According to Shiina, "all of the phase girls lost 40-60% of our CCV" due to Youtube's new age verification. First confirmation from vtubers that the cull is a real thing?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZCqE4mZL6n4
If this is true, then it affects everyone and it doesn't really mean much in the grand scheme of things. All it does is lower the universal ccv so what's the problem?
Why don't the girls with a normal 300-500 CCV have less CCV then? They're the same as usual.
>>104192600Well shiina is full of shit because other phase girls I watch havent seen any lossmaybe it's because they're more Oji-san pandering
>>104192600Maybe she should stop cucking her fans for starters.
I like Shiina but I've always felt like she was botting her CCV from mid 2023, and also her subs and video views off and on until she had hit certain milestones.
>>104192821Her plan seems to be to get the other talents to cuck their fans.
>>104192600I watched that boyfriend-having bitch recently and her twitch chat was DEADLike literally buried 100m under the ground deadno one was posting despite the 200 viewers and the stream was about chatting
Has the new age verification even been rolled out yet?
Shit like this actually makes me feel sorry for 1views who get similar levels of engagement but since they're not viewbotting they feel sad and depressed from not attracting viewers who will be exposed to viewbotted streams instead
>>104192600>cull is a real thing?Various different culls that have been a thing as early as of 2021 The only difference with this current cull is that it seems to be fucking with non-vtubers as well
>>104192600>>104193110fucking h1b company with an h1b ceo
>>104193019I don't think she ever streams on twitxh
>>104193157even more sus she gets hundreds of viewers out of nowhere
>>104193069>but since they're not viewbotting
>>104193019That suits me fine. I prefer to lurk too because I'm not hip or funny enough to make a meaningful contribution to a chat.Passive consumption is something relaxing to zone out to rather than try to socialize.
>>104192629Because you’re not competing with other vtubers but the algorithm for ad rev.
>>104193157She only started multi streaming to twitch like a month ago.
>>104193459talking to the streamer can be pretty fun and relaxing as well if you can drop that anxious attitude and if you stop caring so much if you will be perceived as hip enoughI think most vtubers welcome the engagement no matter the quality because it shows their viewers are more commited and it increases their exposition as twitch algorithm will count chatters as more valuable
>>104192629It doesn't make a difference for the YouTubers that had over 20k views but it makes a big one for people under 5K and that's where the issue is
>>104193229I dont understand your reply. How can they be viewnotting if they're 1views?
Maybe Shiina will make an onlyfans to make up for lost revenue. Thanks youtube!
>>104192600>According to ShiinaLet me stop you right there. If you believe anything that comes out of the sewer of this cunning bitch you need to kill yourself asap. First of all, she only says it because SHE LOST 50% of her viewership and needs to make an excuse for it.Second, not "all Phase girls" lost viewership. That change only occurred in the US, so if any, only the girls based in the US lost viewers. And third, the only affected ones were she and Pippa, since they had the most children and bots in chat. Uruka, Lumi, Ruine, are largely unaffected, the rest I dont know because they dont fucking stream.Finally a reminder, if you watch shiina kill yourself fucking cuck.
>>104192600So, you're telling me half of phase beggar poster is underage? We need 4chan to roll out the age verification
>>104193923post the bee
>>104193923You're right, but her model is sex
>>104193923I can tell you Remi and Erina haven't decreased either
>>104193923>SHE LOST 50%so did lots of other vtubers
Am I a cuck If I find sadbee ntr to be decently arousing? I'm not self insert as the bee obviously.
>>104194127you might be a zoophile then
>>104194015I think easily more than half of vtuber audience is underagewe're talking about a hobby that's about spectating women that play video games badlyvtuber community is full of children and retards
>>104192600So they lost like 300ccv? Doesn't seem that bad to me.
>>104194127S tier: self insert as the bullB tier: self insert as the cuck F tier: self insert as the woman
>>104192600>First confirmation from vtubers that the cull is a real thing?You guys thought it was fake?
>>104193110>ShillUp>bluesky cucks seethingbased cull
>>104192723it's greys that get culled, google takes people that bought memberships as being 18+ and 3views tend to have a higher percentage of their viewers that are members
>>104193923>Ruine
Did we actually need a confirmation? I'm not a numberchimp that obsess over graphs and data and even I noticed that some of the (non-phase) girls I watch have their CCV and views almost halved since mid August while chat speed, comments and likes are mostly normal. I guess that one can argue that they all lost half of their fanbases almost overnight, but allow me to be a bit skeptical about it.
IIRC, a few days ago Mint did a raid with noticeably more people than the CCV she ended the stream with. YouTube is definitely up to something
>>104195133It happened to Saba, the other indies and to Hololive, their views all suddenly dropped around the same time and some girls that used to do 5-8k are now almost 3views
>>104193923So is this true? I'm unsubbing if she has a bf
>>104192629I mean they don't get paid per viewer on ccv, but vod views cumulatively add up and it does matter if suddenly vod views also crashed because way fewer people ever saw it to begin with. I forgot the general estimation but it's like 100k views = 1k usd as an average rubric (but this will vary a lot).so if they were reliably clocking like 10k views per stream for some rando small corpo or high 3view/low4view that's like $100 a stream just to exist (and before cuts and taxes). hence between streaming a lot, memberships and SCs a 3view could get by in most places. wouldn't be striking it rich probably but would be getting by. if vod views were like a third or half their revenue then those getting smashed in half is a big hit for them.as was said for large corpo aka just holos where they can easily have like 30 or 50k vod views off the bat, it's already so much that the vod income can be slashed and still not put them into a bad spot because it's cutting what was already way-way more than enough into still more than enough.
>>104194675But what if that anon is a woman.
>>104196306>anon>a womanHaha, yeah, imagine...
>>104192600it's at least 30%
>>104192899Phase very obviously bots several of their talents at various points, they're just relatively subtle about it.>Brave Group gets into deep shit for their extremely blatant botting and many of their talents lose monetization for it >Immediately after this becomes public knowledge a bunch of Phase girls suddenly drop ~300-500 CCV from their average
wontons
>>104196376a classic
>>104193923>cunny bitchhell yea that's right uoh
>>104195874Money is money, so I don't think anyone is happy about losing revenue. But at the end of the day, given how unreliable VODs are as a revenue stream, I don't think many people are absolutely desperate about lower view counts. Especially if other metrics such as subscriptions and super chats are largely unaffected.IMHO there are two different issues stemming from this cull. The first is the impact on the algorithm: small creators may be recommended less and find it even harder to get themselves noticed, and in general there may be fewer potential new fans coming in at any given time. The other, potentially even worse, is that sponsors may pay less or even ignore certain VTubers with lower numbers than usual. And sponsors, unlike ads, bring in real money.
>>104193923This fella gets mad when he finds out the strippers have boyfriends and don't actually love himSAD
>>104196306then I rapethem
>>104192600wonton?
>>104192600phase cope
>>104192600Two explanation.1. Phase has been view botting and YT cracked down on it so all their numbers are reflecting that.2. It's the age verification system YT implemented in a direct response to conservative American states all passing age verification laws and it's affecting Phase like Shina says.Either option is not a good look given Phase panders to the group that voted for age verification laws, so they have to deal with this and having to block shipping to the US.Nothing is a critical blow yet, but it's not helpful either.
>>104192600>lose viewers>no merch Kinda fucking grim.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpVnx4_yqTohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KqCV6Rk8kOAlooks like viewership is down across the board
>>104192600Bots have no age
>>104192600>First confirmation from vtubers that the cull is a real thing?If it's about a streamer I like the cull is real.If it's about a streamer I don't like the cull is cope.Simple as.
