of cerulean cave, has NOTHING going for it compared to lapras cloyster or seaking. every coverage move that dewgong has gotten over the years seaking has also gotten. dewgong didnt get a water stab move (outside of tms/hms) until gen 4
>onix's stats
>sandslash's movepool
>golbat's movepool
>psyduck/golduck aren't psychic type
>victreebel literally just gimped vileplume
despite being game freak's lovechild and constantly shilled, there are so many problems with genwun mons even for solo playthroughs it's fucking astounding
>>
>>59016587
He's a cool guy.
>>
>>59016159
>looks like something that might actually exist in nature
Yes, that's why they're "peak" lil zoom.
>>
>>59010915
>Never got the spotlight in a spin-off
spoken like a retard who never played the tcg games on the gameboy or the tcg itself
>>
>>59010915
tera leaks says they planned fairy variant for them, but it was reworked into Primarina
>>
>>59016700
okay so flamigo is the best pokemon ever then
>>
>>59010915
I'd say lickitung but then i remembered Lickilicky exists

lickitung still the most forgettable of the OG151 for me btw
>>
>>59016670
>>dewgong may very well be the last wild pokemon you find outside of cerulean cave, has NOTHING going for it compared to lapras cloyster or seaking. every coverage move that dewgong has gotten over the years seaking has also gotten. dewgong didnt get a water stab move (outside of tms/hms) until gen 4
"fun fact" it took until Gen NINE for Dewgong to get Hydro Pump and it still doesn't get Freeze Dry.

>>59016596
leave it to the TCG to save Pokemon that Game Freak screws over. Why is it that every other facet of the franchise respects pokemon more than game freak does?
>>
>>59012859
Golduck can OHKO primal Groudon though.
>>
>>59012896
>Golduck
Super good HM slave.
>>
I feel people shit on dewgong too much, I used the fairy Tera one in the DLC and it over performed.
Granted it was doubles and was backed by hisuian arcanine torkoal and galarian weezing, still a fake out pokemon with AV and thick fat has a niche.

Fake out, drill run, flip turn and triple Axel were all it needed, if anything drill run could have been replaced by either sheer cold or knock off and it would have been even better, there's even an argument for perish song, protect and whirlpool.
>>
>>59016851
>Why is it that every other facet of the franchise respects pokemon more than game freak does?
They have to do more than just put "Pokemon" on the label to get money.
>>
remember when TPCi made some animation for galar with dewgong in it despite dewgong not being in the region and it created a massive controversy that got them to apologize
>>
>>59016865
Not even the best in Kanto, Krabby gets Cut, Surf and Strength
>>
I imagine they institute a Nigger pokemon that eats Chicken, in the next games. Maybe it could evolve from Dewgong, to increase its value to the players.

What do you think?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.